Hello, everyone! Welcome to the next chapter of part 1 of "The Love of a Killer". In the last chapter, Jeff and Rainbow Dash obviously got off to a rocky start because of Jeff chasing her. Now that Rainbow's friends have arrived, how will they react to this new and strange pony? Let's find out shall we? Disclaimer: I DO NOT own "MLP: FIM" or any Creepypasta characters. All rights go to their respective owners.

Chapter 4: Rainbow's Friends

Minutes earlier...

Twilight Sparkle and her friends, Applejack, Rarity, Fluttershy, and Pinkie Pie had just arrived at Rainbow Dash's house to see what was wrong with their friend.

"Are you sure something's up, Twilight?" Applejack asked.

The alicorn glanced at her friend.

"I'm sure, Applejack. All I know is that I saw somepony carrying Rainbow on their back. I thought something was up, so after he flew off, I quickly but quietly followed to see what was going on. Then I saw that the mysterious pony was flying to Rainbow's house and then he went in with her and closed the door. That's why I came and got all of you." Twilight said.

"Who was it?" Asked Fluttershy.

"That's what I want to know."

She turns back to the door.

"Um, Twilight? I don't mean to be rude or criticize, but don't you think you're overreacting just a little bit?" Rarity asked, concerned.

Twilight turns to her friends.

"Girls, listen." She said, seriously, "We're talking about a strange new pony who we don't know anything about carrying our unconscious friend back to her house. For all we know, that pony probably caused her to be unconscious. Besides, who knows what he could be doing to her."

Twilight's friends looked at each other. They didn't know what to think. Maybe their friend was overreacting or maybe there was something really wrong. They all turn back to their friend.

"Twilight, maybe you should calm down a bit." Applejack said with a small smile, "You said Rainbow was unconscious and that someone was carrying her, right?"

Twilight nodded.

"Yeah, so?"

"So, maybe whoever was carrying her probably found her knocked out somewhere and decided to help her."

"You don't know that." Twilight said, still a bit nervous about the situation.

Just then, Pinke Pie looked up to Rainbow's window hole.

"I got an idea." She thought.

She walked forward and cupped a hoof over her mouth.

"Rainbow Dash!" She called.

Twilight and the others look at her.

"Pinkie, what are you doing?" Twilight asked.

"I'm trying to call Dashie to make sure she's okay. But for some reason I didn't get an answer." Said Pinkie.

Applejack walked forward while looking up.

"Let me try." She said.

She cupped a hoof over her mouth.

"Rainbow? Are you okay, sugarcube?" She asked. But there was still no answer.

"I didn't get an answer either. I'm pretty sure she heard us."

"But what if she didn't?" Twilight said, still worried.

For a few seconds, everyone was silent until Rarity spoke up.

"Twilight?"

"Yes, Rarity?"

"Why don't you try knocking? Surely she would hear that." She suggested.

Twilight turned to the door.

"It's worth a try." She said.

She walked towards it and knocked a few times. She heard hoofsteps on the other side and stepped back a little. They heard the knob click and the door began to open. Once it opened all the way, the mares were shocked at who they saw. It wasn't Rainbow. Instead, it was a white pegasus stallion with a black mane and tail. What shocked them the most was his face. There were no eyelids to his eyes and there was a grotesque looking smile cut into his face.

Present...

Jeff looked at the five mares standing before him. They all had looks of shock on their faces. He assumed they were Rainbow's friends. They were all silent for a moment.

"What?" Jeff said.

All of a sudden, the mares screamed in horror. Jeff only sighed.

"Should've seen that coming." He mumbled.

He then noticed he was being lifted up and saw that there was a purple aura around him.

"Wait. What the hell?!"

He felt himself being thrown back and he hit the wall. He landed on his stomach. He started to get up, but he heard the sound of hooves coming near him.

"Hold him down!" He heard one of the mares say.

He then saw four of them run to him and jump on top of him, holding him down. Jeff struggled to get up, but it was no use. He looked up to see the purple mare walking towards him with an angry look. They both stared at each other.

"Who are you and what have you done with Rainbow?!" She asked/yelled.

Jeff grunted as he talked.

"Listen, I didn't do anything to her." He said.

"Oh, really? Then why was she unconscious while you were carrying her on your back?!" The purple mare demanded.

"Look, I didn't do anything. I swear! If I show you she's fine, will that calm all of you down? She's awake and in bed." Jeff explained.

Hearing this, Twilight thought about it for a minute, then nodded.

"Girls, let him go." She said.

Her friends got off of Jeff and he gets up. He shakes himself. He then turned and walked to the stairs. He was about to go up them when he glanced at Twilight and her friends.

"Follow me."

He walks upstairs with the girls following him. We cut to Rainbow's room where she's just laying in bed with a frustrated look, thinking about what happened and wishing it didn't happen to her. She sighed. She heard her door open and saw Jeff come in.

"Hey, Dash. There are some ponies who want to see you." He said.

He steps aside and Twilight and the others came in. They quickly walk to her bed.

"Twilight." Rainbow said.

"Rainbow." Said Twilight.

Once they got close enough, Pinkie pulled Rainbow into a tight hug.

"We're so glad you're okay, Dashie." She said.

Rainbow felt a sharp pain in her wing.

"Ow ow ow! Pinkie Pie, I'm happy that you know I'm fine, but could you please not hug me so tight? My wing still hurts." She said.

Pinkie then let go of her friend.

"Oh, sorry."

"So, what happened? Why were you unconscious?" Asked Twilight.

Rainbow was about to say something when Jeff spoke up.

"I can easily explain that." He said.

They turn to him.

"But first, let me introduce myself. My name is Jeff. Jeff Woods."

Everyone except Jeff and Rainbow got confused looks.

"Jeff Woods?" Twilight asked.

Jeff nodded.

"Yeah. What's your name?"

"My name is Twilight Sparkle."

He laughs a bit.

"What's so funny?" Twilight asked, a little offended.

"Oh nothing. It's just that name. 'Twilight Sparkle'. It's kind of an unusual name." Jeff said.

"Hey, Jeff isn't exactly a normal name either!" Twilight said.

"That's what I told him!" Said Rainbow.

He then looked at the other mares.

"Who are all of you? Do you have weird names too?" He asked.

Rarity steps forward with her brows furrowed.

"Our names may be weird to you, but they're not weird to us. To us, they are really good names. Just like your name may be unusual to us, but you think it's a good name as well." She said.

"That's because it is." Jeff said, "What are your names anyway?"

"My name is Rarity."

She then gestured to her friends.

"And these are Applejack, Fluttershy, and Pinkie Pie."

Jeff looked at the ponies and saw Pinke wave at him with a smile.

"Hello!" She said.

He shrugged his shoulders a bit and looked away.

"Weird names, weird ponies. I guess that makes sense." He mumbled.

"Um, Jeff?"

Jeff turned to Fluttershy who was pointing at Rainbow.

"I hope you don't mind me asking, but why is Rainbow in bed with an ice pack on her head?" She asked.

"Like I said, I can explain." Said Jeff.

He clears his throat.

"It all started when I woke up near a forest wondering how I got there in the first place. I immediately started to quickly walk away from it because who knows what could be in there. But that's beside the point. After walking away from the forest, I came to a town called Ponyville. I explored it a bit and when I tried to think of how I got here, I suddenly started flying. Wanting to know how I was flying, I looked around until I noticed that I had wings." Jeff explained.

Rainbow got a look of confusion.

"You're a pegasus and you didn't even know you had wings? How does that happen?" She asked.

"I don't know. Maybe I hit my head so hard, I got amnesia or something." Jeff said, sarcastically.

Rainbow crossed her forelegs.

"Well, excuse me." She said, a little offended by Jeff's remark.

"Anyway, when I saw the wings, I have to admit, I was a little surprised." Jeff continued, "But then, I started flying around some. And I'd be lying if I said I didn't enjoy it. Flying around felt great! The wind in my mane, the freedom, it was almost like a dream come true for me. But as I was flying, she bumped into me."

Rainbow then spoke up when her friends turned to her.

"Hey. You're the one who bumped into me, dude. Not the other way around." She said, "May I tell my side of the story, please?"

Jeff sighs.

"I wasn't finished yet, but go ahead." He said.

Rainbow then began to tell her friends her side of the story.

"I was just flying and minding my own business when all of a sudden, this guy bumped into me." She said while pointing at Jeff, "When that happened, we ended up falling to the ground which caused my right leg to get hurt. I was gonna tell him to watch where he was going, but then I saw his face. I screamed and flew away as fast as I could. But when I looked back, I saw that he was flying after me! In order to lose him, I flew into the Everfree Forest."

Everyone gasped and turned to Jeff with glares.

"You chased her?" Twilight asked.

Jeff got a surprised look.

"Well... I... I didn't... *sigh* Okay, I did chase her. But only because I wanted information!" He said, defensively.

"Information about what?" Rainbow asked.

"About where I am. Like what world I'm in for instance."

The ponies got confused looks, looked at each other, then back at Jeff. It was really strange having a pony ask what world he was in.

"Why would you ask that?" Applejack asked.

"Because I don't know what world I'm in. Also, I'm pretty new here." Jeff said.

"Maybe he really does have amnesia." Fluttershy whispered.

"Yeah, maybe." Twilight whispered back.

For a moment, there was silence.

"Well? Are you gonna tell me?" Jeff asked, breaking the silence.

Twilight looked at her friends again, then at Jeff. She walked towards him a little.

"To be honest, Jeff, we have absolutely no idea why you would ask that. But I'll tell you." She said.

Twilight told him he was in a place called Equestria where ponies and other creatures live in harmony. She then told him about the various creatures that were in Equestria other than ponies. Like griffons, changelings, hippogriffs, and dragons. She then told him about the rulers of Equestria, Princess Celestia and Princess Luna, the princesses of the sun and the moon.

"Wow. I didn't know that there were more creatures than ponies in this world. I didn't even know it was ruled by someone." Jeff said, a bit dumbfounded.

"Surprised aren't you?" Asked Twilight.

"Very. Twilight, I've got a question."

"Yes?"

"Now that I know where I'm at, may I go back to telling my story?"

Twilight nodded.

"Fine by me." She said.

Jeff turned to Rainbow.

"Dash?"

"Sure, whatever." She said.

"Anyway, when she flew into the forest, I was hesitant at first. But then I shook those thoughts out of my head and flew in after her. I was catching up with her too. That was until I bumped into a tree. I didn't knock me out, but it hurt like hell. Eventually, I got over it and started looking for Dash again. I thought I lost her. It took me some time to find her, but I did. She was knocked out cold. I could tell she was alive because I saw her breathing. I knew I couldn't just leave her there because A, she could've gotten eaten, and B, I wanted answers. So, I picked her up and carried her on my back and flew out of there." Jeff explained.

"How did you know where Rainbow's house was?" Twilight asked.

"After flying out of the woods, I landed in Ponyville. I was lucky enough to find someone who knew where she lived. He told me it was a cloud castle in the sky. It took me a while to find the damn place, but I eventually found it. After doing so, I carried her into the house and up to her room. And to make a long story short, she woke up, we didn't get along well, and you can figure out the rest for yourselves." Jeff finished.

Applejack tapped Twilight's shoulder causing her to glance at her. She had a small smile on her face.

"See, Twilight. I told you he was probably helping her." She said.

Twilight smiles back and nods. Rainbow speaks causing everyone to turn to her.

"Um, hello. Equestria to everypony. Are we missing something here? He freaking chased me!" She said, pointing at Jeff.

He began to get irritated.

"Hey, I may have chased you, but at least I got you out of that forest alive. Can you at least be grateful for that?" He asked.

"He does have a point, Rainbow." Fluttershy said.

"Well, you could've told me to stop."

"I did tell you to stop, but did you stop? No, of course not. You just kept on flying."

"You were the one chasing me. If you didn't start chasing me, I probably wouldn't have gone into the Everfree Forest, and I probably wouldn't have flown into that tree limb and knocked myself out." Rainbow said.

"Hey, I told you to stop. And it wasn't my fault you crashed into that limb. Besides, you're probably not that good of a flyer yourself." Jeff said.

"Hey! I'm a damn good flyer. I just looked back for a second. That's all."

"I'm just saying. If you paid attention to where you were flying, you never would've gotten hurt."

"So, this is my fault?!"

"In a way, yes it is!"

"But you... But you... I..."

"Rainbow."

Rainbow turned to Applejack.

"I hate to say this, but I think Jeff has a point. Because think about it. If you hadn't looked back and paid attention to where you were going, maybe you wouldn't have crashed." She said.

"AJ, whose side are you on?" Rainbow asked, irritably.

"Rainbow, calm down." Twilight said, "We know you're upset about what happened to you, but think about it. At least you were saved by somepony. Sure, he may look a bit strange but you should be thanking him. He's a hero."

Jeff then got an irritated look.

"Why is everyone calling me a hero all of a sudden? I'm no hero!" He said.

The mares looked at each other, then at Jeff, not understanding why he wouldn't want to be called a hero. He did save their friend after all.

"Well, if you're not a hero, then what are you?" Asked Rarity.

"I'm just... I'm just... *sigh* I'm just a regular pegasus. Look, we bumped into each other by accident, she screamed when she saw my face, we went into the forest, I found her knocked out, and I just carried her out of there. End of story. I don't see how that can be called heroic." Jeff said.

"Well, we don't know what else to call it." Rarity said.

For a minute, there was silence. Just then, Rainbow spoke.

"Um, Twilight?"

Twilight turned to her.

"Yeah, Rainbow?"

"How long do you think I'm going to be in bed?" She asked.

"I don't know, Rainbow." Twilight said, "The thing is I don't know how hurt you are. But this evening, I'll be here with Nurse Redheart to find out what's wrong. Sound like a plan?"

Rainbow thinks about it for a second.

"I guess it sounds good." She said.

Twilight nodded. She turned to Jeff.

"You know, Jeff, we don't really know that much about you other than you saving Rainbow. It would be nice if we got to know you more. So, when Rainbow is feeling better or if you feel like it, you can talk to me or any of my friends about yourself." She said.

"I guess it sounds good." Said Jeff.

Pinkie Pie got a little close to him.

"Yeah! And once we get to know you, I'll throw you a big 'Welcome to Ponyville' party!" She said.

Jeff scoffs.

"A party? Huh, count me out."

Pinkie was confused.

"What? Why? You don't like parties?"

"It's not that I don't like parties, it's just the last time I was at a party, well... let's just say things didn't go well for me." Jeff said.

Pinkie frowned.

"Oh."

But then her face brightened again.

"But would you still like to come?" She asked.

"I'll think about it." Said Jeff.

"Goodie!"

Twilight turned to Rainbow.

"Hey, Rainbow."

"Yeah, Twilight?"

"If it's okay with you, can we leave you two alone so maybe you can talk?" She asked.

"I guess that's okay." Said Rainbow.

Twilight nods.

"Okay. Just remember, I'm going to come back here with Nurse Redheart this evening. Okay?"

"Okay."

Everyone then said their goodbyes and walked out of the room. Twilight shut the door behind them. Jeff sat down a took a deep breath.

"So, what do you wanna do or talk about, Mr. Regular?" Asked Rainbow.

"To be honest, Dash, I have no fucking idea." Jeff said.

Author's Note: Well, that does it for this chapter! Sorry if it took a while to write. The reason why it did was because I accidentally deleted my original draft for this chapter and I had to make a new one. But despite all of that, here it is. Anyway, I hope you enjoyed this chapter. If you did, please be sure to read and review. Constructive criticism is welcome. Also, be sure to keep watch for the next chapter. Until then, see you next time, my fellow bronies and pegasisters!