A/N: Hey, yo! It's DJ MBAV fan66! And I have the other awesome songfic that I mentioned in the last chapter, right here and ready to give you!

This is the other song and pairing that anonymous requested. And unlike the last one, this one's not gonna have too happy of an ending. So, grab those tissues and get them ready becasue we're about to get started! BOOM! Lol!

No shout outs this time, my peeps. Since this one is being post right after that last one on the same day. But don't worry! The shout outs will return for the next great tune!

Disclaimer: I do not own My Babysitter's A Vampire or the song used in this songfic. Those rights belong to their original creators. I do own, however, this songfic and it's short mini plot thing that's happening in it. So, enjoy my homies!


Songfic #25

Song: Cold As Ice

Artist: Foreigner

Pairing: Benny/Erica


Benny and Erica where casually sitting at a little cafe, having some coffee and were just chatting it up with each other. They both were having a great time hanging out with each other. They would do this constantly ever now and then. Ever since Erica and Sarah had gradutated about a year ago and Sarah had left for college, leaving Erica without her best friend to hang out with anymore. So, that only left the dork squad to hang out with, but much to her surprise she had started not to mind it so very much. And somehow her and Benny had started to grow more closer.

No, they weren't dating or anything. They were just really close friends. Or to be more accurate, they became BEST friends. But even then there where times were they seemed to be a little more than just that, with subtle flirting going on between the two or touching that seemed a little too friendly for just friends. But they weren't boyfriend and girlfriend. No matter how much the other secretly wanted it to be true.

That's right. Benny secretly likes Erica and she secretly likes him, but they would never let the other know about it because they didn't want to ruin the perfect thing that they had going now. So, they just kept it to themselves, but they still could sense somehow that maybe the feeling wasn't so one sided as they thought. They both had their suspicions about it, but never really bothered to press for answers. Not wanting to risk creating a big agrument over it.

You're as cold as ice

You're willing to sacrifice our love

You never take advice

Someday you'll pay the price, I know

Hanging out with Benny had seemed to changed her a little. She was less mean and stuck up than usual and was more nicer and kinder, but every now and then Erica would still have her 'Erica moments' around him, but Benny didn't mind it as much since her usual insults weren't as harsh or bad as they used to be.

I've seen it before

It happens all the time

Closing the door

You leave the world behind

But then Erica started to see this guy named Jake. He was a vampire like her, but he was one of those vampires that were loaded with money like Jesse was. Benny didn't really like the guy that much. He wasn't sure if it was being a vampire or just being rich, but they guy was kind of a jerk who liked to look down on others. He wasn't like Jesse, an evil kind of jerk who wants to take over the world, but more like just your regular kind of jerk who likes bully you and call you names. The guy acted more like Erica use to do, before they started to hang out together, if not worser.

Benny noticed that ever since Erica had started to date Jake, it had seems that she had started to regress more and more back to her old rude and snobbish ways again. And he didn't like it. So, when they met up together to have lunch, he confronted her about it.

"Erica." he started. She looked at him after taking a bit of her salad. "I don't know if you've noticed this or not, but...you've seem to be acting more like your old and spiteful self again, ever since you started dating that Jake guy. I think he's a bad influence on you." he said to her, gaining confidence as he spoke.

You're digging for gold

Yet throwing away

A fortune in feelings

But someday you'll pay

Erica looked at him as if he was crazy, but deep down she kind of knew that he was right. She was going back to her old self again. But she had to. She didn't want to lose Jake. He was the best thing that ever happened to her...financially that is. She didn't really love guy or anything, but she did have some small feelings for the guy, though. But Erica felt like her heart truly belong with Benny, but what could he give her? He wasn't filthy rich like Jake was. He wouldn't be able to provide for her the way that she wants to be provided for, like being showered in gifts and living in a really big house. Benny couldn't give her any of that and the life that she wanted, but Jake can.

"Are you kidding me, Benny? I haven't changed one bit. I'm still the same Erica that you know, so stop trying to bad talk Jake! He's a really sweet and nice guy." defended Erica, playing dumb even though she did know that it true.

Benny then got more serious in his words. "No! I'm not, Erica! He really is a bad influence on you! You've been treating me and the guys like dirty lately, just like how you use too if not even more, now! I know you, Erica! And this isn't the real you! Not anymore, that is!" he shouted at her. "I bet you're not even really in love with guy! You're probably only with him for his money!" accused Benny strongly.

You're as cold as ice

You're willing to sacrifice our love

You want paradise

But somday you'll pay the price, I know

Erica gasped, as she had a very surprised and shock expression on her face before it then turned to an angry one. "How dare you accuse me of something like that, Benny! I DO love Jake! And he loves me back! And I'm not going back to my old ways because you think he's a 'bad influence' on me! So, you can just keep your stupid accusations to yourself and just BUTT OUT! Because frankly Weir, I just think that you're just jealous of him his all!" yelled Erica back at him in fury and then left after paying her part of the bill, but he could see the truth in her eyes. He knew that she knew that he was right and that she didn't really love Jake and that she was only with him for his money. He knew that one that she truly loved was him.

I've seen it before

It happens all the time

Closing the door

You leave the world behind

After that argument, the two hadn't seen or spoke to each other much anymore. Then one day in the mail, Benny had gotten an invitation to a wedding. But it wasn't just anybodys wedding. It was Jake's and Erica's wedding. Benny was fuming over the thought how she was going to marry someone that she didn't even really love, just to have the life that she always wanted.

So, what if Jake could give her the life she wanted and he couldn't. There was still one thing that was more important than wealth that he could give Erica that Jake couldn't, and that was love. He knew for a fact that she doesn't love Jake. And a marriage without love is basically not even a marriage at all! It would be nothing more than just an empty promise to one another. And Benny couldn't let that happen. He loved her too much to see her live a life of emptiness and no true happiness, at all.

He had to stop this wedding from happening! He thought about it for second before it came to him. Maybe if he finally confessed his feelings to her, so that way she will finally know just how much he truly cares for her...then she'll come to her senses and call off the wedding! And then she'd choose him over the life of luxury and they can finally be happy together! So, that was the plan. To make Erica see that he's the one that she loves and really share her life with.

You're digging for gold

Yet throwing away

A fortune in feelings

But someday you'll pay

On the day of the wedding, just when the Pastor asked the crowd if there was any reason why they shouldn't get married, Benny then stood up in his tuxedo saying, "Yes! There is!" Gasps spread throught out the guest, but he didn't care as he then made his way up to the alter, to where Erica and Jake were.

He stood there and looked a rather furious Erica in the eyes with determination and love in his own. "Erica. You can't marry Jake." he said to her. "And why not?" asked Erica in slight annoyance for him doing this at her wedding. "Because...becasue..." he stammered, trying to build the courage up to say it. "Because I love you! That's why!" Benny finally blurted out to her, which caused the crowd to gasp again. Erica's expression then softened as soon as she heard him say those words to her.

"What did you just say?" she asked slowly in a soft tone. "I love you, Erica Jones! So, please don't marry this other guy because I know for a fact that you don't love him back. Instead, the one that your heart really belongs to his me, Erica. Just as mine belongs to you. So, don't choose the fortune of money over the fortune of what really matters in life...love." confessed Benny sincerely, with such loving and pleading eyes.

Erica almost wanted to cry at his confession, but did she really want to marry for money and not love? She looked over to Jake, seeing him pissed off a bit and then she looked back towards Benny and those green passionate eyes of his. She then made her decision.

"I'm sorry, Benny. But...I love Jake. And I want to marry him, not you. I'm afraid that I don't share the same feelings that you do for me with you. I'm sorry." she said remorsefully, even though her heart was breaking when said that and that it was really just a lie. She did love Benny back, but she loved the lap of luxury even more. Being rich made her feel like she was somebody to the world.

Benny stood there in shock, as he felt his heart being shattered at her reply. She chose money over him. Over...the love they shared between each other. She was willing to sacrifice their love just for some pretty boy and his expensive things. A tear ran down his cheek slowly, as his eyes began to water as he just stared at her.

"No. I'm sorry. I'm sorry that I thought that maybe you had changed for the better. But I see that you were right all along, Erica. You haven't changed at all." he finally spoke, in a sadden and heartbroken tone. "Because you're still the same selfish and cold hearted person that you use to be!" blurted out Benny in frustration, as he wiped the tear away and then stormed off out of the chapel. Erica felt her heart sink for doing that to him. She hated seeing him look so...so...so...broken. But pushing her feelings aside, she continued on with the wedding, regardless.

(Cold, as, ice)

You know that you are

(Cold, cold) (as, as) (ice)

As cold as ice to me

(Cold, cold, cold) (as, as, as) (ice)

When Erica returned back from her honeymoon with Jake, she found that she had several missed messages from Sarah. Erica was baffled by why Sarah would leave so many messages, especially when she knows that she was on her honeymoon with Jake. Erica had left her phone there before leaving because it was their honeymoon after all. And really? Who wants to be disturbed while their honeymoon, right?

So, when Erica pressed play to listen to them, her heart dropped and then shattered into a billion pieces at what she heard. It was about Benny and how he was involved in a car accident. Apparently, after he left, he was so upset about her decision to still go through with marrying Jake that he had gotten drunk that night and then tried to drive himself home. Only to wind up passing out at the wheel and crashing into a tree. They had rushed him to the hospital, only for it to be too late to save him.

The phone fell from Erica's hand when she heard that, and then she broke down in heart wrenching tears, dropping to the floor herself. Benny was dead and it was all her fault! "If only I didn't go on with marrying Jake! If only I chose loving him instead, over wanting to be wealthy. Then...then Benny would've still been alive! But instead I chose to break his heart and now...mine is broken too." she cried, regretting her decision to marry for money instead out of love. And now, she had paid the ultimate price for it too. Her one true love's heart and life...gone forever.

So, here she is. Erica Jones. Stuck in a marriage with a guy that she doesn't even love. Only so she could live the good life, but...what is living the good life without love? For now, Erica finally understands that love is truly the good life and not wealth.

(Ooh, ooh, ooh, you're as cold as ice)

(You're as cold as icccce)

You're as cold as ice

(Cold as icccce)

(You're as cold as icccce)

You're as cold as ice

(Cold as icccce)

Cold as ice I know

(You're as cold as icccce)

Oh, yes I know

(Cold as icccce)

(You're as cold as icccce)

You're as cold as ice

(Cold as icccce)

Cold as ice I know

(You're as cold as icccce)

Oh, yes I know

(Cold as icccce)


A/N: And there you go! Songfic #25!

Wow! That was a long one, huh? Lol! But I got it done! Lol! I'm not sure if it really goes along with the song too well, but I like to think that it might of came pretty darn close. Don't you? Lol!

So, anonymous! There's your second song request! And it's a Bennica, just like you wanted it to be! So, how was it? Did you like them both? I hope so! Lol!

Until next time my songficers, this is DJ MBAV fan66! And I'm outta here! PEACE! Lol!