Found the prompt on wrestlingkink . dreamwidth . org
Full Prompt: Randy isn't really happy in his relationship with Seth, but he knows that he has Seth wrapped around his finger and he doesn't want to completely break it off with him so he suggested an open relationship. Seth isn't really feeling an open relationship, but because he loves Randy and wants to keep him happy, he agrees to it. Fastforward a little bit and Seth casually mentions to his friends (preferably to one or a couple of the divas) that his relationship with Randy is now an open relationship. Word travels quickly backstage and soon most of the locker room is scrambling to get a piece of Seth. Seth is at first a little hesitant, but then goes along with it and starts to fuck everyone. Meanwhile Randy is getting absolutely zero play and he's mad that Seth is getting all the action and he's getting none. He approaches Seth about calling off the arrangement. How Seth reacts and what happens next is up to the writer.
Randy narrowed his eyes at Seth, who was laying next to him on the bed reading a book. His glasses were perched on his nose and his brows furrowed as he read. Randy continued to stare at the younger man as he tried to find a way to broach the topic on his mind with Seth. He knew Seth wouldn't take this very well, but there was really no way to ease Seth into this. He either had to go for it and just explain the situation, or suffer in silence…and Randy refused to suffer any longer. Randy and Seth started dating since 2013. Only four months after Seth had made his move from NXT to the main roster with his Shield brothers, Randy made his move on the two-toned haired man and entered into a relationship with him.
Emotionally, Seth was everything Randy could ever want in a partner. Seth was a genuinely sweet and caring person, not at all like the character he currently played on TV. He was also very supportive of Randy and cheered him on whenever he did projects outside of the WWE. He was very attentive to Randy's emotional needs and they also had a similar belief system, so rarely did they ever fight. If they did fight, it was always over something stupid like Randy forgetting to unload the dishwasher or Seth leaving the toilet seat up. The also had similar interest and had many things in common, so they always had fun whenever they went out together.
However physically, sexually, they were never compatible…or at least Randy thought so. There were many things Randy didn't like about Seth's body and Seth's sex. When it came to his body, Seth was a bit too big for Randy's liking. He normally dated smaller men and women but Seth couldn't change his body make-up, so Randy learned to accept Seth's body, and eventually started to enjoy it, but there were other things that irked him.
Seth's body hair was one of those things. Seth was much hairier than any guy or girl he ever dated. Randy kept his body smooth and he liked for his partner to do the same. He didn't like that fact that Seth had chest hair and don't even get him started on that hideous beard growing on Seth's face. He'd dropped numerous hints about his hatred for body hair but either Seth just ignored his hints, or the hints just went right over Seth's head.
Seth was also too active for Randy's taste. Randy liked to be one that was in control and called the shots in the bedroom and while Seth wasn't dominant like Randy, he definitely wanted to be more involved in the act. He didn't just want to lay there and take it, which at times turned Randy off.
Randy found himself pushing away all of his dislikes in order to keep the relationship going, but in these past five months he found himself not being able to anymore. Those dislikes drove him to stare and ogle at other men and women that more so fit his physical type. Sometimes he would do this in front of Seth and even though it was disrespectful, he couldn't help himself. It had even gotten to the point of him flirting with other attractive people when Seth wasn't around. He knew that if he didn't address the issue, he'd end up sneaking around behind Seth's back and he didn't want to do that. Randy only saw two options: either they opened up their relationship or he broke it off with Seth. He couldn't continue to sacrifice his sexual needs and if they wanted this relationship to work, he was going to have to go outside of the relationship to satisfy those needs.
"Baby…" Randy called out hesitantly. Seth looked up from his book and over at Randy, waiting for him to continue. "We need to talk about our relationship."
"Talk about our relationship?" Seth questioned. He didn't know what this was about. He thought their relationship was fine. They rarely fought and they both loved one another. He didn't understand why they needed to talk.
"Yeah, well…these past couple of month I've been pretty…disconnected from our physical relationship." Randy started to explain.
"Disconnected from our physical relationship?" Seth questioned. "What the fuck does that even mean?"
"I'm not satisfied…sexually." Randy confessed and Seth allowed a shocked look to cover his face.
"You've never said anything before…" Seth mumbled as he placed his book on the bedside stand.
"I know, I didn't want to hurt your feelings…and some of my turn offs…well, you can't control." Randy said and reach over to take Seth's hand in his. "Sex is very important to me and while I get off when I'm with you, I'm not completely fulfilled." Randy explained and Seth looked down at their intertwined fingers. He was embarrassed by the fact that he wasn't sexually satisfying his boyfriend. They'd been dating for over two years and in that time, Randy hadn't really received pleasure while he'd been pretty satisfied by the sex. It made Seth feel a little selfish, and he wanted to make this right.
"What do you want me to do to make this better for you?" Seth asked and Randy sighed.
"I want to have an open relationship." Randy confessed and Seth snatched his hands from Randy's grip.
"An open relationship!" Seth exclaimed. "I don't know about that Randy…" Seth trailed off.
"Look, baby. I think this would be perfect for us." Randy started. "Like I said there are some things that you'll never be able to change because they're apart of your genetics, and I think we could do this as long as we lay down some ground rules. We love one another and respect one another enough for this to work. We both completely trust one another, and it's a chance for both of us to have fun and explore our sexualities. We can also pick up new things and bring them back to our bedroom. It'll be fun." Randy tried to reason with Seth, but Seth shook his head.
"I still…I don't know…" Seth stuttered out. "I really just wanted this to be you and me…" Seth tried to explain but Randy quickly injects.
"Look, Seth." Randy started and cupped Seth's cheek and looked into his eyes. "I can no longer push my sexual desires aside and I refuse to sneak around on you. We either agree to open up our relationship, or we break up." Randy said and watched Seth's eyes widened when Randy mentioned breaking up. "I'm sorry to do this but I know that if we continue to stay monogamous, I'll eventually end up cheating on you and I don't want that. I'd rather leave, than do that." Randy explained and Seth nodded.
Seth still wasn't sure about having an open relationship, but he didn't want to lose Randy. He loved Randy and felt like he could be the one for him. Seth was sure that once they got past Randy's 'open relationship' phase, they'd go back to being the loving monogamous couple that they once were.
"Okay…" Seth said reluctantly. "Okay, we can do this open relationship thing." Seth reluctantly agreed and Randy smiled and kissed Seth on the lips. He was happy this worked, now he would actually be sexually satisfied. "But how does this work? What are our ground rules?" Seth asked.
"Um basically you can have sex with whoever you want whenever you want." Randy started to explain the rules to their arrangement. "But you always have to use protection and if the protection some how fails, we have to let one another know and be tested." Randy explained and Seth nodded in agreement. This sounded reasonable. "It's okay to go out for drinks or eat or just casual dates with the person you want to sleep with because you might have to woo them into bed, but it should never get serious with that person. Also, our relationship shouldn't suffer. If anything, our relationship should get better. If we ever feel like our relationship is suffering, then we close the relationship again." Randy said and Seth nodded.
"These rules seem fair." Seth said and Randy nodded and kissed Seth again.
"I know you're still a bit apprehensive, Seth." Randy started. "But you'll see, this will be fun and great for the both of us."
A week had passed since Randy and Seth declared their relationship open and everything was still fine on the home front. The way they acted with one another and the way they felt about one another hadn't changed. Nothing about the relationship had changed, except the fact that Randy went out almost every night. Seth assumed Randy was going out to sleep with other people and that was a blow to his ego. It still hurt Seth that he wasn't, sexually, enough for Randy but if he wanted this relationship to last, he would have to put his ego aside and let this open relationship thing play out.
And while Randy went out to pick up other people, Seth couldn't bring himself to do it. Even though Randy said it was fine, he still felt like he was cheating on him. He talked about these feelings with Randy and he assured Seth that it wasn't cheating and he could sleep with anyone, but Seth still couldn't find the motivation to pick up dates. So whenever Randy went out Seth said behind in their hotel room, counting the hours until Randy came back.
Seth jumped in surprise when his phone buzzed across the nightstand. He wasn't expecting a call or text and he was half-asleep when the phone buzz. He reached out and grabbed it before unlocking the phone and reading the text.
"Hey sexy! Adam Rose and I miss your face. Come to hotel bar plz! J" Alicia Fox texted him. Seth smiled as he read the text. Adam had been his friend since his NXT days and Alicia immediately took to him when he came up to the main roster. They were good friends, and they always seemed to know when he needed company.
"Be there is ten." Seth texted her back and then rolled off the bed. It would probably be a couple of hours before Randy came back and he was tired of waiting on him. He might as well get some drinks with his friends. Seth took off his pajama bottoms and slipped on a pair of skinny jeans and a T-shirt. He quickly found his shoes and put them on before grabbing his wallet and keycard and headed out the door.
It was a short elevator ride down to the lobby and when the doors opened, you could see right into the hotel bar and lounge. Adam looked up when he heard the elevator ding and saw Seth step off. He waved Seth over and he quickly made his way into the bar and over to their table.
They exchanged hugs and greetings before a waitress came over and took Seth's drink order. The waitress quickly brought him a drink and the trio of friends start to talk and bullshit over the weak drinks the bar served.
"How am I suppose to get drunk off of this shit?" Adam complained as he looked his drink.
"I'm pretty sure there's no whiskey in this whiskey sour." Alicia noted as she placed her drink down on the table.
"Can't go wrong with bottled beer." Seth teased and Adam gave him a playful punch on the shoulder.
"Oh my God…" Alicia gasped out.
"What?" Seth and Adam asked at the same time.
"Don't look now Seth." Alicia started. "But that guy over at the bar is checking you out."
"What?" Seth repeated as he whipped his head around to see.
"I said don't look." Alicia groaned as Seth looked at the man sitting at the bar. He smiled at Seth and Seth smiled back before turning to face his friends.
"He's cute." Alicia said as she observed the man. "You should go talk to him."
"I can't believe you're encouraging him to cheat!" Adam exclaimed and Alicia rolled her eyes.
"You know I never liked Randy." Alicia explained.
"Well I guess it wouldn't be cheating since we're in an open relationship." Seth spoke before he thought and saw Alicia and Adam looking at him with shocked looks on their faces.
"When did this happen?" Alicia asked and Seth started to explain everything to them about why Randy wanted to open relationship and the whole agreement.
"I say have fun." Adam commented and Alicia agreed.
"Right now, Randy is having his cake and eating it too…why not do the same." Alicia encouraged. "If Randy is leaving you at home alone to fuck someone else, do the same. Have fun, Seth and if Randy doesn't like it, then it's his fault for opening up the relationship."
"Alicia's right…go for it." Adam added and Seth thought about what they said and they were right. If Randy was going to go out and have fun, he should too. It wasn't fair to him to just sit around and stay miserable while Randy fucked the whole town.
"You two are right…I should go for it." Seth said before taking a sip of his beer.
"You're gonna go for it with him?" Adam asked, pointing to the guy at the bar.
"No, he isn't really doing it for me." Seth explained and Alicia rolled her eyes at that statement. "But I am going to go for it."
After his talk with Adam and Alicia, Seth started to feel better about the open relationship and decided to take a more proactive approach to the whole agreement. After Monday Night Raw, Randy left Seth to his own devices. Instead of waiting in the hotel room like he normally would have done, Seth decided to go down to the hotel bar to see who he could see.
The first person who he would end up in bed with was Brock Lesnar. When Seth went to the bar, he saw Lesnar sitting at a booth by himself. It didn't surprise Seth that Brock was alone. Brock was introverted and typically went out of his way to be by himself. It did surprise Seth when Brock waved him over. Seth inwardly said 'fuck it' and joined Brock at his booth. The two had never really talked before outside of work, so it was interesting that Brock wanted to talk to him now and after a few more drinks, Seth found out Brock's real intentions.
"So, um, I heard you and Orton are opening up your relationship." Brock mentioned and Seth chuckled at his words.
"Adam or Alicia? Which one told you?" Seth asked with a smile on his face. He knew those two couldn't keep their mouths shut. He figured it'd only be a matter of time before the whole locker room knew.
"Alicia is good friends with Paul and Paul casually mentioned it to me when we were driving here." Brock explained and Seth took a gulp of his beer before speaking again.
"And I take it…you want to sleep with me." Seth said and Brock nodded.
"If you'll have me…" Brock trailed off and Seth gulped down his beer before standing up.
"Let's go back to your room."
Even though Brock played a breast on TV, he was surprisingly a gentle and selfless lover. He took his time with foreplay and prepping Seth for sex. He had a large penis and was well aware of it. Throughout sex he would ask Seth if he was okay and when they finished, Brock even checked Seth entrance to make sure he hadn't torn anything. It was two in the morning when the finished and Brock promised that when he came back on the rode they would do this again if Seth's relationship was still open. Seth agreed before leaving the room and going back to his own, smiling at having been thoroughly fucked. Honestly, he could get used to this.
After sleeping with Brock Lesnar, it was if the floodgates broke backstage. He was constantly being propositioned for sex by his peers. Seth never knew he was such a hot commodity backstage, but Adam and Alicia filled him in on some of the things that the Superstars and Divas said about him and a lot of those things made him blush, but it also gave him a newfound confidence. When Randy spoke with him when they made the relationship open, it made him feel ugly but now he felt sexy again. Nothing could take away his confidence again.
He ended up sleeping with Nikki Bella, Cesaro, Wade Barrett, and couple of other Superstars and Divas before being approached by Dean Ambrose and Roman Reigns. Even though they played enemies on TV, they were all still very close off camera. Seth thought of Dean and Roman as his best friends, so it wasn't unusual when Dean and Roman invited him out for drinks at a bar downtown. However after a few drinks, Seth found himself sandwiched between the two at the booth they were sitting in. Seth was sitting on Roman's lap while Dean sat on the side of them. Seth could feel Roman's lips on his neck and Dean kiss his lips. Seth reached out and palmed Dean through his jeans while he rubbed his ass on Roman's clothed erection.
"We should get out of here." Roman said and they all agreed. Dean quickly threw down some money for the drinks before following Seth and Roman outside.
Once they were outside, Roman pulled Seth in for a kiss while Dean came up from behind Seth and wrapped his arms around him. Dean kissed Seth's neck as he rubbed his hard on against Seth's butt. Seth chuckled as he pulled away from Dean and was about to make a funny comment about Dean rubbing against him, but something caught his eyes.
"Randy." Seth said with a smile on his face when he saw Randy staring at him. He tried to move away from Roman and Dean and move over to Randy, but Dean and Roman had a tight grip on him. "Hey, what are you doing?" Seth asked with a friendly smile on his face. He was always happy to see his boyfriend.
"I'm meeting someone." Randy said quickly as he looked over the trio.
"Okay well, have fun!" Seth said and smiled at Randy before leaving with Dean and Roman. Later that night when Roman was fucking him from behind and as Dean shoved his cock in Seth's mouth, Roman made a comment about how glad they were that he had opened is relationship. Seth would have told them how happy he was about the open relationship too if his mouth hadn't been full.
Meanwhile on the other side of the relationship, Randy was not having nearly as much fun as Seth was. He was sure that once they opened their relationship and word got out, men and women would be flocking to him. That wasn't the case. Asides from sleeping with Seth, Randy was completely dry in the sex department. A couple of people approached him backstage when they found out about his open relationship. They asked him if the rumors were true and he said yes. He thought they were going to ask him for sex but it turns out they only wanted to confirm the open relationship with him so they could fuck Seth.
Nikki Bella was one of the people that approached him. By the way she was acting, he thought the Divas champion wanted him but it turned out she wanted Seth. She said John was giving her one night to satisfy her curiosity when it came to Seth and she thanked Randy for opening up their relationship. Cesaro, Wade, and few other Divas and Superstar approached him to confirm the open relationship so they could sleep with Seth.
He couldn't believe Seth was getting all of this attention. He wasn't even that sexy. Yeah he was cute, like a puppy, but he wasn't this sex God that everyone seemed to think he was. They'd be disappointed just like he was and they'd be running to him, or so he thought. As whispers of how good Seth was in bed ran rampant through the locker room, more and more people approached Seth. This wasn't how it was suppose to be, this wasn't fair to him, and it made him sick.
He became even more sick when he saw Seth out with Roman and Dean. He never really cared for Reigns and Ambrose. He didn't know why he disliked them, it was just something about them, but now he had a real reason to hate them. He saw them kissing and rubbing against Seth as they stood outside of a bar. Seth looked up and noticed him and Randy felt really awkward as he spoke with Seth. Seth either didn't feel awkward at all, or just chose to ignore it. He could feel Roman and Dean's judging eyes on him and he couldn't take it anymore. He told Seth that he was going to meet someone in the bar, even though he wasn't, just so he could get out of this awkward conversation. It made his blood boil when Seth told him to have fun because he knew he would be having no fun tonight.
The next day things became exponentially worse when he over heard Roman and Dean talking about their night with Seth. He was in catering, eating some fruit, when the duo sat down only two seats away from him. He could clearly hear everything they said.
"Last night was fucking incredible." Roman commented and Dean nodded.
"Yeah, I don't know if I miss Seth's mouth or his tight ass more." Dean said and Roman let out a chuckle. Randy rolled his eyes, Seth's ass was not that tight.
"That thing he does with his tongue when he sucks cock…" Roman said and they both let out moans and Randy scoffed. He hated Seth's tongue thing. It gave him no pleasure at all.
"Do you think he'd be down for a repeat?" Dean asked and Roman shrugged.
"I don't know, let's find out." Roman said and pulled out his phone.
"Asking if he's up for a repeat, tell him we'll order room service this time and get real food." Dean instructed and Roman began to type. "Not just champagne and strawberries." Roman continued to type and then sent the message when he was done. Randy couldn't help but roll his eyes at the strawberries and champagne comment.
A few seconds later, Roman and Dean got their answer.
"He said yeah…he can't pass up free food. He'll meet us after the show." Roman said and the friends high fived each other.
"Man, I'm so thankful Randy opened their relationship up." Roman said loud enough for Randy to hear. "If he was ours, we'd never share him."
"We'd fuck him well enough that he wouldn't want anyone else." Dean said and the duo laughed.
Randy stood up, knocking her chair over, before storming out of catering. This would end tonight.
Once the were back at the hotel, Randy watched Seth as he got ready for his night with Roman and Dean. He had slipped on a pair of really tight jeans and a tight T-shirt. He'd sprayed cologne on and neatly pulled his hair back into a bun.
Randy couldn't let Seth sleep with anyone else. He was tired of this unfair open relationship and it stopped now.
"Seth, can we talk?" Randy asked.
"Sure baby." Seth said and went over to sit next to Randy on the bed. "What's up?"
"This open relationship." Randy sighed. "It's not working, it has to stop." Randy admitted.
"What!" Seth exclaimed. He was shocked by Randy's admission. "I thought…I thought this was what you wanted. What made you change your mind?" Seth asked and took Randy's hand in his as a sign of support.
"Well, this…this…it isn't fair." Randy struggled to get out.
"Isn't fair?" Seth questioned. "I don't…understand." Seth said in a confused tone. "What's not fair?"
"This!" Randy exclaimed as he took his hand from Seth's and motioned to his outfit. "You have everyone running after you. You've fuck countless men and women since we opened this relationship and I've had zero sex outside of sleeping with you and we both know that isn't really pleasurable for me. I don't understand why all of these people are after you when you're not even that hot. This isn't fair and I want it to stop, now!" Randy ranted and Seth scoffed before shaking his head.
"I see." Seth started and then stood up. "You never wanted an open relationship. You just wanted to fuck whoever you want whenever you wanted while I sat at home twiddling my thumbs."
"No Se-." Randy started.
"No." Seth cut Randy off. "Don't deny it because that's exactly what you wanted. You know what Randy…" Seth walked over to the closet and started to take his clothes out and repack his suitcase. "I'm not going to allow you to just cut me down and speak to me any type of way because there's a locker room full of people that think I'm enough for them." Seth spoke as he finished up packing his suitcase. "We're done Randy." Seth said as he grabbed his suitcase. Randy jumped up to stop Seth.
"Seth please…" Randy started. "We can work through this."
"No we can't…because you don't respect me." Seth spoke. "You used my emotions to get what you wanted and it backfired and you wanted to hurt my confidence so I'd stop the open relationship and that backfired." Seth explained. "Like I said, you don't respect me and I can't be with someone that doesn't respect me." Seth said before leaving the room and making his way to Dean and Roman's room. Tears rolled down his face as he knocked on the door.
Dean opened the door, a big smile on his face, but the smile quickly disappeared when he saw a crying Seth standing in front of him. "I broke up with Randy. I didn't know where else to go." Seth sobbed and Dean pulled him inside the room. Roman came over and took his bags and Dean led him to the bed. Dean laid Seth on the bed and Dean cuddled up behind Seth. Roman laid on the other side of Seth and wrapped his arm around the smaller man.
"He didn't deserve you." Dean said before placing a kiss on Seth's neck.
"You're right." Seth spoke. "He didn't deserve me…" Seth trailed off as he thought back on his relationship with Randy.
"And I'm glad it's over."
Thanks 4 Reading
YoominC16