Peter had been out web slinging as Spider-Man during the night and had to stop a shootout between competing crime families, he was looking forward to just relaxing in his home. He made it to the top window of the home that he shared with his girlfriends Jennifer Walters the She-Hulk and Mary McPherran the reformed villain known as Titania who had been known as Jennifer's arch enemy.
Mary as Titania had been a professional wrestler at the UCWF who to get ahead in the competition volunteered to get experimented on by the Power Broker to gain incredible strength and size. She got caught and banned from the company and in her trials, Jennifer had been representing her but quit when she found out Mary was using falsified documents and perjury to try and get her off. She became a criminal villain and had a huge hatred for Jennifer and a huge desire to best her, blaming her for losing her case.
Peter himself had faced her not long after she became a villain and despite her greater strength, her inexperienced with her powers or fighting other Superhumans combined with Peter' s own speed, reflexes caused her to lose to him in a embarrassingly one-sided defeat and caused her to be terrified of him for years.
During their time dating; Jennifer would like to joke about her biggest rival able to go toe and toe with her and yet she is terrified of her boyfriend. Plus she would wonder if her obsession with defeating Jennifer went beyond that and if she was actually in love with her.
Mary did end up reforming for good in her latest parole and managed to patch things up with Jennifer, Jennifer even introducing Mary and Peter to each other. After a month or so Peter and Jennifer found themselves growing closer to Mary as well as forming attraction to her and Mary revealed that she felt the same for the both of them (having accepted that she was in love with Jennifer after denying it for so long). She ended up admitting that she found Peter's get up among his things when they weren't looking but agreed to keep quiet.
After some discussion, Peter and Jennifer got Mary to join with them making their relationship a polyamorous one. Peter took a moment to look at the photos of them together framed including one of the various roleplay sessions they had with them in their suits. One had Mary posing victoriously as Peter and Jennifer were down to the ground posing as if they were defeated and kissing her boots with Mary holding his mask like a trophy.
It was great with the both of them and Mary had made it fun when she played up her desire to best Jennifer, like wanting to proof that she could kiss or make out better than Jennifer could or when they were sparring. They would also spar with Peter and have him act as a referee for some sparring sessions, including flirting with Peter to rule in their favor when they couldn't agree on who would be the winner.
Peter saw Jennifer and Mary wake up and pull the quilt aside for him, "Are you going to get out of that spandex and join us or what?" Mary asked as Peter quickly stripped down and joined them and found himself sandwiched between his two super strong Amazon esque tall girlfriends as they embraced each other. Mary was thinking that for their next roleplay sessions that she wanted Titania and her fellow hero Spider-Man to take down the villain She-Hulk.
For this little drabble I rewrote Titania's origin and gave a reason for her vendetta against Jennifer as I don't know how it started in the comics. Also I am thinking of trying a new story of universes colliding and with a harem with Spidey being with heroines from different universes. With:
Black Cat
She-Hulk
Power Princess
