"Mom fucked me in the ass because she loves me the most." Lily proudly declared to Chloe and Sophia.
"That's not what it sounded like." Chloe said. "It sounded like you were in trouble." Chloe smirked.
"Oh shut up." Lily said.
"And the cum in your hair doesn't exactly seem very loving to me." Chloe said.
"Shut up or I'll fuck you up the ass!" Lily said.
"You'd get in trouble for that too." Chloe said. Chloe was right. They weren't supposed to be sticking their cocks up the other's asses. At least that's what Alex had told them. Harper had no opinion on the matter. But Lily didn't really care at all that much about getting in trouble.
Chloe knew that usually Lily wouldn't care. She could see the rage in her eyes. But she had just recently been punished so there was no chance at all that she would try to do anything right now.
Chloe was wrong. It happened quickly. Lily shoved her cock into her mouth and fucked her face.
"Make it sloppy my bitchy sister." Lily said. "Because that's the only lube you're getting." Lily then turned to Sophia. "Don't you dare do a thing. Don't you dare call for either of them. Don't you dare go get them." Lily said to Sophia and Sophia just nodded and then once Lily looked back at Chloe she looked down at her growing erection. A symbol of her growing desire to get fucked in the ass.
Chloe made it sloppy. And tried her hardest to make Lily cum because maybe she'd rethink fucking her in the ass. Lily stopped her once she thought that her cock had been sufficiently lubed.
Spit was a terrible lube was what Chloe learned once Lily had pushed her over her own bed and spit on her asshole. Then Lily pressed her cock against and then into Chloe's asshole. Spit. It was a terrible lube. Especially for a virgin. Lily fucked Chloe's asshole. Chloe looked at Lily with anger. But she knew Lily would get in trouble for this. Mom wanted to take all their anal virginities. She would be really mad when she finds out the Lily stole Chloe's virginity. Lily's ass was going to get destroyed when Mom found out. Because mom would definitely know that Chloe's ass had been used, even if she didn't say anything. And of course Chloe was going to say something
But as Chloe was getting off on her punishment fantasies Lily was getting off in Chloe's ass. And it was getting Chloe off too even though she didn't want to.
Chloe shot ropes of cum while Lily fucked her anus. Ropes of cum all over herself.
"Ah ha! You like having cock up your ass!" Lily said.
"Of course I like cock up my ass. But I don't like you forcing yourself on me!" Chloe said. She was thoroughly embarrassed that Lily had made her cum so easily. Maybe she was a submissive slut just like Sophia was. Sophia was watching this whole thing. She stroked herself and wished it was her. Maybe mommy would soon take her anal virginity since she would know that Lily took Chloe's anal virginity and it would be a risk that Lily would take Sophia's as well. Sophia wouldn't mind if Lily forced her cock up her ass at this very moment though.
Lily blew her load into Chloe's anus. Ropes of cum filling her up. Then leaking out once Lily pulled out and Lily kissed Chloe.
"Sophia. Lick this mess up." Lily said. And Sophia willingly did so. Such a submissive slut. Chloe didn't say anything but she was a bit annoyed that Sophia was so willingly eating up evidence. Lily would still get in trouble though.