Disclaimer: I own nothing, everything belongs to Eric Kripke, just borrowing them for your entertainment.
Summary: Previously a Dean/Reader smut oneshot. Now a Dean/OC smut one shot because of a reviewer; same OC from my story 'The Change Up'. In this version, Angelica and Dean have been dating for almost a year and all it takes is a game for them to admit their love for each other and vent their sexual frustration. Castiel does not exist at all in this version. Hope you enjoy and review!
December 25 1996
Christmas Day
Angelica's POV
I was sitting with Sam and Dean in the hotel we were sharing all together drinking eggnog when Sam came up with the idea of playing truth or dare. Of all the days it could've been played it had to be Christmas.
"We should play truth or dare," he said as he takes a sip of eggnog.
It was completely out of the blue but we went along with it.
"I'm in. Dean, you in?" I asked as we sit on the floor in a circle as if we were going to play 'never have I ever'. Dean say yes. All that was missing was the beer bottle if we were playing that game but it was just the opposite.
"Angel, truth or dare?" Sam began.
"Mmm, dare." I said without thinking.
"I dare you to hum a song of your choice and one of us has to guess it."
I start humming the first song that comes to mind by AC/DC knowing it was one of Dean's favorites.
"Highway to Hell!" Dean yelled it out quickly.
I put a finger on my nose and nod at him and he makes a victory move with his arm and a fist with his hand.
"Since you got that correct you should go next. Truth or dare?"
"Truth. Have you ever practiced kissing on the back of your hand pretending you were kissing someone else and who?" Dean replied and asked the question at the same time.
I blush and look down at my dress and start playing with the hem of it. "Yes and I'm not answering that second question. Sam you go. Truth or dare?"
Just as Sam was about to answer, Dean cut in. "No you can't do that! You have to answer the whole question with nothing but the truth!"
Both of us lean subconsciously closer together. "No I don't because you can't ask two questions and make it into one whole question! But fine! It was you I pretended to be kissing. Happy?"
"Very." he said in a satisfied tone as he pulled his head away from mines giving me a small smile.
"Are you two done?" Sam asked looking between us with amusement.
We turn our attention back to him as he continues with the game.
"I choose dare…" he trails off with an mischievous look yet somewhat unreadable expression on his face as we wait for the inevitable.
He was probably sensing our sexual frustration because his next statement confirmed it.
"I dare you to do the 7 minutes in heaven thing but go as far as you need to go."
"Okay we can do that. Right Angel?" he said looking directly in my eyes. His eyes are so enchanting and daydreamy I could fall into them as he gave one of those looks that could either leave one with wet panties or melting at his feet without him even touching you.
I take his hand that he holds out then he stands up first and I let him pull me up and he leads me to the closet, throwing a look over his shoulder at Sam and I hear him laugh at him.
As soon as Dean and I are in the closet, he gets right down to business. He slams me against the shelf inside of it and stalked up close like he was the predator and I was his prey and kisses me fiercely and I feel a spark between us the moment his lips met mines. It was so amazing, beautiful, perfect that I could have kept kissing him until the sun rose. I moan into the kiss as I pressed my lips harder to his, never wanting it to end, and as though sensing it he did the same in return. If not for one tiny problem.
Time. We only had seven minutes hence the name of the game.
He bit my bottom lip after a while before pulling away far too soon to my liking and swiftly somehow gets my wet panties off as if he knew what I was thinking at the moment. Although I became frustrated with the clothes separating us, I somehow get the buttons of his flannel undone and slide it off of him and then my hands travel to his belt. He helps me pull them off along with his boxers.
He pulls my dress off and growls at seeing me without a bra. He leans down and places his mouth on one of my hardened nipples tugging it and then begins sucking on it and then giving the other the same treatment making my mind go fuzzy.
"I hate to ruin the moment…but are…you clean?" It was always good to ask though I had no need to because he had been with me for over almost a year and he didn't set his eye on another woman which left me surprised because I didn't think I was pretty or good enough for him. I knew he was no virgin being that I've known him since almost forever since first grade before we got together. We have kept in contact since then which brings the two of us where we are now.
He begins kissing and nipping my neck which was sure to leave a hickey as I feel him nod before he bends down to get his jeans off the floor and grabs his wallet with the condom in it. He rips it with his teeth and slides it onto his cock.
"Jump." he murmured with his mouth still on my pulse point and I do as he grabs the underside of my thighs.
He reached between us as he covered my mouth with his. Our tongues danced and tasted as I moaned into his mouth as he teased my clit which happened to be the most sensitive. My hips began to move as he goes faster and faster as he rubs.
I whimper into his mouth silently wishing he didn't stop. He begins to line his cock up with my opening and then he sinks into me making me feel like it was my first time all over again but once he started moving it soon turned to pleasure as he started to move slowly to get me use to the sensation.
I groan and moan in complete satisfaction in continued bliss into his mouth before releasing his lips to cover my mouth with my hand to cover any noise I make knowing Sam was on the outside of the closet we both were currently in.
"Aargghhh! Dean Move…faster!" I whispered as I uncover my mouth and he obliges as I dig my heels into his hip to make him go even deeper and closer if possible. I dig my nails into his back as I slide my fingers down probably leaving marks. He kept hitting my g-spot and I let go going completely pliant as I let him take me however he wanted to making whatever possible noise that could come out trying to be as quiet as possible though at the same time.
"Cum for me, baby. I want to see you come undone as I feel you soak my cock, " he growled, gripping my hips so hard it would most likely leave claiming marks in a possessive manner. I swear that just the sound of his voice made me shiver uncontrollably and do anything he wanted.
And so I did immediately after hearing those words as my core tightened around his cock and heat spread everywhere in me like a wildfire leaving me breathless before I leave a hickey on his neck like he did to me earlier knowing he liked to be marked as well.
"Dean!" I yelled unable to hold back as I come down from my orgasm high.
He buries his head into my neck quietly groaning out his own release but never pulled out just yet but lays his head on my shoulder as he speaks. "That was the best 7 minutes in heaven I've ever had!"
I nod panting too out of breath to say anything as he lifts his head up to me and puts his hands to my neck as he kisses me once more and we just taste each other for a while leaving my brain fuzzy once more until we're interrupted by Sammy.
"I love you," I whispered hoping I didn't just ruin what I had with him by saying it for the first time.
He gives me one of those heart stopping charming smiles that spread across his face making my heart go warm and made me forget how to breathe for a minute before he speaks as if I did nothing wrong, "I love you too. Merry Christmas baby."
Sam clears his throat on the other side of the door and says as though either flustered or embarrassed as he said, "Your time has been up but I didn't want to interrupt. Time to come out. I'm sorry guys."
Dean and I both laugh before he ducks his head and sucks on the hickey he left on my neck earlier before soothing it with his tongue as he pulls out taking the condom off and he gets dressed back into his clothes and I put my dress and underwear back on.
"Sammy's never going to look at us the same again with what we just did." I said once we get our laughter under control.
A/N: Don't we all wish we could be with one of our favorite brothers? *sigh* I for one do even if it's just one day. I want to say more but I'll just leave this here. Hope you enjoyed and please review! I know this has been done before but I wanted to try my hand at it, hopefully it's somewhat different. Tell me your thoughts. I take criticism well if I say so myself. According to the Content Guidelines and a reviewer, you based stories aren't allowed so I changed it up and replaced this document without taking it down and used my OC character Angelica from my story called 'The Change Up' for those not satisfied with it going into a Castiel/OC storyline. Reviews are much appreciated!