A Different Timeline

Summary: Elena and Hayley are BFFs regardless of the fact that Hayley is a werewolf and Elena is a witch. What happens when both end up pregnant by Originals (Klaus and Elijah)?

AN: a sort of redo of The Originals with the added benefit of Elejah and Klayley being the endgame pairing as I think that these are the best possible pairings (though this is just my opinion)

Also-I'm sort of back but I needed a break as I was stressed out!

Prelude:

Elena Flemming wasn't sure why she stopped in Mystic Falls with her best (and only) friend Hayley Marshall but she did.

As she walked around the town she took a breath and felt the magic buzzing around her before she entered the 'Mystic Grille' to get something to drink when she saw a sharp dressed man sitting at the bar with some tequila.

Once she sat next to him she discovered that he was a vampire but she didn't seem to care as she took the bottle from him and managed to get them glasses as well as salt and limes. He looked at her with dark brown eyes that hinted at blue around the irises but she didn't mind as she poured them shots.

"Can you hold your tequila?" Elena asked him and he snorted.

"Can you?" He parried as he licked the back of his hand and shook the salt on it. Licking the salt he downed his shot and sucked on the lime wedge.

She smirked and repeated the action on herself before holding out her hand.

"Elena Flemming." He shook it and smirked.

"Elijah Mikaelson."

She wasn't sure who started it but after the tequila ran out they switched to whiskey and somehow they ended up in his house and in his room. Her fingers were undoing his button up shirt while he was tearing her jean shorts off her body.

The feel of skin on skin caused them to burn for more and once they were bare they couldn't stop meeting their pleasure until the morning light when she left him with a kiss and a whispered promise of meeting one day.

"Why are we in the Bayou?" Elena wondered some weeks later as she was delicately sipping some ginger ale and nibbling on saltine crackers. Since her time in Mystic Falls her stomach had been acting up and she didn't want to be reminded of the drinks that fell between her and the vampire because what she knew was happening to her couldn't happen.

"Car broke down," Hayley grunted before they left the safety of the car. "Maybe I can…" she stopped as Elena stiffened, causing them to see witches coming towards them.

Darkness enveloped them…

Elijah was glowering at the witches and Klaus once it was revealed that Klaus and himself were going to be fathers…

The witch he met in Mystic Falls wasn't keeping eye contact with him while Hayley was glowering at them both.

"Were you-" Elijah asked Elena once he caught her eye and she glared at him, moving her hand and making him get a migraine the size of Louisiana.

"It'd be hard to get knocked up when I haven't been with anyone since you unless Hayley can suddenly shift genders," Elena snarked at him. "You're gonna be a daddy and I don't know how vampires can reproduce."

"You've been with someone else," Klaus growled at Hayley. "ADMIT IT!"

"Is there a gender changing spell?" Hayley asked Elena who shook her head. "Yeah…no, you're going to be a dad. It's just been Lena and I for a very long time."

Elijah moved towards Elena and touched her cheek.

"Did you do a spell?" He asked and she shook her head.

"I would remember doing a spell but I don't," she sighed. "I have no idea how it happened and I've been trying to figure it out."

Elijah scooped Elena into his arms while he motioned for Klaus to get Hayley and once the brothers were in their plantation home, Hayley went out back with Klaus following her and Elena was laid on the couch.

"I wanted to tell you once I discovered how this happened," Elena began. "I did but I'm no closer to discovering it. Was magic involved? Was it from the bloodsharing we did? Is there a mystical reason or was it just a one-off chance?" She wanted to curl up in a ball and cry but she wasn't going to.

Elijah was running a hand through her hair and holding her close. He could remember the night pretty vividly and still taste her blood on his tongue.

"I never told you why I was drinking," he mused. "I recently found out that my youngest brother-he's alive-was shacking up with my girlfriend behind my back."

"He sounds like a douche," Elena tittered through a yawn. "I was there with Hayley who got info on where her family could be or something and I felt the magic in the town buzzing." She shrugged one shoulder. "I didn't think that would change the course of whatever my destiny was going." Her hand touched where her bump would be on display and he covered it with his hand. "Where is your younger brother now?"

"Niklaus said that he 'made him regret betraying' me," Elijah sighed. "Knowing Niklaus he possibly killed him or had him neutralized."

"He better not neutralize you or I'll neutralize him," Elena snarled at the thought of Elijah being hurt which freaked her out. "I…I don't…" she didn't finish it but Elijah hushed her and kissed the top of her head.

"He won't," he promised. "I made him a deal that he couldn't refuse."

Hayley was watching the water in the pool move this way and that as the pool cleaner started its work. The familiar scent of Klaus sitting next to her made her stare at him.

"Do you think that I'm going to be a good mother?" She asked. "I never knew my birth parents and my adopted ones kicked me out at thirteen when I triggered my curse."

"Is that when you met Elena?" He asked, bypassing her question. He didn't think that he would be a good father having Mikael for one.

"I met her two years earlier when she was being picked on," Hayley chuckled. "A bunch of kids were teasing her for being a witch. I stood up for her and when I was kicked out her grandparents took me in."

"Did you know that she was a Petrova doppelganger?" He asked and Hayley shook her head.

"Not until Tyler saw us in the mountains and asked if she knew Moira Gilbert," Hayley snorted. "We looked and no-not twins," she added as Klaus opened his mouth. "We both discovered the truth of Petrova doppelgangers."

"What is the truth?" He asked and she turned to look at him, her amber eyes glowing in the light of the moon.

"Answer my question of me being a mother and I'll answer yours," she said with a slight smirk. "I know that you were dodging my question."

"You would be a good-if not better-mother then the one you know," he answered. "I just hope that I'm a good enough father."

"You're going to be a good one," she said honestly. "Though doppelgangers appeared two thousand plus years ago and every ten to thirteen years two doppelgangers will appear until one of the doppels will have children so that it continues."

He nodded and looked at the water.

As the two pregnant women were asleep Elijah was sitting in his study with Klaus.

"Did you neutralize Kol for him betraying me?" Elijah asked.

"I did," Klaus said with a nod. "He and Katerina are neutralized and will regret betraying you."

"Elena doesn't want me neutralized or else you will be," Elijah warned. "I promised her that you wouldn't."

"And I won't," Klaus hummed. "The deal between us still stands-Kol and Katerina are going to be unheard of for ninety years…unless Rebekah catches on to what happened."

Elijah took a drink and held the glass out to him.

"To our impending fatherhood," he hummed and Klaus nodded. "May we not be like Mikael."

"Cheers to that," Klaus downed his drink. "How did you meet Elena?" Elijah flashed him a smirk.

"How did you meet Hayley?" Elijah parried back.

"I saved her from Katerina and Kol and one thing led to another with the use of bourbon." Elijah nodded.

"Mystic Grille where I was drinking tequila and she came in," Elijah admitted. "Drinks were shared, a night and some bloodsharing before she left."

"She was the girl in a green one shoulder shirt and ripped shorts," Klaus realized as he remembered seeing her leave the house, touching her lips with a smile. "I think that she likes you."

"I like her too," Elijah admitted as he poured himself another drink and one for Klaus. "Should I begin dating her?"

"My advice is go for it," Klaus told him. "It's good and I did date Caroline for a while." Caroline Forbes was a sore spot for them as they remembered walking in on Caroline, Stefan and Rebekah the night of the ball while Moira was in Damon's bed.

Sophie had Elena's blood and on the outskirts of New Orleans she bound herself to Elena instead of Hayley.

Sabine watched her in curiosity and slight anger as there wasn't enough of Elena's blood or even a drop of Hayley's blood for the linking spell.

Sabine would have done anything to have her lifeforce tied to that of the wolf who was carrying the one thing Klaus would love that she could kill.