After the loss at Nationals, Jesse can't face his Vocal Adrenaline students and calls his friend Andrea instead. Talking with her, though, painfully reveals his well-concealed sense of inadequacy—and his unquenchable feelings for one Rachel Berry.
This fic is basically 3k words of Jesse moping, in a weird half-dialogue half-rant format. I've felt the need to write this since I've rewatched 'Nationals': that three-second shot of Jesse on the verge of tears has been haunting me, and I had to get the story out of my system. Most of all, I needed him to get some of the love and validation that the show deprived him of.
In my mind, it isn't at all out of character for Jesse to be this miserable in private. He is crazy talented and he knows it, but he also has deep self-worth issues (due to his demanding and not very loving upbringing), for which he compensates with pride and overconfidence. He also has his (in)famous showface that rarely goes away, and he doesn't feel comfortable being emotionally vulnerable. Except with Andrea—and, well, with Rachel.
By the way, I know Jesse and Andrea's friendship is mostly fanon, but I like it very much nonetheless.
Jesse had never felt so upset in his life. His heart, his mind, his guts were telling him conflicting things, and his knees were starting to give way under him as the adrenaline of the competition slowly went away. He barely managed to close the door to his room before he had to sit on the bed. He was feeling lightheaded, with black pushing at the edge of his vision—the way he would feel after a long training when he hadn't eaten enough. But it wasn't low blood pressure, Jesse knew that. It was the same dreadful mix of emotions and thoughts as that damn day two years before, but somehow a hundred times worse. Then it had been divided loyalties, two shattered hearts, and the gut punch of feeling like an utter bastard, but now… damn, he'd added so many failures in the past two years that he had no idea how his showface was still so good. He was starting to feel like a hollow husk at times. Something had definitely broken back then, and the constant, cyclical reminders of what he'd stupidly lost weren't doing him any favors—that evening after Nationals, the castle of cards that had been Jesse St. James's so-called adult life was a breath away from collapsing, once and for all.
Jesse kicked off his shoes, threw the suit jacket haphazardly on a chair, and lay down on the bed, trying to steady his breath against his inner turmoil. After a while, he felt blindly around his legs for his phone, until he found it lying precariously near the edge of the bed. He then flung the duvet up over his head and snuggled under it, shirt and nice slacks be damned. He unblocked his phone and opened his recent calls, dialing his best (only?) friend's number.
"Victory boy! Hey!" a chipper voice answered.
"Andrea…"
"Ah. You didn't win, then."
Jesse sighed. Andrea's reaction made him realize he sounded as dejected as he felt—something he'd long learned how to conceal, but the Chicago air must have jinxed him or something. Or maybe he was simply beginning to crumble under the pressure of his feelings. Whatever.
"I feel like crap, Andy. I should be with the guys, drowning our disappointment in ginger ale or what-have-you, but I don't even have the energy for that. I barely managed to tell them I was proud of them—and I am—before I had to get out of there. They were crying, Andy, and the looks on the seniors' faces… I just—I couldn't stay."
Jesse knew he was rambling, but a big part of his and Andrea's friendship had always been taking turns in unloading while the other listened and then offered some honest advice. No one else in his life had ever made him feel safe enough to be so open and vulnerable—except for Rachel, but he'd thrown away his chance to have her at the other end of the line again, hadn't he?
"I'm sure they understand, Jesse. You told them you were proud, and that's what matters. Remember how nice it felt when they would tell us? Eased the disappointment of losing somewhat, no?" Andrea asked, a tinge of wistfulness in her voice.
"Yeah, well… god, they worked so hard for this. I really thought we'd win, you know? I honestly miss the high of victory—as I'm sure you do, too," Jesse said with a smirk, getting a chuckle from Andrea in response. "Nevertheless, Carmel High is going to kick me out the minute I get back to Akron, as they so candidly told me they would when I got the job. And I guess they have all the rights to do it—what kind of failure am I, four-time champion and I can't even coach fucking Vocal Adrenaline to victory? I wouldn't want to keep me around either."
Jesse heard himself getting whinier by the minute, and he hated it, hated how earnest he ended up being while talking with Andrea (and with Rachel, too—he never quite managed to keep his walls up for long with her either… Stop! Stop thinking about that!). Andrea hesitated and exhaled, and Jesse could imagine her shaking her head as well.
"Why didn't you win, though?" she asked at last. "I've seen those videos you sent me: the choreo was incredible! What happened?"
"A ragtag bunch of misfits, that's what happened," Jesse answered, trying to sound mean but only managing desolate. Figures. "The New Directions really busted their asses this year, apparently. You should have seen them, everyone performed at a level they'd never reached before—and you know how they've always been so endearingly energetic. I loathe to admit it, but they were great, and I guess they did deserve to win. Probably. Couldn't tell that to my guys, though," he chuckled, gloomily.
"I'm glad to hear that," Andrea said, with a careful, knowing tone that Jesse instantly dreaded. "Is that it, though? This whole call just because the New Directions finally snatched first place after years of trying?"
Jesse didn't answer. He couldn't, he wouldn't tell Andrea the real reason of his moping—besides, he knew she could easily guess it.
"Unless..." (There it is.) "What about Rachel, Jesse? Did she sing?"
Jesse was thankful the conversation was happening on the phone, Andrea at one end of the nation and himself buried under a duvet in a hotel room in Chicago. He wouldn't have been able to sustain her gaze, otherwise. At least on the phone he didn't need his showface, and his instinct to flee from emotional vulnerability was somewhat tamed (but not much).
"Jesse?"
He squeezed his eyes shut and gripped the phone more tightly, hoping to keep at bay the flood of emotions that he could sense coming. At last, he whispered: "Yeah, she did. It's All Coming Back to Me Now".
"Oh."
And that was it. Andrea's understanding tone was all it took for the floodgates to open and for Jesse's rambling, vulnerable side to come out in full force. Tears threatened to escape his eyes, but he them firmly shut—he would not cry.
"God, Andy, when she sung that song—it felt like she was saying all those things to me!" Jesse's voice traitorously cracked at that last word.
"I don't think that's—"
"I know!" Good lord, he was whining again. "I know that it's ridiculous! that I'm reading too much into it, that they chose the song way beforehand and Rachel has much better things to think about than me… But what if she was singing about us after all? The words are rather fitting, and she knows that—same as she knew we were bound to meet here tonight. It's there, Andy, the whole story! Me being an idiot, all my mistakes and the hurt I inflicted her—she was reproaching me, and I cannot blame her because I deserve it. And I especially deserve to hear it from her magnificent voice, even if god knows I don't need to be reminded of what I did to her." Jesse was breathing heavily, almost unable to articulate his feelings, his words spilling out at an alarming speed.
Andrea remained silent for a few seconds, then answered with a deliberate yet soothing tone—the one she reserved for Jesse's rare mopey moments. "I don't think your history with Rachel had anything to do with the song, Jesse." He scoffed lightly, but she ignored him. "Besides, you were a teenager back then, and you were forced between a rock and a hard place. Shelby was a bitch that manipulated you and treated both Rachel and the parents of that baby like dirt. Sure, you were a bit of a dick, but you've got to cut yourself some slack. You were not stupider than the average teen in love, all things considered."
Jesse tried to scoff again, but what escaped his throat sounded more like a sob than anything else. "Andy, you don't understand," he pleaded, pressing the heel of his free hand on his eyes. "I threw away the one truly warm thing in my life because Shelby threatened to take away my scholarship to UCLA, and look how well that went," Jesse laughed bitterly. Ah, the familiar taste of self-deprecation. Saying all that out loud felt better than just mulling over it constantly, though. "I'm such an imbecile—I got college handed to me on a silver platter, and I couldn't even manage to float just above the pass grade? Or, I don't know, use my fucking brain for a change? And to think I would be so conceited about it, as if I could ever hope to accomplish anything intelligence-related…"
"Jesse, stop!" Andrea interjected vehemently. "You're spiraling and you're starting to sound like your father. You're not stupid, you're not brainless—you're smart, and the most brilliant guy I know as far as musical theater is concerned. And don't start with how acting or singing or whatever is bullshit, because I'll come down there, slap you, and then find your dad and punch him on his ugly mug." At that, Jesse felt a sharp surge of affection for his friend, regardless of her proclivity for mild physical threats. "We all sweated blood in Vocal Adrenaline, but we were happy and good—you above all, because performing is your passion and your talent. Who cares if you didn't pass gen eds? You're wonderful, and you will take Broadway by storm soon."
"Ms. Tibideaux didn't seem to think so," Jesse replied, dejectedly.
"Who?"
"Carmen Tibideaux. NYADA?"
"What does she have to do with anything now?" Andrea asked, confused. "That was years ago."
"Yeah, right—the first of my many failures." Jesse's tone was more bitter than he expected. He intentionally hadn't thought much about his audition since, but he guessed disappointments never actually stopped stinging, did they?
"Come on, Jesse…"
"I didn't get in, okay? No point in sweetening the pill. I was good but apparently not enough—and I always knew that, but now I have confirmation from the woman's own voice that I 'showed promise' but couldn't overcome the obstacles to be the best. So really, I don't know what the fuck I'm doing with my life." Was he being overdramatic and overly self-critical? Absolutely. At that moment, though, Jesse had no idea how to stop.
"Enough!" Andrea exclaimed. Deep down, the rational part of Jesse's brain had realized he was being maddening, but he also had to admit he didn't mind Andy's forceful tone. It felt strangely soothing, being told to get a grip from someone who cared about him.
"I can't believe you are saying this," she pressed on. "I've already told you: you are incredible, and I won't let you wallow in this kind of negativity. The audition was years ago, and believe me, I've seen you get absurdly better in the meantime. Ms. Tibideaux said you showed promise, and that's good! You did and you do, and you will reach even higher that she could ever imagine."
Jesse hummed, not entirely convinced but certainly relieved that someone else was eager to vouch for his talent. He knew he was good (okay, very good), but that didn't mean he wasn't, from time to time, afraid he'd been deluding himself due to his own arrogance.
"When did you speak with the woman?" Andrea asked.
"She was here to see Rachel perform. And when I went and told her she shouldn't let Rachel slip through her fingers, she remembered me and made a list of all the flaws in my audition. Lovely experience, really," Jesse said, with a bitter chuckle.
"Aw, you put in a good word for Rachel—that's so sweet! Did you tell her?"
"I can't! Are you crazy? She cannot know ever. I don't deserve her knowing, if anything I owe her." Jesse replied, his voice half-strangled. (Pathetic.) "Rachel and I bantered for a couple of minutes before the competition, and it almost got me punched by Finn, in addition to giving me some serious doubts about my ability to function properly." He smiled at the memory. Rachel's red dress was still incredibly vivid in his mind. "God, Andrea, you should have seen her—she was radiant. I'd ever seen her inhabit the stage so perfectly. She is the one who deserves to take Broadway by storm and who will. She's a powerhouse, and she's absurdly talented, and tonight she looked so beautiful with that smile of hers, and then she sang Céline and I couldn't—"
Jesse heard Andrea exhale, as if ready to answer, but he rambled on, unable—unwilling—to stop now that someone was there to listen to him for once.
"I just—I miss Rachel so much. She earnestly thought I was worth all the fuss. Even with Shelby, it'd always seem like my work was barely acceptable, and that all the trophies were just due to luck and the power of a good routine or something. Which yeah, I guess is true, but—honestly, Andy, except for you, Rachel's the only person who'd always tell me how much she liked when I performed, and how good I was. I was starved—I am starved for that, Andy. D'you know my grades improved while I was in Lima with her? I actually had to study, and I wasn't half bad at it. All thanks to her. God knows why she stayed with me after the initial razzle-dazzle, because she was way better that I could ever deserve. And she definitely deserved more than yours fucking truly," Jesse spat out.
"And I guess she will have it," he continued, barely taking time to breathe, "since she's getting married soon to Finn. And sure, I hate him and he hates me, but I can see how Rachel looks at him, and he looks at her the same way. I mean, he's a rhythmically-challenged dumbass, but I can't deny he makes her happy—that's the truly important thing. I ruined everything, and I know I'd never be able to make her feel that way. I think Rachel could really be the one, you know? I feel it in my bones, I'll never be as happy with anyone else as I was with her… But it doesn't matter. All that matters is Rachel won't have a fuckup like me beside her, who'd just end up wiping her wonderful smile away."
Jesse had to stop—his throat was aching due to the strain of putting one coherent word after another, of trying to talk as fast as his inner turmoil demanded. Tears were escaping his eyes and running down his cheeks and in his hair. He didn't care that he was crying, though: he already felt like an utter failure, another embarrassing thing wouldn't change anything. Besides, it was nice, having a friend listen to him while he moped and pined. Crying is good, right? It helps get the toxins and the sadness out, doesn't it? A good cry and I'll stop feeling like shit—
"Oh, Jesse…" Andrea whispered after a beat, and that shattered Jesse's attempts at regaining his composure—he started sobbing uncontrollably, burying himself more and more under the duvet.
"Why didn't you ever tell me that?" Andrea asked, softly. "God, Jesse, I wish I was there to hug you. Believe me, though, Rachel is right—everything she told you and everything she thinks about you is true. You've had a lot of shitty people in your life, but never for a second doubt that Rachel was sincere and saying things as they are. You're brilliant and very talented, whether you believe it or not," Andrea added, in a decisive tone that drew a wet smile from Jesse, "and no amount of Shelby or Ms. Tibideaux or your asshole of a father can claim otherwise. All that hard work and dedication… you do deserve the world, Jesse."
Calming his breath enough to answer took Jesse a moment—his gratefulness to Andrea and his longing for Rachel were a killer combination, and he didn't want to start bawling again.
"Thank you, Andy," he finally managed to say. "I just wish I'd made fewer mistakes, you know? Maybe then I wouldn't always feel like such a failure, maybe I wouldn't be so lonely all the time and it wouldn't hurt this much… I know things between me and Rachel probably won't ever be mended, but gosh what I wouldn't give to sing with her on a real stage, to have a partner that inspires me to be better and lets me share the spotlight with her." Jesse exhaled shakily, willing himself to not cry until he had finished talking. "It's too late now, though, and it's all my fault, no point in denying that. I just wish for her to be as wonderful and captivating as she was tonight, forever—she lit up the whole place. I really hope I didn't make an ass of myself with Ms. Tibideaux, and that Rachel's dreams will come true. No, scratch that: I know they will. I just pray I'll be able to get a glimpse of her happy as can be."
Andrea's silence at the other end of the line was almost deafening, but Jesse pressed on, feeling that he'd never have another chance (nor the nerve) to admit to it all out loud.
"Sorry for the rant, Andy. We lost Nationals and it hurts like hell, but it will pass—it's going to be a nifty addition to the You're A Failure pile, though," Jesse mused, with a self-deprecating chuckle. "I have no idea what my plans for the future are going to be, after Carmel High parts ways with me. I guess I could finally try and go to New York for real. It's just that, you know, seeing Rachel again really threw me for a loop, even after all this time, and I'm not sure why—"
"It's love, Jesse," Andrea interjected. "The way you talk about Rachel—you love her."
Jesse inhaled sharply. Repeating that to himself was one thing, but hearing someone else say it so matter-of-factly felt real, definitive. (Scary.) "Hurray for me, then," he muttered, at a loss for words to describe how his heart was ablaze, dismayed, and longing at the same time.
"I really hope you and Rachel will put your cracked pieces back together, Jesse," Andrea said, sounding softer than she did at any other point in the phone call. "You both deserve a great life, and to have your talents shine—you and her alongside each other? Musical theater won't ever be prepared, let me tell you."
"Thank you, Andy." Jesse's eyes had filled with tears once again, and he'd once again buried himself under the duvet, in hopes of preventing the onslaught of painful memories he was sure would come. But it was no use—he thought back to Rachel singing, and a loud sob escaped his lips. Tears started falling freely down his cheeks and neck, reaching his hair and the collar of his shirt. "I wish. I'm not sure I believe that, but god, I wish."