A/N: I finally managed to wrap up the PWP fic I always wanted to make since the Panty Pinata Polarization ep. Credit goes to Lee Kadivar for the later parts of the story!
"No! That's not fair!" Sheldon was nervously pacing up and down in his living room behind the beige single-seater. Arguing with the person on the other end of the phone line. Leonard was sitting there grinning silly. He was barely holding the chuckles, listening to the conversation.
Howard and Raj were preoccupied the whole time with their quest to find the mansion of supermodels somewhere around Los Angeles. They knew Sheldon was in another spat with Penny, but didn't pay much attention to it.
"Sheldon Lee Cooper, you go and apologize to that young lady right now!" Mary Cooper demanded over the phone. Penny earlier revealed everything about her standoff with Mary's son, after Leonard gave her the phone number. Mary found them amusing, even flirty, but in the end, she wanted Sheldon to end the standoff before any of them took it too far.
"Alright! Goodbye." Sheldon ended his conversation, promising his mother to make things right with Penny. He was furious. Letting his mother into his game with Penny crossed the line. Leonard smiled behind his back, he was sure that Sheldon will now apologize to Penny and the days-lasting dispute he had with Penny, will finally be over. His mother was the last hope, Sheldon always listened to her.
Bad news for him, Sheldon did not buckle under. No. Not this time. He gripped the wireless headset, almost crushing the casing, his right fist started to shake. He took a deep breath and closed his eyes, his usual way of relaxing. Sheldon calmly turned around and walked slowly towards the leather couch and placed the phone into the holder. He slowly crouched down towards Leonard, sitting in the beige armchair.
"That's strike three, Leonard."
Leonards' face became pale, his heart sank into his stomach. His plan did not work and now Sheldon was heading over to Penny's, more determined than ever. Leonard noticed his dark eyes and dead straight expression. Who knows what he will do to her now.
"Sheldon, please. Just end it already!"
"Oh, I'm ending it, right now." Sheldon replied and gave Leonard one last look, before heading towards the 4B.
*Knock, knock, knock
"Penny."
*Knock, knock, knock
"Penny."
*Knock, knock, knock
"Penny."
As soon as Penny opened the door, Sheldon pushed her out of the way and stormed inside her apartment. Penny gasped at his sudden entrance into her apartment. She was left surprised standing by the door, getting annoyed again by Sheldon's behavior.
"What the hell do you think you're doing barging in here like that..." Penny closed the door and turned around to face him for another round of dispute.
"Spare me your talk this time. You know very well why I'm here." He turned around and faced her. Arms crossed over his blue Superman T-shirt.
"I'm sorry, ok? Leonard gave me the phone number to stop this..." Penny waved her arms back and forth between them. "Whatever it is we got ourselves into." Penny noticed his deadly stare burning right into her eyes.
Before she could finish, he was already towering over her, slowly coming closer with each short step.
"Forget… Leonard." Sheldon demanded, almost angry when he heard and said his name. "The only thing that matters is what you want."
Penny was slowly stepping back until she bumped into the door. With Sheldon getting uncomfortably closer with each sentence. It felt like a slow motion dance. She kept backing up, he kept coming towards her. She kept stepping back and watching his eyes. He kept staring into hers, as to find out who will twitch first.
"What are you trying to accomplish here, Penny? Do you want me to stop?" Penny felt scared with a feeling of a lump in her throat. Her breath was short, as was her step. She was becoming scared of him. What is he up to?
"I..." Penny tried to fight back, but her voice lacked that distinct fiery tone. His confidence began to affect her.
"Or does this game... excite you?" His blue eyes locked deep into her scared deer-in-the-headlights green and blushed cheeks. Her plan failed and now her villain grew more powerful than ever. Damn his blue eyes staring at her like that, making her lose the words.
"I, umm… just wanted to have a little fun…" Penny almost flirted with him, acting like a naughty school girl who got caught.
"Does playing games with the guys provide you with a particular satisfaction?" Penny's right heel bumped into the door at that moment, causing her to gasp again. There was no way out, he now had her pinned against the door.
"Sheldon, please. I didn't mean to go this far… But there's something about you… Something that makes me go further and further…" Penny tried again to plead her way out of this, begging him to stop. He bumped his palms flat on the door on each side of her torso, trapping her against the door and his body. It was loud enough to make her flinch and gasp again, realising she was now completely at his mercy. There was a part of her that knew he won't go too far. The other was getting scared.
He was never this aggressive or close to her before. But his stare, pose and voice… Everything about him in that moment triggered some primal, animalistic urges in her, wanting him to do with her whatever he desired.
"It's too late to apologise, Penny. I won't let you get away this time. For all the times you were eating my food… Sitting in my spot."
Sheldon closed the little distance their bodies had with each sentence. He saw the dissipating green in her eyes, he felt her short breaths on his neck.
"Wearing these scanty… tight clothes…" His gaze retreated from her eyes to her sexy body, checking her out for head to toe. Her current fiery red sexy top proved his point nicely. Teasing him with her cleavage and exposed belly button. Huh, she thought. He did notice them after all.
Sheldon brought his right hand up to her face and slowly ran his fingers across her beautiful blushed cheeks.
Penny felt like her heart was about to explode and her body would melt right there. She closed her eyes, causing a tear to run down on her cheek. Getting caught by his touch.
"Ruining my laundry night." He was almost whispering, they were so close together.
Penny was left speechless. She was trying to gather her thoughts for a comeback. She must not allow showing any more of her weakness. The weakness in her knees. Or how aroused she became by his words and closeness.
"Turning my world into chaos..." His right hand was now coming down across her neck, tracing her perfect curves across her bare shoulders and down to her waist. Gently gripping her. Feeling her taut shape. Pressing her still and against the door. His hand soon reached the edge of the red top she was wearing. "And I cannot stop you." His fingers dug into her exposed warm skin on her waist, slowly travelling towards her butt. He was actually feeling her up at this point. And her betraying body did nothing to stop his advances.
"Sheldon? Isn't this getting a little out of hand for you? If you don't stop this now..." Her voice was shaky and scared of what he will do next. But still didn't want him to stop.
"Didn't I warn you about playing with forces beyond your ken?" He gave her ass a little squeeze. "Mmm, nice and tight." He whispered. "And judging by your reactions…" He moved his hand across her hips, tracing his fingers across a line of exposed skin between her red top and black pants.
"Sheldon..." Penny tried to stop him by placing her hand onto his, right on her belly. It only stopped him for a second.
"I'd say… wet… as well." Just as his hand slipped into her pants and middle finger scraped across her bare clit.
His low sexy growl "Mmmm, yes you are…" almost made her come right there.
"Sto...Ohh… fuck… mmm..." Penny' knees buckled under his touch and tone in his commanding voice. She closed her eyes and leaned her head back onto the door. Struggling to stand on her feet as his index and middle fingers kept nudging deeper inside her. It wasn't long until he gathered enough of her juices. He slowly removed his palm and rubbed his thumb against the wet fingers. They both stare at them as he spread them apart, with glistering substance sticking between them. Tip of his tongue swiftly sampled her sex juice and forever stored her scent.
Penny's left hand finally reached up towards the bulge in his pants.
"Looks like I'm not the only one who finds this exciting… It's about time you finally stop resisting your urges." She whispered and almost pressed her lips onto his. "We both know it's the only way to settle this."
He closed his lips onto hers, both tongues soon found each other in a fiery dance around their fused mouths. The sound of deep kissing and moaning filled her apartment. Penny held onto his body as he pressed her against the door. He held her up with his arms again, gripping her sexy ass.
As he came up for air, Sheldon pulled her top over her head and let it fall onto the floor. That red has been driving him insane, especially because she wore no bra underneath.
Penny felt his erection again, now pressing against her belly. She needed him just as much as he needed her. Sheldon's depressed urges were getting free. Penny knew all along he had a deal. Now finally awakened, she will get the better end of this deal. Compared to Leonard and the other guys, Sheldon won't play nice or gentle tonight. The way she teased him these days, she couldn't wait to see what he has in store for her.
"So, this is what you wanted all along..." Sheldon swiftly pulled her pants to her ankles. Penny took a step to get one leg free and he pushed them further apart. He didn't bother with her panties, instead he just moved them aside.
"I knew you wanted the same thing. I know you do. Ugh..." She felt his fingers now playing with her wetness again. This time more, reaching deeper into her sex. Mapping out her pleasure areas. Mentally cataloguing what spots affected her the most.
"Fuck!" Penny exclaimed as Sheldon found her g-spot. His long nimble fingers reached spots no one else ever could. She knew as her pleasure increased that this was going to be one wild ride. "Shel-ommf..."
Sheldon's mouth covered Penny's as he had a second finger to join his first. He moved them back and forth as if walking them against the walls of her vagina. Mint exploded onto Penny's taste buds as Sheldon stroked her tongue with his. Quick little flicks that only served to heighten her senses.
Her nipples were hard pebbles now. His fingers… soaked in the juices flowing from her.
"Is this what you wanted all along?" his voice moved to her ear. Her body pressed harder against her front door. "You push and push me until I snap?"
"I want you to stop being so damn controlled. A little chaos is a good thing." Penny whispered before biting and sucking on his earlobe. "Kiss my Barbie already..."
"Embrace the chaos…" Sheldon half moaned. "Are you sure you want me to do that?"
Penny suddenly bit Sheldon's neck as she pushed against his fingers still inside her. Her orgasm getting so close…
Sheldon released a deep low growl as he removed his hand from her wet warmth to pull down her soaked underwear. The last little piece of clothing left on her. His free hand wrapped itself into the hair at the back of her head. He pulled her head back as his lips descended to her neck. Nibbling, sucking, quick short bites followed. He slowly kissed his way lower and lower. Her lovely breasts were the first stop. So firm and perfectly sized for his hands and lips. Tweaking her pebble hard nipple with one hand while circling the other with his tongue.
Her taut belly showed a faint hint of muscles as he kissed past her belly button towards her inner thighs. Penny bumped her head back into the door when he missed his target on purpose. She tried to guide him in between her legs, but he really loved to tease her further. Slowly inching closer and closer.
His long tongue finally darted into her wet clit, circling a nub of flesh and sucking on her lips.
At the same time, his fingers kept pushing and worming inside as far as he could get them, bringing her closer to the brink again.
Penny had nowhere to lean her hands as Sheldon expertly continued to eat her out. She finally found some balance on her legs and caressed his short dark hair.
He gripped her right leg at the knee and brought her upwards for even a better access to her wet pussy.
"Mmm, you're so good at this, sweetie… yesss..."
Penny leaned her foot on his shoulder and gripped onto the door knob for better balance. His combination of circling and kissing around her lips and clit, together with slow fingering was driving her insane. His heightened senses of touch and hearing of her moans warned him when she was about to cum. Preventing yet again her first orgasm was all part of the game.
"Oh fuck… you… So close..." Penny couldn't stop the loud gasps of pleasure coming from her mouth. Her denied orgasm caused her entire body to be alight with sensations. This is what she had been needing.
Sheldon smirked down at her as he straightened his body. He watched a beautiful flush crept up her body as his eyes devoured her. The hand in her hair tugged hard, pulling Penny's head backward, tilting her face upward to his.
"Careful of what you ask of me, Penny. I am not like the others." Sheldon's deep Texan twang slowly taking over his normal voice. "I don't play nice."
"Fuck… you…" Penny slowly enunciated each word between heavy breaths, fighting the pain."...Doctor. And your rules."
Penny watched amazed as Sheldon's control fully snapped. His hand tightened in her hair. His eyes grew dark… stormy… reminding her of the Nebraskian summer storms back home. He released a guttural half-groan half-growl that sent flashes of pleasure through her body only to settle in her convulsing loins. Penny knew she would never forget that sound.
Sheldon's mouth crashed into hers as he slammed her into his body. His hands and mouth pulled her back away from her door as he stepped back. It was almost an exact rewind of their earlier movements. The major difference being that Sheldon was not only touching her this time but biting, sucking and nibbling on any sensitive flesh he could reach.
Suddenly Sheldon spun Penny around so her back was to his chest. Then he spun them both to face the arm of her love seat and took a few steps to push her over. His strong hands forced her to bend at the waist so he had complete access to her. Her pants and moans were the only sound filling the room.
Penny couldn't believe that this was actually happening. Her whack-a-doodle doctor managed to strip and manhandle her better than any jock ever has been able to. She hadn't even gotten a chance to fight back. He had distracted her so thoroughly that she couldn't tell just how she went from getting fingered while pressed into the door, to being bent over her couch, naked, with only her panties still hanging on wrapped around one ankle.
Clank…
Penny's breath froze at the sound of his belt hitting the floor. "Sheldon… you don't wear a- OH FUCK!" Penny screamed as she felt Sheldon's bigger-than-average thrust into her hard enough to finally trigger her orgasm. He slowly pulled out till just the head was in her spasming wet channel.
"Is this what you want, Kitten?" Sheldon's deep baritone twang sounded in her ear. "Is this how you want me?" he matched his words with his moves, penetrating into her.
"Mmm yessss… Fuck… me…" He finally had her completely naked bent around the arm of the green sofa, his hand pressing her back down into a submissive position. Legs spread wide with a clear view of her glistering sex. He slowly took off his superman shirt and a long sleeve lime-green shirt underneath. He quickly grabbed her wrists and used that to tie them together behind her back.
"Wait, what are you doing... " Penny tried to resist being tied up, but he did it so fast, she barely could catch a glimpse of him gripping her hips. She never looked sexier to him than in that moment. Turned on and angry at the same time, looking back at him from that position. Blonde hair falling over her face, teeth grinning. Her gorgeous rear stuck up completely at his disposal to get banged in doggy position.
"Ohh… Yesss!" Penny's answer changed to a high pitch whine as Sheldon slammed balls deep into her suddenly. "Oh… Fucck….. Doctor…." Her head shot straight, jerking in the rhythm of him slamming hard into her from behind. "Fuck… me… ohh…. Yess…" Each short word muffled by the pillow her head was leaning onto, matching his thrusts. Tied up and manhandled, she enjoyed it much more than she thought she would... and should.
"Yes?" he growled as he changed to a soft gentle thrust. He pulled her head up but kept her hips pressed into the arm of the couch so that he could talk to her ear directly. He gently pushed in and out of her. " Tell me…"
Penny repressed a moan at his commanding tone. She did not want to lose this fight… she couldn't show him weakness. But at his dark chuckle, she knew… she knew she had lost. Her secret… her darkest secret she hid from everyone… he knew. He knew!
"You like this, don't you..." Sheldon licked up the side of her neck tasting the salt from her sweat. "Tell me… Do you like being dominated by me like this?"
There was no way Penny was going down without a fight. "Fuck you!" She gritted out between her teeth while trying hard not to moan. Smack! Her butt now marked pink with the print of his palm. She shrieked in such a sexy way.
"We will see…" Smack! The sound of his hand slapping her ass again. Penny shrieked each time he did this, while still giving it to her hard. He loved the sight of her pinkish branded ass marked with his palm. Punishing her for her disobedience.
Sheldon grabbed both of her tied wrists and held them both in one hand. He wrapped the other large hand around the back of her neck. He could feel her pussy clench him harder as he pushed her head into the couch cushion.
Sheldon stepped over her legs and pushed them close together. In this position with closed legs her pussy felt even tighter. Making her sexy hourglass figure even more prominent. Sheldon marvelled her perfect butt, shaking like a jello as his cock disappeared into her sex again with each thrust.
Penny desperately tried to rub her clit against the armrest cushion, but with legs tight together, just couldn't get to it.
Penny had never been so turned on before. Bent over with her hands tied behind her back and her ass spanked hard a few times. All while getting slammed with his fat cock to the brink. Knowing that Sheldon of all the people knew her most secret kink as well. She knew in her heart that she was a goner. That she was… his. But her head did not want to listen. She is an alpha female. She doesn't bend to other people's will. But then again, Sheldon himself is not like other people. How the hell can he make her willingly bend over, casually fucks her brains out and at the same time, responds how that's physically not possible? She hated her opposing feelings.
Sheldon slowly straightened back to his full height. He could see the resistance in every fiber of her being as he undid the knot and let go of her arms. She still had it in her. Now probably more than ever before.
He understood that drive. To not give in. To not conform. To not… submit. Penny was no pushover and the more she fought him, the more aroused he became. Oh, he would stop if she truly wished it… but he knew. He knew what she needed. Just as he knew he would relish giving it to her.
Sheldon pulled back, pausing for just a moment. Waiting for the cue to move. Waiting… waiting… there! Penny's body relaxed just enough, now resting on her elbows…
"Oh, Fuuuuckk!" Penny screamed as Sheldon suddenly slammed into her pussy deeper as ever before, hitting her cervix. She clamped her muscles down around him. Two could play this game. She knew her Kegels would come in handy someday.
Sheldon grunted as her muscles contracted around his hard cock. Pulsing rhythmically around it. A rhythm… not naturally done. He looked down at the submissive blonde beneath him. Her body showed she was enjoying this but there was something… else.
Sheldon shifted his hold on her head, turning her sideways so he could see her eyes. "There…" he thought to himself. "There's my hellcat."
Sheldon could see the fiery spirit that always lit up her eyes during their spats. That passion that never failed to ignite his own. His passion flared as he saw the defiance in her eyes. He wanted to control that passion. To mold it into what she could be. The best version of herself.
"Tell me, Kitten…" Sheldon practically purred in her ear. "Whose are you."
Penny groaned, but did not want to answer as Sheldon continued to slam into her. Filling her each and every time to the max. Seeing how her lustful pussy is eagerly swallowing his whole cock, with fluids glistering all around making this an easy effort. Her whole body was jerking from the force of his thrusts.
She tried to move positions to get a different angle so she could drive him wild and find her own release, only to be forced back down on the next thrusts. Above all, she didn't want to admit and submit. But with each slam of his cock, her shields of defiance were coming down.
"Sheldon…" Penny pleaded.
"Yes, Kitten?" Sheldon changed the angle of his hips. He knew he was keeping her on the brink of another orgasm. The new angle made him stroke her g-spot with each movement of his hips. Each stroke was a little different than the previous. Harder… faster… slower… softer. He constantly changed his rhythm so she had no hope of any kind of control. However… not with enough pressure to stimulate her orgasm. Thus further heightening the pleasurable torture he knew she was experiencing.
Sheldon was one hundred percent, absolutely, positively in charge. Of her body, her pleasure, her release… And she loved every minute of it. Every stroke, every angle change… Each stroke shooting her past any previous encounters before. His deep, Texan voice melted her and set her on fire.
She nearly blacked out from pure pleasurable torturous need as he released a deep, deep, growl. Her eyes rolled as she felt the peak getting closer… closer… standing with just her heels still on the edge of bliss. Tingles of electric pleasure scuttled along every nerve ending in her body setting her body on fire. He pulled back slowly… microscopically. She felt every edge, wrinkle, twitch, pulse throbbing between them. Her clit was rubbing against the damp armrest with each minute movement. Her heart pounding out of her chest in anticipation of what she knew would be the most intense orgasm anyone had ever felt. As his head reached the point of barely being inside her, everything froze for her. All she could feel, see, focus on was him. Her Doctor. Her whack-a-doodle. She felt as if her soul met him in that brief pause. She knew he would push her over with his next stroke. She waited...and waited… thump… thump… thump… Her eyes snapped to his as it dawned on her... He had stopped.
"Please…" Penny did not know if she could take it anymore. "Doctor… please." Penny begged while moving her hips. Trying to get him to move again. She wanted to cum.. She wanted… no, needed to feel him release inside of her. To feel him confirm that invisible claim on her. To be… his.
"What? Please, what?" Sheldon growled as he kept himself buried in her sexpot, not moving. The sofa was already moved out of place. He had to win completely. He had to… so he could help her harness that passion.
Penny shook her head.
"Say it!" Sheldon commanded as he slipped a hand under her to stroke her throbbing clit. Pushing her even closer towards that edge.
"Fuck! Make me cum already Doctor, please! Claim me… Make me yours…" Penny sobbed.
Yes… mine…" Sheldon's responding growl and thrust slammed into Penny's head, heart, and body. "You're mine." Nothing and no one would ever top this.
"I'm yours…" Penny agreed. Admitted what she felt. Sheldon's speed doubled at her agreement. His force seemed to triple. Faster… faster… until…
"You know, I always wanted to claim you like this..." Sheldon pulled out. Penny moaned as she felt his cock leave her completely. But he slowly pressed the tip against her ass and spooned himself onto her to pick her up.
"No, wait!" He was swift. With the tip of his drenched cock already inside her ass, he suddenly straightened both of their bodies upwards. Her shorter body had nowhere to go but down, impaling on his rock-hard cock, easily bringing it deep inside her in one single moment.
Her eyes rolled backwards as she felt him in what it felt like her stomach and his hand already buried as deep in her pussy as he could manage. Every inch of her body tingled. In that moment, she felt everything. Every air shift, every dust particle landing on her, every single sweat drop, every point of friction against her, every breath against her neck. She felt as if she was holding onto a live wire… no… that she is a live wire… about to release a massive surge… about to explode…
"Cum for me kitten…" Sheldon whispered in her ear. "Cum…"
Penny's world exploded as Sheldon bit her shoulder hard right where it met her neck. Everything became nothing but intensely pleasurable release. He moved only slightly in his hips to stimulate her. They just stood there fused together, him behind her, one hand fingering her pussy, another covering her mouth muffling the orgasmic shriek. Something that would definitely cause Leonard to come knocking on her door. Her squirt was already dripping from his palm down her legs. He was bringing out the flow with distinct squishing sounds.
"Whose are you…" Sheldon could barely whisper into her ear.
"Yours… I'm all yours…" Her body was convulsing against his on it's own. Penny passed out the next moment from the intensity he overloaded her with. And finally admitting what she knew for so long.
Her final words were enough for him to not be able to resist any longer. His seed coated her insides again and again. Her orgasm caused his own. Pulse after pulse of released tension flowed through them. Sheldon held her tight against his body long after their experienced explosions.
Penny picked up his whispering groans and heavy hot breaths of orgasm when he was filling her in the same rhythm. Being gripped tightly up against his naked body, to feel and hear him moaning against her, her pleasure carried on until he was completely drained.
Finally… he released her to slump to the floor carpet next to the sofa. His load of cum slowly oozed past her pussy lips, down to her thigh. It took her awhile to gather her strengths. When she finally looked up… her lover was already getting dressed, looking like nothing had happened at all. Not a single bit of evidence showed anywhere on his body of what they had just done.
"Wham-bam, thank you ma'am… auff..." She sarcastically remarked, propping up against the sofa and scooping some of his cum off between her legs. Still feeling the tingles and aches over her body. Sheldon was already there besides her, covering her naked body with a bathrobe.
His eyes and smile spoke volumes. Even though he tried to hide his emotions, Penny saw them. The real him, enjoying this just as much as she did. He knew who had won in the end and would never forget it. Nor would he let her.
They both sat on the couch and Sheldon put his arm around her shoulder. Penny leaned onto his blue Superman shirt, as he gently combed her disheveled hair behind her ears. She leaned towards him and kissed him goodnight. They just entered some new weird relationship without even saying a word.
"Let me bring you your laundry back. I also resend your strikes and you are no longer banished." Sheldon said quietly after the kiss was broken.
"Can I sit wherever I want?" Penny looked at him.
His eyes met hers. Stormy blue to sparkling green. A wicked gleam appeared as a smirk crossed his face. He kissed her forehead and headed to the front door.
"Good night, Sheldon."
"Penny?" Sheldon turned towards her, when he opened the front door.
"Yes?"
"Well played." The door clicked shut before Penny could fully process all that had just happened. She got up on her feet and dragged her way to the bathroom for a much needed shower.
"Hey! So is everything okay now?" Leonard asked from his armchair when he saw Sheldon walking in. Howard and Raj were preparing to head home.
"Everything is fine, Leonard. In the end, Penny and I managed to come to an agreement." Sheldon commented casually as he headed for his room and then a long shower. Innuendo flew past Leonard's head, he was glad the war was finally over and didn't pay much attention to anything else.
After going for a soothing soapy bath, Penny was lotioning her skin and noticed in the mirror. On the spot where her neck and shoulder meets was a very dark prominent hickey displaying to the world she was currently taken. The physical representation of his claim on her… set another brief orgasm through her body.
Penny stumbled to her bedroom and collapsed as soon as she reached her bed. She knew she will feel this rough fuck for days to come.
She also knew Sheldon will very soon be completely disinfected given what he just did to her. Her mind was already thinking about how to get even. How she will tie him to bed and suck him for all he's worth. He sampled her now she needs to do the same. For now she could only try to imagine how his gorgeous cock would feel deep down in her throat with her head leaned back against the bed, his sweet thick cum filling her belly…
Both of them drifted to sleep not knowing they shared the same wet dreams that night.