It was Brittany's birthday and Sam wanted to make her feel special, so that night, Sam asked her what she wanted to do, any fantasies she wanted them to play out.

"I want to have a threesome," she said confidently, like she had thought about it many times before.

Upon hearing this, Sam suddenly got really self-concious, was he not doing enough to keep Brittany satisfied? But it was her birthday, he thought, and if she wants to have a threesome then why should I stop her. Sam assumed that she was gonna call Santana over, which would mean he could fuck her too, and watch the two girls together. He asked anyways, "Oh.. umm… okay… with who?"

"That, my friend," she said with a wink, "will be a surprise! But you're okay with it, right?"

"Yeah yeah sure, whoever it is will be fine, just please don't call Rachel."

"Don't worry, I'm not calling Rachel" She stood up and hurried out of her bedroom and locked herself in the bathroom so Sam couldn't see who she was calling. He could, however, still make out her voice if he was really quiet and listened very carefully.

Brittany, in the bathroom, knew just who to call. She knew who would be up for that no questions asked and no weirdness the next time they were hanging out, Puck. She didn't want to tell Sam because she was afraid he would get weirded out being with a dude, although she has noticed some weird energy between him and Blaine that is definitely not one-sided.

"Hey It's Brittany!" she said when he answered the phone.

"Oh hey Brittany, happy birthday, what's up?"

"So, umm, Sam and I were actually wondering if you wanted to come over and, you know, hang out with us for the night," she said with a hint of seduction in her voice, letting him know what would happen tonight.

His voice wavered, "I don't know Brit, I've had plenty of threesomes with two girls but I've never done it with another guy before. Are you sure Evans is okay with this?"

"Of course he's okay with this" She paused. "Your choice" she said all singsongy, "you'll be missing out on a great night… unless you wanna prove that you're not too chicken to do it and make me happy on my birthday?!" she ended, one final pitch to Puck.

"Hey! I'm not a chicken, I'll be there in 10 minutes."

"Door's unlocked, just come right up." He hung up.

Yes! The oldest trick in the book, works every time.

Sam heard bits and pieces of it from Brit's bedroom but not once did she give away the name of the hot girl she was inviting over.

10 minutes later, when Puck arrived, he opened the door and headed upstairs just like Brit had told him to. He knocked on the door not sure if he should go right in or wait.

Sam was eager to see who Brittany had invited and when she went over to the door and opened it and he saw Puck on the other side, boy was he shocked.

"Alright let's get to it!"

Sam was still, mouth wide open. He had told Brittany that whoever she invited would be fine, but he thought she was going to invite a girl. It was her birthday and he didn't want to make her upset. He was also worried that if he left, that his girlfriend would end up fucking Puck anyways. If he focused on Brittany, it would be like Puck wasn't even there, right?

Brittany ran over to the bed and jumped on it, sprawling herself out for the two boys to come and get.

Sam was the first up; he laid down on Brittany's right and turned her head toward him, pulling her lips towards his. They began making out as Puck made his way onto the bed on her left. He began spooning her and kissing her on the neck.

Sam slowly moved his knee up her inner thigh and brushed her underwear under her Cheerios uniform, she was already soaked. He gently rubbed his knee there again, teasing her.

"Sam… please" Brittany moaned between kisses.

By the time Sam had kissed Brittany's body all the way down to her belly button, Puck's hands were already up her skirt and beginning to pull her underwear down. Sam's hands joined Puck's and began to help him pull her lacy thong down around her ankles.

She kicked it off so she could spread her legs wide. Both boys were now kneeling by Brittany's hips, waiting for her to present herself to them. As soon as she did, both heads went down, eager to be the one to eat her out.

They banged their heads together and gave each other a quick weird glance before Brittany helped them get in position. "Puck, stay there, Sam come lay next to me with your head that way. Now you can both eat me out at the same time."

She didn't have to tell them twice. Sam quickly adjusted his position and began using his tongue to trace circles around her clit while Puck began pushing his tongue into her slick opening, lapping up all of her juices. Moans of pleasure escaped Brit's mouth and Sam began to full on suck at her clit now. This elicited even louder, more pleasuring screams from Brit as she removed her cheerleading top. Sam reached up with his one hand and began massaging her tit in his hand, flicking the nipple every once and awhile. His and Pucks erections both growing

Meanwhile, Puck was still thrusting his tongue into Brit's cunt, tasting every drop of her wetness. Sam was starting to get a little jealous of Puck because he said, "Brit, he's getting to taste all of you, and I barely got any."

"Oh you wanna taste my juices, don't you Sam? Would you do anything to taste me?"

"Yes, Brittany, I'd do anything, just, please!"

"Ok, make out with Puck. Then I'll let you taste me, how bout that!" She was eager to see the two boys kiss and figured this would be a good way.

Much to her and Puck's surprise, he turned to Puck and started to lean in.

"Hold on a second here, what's in it for me if I do this"

"I'll let you fuck my asshole while Sam fucks my pussy" she knew how much Puck loved ass play and she was using that to her advantage, she was gonna let him do that anyways.

He weighed his options, but eventually gave in. He leaned over Brittany's body and crashed his lips into Sam's. After a few seconds, Puck realized what a great kisser Sam was, those lips were good for something.

This really turned Brittany on, they both seemed so into the kiss, she began fingering herself and rubbing her clit while she watched, also noticing how much harder both of the boys were than before they started kissing.

When the kiss broke apart, both boys instinctually began removing their clothes, their hard-ons becoming uncomfortable at that point. Sam licked off Brittany's fingers that she had been using to finger herself and then dove into her slick folds, licking up everything she gave her. "Ohhh Sammmm, I'm gonna…" Before she could finish her sentence, gooey liquid came out of her hole, Sam swallowed it all and sat back up. Puck was kissing Brittany now, eagerly awaiting fucking her in the ass.

Before they could get to that, Brittany began palming at Puck's dick. It stiffened even more at her touch and she moved down so she could wrap her mouth around it. "Ohh Brit… you're so good at this, you're the best"

She let up for a second, taking her mouth off of his dick, warranting a whimper from Puck. She motioned for Sam to come closer. "Kiss him again, that was hot" Without much hesitation, the two boys leaned forward and made contact again. Brittany continued to suck on Puck's dick causing him to make moaning sounds in Sam's mouth.

Sam wasn't into guys, but it was hot. Puck's hands were in his hair and Sam's arms were wrapped around Puck. Puck broke the kiss, but only to give a warning to Brit. When he came, he bit down on Sam's bottom lip and Brit swallowed his whole load.

His dick began to soften. Puck looked anxious, "but wait!" he protested, "you said I could fuck you in your ass!"

"Sam, come down here and help Puck get hard again"

"What do you mean Brit?"

"I mean…" she said, motioning to his soft dick, "suck him off until he's hard enough to take me in the ass."

Surprisingly, Sam didn't protest. He reached down to grab Puck's dick. He hadn't noticed how big it was until now. He looked up at him, looking for the green light. Puck just nodded, he just really wanted to be hard enough to fuck Brittany in her ass and if she wasn't gonna help him, I guess he could do worse than Sam.

"I've never done this before so just tell me if it hurts, okay?" he mumbled before going down on one of his good friends. He quickly licked Puck's cock from the bottom to the top before taking it in his mouth and bobbing up and down. He tried to copy what Brittany had done to him earlier. Whatever he was doing seemed to be working because Puck was moaning louder than he was when Brit sucked him and Sam could feel him getting hard in his mouth. He liked the feeling of having Puck scream his name, it made him feel so powerful.

Puck opened his eyes ever so slightly to watch Sam go down on him. Puck was completely straight, but even he had to admit that this felt good and that Sam looked kinda hot.

When Puck was sufficiently hard, Sam let up, pulling his mouth off the cock that he'd actually enjoyed tasting.

Now came the best part, they were gonna DP Brittany. Sam laid down flat on the bed and Brittany straddled him, lining his cock up with her pussy. She slowly began to work herself down Sam's dick, when, out of the corner of his eye, Sam saw Puck get off the bed and move towards the door. He didn't want Puck to leave. He would never admit it but he liked it better when Puck was there. Luckily, Puck was just walking over to the bag he brought with him, he crouched over and started rummaging through it. Whatever he was looking for, he couldn't find.

"Fuck!" he shouted, startling Brittany and Sam, "I forgot the lube."

"Oh, that's not a big deal" Brittany shook it off, "we can just use saliva, it works, trust me"

He came back over, straddling Sam's legs as he pushed Brittany forward onto Sam's chest. He shoved two fingers forward wanting Brittany to wet them before he shoved them in her ass, much to his surprise, it was Sam who lifted up his head to wet the fingers.

Puck rubbed a little bit of Sam's saliva on Brittany's hole before pushing the first finger in. Brittany was already moaning like crazy just from riding Sam's dick. He worked that finger for a little before pushing the second finger in, stretching her out. He was about to push his dick in when he realized that it wasn't nearly lubricated enough. That would be extremely painful for Brittany and he didn't want to hurt her.

He stood up off of the bed and walked up to where their heads were. "Sam, can you help me out here?" Sam knew exactly what he meant and went down on the boy for the second time of the night, getting his cock as wet as possible.

Puck walked back behind Brittany and quickly rimed her with his tongue, making extra sure she was ready before slowly sliding into her ass. When he got in pretty far, he stopped, waiting for Brittany to give him the all clear.

Once she did, he began pounding her hard, he could pretty much feel Sam's cock in her pussy. "Oh fuuuckk guys, I'm gonna cum" Brittany said. Her face scrunched up and her holes tightened as she rode out her orgasm. Those clenching walls around Puck's dick made it almost impossible for him to hold out any longer as he shot his load in Brittany's ass.

Sam was barely holding out, he knew it would only be a matter of time before his cum filled up Brittany as well. "Fuck" he was moaning.

"Wait, dude," Puck interrupted, "I want to return the favor." Sam looked confused "You blew me earlier, so now I want to blow you."

'Wait are you serious?" Sam asked as Brittany got up off of him.

"Yeah totally"

Sam's dick was throbbing now and he wanted, more than anything to cum. So, when Puck's hot mouth began swallowing his cock, he didn't hold out much longer, his cum filling Puck's mouth. Puck swallowed without hesitation.

"Thanks man that was awesome"

The two boys pulled on their boxers and Brittany put on some panties and a sports bra and the three teens laid down in bed with Puck in the middle, Brittany to his left, and Sam to his right. Puck never expected to fall asleep spooning Brittany while being spooned by Sam. As he fell asleep, he could feel Sam gently stroking his arm and his abs pushing against his back. He would do this again, no matter what. He would find an excuse to have a threesome with Sam and Brittany again. They were both so amazing, he never thought Sam would be so willing to do that.

Asleep, Puck dreamed of Sam blowing him again, the only difference was that Brittany was nowhere to be found, it was just him and Sam. Sam had a similar dream, also excluding Brittany.