***Blaine's POV***
"Okay everyone circle up"
Everyone turned their heads to see Brittnay holding the empty liquor bottle that they had just finished standing next to a giant whiteboard.
"C'mon guys let's play spin the bottle!" She shouted as everyone began to circle up. "You all know the rules, but i'm gonna write them up here so no one forgets, okay? Also, everyone has to sign the board which means no chickening out, you have to do everything"
I had never played with rules before; I watched curiously as Brittany wrote the rules on the whiteboard.
They read:
Between the Same Two People (no matter who spins it)
1st time: peck
2nd time: 3 second kiss
3rd time: 15 second make out (with tongue)
4th time: 1 minute make out with tongue while sitting on their lap
5th time: give each other oral for 30 seconds each
GAME ENDS AFTER ONE PAIRING HAS GOTTEN EACH OTHER 5 TIMES.
I watched as everyone went up to sign the board: Finn, Quinn, Santana, Puck, Brittany, Sam, Jake, Kitty, Mike, and Tina. I was the only gay guy, with Kurt in New York with Rachel, and I didn't want to make anyone else uncomfortable. I got up to leave saying: "I don't think I'm gonna play guys."
"No, dude, c'mon you're so playing, sit your ass down!" Sam said, pulling me down next to him, "right everyone?" That was followed by a wave of "yeah's" and "totally's" that made me feel that much more comfortable. The alcohol helped too. And best case scenario, I would get to kiss Sam. I've been wanting to kiss Sam for a long time and tonight I finally might be able to without ruining our friendship and freaking Sam out; he was straight, something that I often had to remind myself of. So I went up and signed the board and then sat back down next to Sam.
"My house, so I go first!" shouted Brittany as she spun the bottle around the circle. It slowed to a stop right in front of Kitty. They both leaned across the circle and quickly kissed each other, warranting a whistle from Puck. "Okay your up Kitty."
She spun the bottle and it stopped on me. I was drunk enough to not really even think twice about it. I leaned across the circle and gave her a quick kiss and then sat back down. Ok, my turn. I spun it around the circle and it landed on myself, I looked over to Brittany confused about what I should do. "Kiss the person to your left" she said confidently, making me wonder just how many times she had played this game.
Of course to my left was Sam. He had pulled me down to sit next to him when I had tried to leave earlier. Everyone in the circle was silent. "Are you ok with that Sam," I asked, hoping for a yes.
Just as Santana started to say, "you have to, it's the rules," Sam grabbed my face and pulled me in for a quick kiss. Seeing the look of shock on my face and the whooping coming from everyone else, he brushed it off saying, "what? It's just a game." I had envisioned Sam kissing me before but that was even better than I'd imagined.
"Dude." I snapped out of it to see Sam looking right at me. "What?" I said back. He motioned to the bottle that he had just spun and it had landed back on me. Was this a dream? I get to kiss Sam again? Knowing that he was okay with it the first time, I kinda leaned into it this time. Our lips came together as everyone began counting "1… 2… 3!" As we pulled apart, I could have sworn that Sam gave me a wink. Did I imagine it? Was he joking? Or did he actually mean something by it? Nah he was probably just drunk.
It was my turn again, and much to my surprise, when it landed on Santana, I was somewhat relieved. I guess it was because she was a lesbian so she couldn't get the wrong impression like Rachel did last time we played at her party.
The game continued:
Santana got Jake
Jake got Tina
Tina got Finn
Finn got Puck (lots of hesitation on this one but they eventually did it)
Puck got Sam (more hesitation- mainly from puck seeing as he had just kissed finn and didn't want people to think he was gay)
I was hoping that Sam's spin would land on me again, however, it slowed right in front of Quinn instead. I tried to hide the disappointment on my face, but nobody was focused on me anyways. The game continued.
Quinn got Mike
Mike got Brit
Brit got Me
After a quick kiss with Brit, it was my turn again. My mouth practically hung open when it landed on Sam. This was the third time which meant a 15 second makeout with tongue. I was so happy but Sam looked hesitant. Everyone in the circle began chanting "Do it, do it, do it!" Sam gave a little shoulder shrug and yelled "Come here dude!" as he pulled me into the kiss. Everyone began counting to 15 but I tuned them out. I was focusing on Sam, his mouth, his tongue. It was the best kiss I had ever had.
***Sam's POV***
When Blaine's spin landed on me again, I knew what we had to do then. I was secretly hoping for it to land on me again. After kissing Blaine twice already, I realized what a good kisser he was and I would be lying if I said I didn't want to kiss him again. But I'm not gay. I hid my excitement by pretending to be hesitant. Once everyone started chanting, I knew I just had to go for it. So I did. As our lips came together for the third time that night, I began to drown out the voices counting to 15 and the cheers and whoops. I guess Blaine must have been doing the same because it took a tap from Tina on Blaine's right and one from Quinn on my left to break the kiss. When they finally pulled apart everyone was staring at us with their jaws dropped. "What?" I shrugged.
Puck was the first to speak, of course. "Is there something you're not telling us Evans?"
"No, why? Because I kissed Blaine while playing spin the bottle? That doesn't make me gay." I shot back.
"It kinda seemed like more than that. When we said that time was up, you guys kept on going for a while, until Tina and Quinn had to practically pull you guys apart." Puck responded.
My face flushed, I didn't realize we went for that long without noticing. I've caught myself staring at Blaine in class but he's my best friend, I thought that was normal. But I know I'm not gay. Definitely not. But I can't help myself from thinking about kissing Blaine again. I just grabbed the bottle and spun again. Tina. Okay that's fine. I can do that no problem. The game continued for many rounds and I was exempt.
Tina got Mike
Mike got Kitty
Kitty got Finn
Finn got Puck (again - both wiped their mouths with disgust after their 3 second kiss)
Puck got Brit
Brit got Santana
Santana got Mike
Mike got Blaine
Blaine got Quinn
Quinn got Tina
Tina got me
My sweaty hand grasped the bottle. I was both hoping to get Blaine and dreading it at the same time, just because of what other people might say. The bottle seemed to spin in slow motion. It began to slow down as it passed Mike. It passed Brittany and ever so slowly passed Tina. It was just barely pointed at Blaine, again. This time, everyone just started laughing, including me and Blaine. It was honestly funny at this point.
He got up and plopped himself down in my lap. Brittany started the timer on her phone. One minute. He crashed his lips into mine as soon as the timer started. It was a little rougher than I was anticipating, but I wasn't going to complain. After a little bit, a problem began to arise for Blaine, down there. There was nothing he could really do at this point to stop it without drawing attention to it, and as a fellow dude, I know how embarrassing that is. We also just had to finish the minute. Because he was sitting on my lap, I could feel his dick pressing against the fabric of my jeans, in that area. My first reaction was uncomfort. I had never even kissed a dude before, let alone felt someone else's dick, even if it was through layers of fabric. He began to run his hand through my blonde hair. I would have done the same but he puts like 10 pounds of hair gel in. We continued the kiss until I noticed that I was beginning to have the same problem. I could feel my hardening dick begin to press up against Blaine's. I was so confused. I'm straight. So how can I get a hard-on from making out with Blaine. My best friend. Was it just my imagination, or did Blaine start kind of rubbing against me. Nope, definitely not my imagination. At this point we were both so hard that I was concerned about finishing the minute without cumming in my pants. That would be even more embarrassing. Just as that thought crossed my mind, the timer went off.
***Blaine's POV***
I heard the timer go off this time and I pulled away from Sam. Trying to think of the best way to hide the issue in both of our pants, I kinda stayed sitting on his lap for a second and eventually sat back down next to him with my legs in a way that would slightly hide it.
"Hey Brit do you happen to have a blanket down here? I'm a little cold." I asked, hopefully. This was the best I could think of quickly. Sam caught on to my thought.
"Yeah me too, just bring us a big one and we can share." Sam pitched in.
Brittany came back with a big blanket and threw it at me and Sam. We spread it out so that it covered our legs and that area. No one seemed to be suspicious. Although if I did have to lean forward to kiss anyone, they would notice. Thank god I spun and it landed on Tina, who was seated to my right. I just barely had to lean over to kiss her, still protected by the blanket. Once again the game continued, including myself and Sam, but not together.
Tina got Kitty
Kitty got Jake
Jake got Puck (we let him spin again- no weird incest shit happening here)
Jake got Santana again
Santana got Brit again
Brit got me
I got Puck (who at this point had already kissed 2 dudes and was slightly less hesitant)
(neither of whom noticed my hard-on. Sam could barely keep from laughing, as he already knew about it obviously)
Puck got Quinn
Quinn got Sam
Sam got Mike
Mike got me
It was my turn again, and as much as I hoped I would get Sam, I didn't want to make him uncomfortable (although he has been pretty into everything that we've been doing so far). I mean having your gay best friend suck you off in front of all your friends was definitely a weird situation. Especially because Sam was straight. Although, compared to how hesitant Puck and Finn were to kiss each other, it seemed like Sam didn't really mind kissing another dude. Maybe I have a chance with him after all. Also, I was super uncomfortable with my dick rubbing against the fabric of my jeans and I'm sure Sam was having the same problem. So, when the bottle slowed to a stop in front of Sam again, everyone knew the game would be over as soon as we both did it. Sam looked super uncomfortable so I asked him: "are you okay with this, we don't have to do this." To which Brittany interrupted "Uhh, yeah you actually do. Remember, you both signed the board. Rules are rules, pants off."
***Sam's POV***
Brittany had a point, they had signed the board before the game started. When I signed I never imagined what would happen if I had gotten to number 5 with a dude. I signed it hoping to get in Quinn's or Brittany's pants. I guess I just had to do it, if I had to do it with anyone, I would have picked Blaine. I couldn't even imagine having to do it with Puck, or even Finn. Blaine looked extremely shocked when I reached under the blanket and began to fumble with the button and zipper of my jeans. "What? We have to. I thought you'd be a little more excited than this, come on man do you not think I'm hot or something?" Blaine just laughed and shrugged his shoulders and began to help me with my pants. I was just now in my boxers and I reached over to help Blaine with his jeans, leaving him in his boxers too. I suddenly froze. I had no idea how to do this. I'd never sucked another dude off before and I didn't want to do it wrong or hurt him. Luckily Blaine said he'd go first.
As Blaine removed my boxers, he looked awe-stricken. I guess I was pretty big at 9 and a half inches hard. Brittany began the timer and Blaine began. His tongue brushed my tip, licking up all of the precum. He licked my shaft from base to tip and then just took as much as he could in his mouth. Moans began to escape my mouth as Blaine got more and more in his mouth. This was even better than fucking a girl. No girl that I dated ever wanted to give me a blow job and now I know what I was missing. Just as the timer went off and Blaine began to let up, I couldn't stop myself from moaning, "Blaine… I think I'm gonna cum." Blaine looked at me for approval to keep going until I finished and I gave him a quick nod. It only took five more seconds for me to shoot my load right into Blaine's mouth. "Ohmygod i'm so sorry i should have warned you Blaine." Blaine didn't seem to be too phased by it as he swallowed the whole load.
Now it was my turn. I slowly removed Blaine's boxers. I was startled at how big Blaine was. Not as big as me, but it looked to be about 8 or 8 and a half inches. I tried to copy what Blaine did to me. As soon as my tongue hit his tip, a shudder ran through his body and he moaned something that sounded like "yes... sam". That gave me all the confidence I needed to just go for it. I guess having a big mouth comes in handy sometimes. It didn't even take the full 30 seconds for him to cum. He gave me plenty of warning but I wanted to try to swallow it like he had done for me. I got most of it but some leaked out. Seeing as I still had some time left, I licked up the rest of it off of his dick and his stomach. The timer went off and we both began to redress. Everyone in the circle looked at us with their mouths wide open. Great, now Puck would tell everyone that I was gay, even though I'm not, and then I'll get a slushie in my face every day. He was hoping that everyone was drunk enough to forget what had just happened, except for maybe Blaine.