Disclaimer: I know I've probably said that before and all, and of course I owe nothing in Supernatural-I wish though-but here is a second time. Though, I own Eve, the Blakes and Arial, those are mine ;P

Author's Note:

Deangirl93, Deanie Bean's Lover Gal92, Lucy Colt, sammysexslave: thanks guys for the reviews, so glad you liked the last chapter hope you will like that one as well.

Sorry for the disappointment of the break up last chapter, is Eve leaving or staying? Is she and Dean gonna get back together or not? Let's find out! Enjoy! ;)

Dean was now standing alone outside of the office looking confused, he didn't know how he would deal with such a situation, Eve technically broke up with him saying that she might stay with her family instead of leaving. He didn't know for sure if she was going to leave with him and Sam or would stay with her family as she said she might do. And if she stayed after what she told him about their relationship, would he consider that nothing and that what she said was just an irrational talk when she was mad? Or they really broke up?

Dean didn't consider the option that Eve would really stay with her family, he couldn't even imagine that. And for a second, Dean thought that if Eve decided to stay, he would carry her and force her to get into the Impala, whether she liked it or not.

But he was so confused and after what happened that day and what they heard, Dean couldn't think straight so he preferred to go back inside the office at least Sam and Castiel were there and he could use some help.

"Where's Eve?" Martin asked once Dean got into the office.

"She went up to her room; she is tired after all what she heard!" Dean told him.

"Well, better, because we need to talk!" Martin told Dean who shared a confused look with Sam then looked back at Martin. "We know about the relationship with you and Eve; and that when you two declared your love it saved her life."

"So?" Dean asked still confused.

"It wasn't gonna save her life if it wasn't true Dean!" Mark told him. "This means if it saved her life once, it could save it again."

"I don't agree with that!" Ben burst. "I think Eve will be safer with us!" he said.

"No one asked for your precious opinion!" Dean growled.

"Yes Ben, no one asked!" Mark said.

"Mark, really?" Ben said with a sarcastic smile. "I don't think Eve would care if you agree or not, and I bet that because of what you did she won't even listen to you. So, why don't you leave this job for the pros?"

"Ben!" Martin snapped. "You know what happened better than anyone, and that Mark was forced to sell Eve out thinking he was saving her,"

"Well, she doesn't know that!" Ben said with an evil smirk.

"I will make sure she knows; but so far, you're not allowed to talk if no one asked you!" Martin demanded.

"Wait here!" Sam started. "Eve hates Mark, she said it to me herself," Mark sighed. "I'm sorry," Sam told him with a sympathetic smile. "She needs to know if he was tricked to do what he did!"

"The demons manipulated me, compelled me to do that," Mark said. "I still have no idea how I did it, all I remember was seeing Eve's hurt face looking at me. After that I knew what happened, and that she went with the demons to save my life after I sold hers," He paused. "I deserve this, all of it; I should have fought for her more than that."

"It's over now Mark!" Dean told him. "You should talk to her and sort it out, things can change, just show her that she can trust you again." He said and shared a sad look with Sam, both of them remembered the time they lost all the trust and faith they had for each other when Sam left with Ruby taking her over his brother.

"Well, let's deal with this later," Mark huffed. "Now, it's better to let Eve go with you guys, it's better for her!" he told the Winchesters.

"I hate to break this to you but she told me she was thinking about staying here," Dean said. "And, she," he paused. "She broke up with me."

"What?"

"Dean, I think it's just because of the stress not that she," Sam started.

"Doesn't matter!" Dean cut him off. "We will talk about this and figure it out, now we need to know what she is going to do."

"Working on it!" Arial stated suddenly and vanished.

...

Eve was laying on her bed in her childhood old room. The room was just like the last time she left it, childish and comfy so she preferred to stay there to get her mind clear, she kept thinking of what her uncle's said and what she should do now, but her mind went to something else, to someone else. Eve was thinking about Dean, about what happened with them and what she said. She loves him and loves him more than anything but she now knew better that they can't be together, at least not as a couple and that's why she was thinking of staying with her family instead, even though she didn't know how she would handle being away from Dean.

"You're so wrong on this!" Arial said showing up in the room with her. Eve looked at him blankly and said nothing. "You can't leave Dean and Sam!" he told her.

This time Eve sat straight in her bed looking mad. "Says who?" she snapped and before Arial could talk she continued. "Yeah, heaven again!" she said sarcastically. "They decide who stays with whom, who leaves whom, and we should obey, right? Well, breaking news, I'm not doing what anyone wants me to do!" she snapped. "I'm doing what I think is right, I'm the one who got into this shit and the one that needs to decide, not anyone else!"

"Eve, Eve," Arial walked to her trying to calm her down but she snapped again, hysterically.

"Don't you dare touch me!" Eve snarled. "I'm untouchable, remember!" she mocked. "Just get the hell out and leave me alone, GET OUT!" she yelled at him.

"Not before telling you one thing," Arial said calmly. "Whatever the decision you're going to make, just be sure you won't make it when you're angry, it won't be the right one!" he said and vanished.

Eve kept staring blankly at the spot he was standing at for few minutes; her mind was racing with thoughts of what he just said. She needed to think hard on this one, stay or go? To stay with her family? Or with the Winchesters? And there was a huge difference between what she wanted and what she had to do.

The rush of thoughts had stopped when Eve heard the knocks on her door, she didn't really want to see or talk to anyone.

"Eve, its Sam!" Sam said softly waiting for her to call him in.

"Sam, I really don't feel like talking to anyone now!" Eve said, still in her bed.

"I know," Sam said still out. "Just few minutes please!" he pleaded.

"Fine," Eve sighed. "Come in!" she told him.

Sam entered the room smiling sympathetically at the sight of Eve curled up in her bed like a little baby, she looked so fragile, so sad and weak. Sam thought she would probably be crying or worse that she would be hysterical but Eve was surprisingly calm that she wasn't even crying, and that made Sam more sorry for her, he thought that crying and getting emotional would be better as a pain relieve but now she was just dying from the inside and she couldn't express it.

Sam reached next to her sitting on the bed. "Are you better now?" he asked patting on her knee.

Eve lifted her head up to look at him. "No, I'm not!" she sighed. "Sam, I don't want to be rude or anything, but what do you want? I need to be alone!"

"I'm only here to tell you that whatever the decision you will make, we will support you!" he said softly.

"We? You mean you will support me, not Dean!" Eve told him bitterly.

"Not if you're coming with us!" Sam smirked making her give a little smile.

"Smooth!" she muttered. Sam gave her a warm smile.

"Look," he started. "I know how hard this is, with the demon blood, being the devil's prom dress, and the whole heaven and hell issues; I know what you're going through now." Sam said reaching to hold her hand. "You're strong and I trust your judgment," he paused and Eve gazed at him waiting for what he wanted to say. "Just think of who you trust and feel safe with, and take your time to make up your mind." Sam said.

"Thanks Sam," Eve said and hugged him.

Sam hugged her back wrapping his arms around her. Eve started to shake in his hands and Sam realized she was crying. They stayed like this for a while, Eve was crying against Sam's chest while he was soothing her and rubbing her back letting her express all her stress and emotions she had.

"Eve," Sam called softly.

"Humm?" Eve answered with a sniff.

"You better now?" he asked. Eve pulled away from Sam's hug.

"Kinda, not much but better," she said then she leaned to press a kiss to Sam's cheek. "Thanks Sammy." He smiled at her. "Um, how is Dean now?"

"Not okay!" Sam said it in a "duh" like. "Did you really break up with him?"

"Yes and no!" Eve said and Sam looked at her with a raised eyebrow. "I don't think that we can pull this off and be together, lots of problems Sam, and I really don't want to hurt him, not ever." She said. "I love him, love him more than anything or anyone, but, I'm just confused and need time to figure this all out, time off that's all."

"Look Eve, I know this is between you and Dean, but," Sam sighed. "Dean never fell in love before, yeah he had few crushes and yeah he got with many girls, but none of them was good enough that he fell for or was committed to; don't break his heart because he will never recover from this."

"Sam," Eve started but she was cut off by Sam.

"Just talk to him and tell him what you want, don't back off suddenly and lose it all." He said.

Eve smiled. "What would I do without you Sammy?" she said.

"Huh, I'm like your guardian angel!" Sam said smugly, joking. "Just get some rest now, and see you tomorrow, okay?" he said standing up.

"Okay," Eve smiled. "Thanks again Sam, really!" she said in appreciation.

"No worries." Sam said simply. "Night Eve!"

"Night Sam!"

...

Eve's P.O.V

That was one hell of a bad day; it started bad and ended bad. I think I can simply call it a son of a bitch day, if that's even possible. Started with my dad's memorial and ended up with me knowing what is my life purpose and why I was even born for, which wasn't pleasant. To know that my whole life was based on a deal made by that bastard Widmore my great grandfather.

And now I have no idea what to do, to stay with my family? Humm, let's think with logic now, shall we?

Well if I stayed with them, I will lose Dean and Sam, probably losing Dean forever-and I can't live with that. Not to mention that I'm making the same mistake to stick with them again like I did before when my dad was alive and I don't trust them, not really. I trust uncle Martin and Simone but who said they will be here for me all the time or work as my personal bodyguards? Uh, no one said that! Martin has to run most of the family business and Simone has work in Florida anyway. And Libby, well she is my best friend but she is not a hunter and even with the ability to fight the poor girl won't last in such fights.

That leaves us to the biggest pain is the ass Ben and my brother, well no need to talk about them because I don't want to say many F words now, so let's keep it classy! All I can say that I don't trust them, and I will never do. I rest my case!

Now, there is the other option, to leave with the Winchesters. Well, if it wasn't for me and Dean issues now, I'd have picked that choice blindly. But now, I need to think harder. Again, let's think logically! It was fun the first time!

I love Dean, and I trust both boys with my life, but after what I said to Dean it will be hard to be at the same place all the time. As I told him, I need a break to think about the whole me and him thing, emotions are not enough now. It's a big challenge for our relationship at the moment. Two words, no sex! I love him and I want to be with him fully but I can't because of my family curse and my powers-the whole I need to remain a virgin thing which god only knows when we can break this curse or how. AND as long as I'm with Dean, he will be in danger. I remember the night of our first date when I knocked him out when I got so mad, that was a nice way to end the night!

Still, even with this, the Winchesters are the ones I trust and maybe with a small conversation with Dean, he will get my point of view.

Huh! I guess I just made a decision!

...

"Hey, hey, hold on!" Eve said running to catch Dean before closing the Impala's trunk. "What? You were planning to leave without me?"

Dean looked at her in confusion. "I didn't know if you were coming or not!" he said simply.

"Well, you could have asked!" Eve said handing him her duffel. Dean took the bag from her butting it in the trunk without saying a word. "What? Are you giving me the silent treatment now Dean or what? We are not in the third grade anymore, you know!"

"No, I'm just waiting to see if you're going to change your mind or not!" Dean said sarcastically.

"If you don't want me to come with you just say it Dean!" Eve snapped.

"I didn't say that," Dean snapped back. "But is it your last call or you will change your mind and decide to stay here with your loving family?"

"Watch it Winchester!" Eve snarled taking a step closer to him but suddenly Dean grabbed her pressing her against the car standing in front of her.

"Or what?" he said glaring at her.

Eve's breath was caught when Dean did that, and she couldn't resist. "Or this!" she said and grabbed him from the shirt brushing her lips to his kissing him eagerly, the kiss got more passionate and lingering, they made out for a while, then pulled back due to lack of air. "That was hot!" Eve said breathless. Dean smirked proudly. "But," he looked at her questioning. "But this sums up what we can do."

"So, you still thinking of this break right?" Dean said, annoyed.

"Yes," Eve sighed. "I just need to get my mind clear, you being with me is not fair for you right now! I need some time."

"Okay!" Dean said simply taking a step back from her.

"Okay?" Eve exclaimed. "That's it, okay!"

"Yeah, you need a break and I get it!" Dean said making her confused. Eve didn't expect this; she had prepared herself for a fight that Dean's reaction now made her confused and little disappointed.

"Okay, thanks... I guess!" she said. "Um, I will go say goodbye to the guys inside and get Sam and we are ready to go!" Eve informed.

"I'll wait here!" he said. Eve gave him a weak smile and headed inside.

So, she is leaving but they are still in a break up! Hope you liked it. Next time we will meet one of Dean's old "friends" and it won't be so easy on Eve, guessed who? ;P that's for next time! Please review!