She headed for Katie again. It was getting dark but she didn't care. Katie's was probably closed, but she didn't want to get stopped. Sylvia was starving. As she headed into town, she spotted both Chase and Rubble walk into an alley. Sylvia stopped. "Why are they there?" She forgot about going to Katie's and follow the shepherd and bulldog. As she turned the corner, she saw something she never wanted to see. She heard his bark, "my daughter's name was-" she growled, "Get away from him Rubble!" He perked up, "My daughter, Sylvia!" Sylvia growled. She saw Rubble's ear perk up. "Your not my dad! Rubble get away from that monster!" Sylvia watched as both Marshall and Chase ran out. Chase had jumped over Rubble. He was growling. Her father spoke, "Honey I-" she growled again, "I was never your daughter!" Chase stopped growling, "Sylvia?" Chase tilted his head. Sylvia stopped, "Yes?" Chase barked, "What are you doing here?" Sylvia perked her ears, "I was on a walk when I saw you guys walk into an alley and I got curious. Thought I could help." She watched as Marshall and Chase ran back. "Piper!" Her dad has yelped. "Who's Piper?" Sylvia barked, getting closer. "My wife." Her dad's words trembled. Sylvia couldn't take it anymore. She lost all thoughts. She tackles her father, her jaws snapping. She growled. She watched Chase join in the fighting. She heard yelping as she pinned her father. Then she heard a mans voice. They stopped fighting Naz Chase and Marshall ran out of the fight and to the sidewalk. Chase ran after the car, but it was too late. Sylvia and her father ran out to the sidewalk. Marshall stood there in shock, Chase climbed a crate and howled sadly. A collar fell off the crate and Sylvia looked at it. "Rubble's collar." "I knew these guys. We have to leave quickly." She barked. She heard her father bark, "Piper!" She looked behind her, her father not there. They ran into the alley. Her father lay there, next to a golden retriever. The golden retriever lay there. Marshall gasped. Chase stay on the crate, his head between his paws, sadly. "Sylvia! Hold him!" Marshall yelled, putting a puppy in her paws. Sylvia was surprised. "To the lookout everyone!" Marshall yelled. Chase got up and helped Piper up, and gently started walking to the lookout quickly. Sylvia picked up the pup and headed for the lookout.