Twilight and Rainbow Dash continued to search for Chloe, but they still couldn't find any traces of her and they still don't know to where did she went either, and this started to make the two mares worried, and then Twilight said "I hope she's alright. We just need to search everywhere until we find her.", and then Rainbow Dash said "I hope so. I wonder where is she right now.", and they continued to search for Chloe everywhere.
Meanwhile, Chloe is walking with Yigal, Gilad, Ezra and their animals into the place where they're going to celebrate Chloe's birthday, and while walking with them all, Chloe asked "When do we get to that place you talked about?", and Yigal said to her "Don't worry about this. We're going to get there really soon. Trust me, girl.", and then Gilad said with a rather angry face "Maybe you shouldn't talk until we get there, you annoying little girl?!", but then Ezra said to him "Don't be too harsh on her, Gilad. She's just a 9 years-old girl, and she just asked when do we all get there.", and then Gilad said "Fine.", but his face still looked a bit angry though as they all continued to walk towards the exact place where they're going to celebrate Chloe's birthday.
Meanwhile, Twilight and Rainbow Dash still searched for Chloe, but they still couldn't find her anywhere, and then Rainbow Dash said while being extremely worried "Where she could be? I feel like something bad have happened to her.", and then Twilight said "Don't worry. I'm sure she's okay somewhere, and I hope we'll find her before everypony runs out of patience.", and the two mares continued to search everywhere for Chloe in hopes they'll eventually find her.
Meanwhile, Chloe still followed Yigal and his brothers as well as their animals, and after walking with them and following them for a while, they all finally reached the exact place where they'll celebrate Chloe's birthday. The place they all reached to looked like if there's nothing but grass, but Yigal said that this is exactly the right place he, his brothers and their animals have thought about, and then he told Chloe to go there and check while they'll just stay behind and watch her. However, what Chloe didn't know is that this place is not a place where she can celebrate her birthday - the truth is that the place is actually nothing more than a trap.
However, soon enough, Chloe suddenly began to hear some twigs snapping right below her feet, and then suddenly the sounds got bigger as the entire ground below her began to snap and break apart, because it's actually made out of twigs and branches, and Chloe fell down screaming as a huge hole began to form on the ground, thus uncovering the trap.
Chloe ended up landing on the bottom of the huge hole, and then she looked up and cried out for help "Yigal, Gilad, Ezra, help me!", and so the three adult human males and their six special animals all came and they all stopped at the edge of the hole and they all looked down at her. When Chloe looked up at them, she cried to them all "Please, get me out of here!", but then Yigal and his brothers all laughed evilly at her while their animals all gave her evil smirks, before Yigal called to her "Goodbye, Chloe! It was been so nice to meet you, but unfortunately, you're useless and you're not worth apto any of us!", and then Gilad added "There's no way we can use you to fight those stupid and pathetic ponies and take over their world!", and then Ezra added "Three adult males like us don't need a stupid 9 years-old girl like you to help us destroy those disgusting ponies who hates us the most!".
However, when Chloe heard what the three adult human males just said to her, she asked them "What do you three mean?", and then Yigal explained "We tried to destroy ponykind and take over their beautiful world so we humans can rule over those filthy animals who call themselves good creatures, and our special animals, which none of them were ponies, will all help us to succeed in our revenge against ponly kind!", and then he laughed evilly, those revealing to Chloe that he and his brothers were the three adult human males who caused troubles to Equestria and threatened ponykind and other creatures alike.
"I should've known I shouldn't trust you three and your animals in the first place! You didn't tried to help me celebrate my birthday, you all led me to a trap!" Chloe cried as she looked up at Yigal, his brothers and their animals in anger, and then they all just laughed at her and then Gilad said to her "Exactly, you stupid little girl! Did you really thought that we're your friends?! You're absolutely dead wrong!", and then Ezra added "There's no way even children like you can trust us! Even if you're a human too, that still doesn't mean we don't dumb the useless behind!", and then Yigal called to her "You'll stay there and never come out of that hole ever again, little girl! Goodbye!", and then he and his brothers all laughed evilly as they turned and walked away from the hole, and their animals followed close behind them, thus leaving Chloe trapped in the hole all alone.
Chloe cried for help, but no one answered and no one came to find her and get her out of the hole, and this made Chloe very sad as she started to cry as she thought she's going to stay inside the huge hole for the rest of her life. "I guess I won't be celebrating my brithday after all, just like in all the other previous years! I should've known I shouldn't trust that Yigal and his brothers as well as their vicious animals! Now I'm trapped in a huge hole with no way out! I guess that for me everything's over, and this time, for good!" Chloe cried as she thought that she'll end up dying in the huge hole without being found and rescued.
However, just then, a voice called out her and so she looked up and saw Twilight and Rainbow Dash looking down at her before they both descended into the bottom of the huge hole, and once they reached the bottom, they approached Chloe, but she wasn't very happy to see them, and so she made a sour face at the two mares before she turned her head away from them.
"Chloe, Rainbow Dash and I We're been looking for you everywhere! What are you doing here at the bottom of this huge hole?", Twilight asked, but the human girl said to them "Just leave me alone, you two! I don't trust you two! In fact, I don't trust anyone from now on!", and then she started to cry again. Then, Rainbow Dash approached closer to her and asked her "What's wrong, Chloe?", and then she added "Don't you want to come with us so we can celebrate your birthday party?", but then Chloe turned to her with anger rising in her and then she said to the Pegasus mare "Or maybe to lead me into another trap like Yigal and his brothers as well as their evil animals did!", and then she added "I'm not going anywhere with anyone! I'm staying here!" and then she sat down while still looking away from her and from Twilight, showing them that she believes that she'll fall into the same trick twice if she trusts them.
However, Twilight said "You're coming with us, Chloe. We'll show you that you can trust us. We'll show you a real birthday party!", and then she used her magic to levitate Chloe, and then she place her down on her back, before she and Rainbow Dash took off while taking her with them, and so the three flew together back to the royal castle.
Once the three arrived back at the royal castle, Twilight and Rainbow Dash took Chloe with them to the place where everypony were all still waiting for Chloe to come, and once she entered the giant room along with Twilight and Rainbow Dash, everypony called to her happily "Happy birthday, Chloe!", and this made Chloe confused and then she suddenly asked "Why? Why did you all did all this for me? Is this some kind of a joke?", but then Celestia approached her and said to her "No, it's not, my dear daughter. This is real, and this is all for you! This is your birthday party you always wanted and always dreamed of!", and then she added and explained "The reason that my dear and beloved subjects and I told and/or wrote for you and we have no time to be with you it's because we wanted the birthday party to be kept a secret until we finish, and we also wanted to keep it a surprise for you!", and this shocked Chloe when she realized that everypony really cared about her and wanted to celebrate her brithday for her, and so she finally gave a happy smile to everypony in return for throwing her her birthday party.
Then, Chloe said to everypony "Thank you all, my friends! I should've known I can trust all of you all along! Now I'm so happy to finally celebrate my ninth birthday!", but then she suddenly realized something and then she asked "But wait a minute, where's Aylene?", and then Celestia asked her "Who?", and Chloe answered "Aylene is my friend, and she's Pegasus filly who is around my own age.", and then Luna asked her "How did you met her?", and Chloe explained "I saved her from some three bad colts who wanted to still her precious doll away from her, and that's how we became friends in the first place.", and then she added "That's too bad she haven't managed to go to my brithday party, because I've invited her to the royal castle to celebrate my birthday party with me and with all of you as well!".
Then, suddenly a familiar voice was suddenly heard and it said Chloe's name as a turquoise Pegasus filly with red mane and tail, magenta eyes and five flowers on her flank for a cutie mark came through the doors and approached Chloe as well as everypony else, and then she asked "Who said I won't be coming to your birthday party, Chloe?", and this made Chloe smile as she ran to Aylene and then she hugged her tightly and said to her "Oh, Aylene! I'm so happy you came to my brithday party after all! I thought your mother would stop you!", and then Aylene said to her in front of everypony "Stop me? Oh no, she won't! She don't even know I went to the royal castle to celebrate your birthday!", and when Chloe let go of her, she said to her Pegasus filly friend "Thank you so much for coming here, my friend!", and then everypony started to celebrate Chloe's birthday.
During the birthday party, Twilight introduced Chloe to her dragon assistant, Spike, and he explained to her that he's a good dragon who is extremely kind and friendly to ponies and other creatures alike, including other dragons, despite dragons are usually harmful and mean bullies and they always like to torment and humiliate, and that he's one of the only dragons in all of Equestria to be good, friendly and kind to his friends and surroundings.
Once the birthday party was over, everypony said goodbye to Chloe and they all went back to their homes, and Chloe also said goodbye to Aylene, who went back to her own home and hoped that her mother won't catch her on the way, and then Celestia and Luna took Chloe with them back to her bedroom, used their magic to place her down on her bed, and then they covered her body with the blanket, and then Celestia kissed the human girl on the forehead, before the two Alicorn princesses turned away and left the bedroom, and then they closed the doors behind them, thus allowing Chloe to finally fall asleep peacefully and quietly.