A full month have passed since Kenai met all the Hippogrifs on Mount Aris, as well as he met Queen Novo and her daughter, Princess Skystar, and this is also 53 months (4 years and 5 months) since Chloe first arrived in Equestria, and it was also 41 months (3 years and 5 months) since Aylene became her beloved sister, and now they're happy to be with their centaur best friend, Stephan, while Shujaa and Kenai have good homes in the royal castle and Fluttershy's cottage, respectively.
One night, Chloe and Aylene were asleep in their bed, but what they're dreaming now will finally tell them the secret of Yigal, Gilad, Ezra, and even Black Heart's pasts, which was something they've never seen in their dreams before.
In their dream, Chloe and Aylene found themselves and each other in the same white void from before, and just then, two male voices called for them by calling their names, and when Chloe and Aylene turned, they saw the spirits of Jack Williams and Wild Berry coming towards them to greet them again, and so Chloe and Aylene rushed to meet their long-deceased human grandfather and Pegasus pony father, respectively, and when they reached and got close enough to each other, Chloe and Aylene were both rewarded with tight, warm and loving embraces from their the spirits of their long-deceased good biological family members.
Then, Jack Williams said to his granddaughter "It is an honor for me to met you again, Chloe.", and then Wild Berry said to his daughter (Aylene) "Now we want to show you something we found thanks to our spirit magical abilities. Something that will explain to you and to your human sister, Chloe, how Yigal, Gilad, Ezra, and my traitorous wife, your birth mother, Black Heart, all came to be in the first place.". Then, Jack and Wild Berry used their spirit magic abilities to take Chloe and Aylene with them to see Yigal, Gilad, Ezra and Black Heart's pasts.
Then, Chloe, Aylene, Jack and Wild Berry found themselves in a familiar environment back on planet earth, and it turned out to be Yigal, Gilad, Ezra and their mother's home. Then, they teleported inside to see Catherine Peterson Yosefsberg with three children - two of whom are young children, and the third was just a little baby boy whom Catherine held and carried in her arms, and it was years before she became an unhealthy drunk herself, and just then, a adult man entered the house and it was none other than Yigal, Gilad and Ezra's long deceased father (whose death is to occur a few years later), and then Chloe asked "So, the older young child is Ezra, right?", and then Jack said to her "You're correct, Chloe.", and then Aylene asked "And the younger child next to him is Gilad, isn't he?", and then Wild Berry said to her "That's right, darling.", and when Chloe and Aylene looked at the male baby's face from a close enough look, then the human girl and Pegasus pony gasped in shock before they turned to Jack and Wild Berry and then Chloe asked "Grandfather, Wild Berry? Is that baby boy who we think it is?", and then Wildberry answered "That's right, Chloe. The baby you and Aylene both looked at is none other than-", and then Yigal, Gilad and Ezra's father said "Yigal." as he looked right at the baby boy that was held and carried in Catherine's arms, thus shocking both Chloe and Aylene to know that now they're both looking at Yigal, Gilad and Ezra when they're all just little kids and a baby boy.
Then, Jack said "I want you to watch some more of this in a later period of time.", and then Wild Berry added "That's right, we'll get to the next part of your enemies' early lives right now.", and then Jack and Wild Berry took Chloe and Aylene to a later time period that was three years later, and there Chloe and Aylene saw a sad moment in their enemies' early lives - they could see Yigal, who is now 3, Gilad, who is now 6, and Ezra, who is now 9 (respectively), all crying and hugging their mother as a coffin is being lowered into the ground to be buried, and Chloe then asked "What's that supposed to be?", and then Aylene asked "Who's the human these other humans are burying in that graveyard?", and then Jack answered "What are we seeing here right now is the burial of Yigal, Gilad and Ezra's father, who died when they're all very young.", and then Aylene said with remorse in her heart "I feel sorry for them, even if they're our enemies, because I too know how it's like to lose a father.", and then Wild Berry said to his daughter "It's okay, Aylene. Even if I'm already dead, I still want you to know that Jack and I will always be with your human sister Chloe and with you too, in your hearts.", and this made Aylene say "Thank you, daddy.", and then Jack said "Let's go and see what happens next, in the next later time period.", and then Wild Berry nodded to him and said "Right.", and then the two used their spirit magical abilities to take Chloe and Aylene along with them to the next time period they're all going to see next.
When Chloe, Aylene, Jack and Wild Berry all arrived at the next time period, the four were back in Yigal, Gilad and Ezra's home, and they could see the three brothers who are now 11, 8 and 5 years old, respectively, but they also saw their mother, Catherine, sitting on aat couch with an unusually inflated belly and stomach, and when Chloe and Aylene saw Catherine's body like this, Aylene then asked "Is there something wrong with Yigal, Gilad and Ezra's mom? Or it's just my imagination?", and then Wild Berry said "You're not imagining at all, darling. Catherine is pregnant with yet another child.", and when she and Chloe heard what the Pegasus stallion spirit said, the two gasped together in shock before they asked in unison "What?! A fourth child?! Yigal, Gilad and Ezra's mom is pregnant with a fourth child?!", and then they both added "That's impossible!", but then Jack said "Oh no, girls. It's not impossible, this is all true, and Yigal, Gilad and Ezra were all going to have a new little sibling to watch over and look after.", and then he added "To see what's going to happen next, we need to go forward to the next time period.", and then he and Wild Berry both used their spirit magic abilities again to take Chloe and Aylene along with them to the next time period to see what's going to happen next.
When they arrived at the next time period, Chloe, Aylene, Jack and Wild Berry were all once again in Yigal, Gilad and Ezra's house, and the three were still 5, 8 and 11, respectively, and they're now under the care of two of their mother's friends, but then the door opened to reveal Catherine walking into her house and coming into a full view in front of her three male children, and when Chloe and Aylene looked at her arms and chest, they saw a newborn baby girl wrapped in towels, which then got and attracted Yigal, Gilad and Ezra's attentions, and even Chloe and Aylene were both in shock to see Catherine's fourth child, and especially to know that the baby is actually a girl and not a boy like her three older brothers, thus also revealing that Yiagl was never been the youngest among his siblings at all, and proving he was only the youngest male among his siblings.
Then, Catherine said to her three older (and male) children "Yigal, Gilad and Ezra, I want you all to say hello to your new little sister. Say hello to your new little sister, Irit.", and just then, the little baby girl (Irit) started to move her arms and legs and slightly open her eyes as Catherine slowly lowered her down and gave her to Ezra so he can hold her first, and after a few minutes, he gave her to Gilad so he can hold her next, and after a few more minutes, Gilad save Irit to Yigal so he can hold her too, as he was the last of the three brothers who is going to be watching over and looking after her, and after a few minutes, Yigal raised his arms to give her back to his mother (Catherine), who then lowered down again and scooped Irit up in her arms and placed her close to her chest, and this made Chloe and Aylene to smile and then Chloe said "Awww, even if these were our enemies, we can't help but say that they and especially their little baby sister were all so cute!", and then tears of joy formed and rolled down their eyes.
However, this is when Jack and Wild Berry took their human granddaughter and Pegasus pony daughter along with them to the next time period, which is not going to be happy at all in there, and when they all finally arrived there, they saw Catherine looking drunk with a bottle of whiskey in her right hand, and this was during the first years in which Catherine started to become an unhealthy drunk, and then she suddenly snapped and then she went to Irit's crib and then she pulled out of her crib and then she started to angrily yell at her without warning, but Yigal, Gilad and Ezra watched what their mother is doing to their little sister, and what came out of Catherine's mouth were hateful words which shocked the three brothers and also scared their baby sister.
Then, the now drunk Catherine yelled at her own daughter "I'm very disappointed to be a mother to a girl like you! I wanted you to be born a boy just like all of your brothers, but I got you born as a stupid baby girl instead! You don't deserve to be mine if you're a girl, Irit! I shall destroy you for not being a boy!", but then Ezra snapped out of his shocked state and then he quickly went up to his mother and quickly snatched Irit away from her, and then he cried "Stop it, mom! Don't hurt our little sister! She deserves to live, even if she's a girl! I truly like her as my little sister, and so Yigal and Gilad does! You can't yell at her that you'll destroy her for not being a boy like us! Even girls like her deserve to live!", and everything Chloe and Aylene saw and heard was enough to make them both gasp in shock again, especially when they both saw how caring and protective Ezra was to his little baby sister, Irit.
However, what Ezra said only made his drunk mother angry and then she yelled at him "How dare you standing in my way, you stupid young man! I'm going to beat you up for defending that rubbish lump of filth whom you dare to call your little sister, you jerk!", and then she started to charge in a zombie-like way (because she was drunk) towards Ezra, but he thought fast enough and knew exactly what to do, and so he started to run to his two younger brothers and gave Irit to them so they can protect her while he goes outside and calls for help, and so he then started to run outside with Catherine following behind like a zombie trying to catch up with his victim, and this is when Ezra started to cry for help as his mother started to get closer and closer on him until she managed to jump on him and pin him down to the ground, but before she can start beating her own eldest son, Catherine is caught and apprehended by a couple of policemen who managed to arrest her and save Ezra just in time, and upon being brought back home, Ezra is reunited with his siblings, and Catherine's two friends allowed themselves to take a good care of the four children while their mother is to be put in jail and sentenced to an entire year for threatening her only daughter and for trying to beat up her eldest son.
Then, Jack and Wild Berry took Chloe and Aylene with them to the next time period which took place at the time Catherine finally returned home after being in jail for an entire year. Catherine's two friends finally left after caring for her children for her for the last year, but Catherine has a cruel and heartless plan in her mind to get back to the life before she gave birth to Irit - she wants to get rid of her only daughter by taking her outside and dumping her somewhere that is too far away for her other children to go and find her, and when night fell in Yigal, Gilad and Ezra's house, Chloe and Ayalene saw Catherine snatching Irit and taking her out from her crib, and then she took the baby girl outside with her, and then she started to walk and wander until she managed to get very far away from her home, and then she started to search for someplace where she can dump Irit and go home without her, and after a long search for the perfect place, she found a box that was actually full of abandoned helpless baby kittens and then an evil idea got into the drunk mother's mind - she will dump Irit to die along with the helpless kittens, and so Catherine carefully placed her only daughter in the box with the kittens, and then she closed it and started to walk away and leave the area with an evil smile creeping on her face.
When Chloe and Aylene saw what Catherine just did to her only daughter, Chloe then cried "What a monster that woman is!", and then Aylene added "How could she abandon a poor innocent baby girl like Irit, as well as with all of those poor little baby kittens who need a new home!", and then Jack said "because of her being an unhealthy drunk, Catherine was truly a heartless beast.", and then Wild Berry added "And she should be ashamed of herself as well for dumping and leaving her own daughter to die!", and then Jack said "Now let's get to the next time period to see how Ezra and his two younger brothers were all going to react to Irit's disappearance, as well as to the big bad story full of lies that Catherine is going to tell them all about their sister.", and then he and Wild Berry used their spirit magical abilities once again to take Chloe and Aylene with them to the next time period, which yet again takes place at Yigal, Gilad and Ezra's home.
When Chloe, Aylene, Jack and Wild Berry all reached the next time period, they saw Catherine has returned back home, but when her three male children asked her where did Irit go, because they're all already aware of Irit's 'sudden' disappearance, and then Catherine said while pretending to be sad in front of her children to fool them "There's no easy way to tell this to you three, but unfortunately, Irit have died in the middle of the night, and I had no choice but go to mourn her before I took her to the graveyard to bury her dead body. I'm sorry, but it just suddenly happened under my nose and I couldn't do anything about it.", and when Yigal, Gilad and Ezra all heard what their mother just said to them about their younger sister being dead, the three brothers all started to cry and shed tears and mourn over her before their mother pulled them all into a tight embrace, but she didn't shed tears because she lied to them and fooled them all.
This also made Chloe and Aylene cry to know that the same drunk woman who kidnapped and twisted Jeff (Chloe's father) also dared to dump her own daughter to die for being a girl, but then they went with Jack and Wild Berry back to the environment where the box with Irit and kittens is still located, and then suddenly, a miracle happened - a young and beautiful woman walked by in the area, but when she heard the baby girl and the kittns crying and meowing together inside the box, she turned to look down and when she saw the box, she approached and then opened it and found Irit and the baby kittens inside it all together, and at first she gasped in shock to see Irit in the box with the kittens, but then she quickly picked the box up and she decided to take both Irit and the kittens along with her to her home, and it turned out that the young woman was wealthy because of how her house looked like, which was in fact a huge and beautiful estate that was just the right place where Irit deserves to be raised (along with all the baby kittens), and when Chloe and Aylene watched how the young woman treated Irit properly like a real mother should, and also cared for the baby kittens as well, this made the two inseparable sisters to shed tears of joy when they realized that Irit is actually going to be living a happy life and grow up to be a wealthy woman like the one who took her in and adipted her as her own daughter (and along with the baby kittens (all of which will be pets to both Irit and her adoptive and wealthy mother)).
Then, Jack and Wild berry used their spirit magical abilities again to take Chloe and Aylene along with them to the next time period to see what happened to Yigal, Gilad and Ezra after their mother was sentenced once again, and for 20 years in jail and imprisonment (for kidnapping and twisting Jeff (Chloe's father)). This could and will uncover how Yigal, Gilad and Ezra received their animals (before Shujaa and Kenai's eventual redemptions), and possibly - how they arrived in Equestria in the first place.
When they arrived at the next time period, Chloe, Aylene, Jack and Wild Berry were all in an environment that looked quite familiar to Chloe - it was the same zoo where she got dumped and fed by her brother and her parents to the tigers in their enclosure when she was just 7 years-old, and when she saw Yigal, Gilad and Ezra quietly breaking into the zoo in the middle night without being spotted and/or apprehended, Chloe looked at what they're doing in shock as they eventually broke into the zoo without startling any of the animals, and then they started to sneak in the zoo and they made it towards the tiger enclosure, and then they started to quietly climb their way down to the enclosure and once standing on the bottom, the three started to search in the enclosure for some tigers, and this is when they stumbled upon a shocking and horrifying sight (which Chloe, Aylene, Jack and Wild Berry also saw as well).
They all saw an adult male Bengal tiger trying to drown a poor defenseless pure black tiger cub to death, but then Yigal snapped out of his shocked state, turned to pick up a large stick, and then he started to run towards the male tiger and then he started to attack and beat him up to make him let go of the pure black tiger cub, and after fighting the adult male tiger for about a few minutes, Yigal gave the tiger a final blow by swiping at the tiger with the large stick one last time, and he managed to break the tiger's neck, thus accidentally killing him.
However, once he killed the ferocious adult male tiger, Yigal then turned to see the pure black tiger cub slowly coming towards him, and so Yigal decided to throw his stick away before slowly lowering down to make himself less intimidating to the pure black tiger cub. Then, Yigal moved his arms and hands towards the pure black tiger cub, and then he started to gently stroke it on the back and the top of the head, and by doing so, Yigal actually managed to gain the pure black tiger cub's trust, but unfortunately, Yigal and his brothers doesn't have any milk which they need to use to feed the pure black tiger cub whose life Yigal just saved, but then Yigal came up with an idea - he and his brothers will leave the zoo, but they will also take the pure black tiger cub with them so they can raise it as their first loyal animal companion, and when Gilad and Ezra agreed with their younger brother's decision to care for the pure black tiger cub, this is when they started to climb out of the tiger enclosure, with the pure black tiger cub is being carried safely in Yigal's arms, and after sneaking out of the zoo all together, Yigal decided to choose a name for the pure black tiger cub whom he saved.
Eventually, Yigal came up with the name 'Tony', but then Gilad and Ezra added the word 'Black' to the cub's name (referring to the tiger cub's pure black fur which also made his stripes invisible), and when Chloe and Aylene saw the pure black tiger cub and heard him being named by Yigal and his brothers with the same name as the pure black adult male Bengal tiger (Tony Black) who was one of their worst enemies, the two sisters gasped in shock to know that this was none other than Tony Black himself when he was just a little tiger cub, and then they heard Yigal saying to his new pure black tiger cub whom he saved "Come with us, Tony Black. We saved your life, and now you're our first loyal animal companion. Come along.", and the young Tony Black responded by rearing up onto his hinder legs and hugging at Yigal's leg with both of his forelegs, thus prompting him to lower down and pick up his new tiger companion in his arms, and then Yigal, Gilad, Ezra and the young Tony Black left the environment all together.