The Reverse Jealousy Game

. . . . .

Prior to their date, Luke had envisioned how his evening with Lorelai was going to go. They would go out for a nice dinner in town, he would walk her home, she'd invite him inside, and they'd eventually make their way up to her bedroom. That was typically how their date nights went.

But the plan for the evening shifted a bit when they were at dinner. As they were eating their desserts and finishing up their bottle of wine, a group of women were seated at an empty table behind Luke. Over the next few minutes, Lorelai noticed one of the women kept glancing over at him.

Finally, Lorelai leaned toward him and said softly, "Don't look, but there's a table of women over there and this brunette keeps checking you out."

"Oh, yeah?" He started to turn his head.

"Dude, I just said not to look," Lorelai quietly scolded him.

Luke turned back to face her. "I wanna see if I recognize her. Maybe it's someone who knows me."

"Okay, but be casual about it," Lorelai said. "I'll tell you when to look." She watched the table for a few moments, and when no one was looking their way, she said, "Okay, now, quick."

Luke turned around and surveyed the group of women, and then turned back to Lorelai. "The only one I recognize is the one with the dark hair and the blue dress. Is that the one who was looking?"

"Yes. Who is it?"

"That's Sadie. You've met her before."

"Sadie?" Lorelai thought for a moment, trying to remember where she knew that name from. "Oh, wait... Sadie from the hardware store?"

"Yup."

"Huh." Lorelai glanced over at the table. She had met Sadie once when she'd gone to the store with Luke, and she looked very different out of her hardware store clothes. "She cleans up nice."

Luke ran his hand over the top of his hair and joked, "She probably keeps looking over here because she's never seen me without the baseball cap."

"Yeah, she's probably thinking that you clean up nice, too," Lorelai said. "Does she live in town? I've never seen her at the town meetings or any of the festivals."

Luke shrugged. "No idea. Maybe she's just got better things to do with her time than to participate in town functions."

Lorelai feigned an offended gasp. "Blasphemy." She nonchalantly glanced over at the table again as she ate a forkful of cake. "You know... maybe you should go over there and say hi to her."

Luke narrowed his eyes at her. "What?"

Lorelai put down her fork and leaned back in her chair. "Maybe you should go say hi to her, see how she's doing, interact with her a little bit... while I watch you." She seductively raised an eyebrow. "I think it's your turn to be the naughty one in our little game."

Luke eyed her for a moment, unsure if she was serious. "For real?"

"For real," she confirmed. "If you're up for another round of gameplay tonight, maybe we could do a little role reversal. Go make me jealous."

They had never done that before when playing the game, but Luke was intrigued by the idea of mixing things up a little. He wiped his lips with his napkin, and then nodded. "Okay, yeah... I'm up for it if you are."

Lorelai grinned. "Let's do it."

"Okay, I'll go say hi." Luke started to stand up, but Lorelai reached for his hand.

"Wait, let's pay the check first so we can leave right away," she suggested. "And then we'll go to your place, it's closer."

After they had paid the check, Lorelai excused herself as if she was going to the ladies' room, and then Luke made his move. He went over to the table of women and said hello to Sadie, and then was introduced to her dining companions.

Lorelai watched him from the edge of the room. All five women were looking up at him... smiling and giggling at whatever he was saying. He wasn't always a man of many words, especially with people he didn't know well, but he looked like he was doing a pretty good job of interacting with them and holding their attention.

After a few minutes, Lorelai sauntered over to the table and linked her arm through Luke's. "You ready, hon?" she asked him, and then she flashed a smile at the women. "Hello."

"Lorelai, you remember Sadie, right?" Luke said to Lorelai. "From the hardware store?"

"Oh, sure I do," Lorelai said, and politely nodded toward her. "Nice to see you again."

"You, too," Sadie replied.

"It's her birthday," Luke said. "Some of her friends came in from out of town to celebrate."

Lorelai smiled. "Girls' night out, sounds fun," she said, and then smiled at Sadie. "Happy birthday."

"Thank you," Sadie replied.

"I was just telling her to stop by the diner tomorrow for a cup of coffee on the house," Luke continued. "A little belated birthday present."

Lorelai was still for a moment, caught off guard, and she blinked a few times before stammering, "Oh, well, cool, sure... that was nice of you." She inhaled a deep breath. "We should get going... you ready?"

"Yup."

They said goodbye to the table and left the restaurant. As they started walking down the sidewalk toward his apartment, she glanced over at him. "Free coffee, huh?"

"I thought it was a nice gesture."

Lorelai pursed her lips. "Mmhmm."

Luke eyed her for a moment. She seemed annoyed, but he was suddenly unsure if she was actually upset or if it was part of the game. "Wait, are you really mad or just pretend-mad?"

Lorelai shrugged. "Maybe not mad so much as surprised."

"I was just being friendly," Luke insisted. "It didn't mean anything, I was playing the game. Wasn't I supposed to be trying to make you a little jealous?"

Lorelai stopped walking and calmly turned to face him. "Yes, but think about it for a minute from my perspective... how would you feel if I was fake-flirting with some guy at a bar as part of a silly game and invited him to come see me the next day outside of the game?"

Luke thought it over for a moment, and then stepped closer to her. "I'd be jealous and probably a little angry," he admitted.

Lorelai cocked her head to the side. "See?"

"I'm sorry," he said sincerely. "I didn't really think about it like that. I mean, it's someone we both know from town, so it didn't seem like a big deal to invite her to come into my public business for coffee. It really didn't mean anything."

Lorelai nodded understandingly. "I know, I get it. I'm not mad, it just caught me by surprise, that's all." She waved it off. "It's fine, no big deal."

"You sure?"

"Yup."

"Okay." He shrugged a little as he added, "See, you're better at the flirting role than I am. It's new for me."

Lorelai smiled. "You'll get the hang of it."

Luke nodded, and then leaned in to kiss her.

Lorelai quickly pulled back and covered his mouth with her hand. "Oh, no," she said, shaking her head. "You're not getting me that easy, buddy... you have to earn me. You have to show me you're sorry for how you acted. Got it?"

As she dropped her hand from his face, Luke had a sly smile on his lips. "Got it."

They went up to his apartment and she led him over to the bed. They stood next to it facing each other, and she folded her arms across her chest. "Take off your shoes and your shirt," she told him.

Luke took off his shoes and socks, and then pulled off his shirt, revealing a white t-shirt underneath.

"That one, too," Lorelai said, gesturing to the t-shirt.

After Luke pulled it off and dropped it on the floor, Lorelai kicked off her high heels and stepped closer to him. "Now, take off my clothes," she told him.

Luke smiled as he reached for her shirt and pulled it up over her head. He dropped it on top of his shirts on the floor, and then she turned around to give him access to her skirt zipper. He unzipped it and slid the skirt down her legs, and then moved up to unclasp her bra. He slid her bra straps down her arms, and as it fell from her body, she turned around to face him.

As he reached to remove her underwear, Lorelai felt a surge of excitement rush through her body. Her heart was racing, and she could already feel herself getting wet as he slowly pulled the lacy fabric down her legs.

As she stood naked in front of him, she could see his eyes moving down her body, and she snapped her fingers in front of his face. "Eyes up here," Lorelai said, gesturing to her own face.

Luke smirked as he moved his gaze up to meet hers. "Sorry."

"Now, rule number 1, no touching unless I give you permission."

"Yes, ma'am," he replied, giving her a playful salute.

"Rule number 2, no calling me ma'am," Lorelai continued.

Luke smirked. "Got it."

"Sit down," Lorelai said, pointing to the bed, and as he did, she moved to stand directly in front of him. "Now, let's talk about what went on tonight. First, you decided to mingle with a table of women in the middle of our date, and then you invited one of them to come visit you for free coffee. That cover it?"

"Pretty much, yeah."

Lorelai put her hands on her hips. "You looked like you were enjoying your little chat with those women tonight."

Luke shrugged nonchalantly. "They were friendly."

"Were you picturing yourself in some sort of wild orgy with them?" she asked. "You as the strong, sexy man satisfying all those beautiful women?"

Luke shook his head. "Nope, I was just talking."

"Talking or flirting?"

"Just talking."

Lorelai doubtfully cocked her head to the side. "Luke."

Luke exhaled a sigh and shrugged. "Okay, fine, maybe it could have possibly come off as unintentional flirting."

"Well, that Sadie is pretty good looking, so I would understand if you have trouble not flirting with her every time you see her at the store."

Luke shook his head. "It's always completely innocent."

"Innocent, huh?" Lorelai stepped closer to him. "So, you've never found yourself thinking about what she'd be like in bed?"

Luke shook his head. "Nope."

"Not once?" she asked as she rested her hands on his shoulders. "You've never pictured her naked?" She leaned forward and brushed her lips against his. "You've never fantasized about doing dirty things to her?"

He was getting revved up by her hands on his body and her breath against his lips, and he instinctively reached for her waist to pull her closer.

Lorelai quickly pushed his hands away as she reminded him, "No touching."

"Sorry." He gripped the bed sheets on either side of him to try to resist the temptation to touch her.

"Answer the question," she prompted him.

"No, I don't fantasize about anyone else... I only think about doing dirty things to you," Luke told her, and then he leaned in closer as he rasped, "And for the record, I think about it a lot."

Lorelai hummed her approval at his comment, and then eyed him for a moment, contemplating her next move. "So, I take it that you would like to make it up to me, your accidental flirting from this evening."

"I would," he confirmed with a nod.

Lorelai pushed gently against his chest, guiding him to lie back against the mattress, and then she climbed on top of him and straddled his waist. She leaned forward over him until her face was close to his. "So, you like doing dirty things to me, huh?"

"Yes."

She leaned even closer and whispered, "You like making me come?"

"Mmhmm," he murmured. "I love making you come."

"Good... because that's your only job tonight." Lorelai moved her body forward until she was kneeling over his head with her center aligned just above his mouth. "This is the first round." She ran her fingers through his hair as she asked, "You good down there?"

As he inhaled the scent of her arousal, he felt his cock straining against the confines of his pants. He couldn't wait to dive in and make her start squirming with pleasure. "Mmm," he hummed from beneath her.

"Okay... start working your magic," she said.

His arms hooked around her thighs as he eagerly started licking her. Lorelai moaned at the contact to her sex and closed her eyes as he went to work. He had a talented mouth, and always seemed to thoroughly enjoy giving her pleasure just as much as she enjoyed receiving it.

His expert ministrations continued for a few minutes as he worked fervently to build her up and send her over the edge. His tongue explored her wetness, he nibbled on her lips, teased her clit... he left no inch of skin untouched between her thighs, and her body was quivering from the intense buildup of arousal. His hands began to roam her body, sliding up the front of her to caress her breasts, and down the back of her to squeeze her ass.

Eventually, when he was ready to make her climax, he focused on her clit and massaged it with his tongue until she exploded. She leaned forward and rested her palms against the mattress, panting to catch her breath as he began gently kissing her inner thighs.

"Oh, my God," she murmured, and after a few moments, she rolled onto her side to lie beside him on the bed.

He rolled onto his side to face her. "Did I pass round one?"

Lorelai smiled and reached over to wipe away some moisture from his face. "With flying colors. You, my friend, are extremely skilled."

"Thank you. I take pride in perfecting my hobbies."

"As the only person in the world who benefits from this particular perfected hobby of yours, I'm much obliged." Lorelai propped herself up on her elbows, then climbed off the bed and gestured for him to stand up. "Up, please."

Luke climbed off the bed and stood in front of her. She stepped up to him, placed her hand on the bulge in his pants, and gave it a squeeze. "Someone's hard for me," she said.

"Always."

"You thinking about the dirty things you wanna do to me?"

"Always."

Lorelai smiled. "I bet you wanna get out of these pants, don't you?"

Luke nodded. "Yup."

Lorelai draped her arms across his shoulders. "I also bet that you wanna touch me some more, huh?"

"Badly."

"Go ahead."

Luke's hands slid up her sides and then he wrapped his arms around her, pulling her up against his body. "Is kissing included in touching?"

Lorelai nodded before pressing her lips against his for a deep, passionate kiss that had their tongues energetically tangling within seconds. When they finally separated, they were both panting for breath.

"What do you wanna do to me?" she asked him.

"Everything," he replied, and he slid his hands down to cup the cheeks of her ass. "What do you want me to do to you?"

Lorelai leaned in and kissed him again. "I wanna hear you to talk dirty to me," she muttered against his lips. "That's round 2. And then round 2 will get me nice and ready for round 3, which includes you making me come for the second time tonight." She moved her mouth to his ear to whisper, "You're gonna make me come again, right, babe?"

Luke let out a soft groan at her words. "Mmhmm, it's my only job tonight."

"Mmm," she hummed approvingly. "Good boy."

He leaned in and pressed his lips to her neck below her ear. She moaned softly and closed her eyes as he alternated between licking and sucking her skin. After a few moments, he pulled his lips away from her neck, and Lorelai felt his breath against her ear. "You're thinking about my cock right now, aren't you?" he whispered, and it sent a tingle down her spine.

Lorelai's eyes fluttered open and she exhaled a few shallow breaths as she nodded. "Yes."

He leaned down and swirled his tongue over her nipple, and then the other one, then met her gaze as he declared, "You're thinking about how badly you want me inside of you."

Lorelai swallowed hard as she reached down to unbutton his pants.

He moved his hand down between her legs and gently rubbed her folds. "You can't wait to feel me moving inside of you, sliding in and out, in and out."

Lorelai's body was shuddering with arousal as she struggled to push his pants and boxers down to his ankles. "Take these off," she urged.

Luke helped remove the clothing, and then ran his hands up her body to her chest. His hands covered her breasts, and he began squeezing them and moving his palms in circles against her nipples.

Lorelai was groaning at his touch as she reached for his hardness. She wrapped her hands around his shaft and gently began dragging her fingers up and down the length of it.

Luke inhaled a sharp breath at the sensations rushing through his body as she stroked him. He leaned into her until his forehead was resting against hers. "You want me to start sliding that in and out of you over and over?" he asked, and then moved his hand between her legs and slipped his finger between her folds. "Like this?"

Lorelai gasped with surprise as he stroked his finger into her. "Oh, my God, Luke," she moaned as she tilted her head back. "Jesus."

Luke pulled his hand away from her. "That's what you want, isn't it, Lorelai?"

Lorelai nodded as she ran her thumb over his tip, smoothing away the bit of moisture that had gathered there. "I want it inside me," she confirmed, and then looked up into his eyes. "But now to decide exactly how I want you to give it to me."

"I'll give it to you however you want," he told her, his hands smoothing up and down her sides.

"So, if I want you to go slow and gentle?" she asked as she moved a hand down to squeeze his balls.

Luke grunted his approval and shifted his feet to steady himself. He was so turned on, ready to pounce on her the second she told him to. "Then you'll get it slow and gentle."

"And what if..." Lorelai pressed a delicate kiss to his lips before continuing, "...I want you to fuck me as hard as you possibly can?"

Luke groaned against her lips and kissed her hungrily before pulling back. "Then you'll be fucked pretty damn hard," he muttered breathlessly.

Lorelai kissed him again, hard and deep, before pulling away and moving toward the bed. Luke watched as she lay on her back in the center of the mattress, and propped herself up on her elbows. Her legs fell open and she beckoned him toward her with her head. "Come here for round 3."

Luke immediately joined her on the bed and kneeled between her legs. As she let her head fall back against the mattress, he crawled up over her body and kissed her. "Tell me how you want it."

Lorelai put her hands on his face and pulled him into another kiss before replying, "Hard... and more talking."

Luke reached down to guide his cock to her opening, and rubbed the tip against her wet slit before he slid his length into her. She moaned loudly with pleasure as he pushed into her as deep as he could go.

He rested his elbows on the mattress on either side of her and moved his lips close to hers. "You feel how deep I am?"

"Mmhmm."

"Buried completely inside you," Luke continued, and he gyrated his hips a little. "You feel that? You feel every inch of me?"

Lorelai was whimpering as surges of excitement rushed through her body. "God, yes."

"You want me to keep filling you just like this? That what you want?"

Lorelai eagerly nodded. "Yes." He pulled out of her to the tip and slammed his entire length back into her, forcing a yelp from her lips. "Ohhhh God," she muttered. "Keep going."

"You sure you can handle that?" Luke asked as he pulled out and slammed into her again. "You sure you don't want me to be gentle?"

Lorelai moaned with pleasure and shook her head, muttering, "Hard."

He started thrusting into her with hard, deep thrusts while continuing the dirty talk she'd requested. The physical and verbal stimulation had her entire body pulsating with arousal, and her moans and whimpers were constant.

Lorelai ran her hands up and down his back, dragging her nails against his skin. "God, it feels so good," she muttered in between gasping moans. "Don't stop."

"Wasn't planning on it," he said before leaning down to kiss her, and she threaded her fingers through his hair as her tongue danced with his.

When they separated, he continued stroking into her at a steady pace, and she watched him intently, enamored by that wild look of desire in his eyes. After a few minutes, when she knew they were both close, she slid her hands up his chest to his neck. "Luke, make me come again," she said in a breathy whisper.

Luke adjusted his body a little for better balance before reaching his other hand down between her legs. She was already on the brink of climaxing, and it only took a few seconds of him rubbing her clit before she tumbled over the edge. Her moans of ecstasy filled the room as she writhed on the bed beneath him.

Once she had settled down from her high, she began caressing his body and murmured, "You gonna come for me? I wanna feel you explode."

"Oh, you will, very soon," he replied through gritted teeth. He slammed into her a few more times before his eyes clenched shut and he let out a growling moan.

As he released inside of her, she moaned contently and smoothed her hands up and down his back. Luke pulled out of her and stared down at her for a few moments as he panted to catch his breath. "Have I mentioned lately how sexy you are and how much you turn me on?" he finally said to her.

Lorelai smiled up at him as she wrapped her arms around his neck. "Not specifically with words, just with actions like the insanely hot body-ravaging you do to me."

"Oh, well, good, as long as the point comes across."

"It does."

Luke placed a few tender kisses to her lips, and then he softly said, "You know I didn't mean anything by inviting her to stop in for coffee."

Lorelai smiled at just the notion of him wanting to make sure she wasn't upset about that. "I know you didn't," she assured him.

"It was just a friendly neighborly thing."

"I get it, it's fine," she told him, but with a sly smile added, "But if she did interpret it as you flirting with her and then tries to reciprocate, I'll have Taylor run her out of town."

Luke smirked. "I don't doubt that." He rolled off of her to lie on the bed beside her.

Lorelai was quiet for a moment, reliving the evening in her head, then rolled over to face him. "You know, you're better at the bossy part of the jealousy game than I am," she told him. "You've got that dominant thing down."

"What are you talking about? You were in charge, you knew what you wanted... it was great. It was fun."

"It was fun. 'Double your pleasure, double your fun' type of fun," Lorelai said, raising an eyebrow.

Luke smiled. "'Totally wore me out' type of fun."

"'Already looking forward to the next time' type of fun."

"Yup. All of the above."

. . . . .

. . . . .