Lily watched as Finn rolled his suitcase through the parking lot of San Antonio International Airport that Saturday a day ahead of Hell in a Cell. She blew the horn of her car and stuck her body halfway out of the window to greet him. "Hello gorgeous!"

"Hello, yourself," he smirked, his eyes hidden behind dark sunglasses. "Can you pop the trunk so I can load my bags?"

"We have to make a grocery run. My mom gave me a long list of stuff to get while I'm out. My dad's having a little get together," Lily informed when he got into the passenger's seat.

"A get together, eh? Is that something I should be attending?"

"Of course. When I told him that I was going to meet you he told me to invite you," she replied. Lily began backing out, not seeing the car behind her. It blew and she slammed on the breaks, causing Finn's head to hit the dashboard. "Sorry."

Sitting up, he rubbed his forehead. "Remind me to never let you drive when we're back on the road. I don't care if I'm half-sleep with a concussion!"

Finn refused to even let her drive her own shopping cart as they entered the store. "You may have a head on collision with some old lady."

"Hey, Lily," a familiar voice spoke and she turned around.

"Oh, hey, Todd," Lily said, acknowledging one of her old classmates. "What's up?"

"Just visiting my family for the weekend," he replied.

"Where are you?"

"Princeton," he nodded, proudly. "Are you at USC?"

"No," she shook her head. "I had other plans?"

Todd raised a brow. "Really? Like what?"

"Dreams," was all she said before reuniting with Finn.

"Who was that?" he asked.

"The boy I had my first kiss with," Lily answered.

Finn's head whipped around. "You could've done better than some preppy rich kid."

"I am a preppy rich kid if you haven't noticed. You just rode in my Mercedes and my house has eight bedrooms even though it's just the three of us," she snorted. "We didn't have jacked up wrestler types walking the halls of my school so I settled for the guy with the least punchable face. I'm sure his father paid his way to Princeton because he's dumb as rocks."

"If that kid had the least punchable face, I'd love to see the guy with the most. Yikes," he grimaced. "What's your type anyway?"

"You.." she giggled. Being around him after that night wasn't as awkward as she thought it would be. That actually helped break the ice between them. There were no more forced small talk or shy glances. They carried on now like a platonic couple.

"Oh, 37 year old Irishmen. If you're willing to bump 37 up to 40, Sheamus is available," he joked.

"Do you have his number?" Lily winked.

"The moment you make eye contact with Sheamus in any way other than to exchange pleasantries, I will call Shawn and make sure he's on a flight from San Antonio to wherever you stand,"

"I'll be sure to tell him that I exchanged pleasure with his trusted chaperone…" an evil grin overtook her face. "Let's not even get into what I'd tell Cathy."

"You like to play the game dirty, eh? I was fooled into thinking you were a good girl but with a name like Lilith I shouldn't be surprised..."

"And that's where I took my first bump at like 3," Lily pointed out the window at the park as she took Finn on a tour around her hometown. "And that stadium is where I was supposed to graduate but it has no roof and it rained so we had to have it in the auditorium."

"Good thing you're not billed from here yet. It's a tradition that the hometown wrestler always loses," Finn replied.

"Yeah, I know. I'm not doing anything tomorrow anyway because H is afraid casuals or nonfan will come just to come and recognize me," Lily turned on her street and pulled up in her driveway.

"Really?"

"Sure, why not?" he asked. Lily stumbled and fell into his hard body. He chuckled as he steadied her. "God, Lilith, I'm the one actually carrying something."

When Lily looked up, her mother was standing in the doorway, nervously wringing her hands. "We're back!"

"Lily, d-did you get everything?" Lily's Mom stammered, rubbing her throat as if it were dry.

"Everything you wanted and some you didn't," Lily smelled meat grilling on the barbeque pit as soon as she stepped inside. "Mom, this is Finn. Finn, this is my mom."

"Fergal, ma'am, pleased to meet you," Finn threw his smile on her but she didn't seem impressed, her expression never changed as she shook his hand. This shocked Lily because her mother was usually very friendly when she met new people.

"My god, what happened to your forehead?" Mom asked.

Finn reached up and touched it. The spot was red and swelling a little. "Car accident. I hope you have car insurance on Lily because I'm thinking about suing."

Again, her mom wasn't amused. "Lily, go wrap some ice in a towel."

When Lily returned, Finn was sitting on a stool with his legs spread. Without thinking, she walked into the V shape they formed and began tending to his knot.

"Lily, I think he can handle that himself…"

"Oh, right," Lily replied, backing off.

"Hey, you made it," Shawn said, coming through the back door wearing an apron. "We're out back, come have a drink with us."

We being Hunter and fellow Texas natives Booker T, Stone Cold and The Undertaker. Shawn always kept his home life and his wrestling life separate so this was Lily's first time meeting everyone. Now that she was in the business, Shawn felt it was time to finally invite them over.

"Do you need help, Mom?" Lily asked, pleasantly.

"Sure…"

They worked together in complete silence on macaroni, chili, fried okra and blueberry cobbler but when they were halfway through the pecan pies, Lily couldn't take it anymore. "Mom, what is it?"

"Are you sleeping with him?" Lily's mom finally blurted.

"What?" Lily was taken aback.

"Are you having sex with him?"

"I understood you the first time, Mom. I'm just confused about why you would ask that?" Lily replied, genuinely curious.

"Nevermind why I'm asking. Just answer the question." Mom firmly demanded.

"I'm still a virgin, if that's what you want to know."

Her mother paused for a minute, closing her eyes before asking. "Have you had any sort of sexual contact with him?"

Lily's face went white. She hadn't always told her mother everything, but she didn't make a habit out of lying to her, either. This was big. She couldn't hide it. "Yes, but it was just once."

"I knew it!"

"How?"

"Mother's intuition, and then some like you both were way too comfortable with you standing between his legs. Did he pressure you?"

"No, of course not! He was the one who stopped it before we went too far," Lily admitted.

"Lily, that's a man and I'm afraid you're going to get hurt doing whatever it is that you're doing with him. I can't tell you to stop because you're thousands of miles away from home ever week so just like with wrestling, you're going to do what you want to do. Just be careful, okay?"

"I don't think you have to worry because he isn't going to let it go any further than it went that night…"

"Are you on birth control?"

"Mom!"

"Hey, when I said be careful I meant more than just emotionally," she shrugged.

"No, Mom, I'm not on birth control and I don't think I need to start the pill. Now on to more important matters..." Lily paused. "...are you going to tell Dad?"

"I kept the wrestling a secret, I guess I can keep this under wraps too but if he finds out on his own, don't involve me. As far as you know I have no knowledge of it because not only will he kill you and Fergal, he'll kill me as well. It'll be a triple murder-suicide."

"I bet," Lily replied, walking over to look out of the back window. Shawn's lips were moving and Finn was laughing at whatever was being said as he held a beer.

Soon the sun set and dinner was served. Lily sat next to Finn as she listened to old road stories.

"Then there was that time in Vegas when Flair, Shawn and H had that stripper-"

"Hey!" Shawn interrupted Booker. "I don't know if you've noticed but this is my wife and that's my daughter."

"Sorry, man, I got a little carried away," Booker chuckled.

"I'd actually like to hear the end of that story," Lily's Mom commented. "What year was this?"

"96..."

"I met Shawn in 97 so he barely skated by..."

"So, Lily, the WWE Universe has been begging Shawn to come back after his segment with Taker the other week. How do you feel about that?" Hunter asked.

"Uh…" Lily's first reaction was to glance at the side of Finn's head because she knew if Shawn came back, they'd soon reveal her parentage and Finn wouldn't be necessary anymore. That action caused Hunter to raise a suspicious brow and his jaw tensed. "If it happens, I think it'll be great. I'm surprised it took this long to get him back in a ring."

Afterwards, Finn helped her with the dishes. Lily added too much liquid and Finn enthusiastically popped bubbles.

"But I'm the child," she scoffed.

"Speaking of child, how to you really feel about Shawn potentially coming back?"

"I don't know. I was enjoying the freedom I have on the road and I know if he comes back that's going to be the end of that. Then of course, we can't be together anymore. Well not together-together," she quickly clarified. "We won't be able to ride and hang together anymore. Let's just pray it's a one off thing or he doesn't come back on the road at all."

"Fortunately, your father likes me so I think he'll let us hang," he replied. He looked at his watch and walked over to Hunter. "Whenever you leave, can I catch you. I have to try to find a hotel."

"I'm getting ready to leave now," Hunter replied, flashing the keys in his hand.

"Find?" Shawn tilted his head. "You aren't already checked in?"

"No, as soon as I got off the plane, Lily was waiting to pick me up and I came straight here," Finn explained.

"Well, the hotel I'm booked at has no vacancies but I'll drive you around until we find one," Hunter said.

"How about I save you both the trouble. He can stay here, we have plenty of guest bedrooms," Shawn offered without thinking twice.

"No, Shawn, thank you but I couldn't. I've already eaten you out of house and home, drunk your beers and heard enough stories to last a lifetime. You don't owe me anything," Finn politely declined.

"I insist. You've been babysitting my daughter and looking out for her. The least I can is put you up for the night on a mattress softer than whatever hotel you were going to check into. Not to mention my wife's breakfast," Shawn bragged.

"Shawn, I can't-" Finn shook his head.

"I'm not going to take no for an answer!" Shawn replied in a firm tone.

"Okay," Finn agreed reluctantly with a sigh.

Lily's jaw dropped upon hearing the exchange. Finn spending the night in her home. What could possibly go wrong.

How did I get myself into this, was the first thought that went through his head as he walked out of the front door to retrieve his bags from Lily's trunk. Hunter followed him out.

"I'll see you tomorrow," Hunter said, extending his hand. Finn met it and Hunter began applying pressure to the grip. It felt bone crushing. "For Shawn to trust you enough to watch over his daughter and invite you to spend the night in his home shows how much respect he has for you. He loves Lily and as her godfather, so do I. It would kill him if he found out anything shady was going on with her."

"Shady, like what?" Finn hissed after H released his hand. He flexed it just to make sure it wasn't broken.

"Anything and I do mean anything that she'd have to keep secret from him," H replied before disappearing into the night. Finn didn't know what H knew exactly but if he sniffed something out, Shawn would eventually catch on, too.

When he entered the house, Lily's Mom was waiting on him. She'd been nice enough but he could tell she wasn't crazy about him. Lily was nowhere to be found and neither was Shawn.

"Let me show you to your room, Fergal," with a tight smile she began taking him on what seemed like a maze of hallways. He assumed she was showing him to a room far away from Lily and heck, if he wanted to get back to Lily he wouldn't be able to find his way to her. Finally, she turned the light on in a nice room with a king size bed with thick bedposts, large pillows. "Will this do?"

"Yes ma'am, it's very nice," he complimented.

"Thanks. I hope you're in for the night. See in the morning," the way she said it told him that she suspected something as well. Shit, things were getting way too close to home.

Cathy: Are you at the hotel?

Finn: I'm in a room...

Cathy: K, I'm about to call you in 5.

It was about 2 AM and Finn couldn't sleep. He threw the sheets back and climbed out of bed. He walked the halls and came to a full stop in front of Shawn's glass gun display cabinet. The sight sent a shiver down his spine.

Pretty soon he found himself in a room that appeared to be Shawn's own personal museum. Framed photos of his best moments, display cases that held every title he'd ever won, every t-shirt that was ever made was lined on the walls and he even had mannequins wearing his Wrestlemania outfits. There was a small nearly empty case in the corner. Inside were two pictures of Lily: one during her debut match and one of her winning her first PPV match. Finn heard the door open and turned.

Lily yelped in surprise. She held a hand to her chest to calm herself. "I didn't know anyone was in here. I was getting a drink from the kitchen and saw the light coming from under the door. I thought that my dad was showed off his narcissist room to the guys earlier and forgot to turn the light off."

"No, it's just me," he replied. "Narcissist room? Everyone in the business today should hope to have accomplished enough to fill an entire room. I've been in this business for 17 years and I don't think I'd even be able to fill one wall yet."

"Yet? You're almost 40. Give up, Grandpa," she teased.

"Grandpa? But don't you want to...hmm. I assumed you had daddy issues but maybe I should take it back a generation," he snorted.

"Ha...ha," she replied sarcastically and began approaching him. That's when he noticed the state of her dress. She was only wearing a pink t-shirt and her virginal white panties were peeking out from under. Her eyes lustfully roamed his shirtless body, his pajama pants riding low on his v-cut.

He put his hand out to stop her. "Lilith, stay back."

"What? Why?" she asked, halting her step.

"Because this is a dangerous game and we can't play it with a full case of guns right around the corner!" he stressed. "I know you want me and unfortunately, I feel the same. You're half naked in front of me and I've been drinking all evening. It's best if you keep your distance."

"What if I don't want to keep my distance," Lily she countered as she took a threatening step forward.

"Lilith!" he hissed through his teeth. "This is a very lovely home but not fitting enough to die in when Shawn wakes up and finds me in here alone with his panty clad daughter.

"My dad sleeps like a hibernating bear," she moved in close, violating his personal space. "Let's finish what we started in China."

"I'd love nothing more but I can't. I can't be your first and I can't help you break your father's heart," he pleaded with her.

"My dad loves you if you can't tell and if we do things the right way, he may give you his blessing. If he isn't crazy about it at first he'll eventually come to accept us like he did my wrestling," she replied. "And I want you to be my first."

"No," he shook his head. "Your first time should be special not wasted on the likes of me. It shouldn't be like this, sneaking around in your own home."

"But it will be special, with you," she cooed.

"Why are you so in a hurry to have sex? Is it because of me because we don't have to do this in order for you to keep my attention, Lilith. I like you for more than your looks or what we can do sexually. Despite our age difference, we get along well, you're passionate about everything you do and you're a great person."

"That just confirmed that you're exactly who I want. Someone who actually cares about me."

"How many times and how many ways do I have to say you're Shawn Michaels' daughter?"

"God, am I not supposed to have a life because I'm Shawn Michaels daughter?" she frowned. "Am I never supposed to date or have sex because I'm Shawn Michaels daughter? I'm only 18 and just months into my WWE career. I'm going to be around for years to come. Being on the road 300 days a year, 9 times out of 10, my future partner is going to be a coworker. I could end up being just a notch in the belt of someone like Dolph or I could be with someone like you," she looked up at him with those blue eyes, how could he say no?

"You are going to be the death of me, literally," he remarked. He knew this was wrong but somehow couldn't stop himself from playing with fire. He couldn't fight it or maybe he could but didn't want to. "Where is your room and more importantly, where is your parent's room?"

"My room is on the other side of the house. My parents room is upstairs."

"You said your dad is a hibernating bear but what about your mom? Does she get up in the middle of the night for any reason? Bathroom? Glass of water? To check on you?"

"No, there's a bathroom in their room, she keeps a glass of water on the nightstand and she hasn't check on me since I was 12. Besides, she downed so many glasses of wine this evening, I don't expect her to be up anytime soon."

"Lead the way," he gestured and off they went. In the dark hallway, he saw a shadow dart between them and then felt teeth nipping at his ankles. "What the hell? Get your puppy."

"He's not a puppy, he's a six year old teacup pomeranian. Stop, Frankie!" Lily scolded. "He probably thinks you're kidnapping me or something."

Once the door was closed, Lily tried to look confident as they stood in her bedroom but he could tell she was nervous. "C-can we turn off the lights? I think it would be for the best anyway in case by some miracle one of my parents do wake."

Finn knew that she was probably feeling shy now that the moment was here so he respected her wishes and hit the lights.

He simply placed my index finger below her chin and gently lifted her head so that their lips could touch. Hers tasted like vanilla. He was hard almost instantly. He smiled a wide and devious smile into the darkness. It was sheer magic the way Lily responded, at first just their lips touching, Finn didn't want to push her in any way. No matter how far they went tonight he still wanted her to know she had the option to change her mind. He felt a slight trembling as their lips moved together delicately.

Lily was beautiful and though he knew he didn't deserve her virginity, he felt it was a privilege to initiate her into the world of sex.

His tongue slipped out to lick her lips. She parted them in response, allowing his tongue into her mouth. Silently his lips moved down to trace over the smooth skin of her neck as she leaned into him. He heard a quiet moan escape her lips. He tugged at her shirt and she took a step back to help him remove it. Though it was dark and he couldn't see her, he knew she had a perfect petite-meets-curvy body.

Leaning down, Finn made small circles around her nipple with his tongue, making them smaller and smaller before sucking the bud into his mouth. He bit down and she began breathing harder.

"I want to touch you," she whispered. He obliged, pushing his pajama bottoms down, he sprung out. Lily took his penis by her hand and caressed it, exploring it with nervous hands. "Wow, they didn't lie. I'm glad the lights are out because I'd die if I had to watch this thing try to fit inside of me."

"Who are they?" his breath hitched as she stroked him.

"Let's leave it at they," she giggled.

"Would they happen to be Della and Marina?"

"Yep. Have you ever…with one of them?"

"No, never! Those two are like one of the guys," he laughed.

"Have you slept with any other WWE employee besides Cathy?"

"No, I haven't and how did we get so far off track?" he asked, walking her over to the bed and pushing her down to sit. "Now it's my turn to touch you."

Going to his knees, Finn kissed his way down her firm stomach to her belly button and then began to continue down to her panties. He inhaled a big whiff of her sweet scent. He took hold of the elastic band of her panties with his teeth and pulled them down. She giggled a little in response.

He ran the palm of his hand up and down her, feeling her wetness. As he rubbed, he would occasionally tease a finger at her entrance. Lily shuddered when he finally inserted a digit halfway inside of her. Spreading her legs wider, she allowed him more room to explore as she laid back on the bed from her sitting position.

He took this opportunity to flatten his tongue and slowly press it along her slit, sliding from the bottom to the top. She gasped, her breath caught in her throat, and then her entire body began to shake. When he reached her clit, he gave it several firm quick licks before sucking the bed into his mouth. She bucked violently against his mouth and he wrapped his arms under her thighs and around her hips to try his best to hold her down. Before long her clit was completely swollen due to his attention turning her into a whimpering mess. As Finn french kissed her clit she came and when he didn't stop to give her time to rest, she came again, her body held firmly in place.

"S-stop, it's sore!" she whimpered.

"It's not sore, it's sensitive but as you wish," he sat up on his knees. Finn moved his penis up and down against her wet clitoris. Though he wanted to enter her right then and there, he wasn't overtly trying to. This action was done mostly for her to feel him and get used to the idea of having him in that area.

"Shit," he cursed, backing away from her.

"What?" she asked.

"Condom…"

"Oh yeah," she replied. "Leave no evidence behind...especially a baby."

"I'd start looking for flights to Japan immediately because my WWE career would be over the second word got back to Hunter. Heck, my life would be over the second it got to Shawn. Both will probably be over for doing this alone."

Finn walked naked through the halls. He knew he was fucked if one of her parents came downstairs. He walked until he made it back to his room. He went ahead and snapped the condom on there because it was easy to leave a condom wrapper laying around and didn't want to risk leaving it in Lily's room. He stared at his bed. He could crawl into it, fall asleep and forget this ever happened but he was in too deep now.

He jumped when he saw movement out of the corner of his eye. It was the dog standing in his doorway. Its head was tilted and he appeared to be judging Finn. "Frankie is it? You'll understand when you meet a girl dog...assuming you aren't fixed...which you probably are. Sorry, bud."

He made his way back to her room and she was still in the same spot.

"Lilith, I've been gone for about five minutes. That should've given you plenty of time to think. Are you sure you want to do this?" he asked. "Once it's gone you can't get it back."

Her response was to buck forward against him. "Yes."

"Okay," he sighed, lining himself up to her entrance. He lightly pressed forward and was met with resistance that caused her to hiss. "I'm sorry but there's no way to avoid hurting you this once."

"Ow!" she cried out when he tried again.

"Lilith, relax," he instructed. "I don't know, maybe we shouldn't-"

"Just do it!" she interrupted, pulling a pillow over her head. "I'm ready."

Overcoming the resistance, he finally entered, hearing her muffled cries.

"Is it in?" she ripped the pillow away breathlessly.

"You can't tell?" he snorted.

"God yes," she grunted in pain.

Finn moved to lay flat on top of her. The more she hugged him, the deeper he pushed, stopping when he was halfway in knowing that this was all she'd be able to take the first time. When she relaxed he began thrusting. He was suddenly halted by the sound of her cries and sniffling in his ear and pulled out. "I can't do this knowing I'm hurting you. Your hymen is broken which means the hard part is over. Things will be much easier next time and hopefully you'll feel something other than pain. I can actually take you out for dinner or something first and it'll be more comfortable for both of us. Me especially since I won't have to think about one of your parents walking in on us."

"But-" she whined.

"But, nothing," Finn replied. He went over to her bathroom and flushed the condom and went back to bed.

"You can't sleep in here!" Lily whispered.

"I know but do you think I'm just going to do that to you and abandon you in a dark quiet room? Trust me, I don't want to be caught dead in here."

"Finn?"

"Hmm?"

"Thank you…" she yawned.

When Lily squinted her eyes open, her clock read 5:15 AM. The gentle soreness between her legs made her smile, thinking back to last night. She'd actually done it...with him. When she rolled over onto her back, she felt a hard body next to her. She sat up like the Undertaker and gasped. She shook him. "Finn!"

"Hmm?" he grumbled in his sleep.

"You have to get out of here before one of my parents wake!" she hissed frantically.

"Oh, shit! I swear I closed my eyes for one second," he threw the sheets back and stood. She could see his penis dangling and immediately closed her eyes as if it wasn't inside of her a few hours ago. He dressed and walked out of her room. She heard Frankie barking at home. "I thought we were cool, little guy."

Lily fell asleep again and didn't wake until 8. She showered, thinking about the scenes from last night. She went over to make her bed and found a small blood stain on her sheets. She ripped them off and headed to the laundry room.

The scent of breakfast hit her as she walked through the kitchen with the folded sheets tucked under her arms.

"Good morning, Lily," her mom spoke.

"Good Morning," Lily grunted, not stopping to chat.

"What are you doing?" he mom found her stuffing the sheets in the washer.

Her mom walked forward and pulled the sheets out. Her face turned as white as the sheets she held. "Oh my god!"

"It's that time of the month," Lily tried to play it off but she knew her mom wasn't buying it.

"I know your time of the month just like I know your birthday. That came and went two weeks ago! Lily, how dare you and under our roof?!"

"Good Morning girls. Whoa, sorry!" Shawn walked by and immediately shielded his eyes once he saw the stain. "Good thing you aren't wrestling tonight with that going on. I'm ready to eat. I'll go wake Finn."

"I'll deal with you later," her mom hissed.

Lily sat at the table, nervously drumming her fingers.

"Morning!" Finn walked into the kitchen with that huge smile on his face. That grin felt very inappropriate in this moment.

The only person who greeted him was Shawn. "How'd you sleep."

"Like a baby," Finn replied and her mom grumbled as she angrily moved around on the stove.

"Alright, here it comes," her mom carefully placed a plate in front of Shawn, Lily and herself. She slammed Finn's plate down in front of him so hard that Lily was surprised it didn't break. Shawn had his head down praying and didn't seem to notice.

Finn raised his brow at Lily in question and she nodded to confirm. He dropped his head in shame. He stared at him food almost like he was scared to eat it for the next five minutes.

"Fegal, you haven't touched your food, honey," Lily's mom sounded concerned but Lily knew she was trying to intimidate him.

"Sorry, I'm not really hungry plus I don't like to eat much the morning of a big show," he replied.

"Come on, I made your plate very special. Just a few bites, for me?" she put a long, thick sausage to her mouth and chomped the tip of it off.

Finn shoved his plate forward and scooted his chair back. "Uhm, I'll take it to go. If you don't mind, I'd like to go back to my room for a few hours."

"Sure, son, make yourself at home," Shawn nodded.

"He already has," Mom mumbled.

Finn: I think your mom is trying to kill me.

Lily: She's a MOM, not a MURDERER. Lol.

Finn: Is she going to tell Shawn?

Lily: Before we had sex she suspected something was going on between us and said she wouldn't but I don't know how she's feeling right now. She said she'd"deal with me later." If she didn't tell him while we were all at the table, I don't think she will...at least not now.

"You ready to go, Lilith?" Finn asked, standing in the kitchen with his bags at around 1:30.

Lily's mom looked at the clock. "Isn't it a little too early to be heading to the arena?"

"Yeah, it is. I had a little running around to do like hitting the gym and grabbing lunch. How about I come back to pick you up at around 5?"

"Lily, since you aren't wrestling tonight, how about you stay home with me? We can sit right there on the sofa and watch the show together the way we use to. Please?" the way her mom said it told her that she wouldn't take no for an answer.

Lily wasn't going to challenge her especially with her father standing there. She glanced at Finn and then back to her mom. "Okay."