Disclaimer: I don't own the Sister Grimm.

Hi! Soooo I have a new story! It's called What If? It is about the Uglies series. It takes place at the end of the 2 book. Also while I'm writing this I'm listening to The Maze Runner on audio. So this chapter might not make sense. But in my mind it makes sense. Anyway, R&R:

Puck's POV

They finally let us look at each other. Right before we were going to be made into soup for their dinner. We were tie up and we hanging around our stomachs and were almost touching the soup.

They were feeling 'generous' so they let us talk out last words to each other. Sabrina said the thing that didn't matter the most.

"Puck you know when you showed me your list. You know when I crossed off number three?"

"Yes?"

"I'm sorry but I thought you knew!"

"Knew what?"

"You knew that I was joking."

NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO! I guess that doesn't really surprise me.

"You thought I didn't know?"

"Well you acted like you didn't!"

"Well… This isn't the right time to talk about this."

"Why Puck?"

"Because we are about to be made into soup!"

Suddenly we jerked down towards to soup.

I knew this was my last chance to tell Sabrina how I felt.

"SABRINA WAIT! I need to tell you something! I love-"

Sabrina's POV

Puck said something that shocked me a lot. Not as much as it would if he told me that he loved me. I never wished I was Lavender more.

First Puck starts hanging out with her, then he falls in love with her? Who is this guy?

The thing that hurt me the most was that he wasn't in love with me. Yes I told him I was joking but I know that he thought he was stuck with me and couldn't be with anyone else.

Something hot touched my feet.

The soup! I looked down at the soup and lifted my feet to avoid them being burnt off.

I felt Puck's pocket knife in my pocket. But nothing I can do now… Said no one ever!

I took the pocket knife that was barely in reach and started sawing at the ropes.

Puck looked like he didn't care. He looked lifeless.

Puck's POV

I felt horrible. I lied to Sabrina. I lied to myself. I lied to the world. And now I was going to pay for it.

I told Sabrina that I loved Lavender.

The one lie that was hardest for me to tell. The one lie that couldn't be more wrong. The one lie that shattered my soul.

And Sabrina didn't even know it.

She didn't know that I despised Lavender and if I had to spend one more minute with her I would kill myself, if it weren't for Sabrina. She didn't know that I knew that she didn't mean that she was joking. She didn't know that the night before I got kidnapped by Lavender I went into the bathroom and tore up my life plan and flushed it.

She didn't know that I was the one person in the whole world that loved her so much that if I were to die, and if I could have one more minute with her or my whole life without her, I would spend my last minute, or even second, with her. Living my whole life without her or dying… I would chose death because it would be better than trying to live everyday without her.

Sabrina didn't know a thing.

Sorry that this was a short chapter… I just had so much feelings in the last two paragraphs and I wish that a boy felt that way about me. Even though I'm not old enough to have a boyfriend but still. I think any girl would want to be treated that way. Anyway please review if you want to… Go read my other story if you want to...You don't have to do anything if you don't want to… Bye!