They're on Sifnos, one of the less populated Greek islands, when an off handed remark that Bonnie makes triggers a spur of the moment magic lesson. Kol had brought them both there, swearing up and down that this is the right location to recover something he buried almost 300 years ago.
Bonnie is alternating between watching Kol survey the landscape while he mutters to himself, and looking at the barren side of the hill they're currently perched on. "I bet this would look amazing with more of those bright red flowers all round it." She says wistfully.
"Like this?" Before she knows it, Kai is kneeling down to dig his fingers into the earth. He chants quietly and right before her eyes, a portion of the hillside erupts in color. Bonnie turns in a slow circle, "How..?" She can barely get the words out. She's got a green thumb, sure, and hasn't managed to kill her Grams' garden, but what he did was something else entirely.
Kai holds out a hand for her to take, and without even thinking about it, Bonnie kneels down as well and links her fingers with his. The jolt of their magic joining together is no longer an unfamiliar feeling, thanks to the countless hours Bonnie has spent soaking up whatever magical knowledge they felt free to give. The entire hillside as far as Bonnie can see explodes in color, and she feels a little giddy knowing that her magic (with the help of Kai's) did that.
"Wow" Bonnie is in awe at the sight. This is what learning magic should have been about for her. Not hurrying up to gain power so she could stop the murder of her friends. A part of her aches that she never got to experience anything like this with her Grams. She watches as the flowers start to droop and shrivel up.
"Hey, what's wrong?" Kai rubs a thumb over her fingers. Bonnie shakes her head, "I never got to do anything like this with my magic before. It was all big spells and people would die if I didn't get it right. I didn't know it could be this light and playful."
"You were robbed of a true magical upbringing, that's for sure. But I knew Sheila, and if she shielded you from all of this, maybe it was for a good reason." Kai squeezed her hand in sympathy.
It always throws Bonnie when Kai mentions her grandmother, she tends to forget he is older than he looks, (due to his acting like a damn child most of the time) and thus had lived a whole life prior to being thrown in his prison world.
"It's not there!" Kol's outburst shatters their comfortable silence. Bonnie rolls her eyes and allows Kai to pull her up to follow the outraged original as he storms off complaining of thieves and untrustworthy people.
That night a sudden rain storm stalled their evening plans, so they stay in and enjoy the meal that Kai prepares. Bonnie didn't think she had drunk a lot, but when she stood up to go, the room started spinning.
"Oh love, I think you're staying here tonight." Kol said as he steadied her form.
Bonnie waved a hand lazily, "Yeah, sure. Whatever. Take me to bed." She squealed when Kol lifted her and carried her bridal style into an empty bedroom. "Goodnight Kai!" She yelled over Kol's shoulder. She didn't hear Kai's answer, but Kol did that head tilt thing that he does when he's listening to someone that's out of normal hearing range. "What's he saying?"
"He just said good night." Bonnie didn't even have to look at Kol to tell he was lying through his teeth.
"Liar. I can't sleep in this. Do you have a shirt I can borrow?" In response to that, Kol walks out and quickly returns with a faded Nirvana shirt. Bonnie laughs because she knows it must belong to Kai.
"Thanks." She quickly changes and is soon under the covers in the one of the most amazing beds she's ever slept in. Between the alcohol and the sound of the rain outside, she falls into a light sleep almost as soon as her head hits the pillow.
She awakens a few hours later, the rain is still softly falling and her head is a little clearer. She lies back and wonders if they'll see it as an insult if she tries to leave to go back to her place at this hour. Probably. So she snuggles back under the covers and is almost asleep again when she hears them.
She's spent enough time with them by now to know that it's Kai moaning. She focuses, but can't hear Kol. Which means his mouth is probably occupied. She rolls and groans into her pillow. She's been doing so well these past few weeks of ignoring when they'll both have to go do something real quick and come back looking disheveled. Or when they're late meeting her somewhere, and she can see a fading hickey on one of their throats.
This is one of, if not the main reason, she hasn't given in to their insistence on her moving in with them. Coming off of years of tagging along after Elena and Caroline while they're out on dates, she knows all too well what it's like to be the third wheel.
'You wouldn't be a third wheel if you join them' the traitorous part of her brain that she normally manages to keep locked down is apparently up as well. Damn alcohol with the lowering of inhibitions.
She shifts in the bed again and the scent from her borrowed shirt hits her nose and she whimpers, 'Why is everything conspiring against her tonight?' The shirt smells so much like Kai that she swears he's in bed with her.
'I was spooning you earlier' She remembers the flippant statement he made all those years ago, and squeezes her eyes shut. She wants to do something to try and relieve some of her tension, but she stops and sternly reminds herself that there are not one, but two beings with enhanced hearing in the next room.
"Bloody hell!" Oh, there's Kol.
She can hear him talking, but not what he's saying. She's never been so torn about wanting to have vampire hearing before. She feels hot all over now, so she kicks off the once comforting, but now stifling covers.
Which was a mistake as well, because now she realizes that it's all too easy for her to slide her hands down and grip her breasts. A soft moan escapes, but she's not worried about being overheard. The rain is still falling, and the boys are both distracted. So as long as she's quiet, she should be fine.
"Slow down a minute." She hears Kai choke out, the desperation in his voice causes her to tug harder on her nipples, while she clenches her thighs together.
"Like that?" Kol sounds smug.
"Fuck, yeah." Kai breathes, and Bonnie decides to go all in. She keeps one hand gripping her breast and slides the other down into her now soaking wet panties. Her first brush over her clit causes her to moan a little louder than she intended. She stills her hands and listens to see if either one of them heard her.
All she can make out is the rhythmic slap of bodies and the grunts and groans of two people that are lost in their own world. So she picks up the pace, bypassing one finger and immediately using two to fuck herself, not even bothering to keep her voice down anymore.
They seem to take it as a dare and Bonnie hears the pace of their fucking increase. They're not holding back either, neither bothering to stifle their gasps and moans, but pitched so she can hear exactly how much fun they're having with each other.
"Fuck, fuck" Bonnie chants to herself, her hips rising and falling to meet her fingers. She's so close she can taste it, just a little more…
"Come on Malachai, don't keep our little witch in suspense. I bet she's just waiting to hear how you sound when you're coming around my cock." Kol's voice along with the visual of him fucking into Kai is what sends her over the edge. Her body bows forward and she hears the windowpanes crack and splinter.
Bonnie flops onto her back, chest heaving, riding the high of a truly awesome orgasm. "Thank you."
She hears a faint 'you're very welcome' from the other room and cracks up.
She also sleeps better that night than she has in a long time.
That night seems to have broken an unspoken rule, because from then on, neither are never more than an arm span away from her. She's always known Kol was the touchy feely sort, but Kai is just as needy, if not more so. She loves it, though. Relishes in the fact that she has these two powerful beings wrapped around her little finger.
She was starting to see why Elena and Caroline liked it so much.
Speaking of her blond friend, ever since Bonnie shared what happened that night, every conversation Bonnie has had with her has started out with "have you slept with them yet?"
Bonnie tries to dodge the question, throwing out various reasons, but Caroline Forbes will not be derailed. She barrels right past any and all of Bonnie's objections like the caring, over analytical battering ram she is known to be.
"Whatever, you're just afraid they're only interested in you because they want something from you." Bonnie starts to deny it when Caro buts in again, "Or you're afraid that you'll let them get too close and they'll leave you, because Lord knows that's happened enough times."
"Jesus Care." Bonnie winces, most times she's grateful for having someone in her life that knows her inside and out, but not when she wants to avoid hearing harsh truths about herself.
"What else you got? Gonna talk about how they're murderers? Guess what, none of us have that moral ground to stand on anymore. None of us, not even you." Caroline stresses.
"Is Matt there, can I talk to him? He's much nicer when he's dropping truth bombs." She can hear Matt shout "NO!" in the background.
"He wants no part of this conversation, don't try to go over my head Bennett. Look, if you're wondering what some people are gonna say?" Bonnie can practically see the eye roll Caroline perfected back in middle school, "Don't. Because like I said, none of us can judge you for who you choose to be with. You're my best friend, you deserve the world. And hey, if they're the ones who can give it to you, then I got your back." Warmth blooms in Bonnie's chest, and she chokes out an emotional "I love you" to her childhood friend before hanging up.
Caroline's words of encouragement are still ringing in her ears when she dresses for dinner that night. Bonnie decides against straightening her hair, opting instead for her natural curls to tumble free. She chooses a rather risqué dress, dark green with a lower than usual neckline and a slit up one side that shows a considerable amount of leg.
She decides to forgo underwear altogether, if tonight ended up the way she hopes it would, that'll be just another thing in the way.
Her nerves are all over the place when she steps out to meet them that night for dinner. One look on their faces, though, and she knows she was worried for nothing. They were both very attentive throughout their dinner, Kol even going so far as to feed her a piece of their dessert. For the life of her, Bonnie could not recall what it was, some dish that had figs dripping in honey. However, she can vividly recall Kai leaning into her slightly, voice husky in her ear as he instructed her to "open up" as Kol ran a piece of fruit along her lower lip.
She accepted the sweet treat and kept her eyes on Kol as she chewed then swallowed. She ran her tongue over her lips to make sure none of the honey remained. Kai groaned in her ear and lowered his head to mouth under her ear, "You're killing me, Bennett."
"We should get going if you still want to visit that club." Kol's eyes are still trained on Bonnie's mouth as she frowns, "Aren't you going to have any? They're really good."
Later Bonnie would swear up and down that she really did just want them try the dessert (she's still not used to living such an extravagant life as to let something that good go to waste) but she can totally see how it would sound like a come on. She would also thank every deity that they were seated in a private room of the restaurant.
One second Kol was sitting next to her eyeing her mouth like it held all the secrets of the universe, the next she found herself sitting in his lap, while he devoured her mouth. Bonnie could do nothing but hold on while he explored every inch of her mouth with his tongue. When she broke away for a much needed breath of air, she felt Kai trailing a hand up her thigh.
Kol started kissing down her neck, but she never looked away from Kai as she shifted in Kol's lap and parted her thighs to make way for his seeking hand. He cursed when he noticed that she wasn't wearing anything under her dress.
Bonnie moans at the contrast of the coolness of Kai's rings against her hot skin. Kol scrapes his teeth against her neck, "Do you know how talented he is with his hands? He's reduced me to a puddle on a few occasions." Bonnie rolls her hips, hoping to hurry up Kai's exploration and get to where she wants him the most.
"Hold her open." Kai bites out, pushing the table away and getting on his knees. Kol rearranges Bonnie so she's sitting in his lap, her back to his front. He drapes her legs over his and widens his stance, so Bonnie is on full display. Kai wastes no time, diving right in and burying his face in her warmth. Bonnie reaches a hand down to grip his head, while the other reaches back to hold onto Kol.
Kai's tongue immediately finds a home deep inside her, but he pulls back to run it along her labia before attaching himself to her clit and sucking hard. Bonnie jolts and tightens her grip on his head, he's got two fingers working in tandem with his tongue and it's almost embarrassing how quickly she comes the first time.
"Well, that has to be some sort of record." Kol runs his hands up over her thighs down to where Kai is still feasting. Bonnie watches as he slides two fingers past Kai's tongue to dip into her wetness.
"Shut up." Bonnie tightens around their fingers and leans her head back onto Kol's shoulder. She can't see what's going on, but somehow listening to Kai eat her out like it's his last meal is just as devastating as watching it happening.
Kol brings his fingers that were just buried in her up to his mouth and makes a show of licking his fingers clean. "I knew you'd taste delicious." Bonnie wants to say something back, but Kai chooses that moment to send pulses of magic through his fingers and Bonnie gives a little scream as she comes again.
She loosens her grip around Kai's head and tries to push him away, but he removes his fingers, grips her thighs harder and latches onto her clit, sucking like it's the last time he'll ever get the chance, and Bonnie just gushes into his mouth. She's pretty sure she blacks out for a second or two, but the darkness may have also been because she blew out all the lights with her last orgasm.
It also serves as a nice cover while they lead a not-so-steady-on-her-legs Bonnie to the car.
Once they're all in the back seat, Kol tells the driver to forget the club and head back to the villa before raising the window. He turns back, and to Bonnie's surprise instead of reaching for her, he grabs for Kai instead.
Bonnie has never understood guys' obsession with watching two girls make-out, but she thinks she's starting to see the appeal now. She watches as Kai slides his tongue in Kol's mouth, and Bonnie knows he's tasting her on Kai's tongue. She sits back and gets ready to enjoy the show she's sure they're about to put on for her.
They do not disappoint.
While Kol is sucking on Kai's tongue, his hands fumble to undo the clasp on his pants. When he finally gets it open, he wastes no time in dropping to his knees and taking Kai in his mouth. Kai leans his head back against the seat and lets loose a moan that has Bonnie thinking she might be ready to go again. He grips Kol's head in his hands and guides him up and down his cock, all the while watching Bonnie, who is enraptured by Kol's obvious experience and skill.
She gets tired of just watching after a while, so she scoots down to kneel next to Kol. He pulls off Kai's dick with a pop, "I was wondering if you were going to just watch." He smiled wickedly, "Let's see if Malachai can hold on until we get back home." The words were barely out of his mouth before Bonnie took over, she'd be damned if she was the only one getting off in inappropriate places tonight. She sends a quick mental thank you to Caroline insisting that they learn how to control their gag reflexes one summer at cheerleading camp.
She doesn't hesitate, just opens her mouth and takes him in so far she can feel him in the back of her throat.
"Motherfuck-" Kai chokes out as she swallows reflexively, hips jerking up on their own accord before he forces himself to sit still.
"Well, I have to say I did not see that coming." Kol said wryly before leaning over to whisper in her ear, "Although I do expect an up close and personal display of that talent later, little witch." He gives her a little love bite on her neck, then surges up to capture Kai's lips in a bruising kiss. He then licks a path down Kai's neck, fangs leaving a slight trail of blood for him to lick up.
Kai was seconds away from magically sealing Kol's mouth. He thought he liked to babble on, but Kol was giving him a run for his money in that department.
"I admire your restraint, mate. You've got the woman you've been dreaming about on her knees with your cock down her throat, and you still have your wits about you. I mean, look at her Malachai" He forces Kai's head down to watch as Bonnie bobs on his dick, "Can't you tell how much she's enjoying it?"
Kai can smell how much she's enjoying herself, it takes him back to that night months ago when Kol had tipped him off that Bonnie was watching them. Her spicy-sweet smell had hit him so hard, he didn't have the sense of mind to try and redirect his magic. He'd never thought that Bonnie Bennett of all people, would be the type to get off on watching.
He'd gotten a chance to test that theory later on when she'd drunk too much and spent the night. He was truthful enough to admit that he'd hoped that they would be loud enough to wake her up and hear what was going on.
Instead she'd surprised him again, by clearly masturbating to their fucking. When she'd left that day (purposefully leaving behind his t-shirt she'd slept and touched herself in) he'd nearly jerked himself raw with it.
But all that paled in comparison to actually getting to taste her. He knew he'd found his new favorite dish to eat and planned on indulging as much as she would let him. When she gushed into his mouth, it took everything he had not to make her do it again and again. He'd drink nothing but her if it were up to him.
He watches from half-closed eyes as she slowly pulls his shaft from her mouth, swirling her tongue around the head. She slides a hand down her body to dip into her channel, with his enhanced hearing, he knows she is sopping wet again. She brings that hand up to rub all over his cock, mingling her juices with his pre-cum before taking him in her mouth again. Kai snatches her hand before she can lower it again and brings it to his mouth, moaning at her taste.
His hips start to buck erratically and he releases her hand in order to cradle her head in between his hands, "Fuck, Bon. Bonnie, I'm gonna, you need to-" He tries to warn her of his impending orgasm, doesn't want to risk the chance of making her so mad that she never goes down on him again.
Because he would seriously cry, and maybe kill someone.
Kol is right there in his ear, "She needs to stay right there, you mean to say? I agree, I can't imagine a better sight than Bonnie Bennett on her knees with your dick in her lovely mouth while you cum down her throat. Or wait," he pretends to think, "Bonnie love? Do you swallow, or would you prefer if we switched places? The taste of a witch vampire hybrid has fast become one of my favorite things."
Kai can feel his magic gathering, getting ready to either explode out of him, or for his siphoning to kick in, so he start chanting under his breath, praying that he's not saying the wrong thing or mixing up the words. Kol snaps his fingers, "I've got it! Bonnie, be a dear and pull back ever so slightly so Malachai can come all over that pretty face of yours."
Fucking Kol Mikealson.
The image of Bonnie's face covered in his cum is apparently just the trigger for him. He can feel his rings respond and collect the magic that was waiting to burst out into the open. As much as he wants to close his eyes to enjoy it, he doesn't want to miss a second of watching Bonnie on her knees for him. He moves a hand down to close around her throat, just like he did in the car years ago in the prison world, and feels her throat working to swallow his cum. He feels Kol's fangs for a second before the original latches on to his throat.
Kai closes his eyes then and just rides the wave.
When he comes back, Bonnie is sitting in Kol's lap. His dick twitches as he watches Kol lick up the little bit of cum that she missed and had dripped down her chin. By the time they pulled up to the front door Kai had fixed enough of his clothing so he wasn't flapping in the wind. It didn't really matter though, because as soon as the car stopped, Kol scooped Bonnie up in his arms as he sped into the main bedroom.
Kai took the time to thank their driver and wish him a good night. He did a cursory check of the villa before stepping out back and releasing the energy that his rings had absorbed. He had had access to his own magic for a while now, but it still gave him a thrill even when he performed a simple spell. The last thing he did was re-inforce the barrier around the house. He'd be damned if something try and take Bonnie from them when they'd finally all come together.
By the time Kai sauntered in, Bonnie was on her hands and knees at the edge of the bed and Kol was buried balls deep. There was no finesse this time, no sweet talking, it was just straight fucking. He guessed even 1000 year old originals had their breaking point.
Kai slowly shed his clothes he watches Kol fuck into Bonnie, curious and a little bewildered by his own non-reaction. He's always been an extremely possessive person, willing to kill in order to get or keep whatever he considers is his. But now, looking at the couple on the bed, the only thing he feels now is the urge to make them both cum.
Yay for learning how to share?
"Were you planning on just watching Malachai?" Kol calls out. "It would be a shame, she feels heavenly wrapped around my cock." As if to emphasize his point, his next thrust causes Bonnie to moan loudly. As much as Kai wants to be buried in Bonnie's body, he knows from experience she'll probably need some time to recover after Kol.
So he picks the next best option. Walking up behind Kol, he glides a hand down his back, around his still thrusting hips to find where he's joined with Bonnie. Kol groans, "Oh whatever you're doing, keep doing it. She just got so much tighter." Kai obliges, playing her clit like it's his new favorite instrument until she starts bucking her hips like crazy, right before drenching his hand.
He doesn't take as much time as usual in prepping Kol, too impatient to sink himself in and feel Kol clench around him. He gives a few shallow thrusts before bottoming out, grinding his hips against the other man. They stay like that until Kol arches back against him, and Kai takes it as his cue to move. He gets a few shallow strokes in before he bends Kol over the bed and lets go, hips snapping at a frantic pace until he feels Kol jerk underneath him, "Fucking hell, love."
Apparently Bonnie wasn't done just yet. She's kneeling at the edge of the bed, one hand massaging her breasts, while the other she has wrapped around Kol's dick pulling in tandem with Kai's thrusts. He can tell Kol is fighting the urge to cum, so reaches up to pull Kol back by his shoulders, while Bonnie moves so she's in the perfect position to take Kol into her mouth.
Her mouth closes around him just as Kai bites his neck, and he feels Kol shudder through his release. Kai didn't think he was that close to the edge, but he unloads as soon as the taste of Kols blood hits his tongue.
They all drop to the bed and Kai notices Bonnie looks utterly wrecked and tired, but in the very best way. He and Kol bundle her between them and as he falls asleep he wonders if he should share the fact that he's still got the cure stashed away.
Bonnie woke up alone.
She allowed herself a few seconds to panic, before she remembered just who she was with. Sure enough, when she finally dragged her sore (but very satisfied) body into the bathroom, she found a note attached to the very fluffy (and very new) bathrobe that was left for her. The boys were swinging by her rental home to get her stuff so she wouldn't have to worry about moving herself later on.
There was also a glass full of what Bonnie thought was orange juice, but turned out to be a potion instead. Kai had whipped it up to ease her sore muscles and whatever other aches she may have. She downed the potion, then went to soak in the massive tub that caught her eye earlier.
She makes the mistake of laying down once she'd gotten out of the tub, and ended up dozing off again, waking up to the two of them lying in bed with her, Kai trying to explain the concept of Chopped to Kol.
"So, you just have to make a meal? How is this a competition?" Kol sounds confused.
"Yeah, but you're restricted to what's in the baskets and the pantry, and you're timed in each round." Kai sounds like a kid explaining the concept of Christmas to his younger sibling.
"Do you get to choose what's in the baskets?"
"Nope. You've gotta work with what you're given."
Bonnie rolls over, "You'd kick ass at Chopped."
"I know, right?" Kai shoots her a grin before leaning down to press a kiss to her waiting lips. "Good Morning, sleepyhead."
"Morning." When he goes to pull back, she reaches out to keep him close, "Thank you for the potion, it worked." He beams, "Yeah?" Bonnie nods, "Yeah, great job." She's learned over the past months that both of them (and herself as well if she's being honest) have a bit of a praise kink.
Kol butts in like the forgotten child Bonnie suspects he always was. "The idea was really both of ours. In fact, I-" Bonnie cuts him off with a kiss.
She supposes it's due to all three of them having been the outcasts in their respective circles for most of their lives, but somehow three damaged people have found each other and surprisingly, they fit together. She's not sure how they'll navigate from here, but she's happy, and that's enough for now.