Harley sat in the office of the police, listening to those around her. She looked like she was doing nothing as she sat there with her eyes closed, but she was taking things in. Hearing the goings on of a police station was almost... home-y. She opened her eyes wanting to see the GCPD and know that her Puddin' was nearby. This wasn't Gotham and her Puddin' was hours away. She sighed got up and bounced to Hotch, he was holding the ID's of the victims.

She frowned, "Hotch. Can I talk to you?"

He nodded and gestured to an office, then closed the door, "What is it Harley?"

"I got word from my Marshall. J is lookin' for me."

"You're certain?"

"I've seen his love letters." She held out the folder with the pictures. "I figure, if you are going to trust me, I need to be honest with what I know. I won't rat on J. That is stupid. But I will tell ya anything else."

"Alright. Thank you, for your honesty." Hotch looked at the pictures, These are love letters?

The search for Tracey Lambert, who went missing after the IDs were made, had some interesting results. Mostly a woman named Sheryl Timmons going missing. Ironically, the police missed her captor by being called away by the call that Sheryl had been abducted. The Father Marks and Morgan had a fight. Apparently, Morgan was abused as a child. Harley found that... interesting. She would dig later. Morgie-poo might just be my new favorite toy. Morgan went to apologize to the priest and found a dead body. Hotch came to the conclusion that the the killer was eating them. Harley was intrigued. I mean sure J was sadistic. He made people eat others, but he never partook. Hell, the only cannibal she knew was Killer Croc. She briefly wondered if he'd take a phone call from her.

The man... the cannibal in question was Floyd Feylinn Ferell. A former Psychiatric patient who had been institutionalized and released upon his 18th birthday. He was very disturbed, yet was released due to Florida law. He would open a restaurant called "Feylinn's Fine Bar-B-Q". When they raid his house, they find: a collection of cooking equipment and a walk-in freezer. The freezer contained his victims and Sheryl in captivity.

Floyd was found in a basement room with walls covered in writing and pentagrams containing books about Satanism and images of the Black Paintings, apparently in the middle of some sort of prayer. The team also found a homemade cookbook containing cannibalistic recipes like "Skewered She" and "Kobe Girl Steak".

When they question him, he refused to talk to anyone but Father Marks. When he arrives Harley goes in with him, Floyd said like he felt abandoned by God, to which Marks replies, "God is in all of us."

At that moment, Rossi, who had looked at the list of search party volunteers, which has Floyd's name on it, rushes in to stop the interview. Floyd does, however, have the time to reply "So is Tracey Lambert." He had served stew containing her flesh to searchers, thereby destroying all of the evidence.

Harley blinked then wrinkled her nose. "I do not appreciate being fed someone without my consent, you fuck!" She rushed the man and was going to punch him. She would remember his name, Floyd Feylinn Ferell. Perhaps if J found her, she would set J after him. Her Puddin' would kill him for her.

Meanwhile...

Garcia went on a date with Colby, whom Morgan had told her to trust her gut about. She didn't completely listen... And after a date at a restaurant, when they are walking together towards Garcia's home, they start talking about coincidences and how lucky it was that his computer glitched when she was around. Garcia replies that she believes everything happens for a reason. Thinking that she is on to him, Battle becomes nervous and shoots her in the chest outside her house, saying before opening fire, "I've been thinking about doing this all night."

16th century English novelist Thomas Deloney wrote, "God sends meat and the Devil sends cooks."

I know this isn't really like the rest but I have really been struggling with Lucky as it is a gut turning episode. I really really hate Floyd. UGH! I will be continuing with the next episode Penelope as it is a good tie for the team. They come together over Garcia.