Chapter 17: Monster.
PETRA WAS FUCKING STAMPY IN THE ASS!
THE HORROR!
"AHHH!" Stampy continues to panic.
"Erm! ergh! yeah, bitch! erm-hrmph!" Petra grunts as she rams her crotch against Stampy's asshole "fukin' U gud. BAM!"
"EEEEEE!" Stampy squeals.
"Cry harder for me, oh yeah...!" Petra has officially abandoned the rule of no disrespect "gunna make U cum, pussy bitch."
"Petra!" Jesse loses her shit, "what the fuck!?"
"Registering verbal complaint, please!" Stacy growls, resisting the urge to just attack and kill Petra.
"Erm-erm-erm-huh?" Petra stops thrusting, turning to look at the others "...what?"
"That was for Lukas!" Jesse stresses, "oh, also you need to cut back on the shit talking."
Stacy's jaw drops, having expected the MAIN PROBLEM to have been the shit talking AND the fact that Stampy is SCREAMING WITH DISTRESS.
"For... Lukas...?" Petra asks, blankly "...OH, fuck! you were gonna give him Stampy's ass!?"
"YES!" Jesse nods, "now we can't do the comparison!"
"We can't?" Lukas blinks "why not? I mean, I'd rather Stampy be fresh, but he's still fuckable, right?"
"No! because Petra just fucked him!" Jesse tries to explain, "and if Petra fucks him in the ass, and then you fuck him in the ass right after, that's pretty much the same as you fucking Petra!"
"And that is NOT ACCEPTABLE." Petra nods, as she understands this entirely.
"Oh? is that how we roll? alright then, got it." Lukas has conformed.
"WHAAAH! WHAH-WHAH!" Stampy cries, huge streams of tears dripping from his face onto the carpet below.
"Stampy, what's wrong? we got her to stop." Jesse doesn't think the trauma should be that bad, she also fails to address the fact that even though Petra has indeed stopped thrusting, she is still physically holding him there, bent over with his ass ripe for fucking, locked into place by the firm grip of her hands.
"THAT...! WAS...! HORRIBLE...!" Stampy shouts "SHE'S RAPING ME!"
"Am not." Petra rolls her eyes "you consented, bitch, remember the deal?"
Stampy breaks into more tears.
"I'm sorry, Jesse." Petra looks back to her sister with genuine regret "I just... Stampy was right there, naked, and he just got my pants off, and then he was putting down my shoulder-pad, and as he bent over, I just... I just really wanted to fuck him, you guys were talking and I wasn't doing much else, so I figured it would be okay to just screw his ass for the time being, especially since we'd probably use his dick or mouth in the puzzle instead of his ass anyway."
"It's... ugh, it's okay, I just... I NEED Lukas to compare them, Petra! you understand..." Jesse's really crushed by this, "it was gonna be so awesome..."
Stacy breathes in frustratedly, not happy with herself for what she was about to do to cheer Jesse up.
"Jesse...?" Stacy asks for attention.
"Yeah?" Jesse looks at her, showing very little interest.
"If you wanted, Lukas could... fuck me... twice." Stacy forces the words "the second time, he could be looking at Stampy while he does it, to trick his mind into thinking he's fucking a man."
"Ugh, I mean... I guess it's something, but it's really not the same as if the ass actually belonged to a man for real..." Jesse considers it.
"I really am sorry, Jesse..." Petra frowns and mopes her way over, leaving Stampy to collapse to the floor in tears "if I could take it back, I would, I wish I could just... transfer that fuckpoint to Lukas."
"I know, Petra, it's okay, I get it..." Jesse acknowledges, "it just really sucks that it turned out this way..."
"Well, I'm not too disappointed." Lukas also tries to cheer her up "I'll do it for real some other time, and tonight I still get to experience your amazing fuckpuzzle."
"Yeah, it's just, if only we had another-" Jesse eyes widen with realization, and her mouth stretches into a grin, "hey...! you guys wanna just get Dan in here!?"
BOOM. Stampy aruptly stops crying, his body tensed and alert at the mention of his archenemy, his eyes wide and his ears pricked in anticipation of where Jesse was going with this.
"Sure!" Lukas grins.
"Heh! problem solved, look at that." Petra nods "this is why you're the brains, Jesse."
"We can't bring Dan into this!" Stacy protests "you're supposed to kill him! not extend our deal!"
"Oh, but Stacy! don't you get it?" Jesse starts, "we'll just tell him that we're extending the deal! we'll still stab him in the back and kill him after! we don't even need to give him any of yours and Stampy's restrictions! don't you see? this is WORSE for him than it was before! I'm pretty much just giving you guys extra! neither of you will need to fuck him, he'll add another number to the fuck puzzle, and Lukas will get to fuck his ass! all this does is sweeten the deal for everyone but him!"
"...at the cost of one more conspirator." Lukas points out "if we do this, then Lizzie and Cassie will literally be the only two people who still think that we're interrogating them to find the killer."
"Which works out great." Petra claims "we should promise him that we'll find Lizzie guilty, but then we just, you know, don't."
"My point is that the more people know the truth about us, the less safe we'll be." Lukas explains "that said, I fully support this plan, and I look forward to experiencing Dan's ass."
"Your blonde hair will go so good with his blue." Petra compliments "I can't wait to see you two guys fuck, it will be... beautiful, now I'm GLAD I fucked Stampy!"
"I'M NOT!" Stampy screams, suddenly rising to his feet.
Everybody looks at him.
"You violated me! I was just undressing you like I was asked, and the moment I was vulnerable, you took advantage!" Stampy storms over and practically spits in Petra's face "we were supposed to make love in a safe, well-communicated fashion! you were never supposed to just, GRAB me, and hammer away!"
"Stampy, calm down!" Jesse holds her hands up for peace, "I'm sorry that happened, okay? we'll add no surprise fucking to the list of restrictions for you and Stacy, and Petra will start being nicer about it." Jesse promises, turning to her sister, "right, Petra?"
Petra wants to say no, but she is actually still feeling guilty about almost fucking things up for Jesse, so she really just wants to keep her sister happy for now, "Alright, whatever, fine..." she agrees "no surprises, and I'll stop with every insult except bitch."
"Petra, you can't have 'bitch'." Jesse presses, "I know it's your favorite, and that the sexslave-fucktoys usually learn to love it, but you're not allowed to do it this time, not unless you're speaking to Dan exclusively."
"Urrrgh..." Petra groans "fine! I'll just use it excessively on Dan then."
"Good!" Stampy nods, then turns to Lukas "and as for YOU, young man! I have three words."
"Suck your dick?" Lukas guesses.
"No! that's mine!" Jesse squeaks.
"FUCK... HIM..." Stampy stresses, leaning in close "...hard."
Lukas smiles, slightly surprised, "Oh? how strange, you seem to be almost enjoying this, Stampy."
"Fuck...! Dan...!" Stampy hisses "I'm not ENJOYING this experience in the slightest, but I'll be damned if THE DIAMOND MINECART is going to have a better time than STAMPY CAT! nuh-uh! you make sure he's more miserable than you could ever make me, understand!?"
"I like this side of you." Lukas nods "it's... dark."
"And sexy." Jesse flirts her eyebrows to Stampy.
"I respect your wishes, Stampy Cat." Lukas agrees "I will do my best to make Dan scream as I tear his lovely ass apart to pleasure my evil dick, and as a bonus, just to be nice to you and show my goodwill towards your cause and future, I will also try to take it easy on your girlfriend, not so easy that it's not enjoyable, but it won't be... Dan."
"See that you do!" Stampy sneers in semi-disgust, he then turns to Jesse "well? what are we waiting for!? get TDM's ass in here, AND HAVE MY MAN LUKAS FUCK IT APART!"
The darkness within Stampy has finally surfaced, below the happy, and further below the fear, a bold, nasty persona has lurked unseen for ages, but now... the beast has risen, and Stampy Cat was no longer a beacon of good and happiness faced against murderers and rapists, rather, as he looked into Jesse's wicked, pleased eyes, he saw himself within them, both as a reflection... and a monster.
The Poll Results are in!
"What do you think the terrifying thing is? (Remember, the location and speaker of the scream was not specified, it could be in the room with them or outside in the hall, even outside of the mansion, and any character besides the three turning around.)"
1. Petra fucking Stampy in the ass. 0 Vote(s). (0%)
2. Captain Sparklez' zombified corpse. 0 Vote(s). (0%)
3. Spider Attack. (Like in the game.) 3 Vote(s). (20%)
4. Cassie killing Ivor. 0 Vote(s). (0%)
5. TorqueDawg's zombified corpse. 0 Vote(s). (0%)
6. Ivor killing Cassie. 0 Vote(s). (0%)
7. Petra fucking Stampy in the pussy. 0 Vote(s). (0%)
8. Some new characters just showed up... in the middle of the zombie horde. 1 Vote(s). (07%)
9. Dan stubbed his toe. 1 Vote(s). (07%)
10. Petra's screaming as a prank, there is no danger. 3 Vote(s). (20%)
11. Lizzie noticed Dan's boner was back and pressing against her. 0 Vote(s). (0%)
12. Petra's screaming because its not a prank, she just set off a trap, and now she's hurtin'. 2 Vote(s). (13%)
13. Stampy's sanity just broke. 0 Vote(s). (0%)
14. The White Pumpkin is here to chop a bitch. (Like in the game.) 2 Vote(s). (13%)
15. Something totally unexpected. Yes, even MORE unexpected than these other options. 3 Vote(s). (20%)
Total Votes: 15.
Total Voters: 3.
All-right! Three people voted again, we are so happy with you guys. As you can see, unfortunately, the correct answer got a grand total of zero votes. All three of you thought that it would be spiders, Petra's prank, or something totally unexpected, which shows that great minds think alike. Two out of three of you also liked the Petra trap and White Pumpkin attack options. And one out of you three threw a bone to new characters in the zombie horde and, the most hilarious choice, Dan stubbed his toe.
Speaking of Dan, he's the NEW poll subject! "Will Jesse be able to convince Dan to go for it?" There's six options, and we've decided to keep the 1/3 vote/choices ratio! So you can vote for your TWO favorites!
Special thanks to everyone who voted, we hope you enjoyed the chapter and will participate again in future polls, such as the Dan one.