On his fourth cup of sweet marshmallow cocoa that day, Garth Fitzgerald jolted when his cell phone rang and spilled the hot brew on himself. He was getting to the point where he didn't give two damns to rub together, but… it was Sam calling. And something in him made him feel compelled to answer it. He stared at the phone for a moment before answering with a hesitant, "Sam?"

"Yeah, hi, Garth, we've, uh… had a bit of a situation come up here and, uh, we were wondering…"

"What is it? You don't sound well," Garth asked, a little weirded out by Sam's lack of composure. He could almost see Sam pinching the bridge of his nose, he sounded so… off. Not that he was really the one to comment on who was feeling "off", but some little bit of him still felt the need to help.

"Uh… did we have a sister?"

Garth nearly dropped the phone into his cocoa at the question. "What?!" he exploded.

"Okay, that kind of answers it, I guess," Sam murmured.

"No, wait, you guys have a sister now?" Garth asked, rubbing his hand against his forehead. "Bobby never told me about her! I mean, he barely told me about Adam, but I knew who he was, at least." He rattled his head, trying to jog his memory. Then, because he knew his lot in life too well, he sniffed his coffee to make sure there wasn't anything strange in it. Maybe poison.

A quick whiff told him no, so he continued. "Tell me about this sister."

"I mean, she looks like she would be our sister, and she just barged in and got all mad at us for leaving her in Maine, but Dean didn't bring anyone with him to pick me up. And she has our grandma's name as her middle name and she has Dad's glare and—"

"Sam, the trials are getting to you, go lie down," Garth instructed and Sam sighed.

"Thanks, Dean."

"I'm serious! I'll put Mr. Fizzles on and we'll talk to you if we need to."

"I know. Thanks, Garth, we'll figure it out from here." The dial tone rang in his ear as Garth tried to wrap his head around the conversation that just took place. He shook his and decided that he needed more sweet marshmallow cocoa. One last one...