Arriving to the party was like arriving to the Oscars, everyone knew your name and you were greeted at the door. Living in Lima is like living in a fishbowl; everyone watching you and tapping on your glass just to get a rise out of you. But tonight, will be different, because I'll have Blaine on my arm. But I still can't shake what 'Cedes told me earlier. What if Blaine really is evil and Puck is the one who should've gone with Kristian? What if Puck is the one that deserves happiness? Puck is handsome, but he's too big of a player for me. If he was the kind boy I suspect he is, underneath all that male bravado, I could see myself ending up with him. But I met Blaine first and I fell for him, he's a person I can see having an actual family with. And even though people don't trust him or thinks a bad person, I think that he's kind hearted and sweet and doesn't matter what anyone else thinks…right? ~ Kurt

NKB~NKB~NKB~NKB~NKB

Artie is at the door greeting with his parents when he spots Rachel. I can't let them see her they'll think she's trash for sure. "Hey um let's go through the back way."

"Why, are you ashamed of me or something?" asks Rachel.

"No! It's just that the line is too long and going in the back way will leave more time for us to get better acquainted," he says in a sly, sexy voice.

Rachel giggles. "OK, but you better not hide me from them the whole night."

"I wouldn't dream of it."

NKB~NKB~NKB~NKB~NKB

"That was his favorite scotch. I'm sorry I thought it would work," says Cooper.

"Don't worry I wasn't counting on it to work," responds Blaine as he was getting ready to pick up Kurt for the party.

"You expected it to fail?"

"It did what I wanted, it lowered his guard. He wouldn't expect me to try again so soon."

Cooper hands Blaine a vial of vervain. "It's double of what I put in the scotch."

NKB~NKB~NKB~NKB~NKB

As Kurt is still getting ready, he thinks about his earlier conversation with Finn. "Because it's supposed to be mine. Burt said it goes to the first-born son. Grandpa gave it to Burt…" "And Dad was gonna give it to you." He decides to cut his losses and give it back to Finn.

NKB~NKB~NKB~NKB~NKB

Quinn and Puck are next to arrive at the party and are greeted by Mrs. Abrams.

"Quinn, hi. Don't you gorgeous darling!"

"Hi Mrs. Abrams. I this is my boyfriend Puck."

"Oh. Well welcome!" she greets in a fake voice.

"It's a pleasure to meet you; I have been looking forward to this party for quite a while," says Puck.

"Well enjoy," replies Mrs. Abrams as she walked off.

"You want to go get a drink?" asks Puck.

"Yeah," replies Quinn. Quinn was looking around until she spotted her mother. "Hey um wait here." Quinn walks over to her mother. "You couldn't leave the badge at home?"

"I'm working Hun. Who was the date you tried to sneak past me?" asks Sheriff Fabray.

"It's no one, just a guy."

"He's kind of old for you, isn't he?"

"Oh what, I'm chasing the dad that ran out on me?"

"I realize that this is still hard for you- "

"No. You know what Mom, just don't talk to me the rest of the night." As she starts to walk away her mother is trying to get her attention.

"Quinn!"

"Come on Puck," says Quinn and she pulls him away.

Kurt and Blaine then walk through the doors of the party and Puck sees them and watches them with an angry look on his face. Reminding him of the first Founder's Party.

NKB~NKB~NKB~NKB~NKB

"Hey, are those your parent's?" asks Blaine as he saw Kurt looking at his parent's wedding rings.

"There's a lot of history here."

NKB~NKB~NKB~NKB~NKB

"Emma!" shouts Logan Fell from across the room.

"Hello Logan," she says with a scowl on her face.

"Hey, it's been a long time," he says as he tries to hug her, but she steps away from him.

"But not long enough." Emma walks away from Logan with determination.

NKB~NKB~NKB~NKB~NKB

"The Founding Families of Lima, Ohio welcome you to the inaugural Founders Council Celebration on this the twenty-fourth of September in the year eighteen hundred and sixty-four," recites Kurt as he looks at the original guest list. Blaine starts to look uncomfortable. "Look at all these familiar names, Sheriff William Fabray, Mayor Barnette Abrams. Wait is that Noah Puckerman Anderson and Blaine Puckerman Anderson?" Kurt asks under suspicion.

"Those are the original brothers, our ancestors. Tragic story really," says Puck as he walks up to Kurt and Blaine with Quinn.

"We shouldn't bore them with stories of the past," says Blaine trying to change the subject.

"It's not boring. Blaine. I would love to hear some Puck," says Kurt.

"But I'm bored. And I want to dance; Puck won't dance with me," whines Quinn. "Could I borrow your date Kurt?"

"Umm I don't really dance," replies Blaine.

"Of course, you do! You know I have some pretty embarrassing stories to tell about this one, of when he was younger and used to dance to 'Mm Bop' around the house-" Puck was cut off by Blaine.

"OK! That stuff never happened."

Kurt giggles. "It's OK if it did! I bet you were adorable," says Kurt smiling longingly at Blaine.

"Oh, he was! Especially in those Toy Story diapers!" exclaims Puck trying to embarrass Blaine further.

"Quinn, I believe you asked me to dance and I would love to," says Blaine as he turns to Quinn to try to leave the conversation.

"Don't forget to show her how to do the jitterbug!" Puck shouts as Blaine walks off with Quinn.

"I am starting to think that you'll go to any length to be alone with me," says Kurt.

"I mean that is the main goal," replies Puck with a sly look.

"Well I don't know who told you, but I don't get around," says Kurt as he tries to walk away.

"But you see, the thing is, is that you put off these vibes that tell me that you want me," replies Puck as he tries to stop Kurt.

"Well I'm sorry if I'm leading you on, that was never the intention." As they were talking, Puck kept getting closer and closer to Kurt and now their standing with their noses inches apart. "Look how about we go outside, clear the air, start over?"

"If I say yes, will I regret it?"

"Maybe or you could give into temptation and follow me."

"Blaine will wonder where I am…"

"Look, if I know Quinn, they'll be dancing until the party's over. Now come on." Puck holds out his hand for Kurt and he grabs it with his mind telling him it's wrong but his heart telling him to see where this take him.

"OK."

NKB~NKB~NKB~NKB~NKB

"Looks like Puck and Kurt are going outside," says Quinn as she spots them leaving.

"Well do you want to go outside?" asks Blaine.

"No, I'd rather dance."

"Well do you mind if I take drink?"

"Just make sure my mom's not watching."

"Here you go."

"Thank you."

NKB~NKB~NKB~NKB~NKB

"I'm glad you said yes to coming out here with me," says Puck as he and Kurt were walking along the pond.

"Well you said that we were gonna start over," replies a worried Kurt.

"And start over we shall. Hi. my name's Puck and you are hot."

Kurt giggles at him and returns his greeting. "Hi. I'm Kurt and thanks for the complement."

"Well it wasn't hard to say when you look like that."

"Well look at you turn on the charm."

"I wish you would've met me before Blaine."
"Well I'm glad I met you regardless."

"Sometimes I wish that people didn't see me as a dangerous guy. But being a dangerous guy is how I get noticed."

"Maybe if you were nice to people instead of being an ass when you first meet them, people will like you better."

"I wasn't an ass to you."

"So why am I an exception to the rule?" asks Kurt as he turns to Puck.

"You remind me of someone very important to me. And the fact that you are the most beautiful person I've ever met."

"Let me guess, Kristian."

"No. That's what Blaine seems to think. You guys just look alike. You remind me of our mother. She was a sweet woman; never had rude thing to say, accepted you as you were, and cared for everyone."

"What happened to her?"

"She died while giving birth to Blaine. The doctors told her it was either her or the baby. She gave up her life so a little baby boy could have his. When I was old enough, I took her last name to honor her."

"She sounds like a remarkable woman," says Kurt as he held Puck's hand and they both were staring at each other with great intensity.

"She was or so I'm told," says Blaine as he walks up to Kurt and Puck.

"Oh, hi, um, how did your dancing go?" asks a surprised Kurt.

"Fine, um, Quinn wants her date back and so do I."

"Um, I'll see you later Kurt," says Puck as he kisses Kurt's hand goodbye.

"That was some conversation I walked in on," says Blaine as he sits down next to Kurt.

"I never knew how much pain he held inside of him."

"That's why I never talk about my family, too many heartbreaks and secrets."

"Well I hope one you'll be to one to tell them to me."

"Are you ready to go back inside?"

"Yeah, I'm just gonna go to the bathroom," replies Kurt as he gets up walks toward the house.

NKB~NKB~NKB~NKB~NKB

"I didn't get all dressed up just to hide in a corner all night, did I?" asks Rachel as she and Artie just sit outside the whole evening.

"No, of course not," replies Artie.

"So then maybe we should go inside," says Rachel as she was trying to roll Artie away from the bench.

"No! I-I mean…don't you like it out here with just us and no one to bother?"

"You're ashamed of me; admit it."

"I'm not ashamed. It's just that my parents- "

"Of course; Mommy and Daddy think I'm not good enough for you, because I have two gay dads so you decided to hide me out here all night so they wouldn't see me!" screeches Rachel.

"I don't care about what they think."

"So why don't you introduce me to them?"

"No, that's not a good idea."

"You know what Artie? I'm going home and you can go screw yourself!" yells Rachel as she was trying to storm away in her Rachel Berry fashion.

"Wait! I'm sorry!" Rachel then turns around with anger clear on her face. "It's just my parents are squares and they rarely approve of who I date. But I want you stay here with me and…"

"Forget it Artie! I'm leaving!" And she walks out with her head held high and determination on where she wants to go next.

Just then Artie's mom came up to him, who heard the whole conversation. "See Artie, that's what happens when you invite the trash to the party."

Artie just sits there with his head hung in shame.

NKB~NKB~NKB~NKB~NKB

"Where have you been?" asks Quinn when she ran into Puck.

"I've been looking everywhere for you," replies a sarcastic Puck while grabbing Quinn's arm forcefully.

"You know your brother barely danced with me and all he talked about was Kurt."

"OK just a minute and stand right here." Puck went over to one of the keep sake boxes and pulled out a crystal.

"Um, you're not supposed to touch. What is that?"

"A very important crystal." Puck pulls out an amber crystal that looked like it belonged in the 1800s.

"How did you know it was there?"

"I put it there."

"When?"

"A long time ago. Tonight, I'm taking it back thanks to you."

"What's it for?"

"Never you mind."

"But you can't steal it."

"It's not stealing if it's mine."

NKB~NKB~NKB~NKB~NKB

"Hey," says Kurt as he walks into the bathroom seeing Quinn at the mirror.

"Hey. How are things with Blaine?"

"Great, just great."

"Really? My radar must be off 'cuz I was getting all sorts of other vibes."

Kurt rolls his eyes, but his eyes land on Quinn's shoulder. "What is that?"

"Don't!" She says as Kurt takes off her shrug, seeing more bite marks.

"Oh, my god! Quinn what happened?"

"Nothing happened."

"That does not look like nothing."

"Just leave it alone Kurt OK! It's nothing to be afraid of!"

"Quinn, you look like you've been attacked by a bear and you say it's nothing?"

"I don't need your help Kurt so just leave me alone!" yells Quinn as she storms out of the bathroom.

NKB~NKB~NKB~NKB~NKB

"Blaine! Oh, my god, I just saw Quinn in the bathroom and she bite marks and bruises all over her body," yells a worried Kurt as he runs to Blaine.

"Look, I'm handling it."

Kurt stops and realizes the heartbreaking truth. "You knew about this all along and you let it continue to happen?"

"Look, Puck is ticking time bomb. One more thing and he could go off."

"It looks like he went off already! It looks like he tried to kill her!"

"Hey. What's going on?" asks Puck as he came up to them.

"YOU ASSHOLE!" screams Kurt as he slaps the shit out of Puck.

"What the hell's goin' on?" asks Puck, shocked what Kurt just did.

"You know exactly what I'm talking about! I saw Quinn! How could you do that to her? And just when I thought you had one good bone in your body."

"I do! You know me. You know what I think of you."

"Well, obviously, they're all lies," replies Kurt as he storms off.

"Kurt wait!" yells both brothers at the same time.

NKB~NKB~NKB~NKB~NKB

"Please don't hurt me! He took off my sweater and I got flustered," pleads Quinn as Puck is rough handling her outside the party.

Puck is silent for a while until he starts talking in a calming tone and soothing her. "You make me really crazy, you know that? But it's OK, I forgive you."

"I swear I didn't say anything."

"Shh, shh. It's OK. Unfortunately, I'm so over you now." He leans in to bite her only to be stopped by the vervain that enters his mouth. He falls on the ground.

"I knew I could spike your drink. So, I spiked hers," says Blaine as he walks up to them. In a flash, both Blaine and Puck are gone. Quinn wakes up and gets off the ground only to find Kurt there by her side.

"Are you OK Quinn?" asks a worried Kurt.

"Yeah I'm fine. I just need to go home."

"Are you sure you can make it there by yourself."

"Yeah, yeah I'm fine."

"I'm going to help you no matter what you say."

"Yeah OK," agrees Quinn. Kurt then walks her home hoping no more disturbing events are headed their way.

NKB~NKB~NKB~NKB~NKB

Blaine carries Puck all the way down to the basement of their home and throws him in there only to lock him up so he can get even weaker from the vervain.

NKB~NKB~NKB~NKB~NKB

"Are you certain?" asks Mayor Abrams after the party in his office with Sheriff Fabray and Logan Fell.

"Five bodies all drained of blood? What else could it be?" asks Sheriff Fabray.

"They've come back," replies Logan Fell.