Will is walking down the hallway towards his classroom when Puck and Kurt appear. Will stops in his tracks.
"Well, don't you look…alive?" says Puck, noticing that Will has come back to life.
"You can't hurt me," says Will in response.
"Oh, I can hurt you, all right," says Puck as a matter factly.
"Mr. Schuester. We need your help," pleads Kurt.
"Ok. Come with me," says Will.
They go into Will's classroom to talk privately.
"Blaine's in the house. Puck's a vampire. He can't get in. We need you. I would go, but…" Kurt trails off.
"But his life is valuable. Yours, on the other hand is…" says Puck.
Kurt rolls his eyes. "Blaine told me about your ring."
"What about it?" asks Will, seeing what information Kurt knows.
"Let me recap; you tried to kill me, I defended myself, you died. Then according to my brother, your ring brought you back to life. Am I leaving anything out?" asks Puck.
"Except for the part where I try and kill you again. Only this time, I don't miss," says Will.
"Mr. Schuester, please. It's Blaine," begs Kurt again.
"I'm sorry, Kurt, but it's not my problem," says Will.
"That's a shame. Because the woman in charge of the tomb vampires can help you find your wife," says Puck, trying to intrigue Will.
"You're lying," says Will.
"Am I? Why don't you ask her for yourself, coward? Come on, Kurt," says Puck.
Puck and Kurt start to leave.
"Wait. I'll go," says Will, relenting.
NKB~NKB~NKB~NKB~NKB
Finn and Anna are still seated at a table and talking at Breadstix.
"So, I have an answer," begins Finn.
"To what?" questions Anna.
"Why you should turn me."
"We're back to that?"
"Look, I wake up every day, and I feel okay, but there's something missing. Like a…like a hole. Some people, they fit…in life, or whatever. I…I don't."
"So, you want a pity-turn? I don't think so."
"You should turn me, because I don't have anything else."
"Do you even know why we turn other people? It's not to give someone a one-way ticket out of loner-hood. Okay? One, we need someone to do our dirty work. Two, revenge. Three, boredom…but, you know, that never turns out well. And then you know there's the obvious one; you love someone so much that you would do anything to spend all of eternity with them. I'm sorry, but you don't fit any of those categories yet." Anna sees her mother enter Breadstix. "So, yeah. Just make sure your thesis is clear, and she'll love it. See you later." She leaves the table quickly and sends a text to Finn.
Anna joins her mother. "Mom, hey."
"Did you get everything?" asks Pearl.
"Yeah, the blood bank was understaffed, because of the rain. I was in and out."
"Who's that you were talking to?"
"A friend from the library."
"Let's get home, Annabelle."
Mayor Richard Abrams and Artie enter Breadstix.
"Hey, you're not going out in that, are ya? The roads are dangerous. Route 5 is completely flooded," says Mayor Abrams to Pearl.
"We'll make do," she answers.
"Mayor Abrams, we have your table ready," says a waitress.
"Great," responds Artie.
"Mayor…Abrams, is it? I suppose it is treacherous outside. My name is Pearl," she greets.
"Hi," greet Mayor Abrams.
"This is my daughter Anna. We've just recently moved to town."
"Welcome. Richard Abrams. This is my son Artie. Please, join us."
"It would be a pleasure."
"Be creepier, Dad. It's not like your son is sitting right here," says Artie in a huff.
"Grow up. Elections are coming. She's a constituent. And a rich one, from the looks of it," says Mayor Abrams rudely.
"You can tell all that by looking at her ass? Awesome. I'm gonna go shoot some pool," says Artie, wheeling away.
NKB~NKB~NKB~NKB~NKB
Will, in his classroom, pulls out his arsenal of vampire weapons.
"Teacher by day, vampire hunter by night," says Puck, looking at all the weapons on the desk.
"I've you to thank for that," responds Will.
"What are these?" asks Kurt, picking up a dart.
"Those are tranquilizer darts filled with vervain," answers Will.
"Just get me in. I'll get Blaine out," says Puck, trying to lay out a plan.
"That's your plan? You're just gonna take them all on yourself?" asks Kurt.
"Well, I'll be a little stealthier than that, hopefully," replies Puck.
Kurt takes one of the vervain darts.
"Whoa. What are you doing?" asks Will.
"I'm going with you guys," answers Kurt simply.
"No. No. No. No. No way," says Puck very adamantly.
"You need me. I'll get in. You could distract them, and then I'll get Blaine out," says Kurt with his own plan.
"You'll get yourself killed. You're not going in there," says Puck.
"I'm going," says Kurt, headstrong.
"So, when you get me in, get out as quickly as you can. I know how to sneak around where they can't hear me. You'll basically just be in the way," says Puck.
"Puck, now is not the time to be the lone ranger.".
"Fine. Kurt, you can drive the getaway car. You're not going in the house," says Puck, trying to give something to Kurt to appease him.
"You can't stop me. It's Blaine we're talking about here. You don't understand."
"Oh, I understand. He's the reason you live. His love lifts you up where you belong. I get it," says Puck, bored.
"Can you just not joke around for two seconds?"
"I can't protect you, Kurt. I don't know how many vampires there are in there. That's how long it takes you to get your head ripped off. I have to be able to get in and get out. I can't be distracted with your safety. Or this will end up a bloodbath that none of us walk away from. Including Blaine. I know. I get it."
"If we're gonna go, let's go," says Will interrupting them.
NKB~NKB~NKB~NKB~NKB
Sam calls Quinn, still sitting at Breadstix. "Where are you? I can barely hear you," he says into the phone.
"Storm washed out Route 5. Now I'm detoured on some random backwoods path to hell," replies Quinn on the other end.
"Well, you shouldn't be talking while you're driving."
"I know, right? I need one of those little Bluetooth thingies." Her signal is going in and out.
"Look, you're breaking up. Just turn around and go back the same way you came. And watch the road. Okay?"
"Okay." Quinn tries to turn around, but her car gets stuck in the mud. "God. Ohh. Ohh. Seriously?" She tries to call someone, but her cell phone isn't working.
NKB~NKB~NKB~NKB~NKB
Will knocks on Miss Gibbon's door and Frederick answers it. "Oh, good, someone's home. Uh, could I use your phone? My car broke down a few miles up the road. This was the first house I saw," says Will.
"Well, lucky you," replies Frederick.
"Yeah. Lucky me. It's no trouble, is it?" asks Will.
"Not in the slightest," replies Frederick with a smirk.
"Great. Whew." Will enters the house. "Hey, man, I really appreciate it. It's rough out there."
"Billy, show our visitor where the phone is in the kitchen. And get me something to drink," orders Frederick.
"Yeah. Sure thing," says Billy. "Hey, Miss Gibbons, this guy wants to use your phone."
"Oh, sure, honey. It's right there," says Miss Gibbons.
"Thanks," says Will. As he walks towards the phone, Billy comes at him with a stake. Will is too quick for him and grabs the stake and stabs him with it.
"Aah!" yells Billy in pain.
Will turns on the faucet and starts the blender to create noise.
"What's happening?" asks Miss Gibbons.
"I'm really sorry. But you're gonna need to invite a friend of mine inside," says Will. He opens the door and Puck is standing outside.
"Oh, I'm sorry. He's not allowed in the house," replies Miss Gibbons.
"I know that. But you've gotta make an exception," says Will.
"Get her out of the house. Now!" yells Puck. Will pushes Miss Gibbons towards the door. Puck grabs her face. "Miss Gibbons, tell me the truth. Are you married?"
"No," she replies.
"Parents, children, anyone else who lives on this property?" asks Puck.
"No. It's just me," she answers again.
"No? Good." Puck breaks her neck and promptly enters the house.
"You were supposed to compel her," says Will.
"It doesn't work that way…"
"She's human."
"And I'm not! So, I don't care. Now, get out of here. And get rid of the body!"
As Will and Puck are in the house, Kurt is waiting in Puck's car. He pulls a vervain syringe from his bag and examines it. A tree branch falls onto the car's windshield. Kurt gasps.
NKB~NKB~NKB~NKB~NKB
Pearl sits down with the Mayor at a table. "I'm in the process of obtaining some property. I understand that your family is the largest property owner in town," says Pearl.
"Well, yes, we are. Dating all the way back to the town's original charter," responds the Mayor.
"Your family came into a lot of new property in 1864."
"You know your history," he says, impressed.
"It's a passion of mine."
"Guy's not even subtle about it," says Artie at the bar, watching his father and Pearl.
"Who is that?" asks Sam in response.
"It's not my mother," responds Artie.
Finn walks over to Anna, who is playing darts. Anna tells him to stay away.
Pearl notices the inter action. "I'm sorry, Mayor. Do you know that boy over there?"
"Yeah it's Finn Hudson."
"That's not a founding family name."
"Yes, but his mom, before she passed, married into the Hummel family."
"You don't say."
NKB~NKB~NKB~NKB~NKB
"Billy, what's the holdup?!" yells Frederick. He tells another vampire to go see what is up. He enters the kitchen and turns off the sink and blender. He approaches the pantry. Puck opens the door and stakes him.
"Aah!" yells the vampire.
Will takes the opportunity to run back to the car. He opens the door and sees Kurt isn't there. "Damn it, Kurt!" He grabs his bag and treks back to the house.
Kurt jumps onto the porch of Miss Gibbons' house. He stays by the wall to keep himself hidden. He starts to move on, but hears Frederick.
"Billy, Jacob, get back in here!"
Kurt runs past the door and goes down a staircase that leads to the cellar. He tries to open the door, but it is locked. He busts out one of the window panes, unlocks the door and opens it. A man is standing guard by a door at the end of the hallway. Kurt gets his vervain syringe out and is ready to attack, but Puck gets to the man first. He sees Kurt.
Puck grabs Kurt by the arms. "Are you insane?!"
NKB~NKB~NKB~NKB~NKB
Quinn gets out of her car and walks around to retrieve a signal on her cell phone. She finally gets a signal, but slips and falls down the bank of the river. She pulls herself up by grabbing what she thinks is a tree branch. Instead she sees it's the decomposing body of Rachel.
"Ahhhhh!"
NKB~NKB~NKB~NKB~NKB
Pearl is talking to Anna in the restroom. "Finn Hudson? Is that what you've been up to?"
"He's my friend. What's the big deal?"
"His family is the reason I was stuck in a tomb for over a century."
"That doesn't mean he'll make the same choices."
"I want you to stop seeing him."
"I've been on my own for a long time, Mother. I can make my own decisions."
"Then stop acting like a child! As soon as Finn finds out what you really are, he will turn on you."
"He already knows."
Pearl turns to her daughter suddenly. "What did you just say?"
"Finn knows. He likes it. And he likes me."
Pearl slaps her. "You stay away from him, Annabelle!"
When they are exiting Breadstix, Anna she sends Finn a text saying, I'll do it.
NKB~NKB~NKB~NKB~NKB
Blaine and Harper are tied to hooks like prisoners of war in the cellar.
"Uhh. Thank you. For trying to help me," says Blaine.
"They just needed somebody to blame. Someone to punish," explains Harper.
Kurt and Puck enter the cellar.
"Kurt…you shouldn't be here…" says Blaine weakly.
"He was supposed to stay in the car," says Puck.
"Why doesn't that surprise me?" asks Blaine with a smirk.
"Whatever. Let's get you down."
"There's vervain on the ropes," Blaine tells them.
"Kurt pull that," instructs Puck.
"Unh!" yells Blaine as Kurt cuts him down.
"All right, let's go. Clothes on," says Puck.
"Wait," says Blaine.
"What? Guys, come on. We have to get out of here," says Puck, trying to get out of there in a hurry.
Blaine and Kurt pull the stakes out of Harper's legs. "Uhh!" yells Harper in response.
"Come on, we gotta go," says Kurt.
"The other one," says Blaine.
Kurt pulls the last stake out from Harper's back. "Uhh!"
"Can you get him in the car?" Puck asks Kurt.
"Yeah," he responds.
"All right, go."
"What about you?"
"You rescue, I'll distract. Go."
Upstairs, Frederick is getting suspicious. It's too quiet. Motioning to the stereo, "Turn that down. It's too quiet."
One of the vampires gets staked.
"Spread out. Now! You two, back of the house. Go. Check out both rooms. Cellar, now!"
In the woods, Kurt is trying to carry Blaine to the car.
"Uhh," groans Blaine.
"Can you make it?" asks Kurt.
"Uhh! Unh."
They fall and Kurt cuts himself on a rock.
"Ohh. You okay?"
"Yeah. Come on, keep going. Come on."
Kurt pulls Blaine up and they continue onwards.
At Miss Gibbons, Frederick sees another staked vampire in the dining room. Puck catches him by surprise. They fight. Puck gets Frederick on the floor and starts punching him. Two vampires come up from behind and pull Puck off. Frederick runs out. The vampires and Puck start fighting. One of them approaches Puck from behind. Puck doesn't see him, but Will shoots at the vampire with a dart.
"I'm going after Frederick!" yells Puck as he runs after him.
In the woods, Kurt and Blaine arrive at the car.
"Come on, it's right over here," says Kurt, struggling to hold up Blaine. He puts Blaine in the car and goes around to the driver's side. He sees the ignition has been removed. "Stefan…"
Frederick busts the window on Blaine's side out and drags him out. He starts beating him. "Aah!" yells Frederick.
"Ugh! Uhh…" groans Blaine weakly.
"This is for Bethanne." Frederick impales Blaine with a branch.
"Aah!"
"And this is for the tomb."
"No!" yells Kurt. He plunges the vervain syringe into Frederick's back.
"Ugh! Unh!" Frederick drops to ground.
"Blaine…" He sits down next to Blaine.
"Unh. Uhh."
Kurt pulls out the branch. He sees that Blaine is starting to fade. "Blaine…Blaine…No, Blaine. Blaine, Blaine. Blaine! Blaine!"
In the house, Will is reloading his dart gun and a vampire attacks him. They wrestle to the ground and Will stabs him with a vervain syringe. Puck comes back into the hallway.
"Frederick's gone," says Puck.
"Let's get out of here," says Will.
"I'm gonna kill him."
Puck and Will exit the house. They see many more vampires approaching.
"How many of those vervain darts do you have left?"
"One."
"Not gonna be enough."
NKB~NKB~NKB~NKB~NKB
Hiram is making dinner and Sam comes into the kitchen.
"Hey, Dad. What's going on?" asks Sam, confused
"What's it look like?" replies Hiram in an annoyed tone.
"Honestly, I wouldn't know. I've never seen it before."
"Well, sit down. You might wanna order pizza. I'm out of practice."
"Mmm. Mystery casserole. Yum," says Sam sarcastically.
"Yeah. Some people aren't meant for the kitchen."
"What?"
"Uh, I know it's been rough. But I'm gonna try. I mean, really try this time. You just have to bear with me, okay?"
"Okay."
"Okay. Good."
The doorbell rings and Sam gets up to answer it. "I got it." Sam opens the door and Quinn and her mom look dejected. "What happened to you?"
"Hey, Sam," says Sheriff, not looking Sam in the eye.
"Hey. What's going on?" asks Sam.
"Is your dad home?"
NKB~NKB~NKB~NKB~NKB
Mayor Lockwood gets a phone call while him and Artie are at Breadstix. While Finn is at a nearby table.
"Alright, give me ten minutes. And keep it out of the news till I get there." He hangs up the phone and turns to Artie. "Grab your stuff. We gotta go."
"Kinda got half a plate of spaghetti left, Dad," says Artie.
"They found Rachel Berry."
Artie has a shocked look on his face. "Are you serious? Where was she?"
"Storm unearthed the grave off county road. They just brought her body down to the morgue."
Finn gets up and goes over to their table. "Wait. She's dead?"
"Come on, Artie, we gotta go." Both Mayor and Artie get up and leave Breadstix, leaving Finn.
NKB~NKB~NKB~NKB~NKB
In the woods, Kurt is shaking Blaine, trying to get him up. "Blaine, please. Blaine! Oh, Blaine, please get up. Get up, Blaine. Blaine." Kurt sees that Frederick is getting up. He notices the cut on his hand and puts it up to Blaine's mouth for him to drink. "Here."
"Kurt, please run," says Blaine in a hoarse voice.
"No."
"Please."
"Blaine. My wrist. Here. Take my wrist. You need more blood."
"Go, Kurt. Run. Run…"
"No. I trust you." Kurt gives Blaine his wrist and he drinks the blood.
Back at the house, Pearl and Anna come home and see what happened.
"So, what you said to get me to do this, about my wife. It was a lie, wasn't it?" asks Will to Puck.
"Yep," answers Puck simply.
"Stop. What's going on here? What did you do?" asks Pearl.
"Me? Your merry little band of vampires spent the day torturing my brother," says Puck.
"Trust me. The parties responsible for this will be dealt with," replies Pearl.
"Our little arrangement doesn't work unless you learn to control them," Puck informs her.
"This wasn't supposed to happen," replies Pearl.
"Well, it did. If I had a good side…not a way to get on it," says Puck. He and Will leave the house.
In the woods, Frederick is regaining his strength. He grabs another branch and walks towards Blaine. Blaine gets up and pins Frederick to a tree. He takes the branch from Frederick and repeatedly stabs him in the heart. "Argh! Ahh! Aah! Aah!"
"Blaine! Blaine! Stop, please!" Kurt tries to make Blaine stop. Blaine turns around, his face is still in its vampire form. Kurt is frightened by him. Blaine stops. He looks horrified at what he's done.
NKB~NKB~NKB~NKB~NKB
At the boarding house, Kurt is staring out Blaine's window. Blaine approaches him.
"How are you doing?" asks Kurt.
"I'm okay. The wounds have mostly healed," answers Blaine.
"Good."
"Kurt…"
"Yeah?"
"What you did today, coming to help me…you could have been killed."
"I know."
"And what I did, I'm sorry that…I'm sorry that you had to see it."
"I've just never…You were like this other person. And it's my fault. I made you…"
"What? No, no, no, no." He walks over to Kurt and sits next to him. "You didn't make me do anything. You were saving my life. And I was saving yours." Blaine caresses his face. "Everything's gonna be okay."
Kurt's phone rings and he answers. "Hey, Finn…What—what's going on? Oh, no."
NKB~NKB~NKB~NKB~NKB
Everyone has gathered at Sam's house.
Quinn brings coffee to Sam. "I made you some coffee."
"Thanks." Sam sadly takes the coffee.
"Are you…is there anything I can do?"
"I just, uh…I need to be alone right now."
Kurt arrives, he hugs Sam. "Sammy…"
NKB~NKB~NKB~NKB~NKB
Kurt and Finn return home.
Kurt touches Finn's back. "Finn…are you okay?"
"I'm gonna go get some sleep." He goes to his room. He pulls out two newspaper articles from the Lima Courier, one with the title "Unexplained Deaths Stump Authorities", scrunches them rips them up. He then pulls out a copy of the Lima Courier with a picture of Rachel on it under the headline "Local Girl Survives Animal Attack". He doesn't notice Anna behind him near the window.
"What are you doing?" asks Ann.
"My…my friend Rachel…She's—She's dead.
"Rachel? The one you thought was a…"
"Yep. Turns out she's been dead all along."
"She's the reason you wanted to turn? You wanted to be with her?"
Finn turns away. "Look, I'm sorry." Finn turns towards where Anna was but she is gone.
NKB~NKB~NKB~NKB~NKB
At the boarding house, Puck enters Blaine's room. He sees blood bags that are empty. Then he sees Blaine sitting on the floor, drinking from another blood bag.