Chapter 62: Playing the Game, Part 2
Finn passed the mask to Puck, who slipped it over his eyes.
"Just warning you now: whoever has my name better not try anything funny." Puck threatened.
"Someone should hold his hands behind him." Santana said. "He can get a little hands-y. He won't be able to resist trying to touch."
"Yeah. Finn, hold his arms back." Rachel commanded. "We don't need him feeling up the kisser and trying to guess that way."
"Uhmm..." Finn said.
"Just do it, man." Puck said, pushing his arms behind him.
"Okay..." Finn grabbed hold of Puck's wrists and held tight. "Got him."
"Pucker up, Puckerman." Santana smirked.
Kurt took a deep breath and nodded to Sam slightly as he passed by to Puck.
Sam discreetly took his phone from his pocket and pulled up the video recorder. As he turned it on, Kurt settled in front of Puck.
"You sure you have a good hold on Puck?" Artie spoke.
"Yeah. Just get it over with." Finn said, turning his head away.
"Come on, I don't have all night." Puck complained, and Kurt pressed his mouth to Puck's, slipping his tongue inside. He felt Puck's tongue slide over his and Kurt let their tongues tangle. Puck gave a slight moan as his tongue ran over Kurt's teeth, before twining around his tongue again. Kurt pulled back from the kiss slightly, nipping gently, then harder at Puck's lower lip, tugging it between his teeth before letting go.
Kurt slipped back to his spot beside Sam as Puck ran his tongue over his lips, the taste of Kurt's strawberry lip balm still lingering on his mouth.
"Did you get it on video?" Kurt whispered to Sam, who nodded as he turned off the video.
"Wanky." Quinn said suddenly. "Puckerman's got a boner."
Finn let go of Puck when Puck struggled to free his arms. Puck ripped the mask off and looked around the room.
"Alright. Who was it?" He asked. "Quinn?"
"Not me." She said.
"Rachel?"
"Not me, either." Rachel shook her head.
"Santana?" Puck said, getting desperate.
"Hell no, Cowboy." Santana laughed.
"For God's sake, who was it then?" Puck demanded.
"Kurt." Tina and Mike said together.
Puck whipped his head around to face Kurt, who merely lifted an eyebrow at the Jewish boy.
"I said not to try anything funny!" Puck snarled. "This is the second time you've done this, Hummel!"
"Second time?" Brittany whispered to Artie.
"It's a long story." Artie whispered back.
"I swear, I'm gonna get you for this, Hummel." Puck threatened.
"Promises, promises." Kurt said, shrugging it off.
Puck snarled again, but Quinn clipped him upside the head.
"Get over it, Puckerman. They said lips and tongue were allowed. It's not Kurt's fault if you get turned on or not." She said. "Now pass me the damn eye mask."
Puck threw it at her lap and glared at Kurt, who ignored him.
Quinn pulled the mask on and said:
"Okay, ready."
Mike licked his lips to wet them as his slid forward, Tina watching warily.
Mike gently kissed Quinn, pulling back after a moment. He rejoined Tina, and nuzzled her with his nose. Tina relaxed. Everyone knew Mike only nuzzled her with his nose when he needed to reassure her that everything was fine.
"Well." Quinn pulled off the mask. "Brittany, Mercedes, and Tina already kissed their persons. Kurt already kissed his, so did Sam. I know what Finn and Puck's lips feel like, so it wasn't them."
She went on.
"Judging by the roughness of the lips, being slightly chapped, I'd say it was a guy, so that excludes Rachel and Santana. Which leaves Artie and Mike."
Quinn looked between the remaining boys.
"Since it didn't take long for the person to get back to their spot, I'm going to have to go with Mike." Quinn said. "Sorry, Artie."
"Don't apologize, woman." Artie said. "Your guess was right."
"Wow." Quinn said, nodding in amazement.
"Don't get used to kissing my boyfriend, Quinn." Tina said, joking around.
"Don't worry. I don't poach other girls' boyfriends." Quinn said.
"Who wants to be kissed next?" Sam asked.
"I'll do it." Kurt said. "Might as well, right?"
Quinn passed the mask over, and Sam helped Kurt fix it over his eyes.
"Okay, ready, Babe?" Sam asked, squeezing Kurt's hand.
"Yep. Let's go." Kurt said.
Kurt heard rustling, heard movement. It didn't take long before Kurt felt someone's warm breath on his mouth. His lips parted slightly, and the other person pressed their lips to his somewhat hesitantly. Kurt turned his head, angling it better as the person kissed him.
Kurt felt lightly chapped lips, not too rough. The person was kissing gently, like the were new at it. Kurt felt the other persons tongue run over his lips, and he parted them more, allowing access. The tongue pressed into his mouth carefully, exploring the taste of Kurt. Their tongues circled, and then the person drew back.
Kurt heard the rustling movement again, and waited until it stopped before removing the mask.
He looked around, first at Quinn, Santana and Rachel. None of their lips were chapped, and they all had experience with kissing. Kurt looked to the boys next. His eyes wandered over Finn, Puck and Artie.
Puck was scowling, and he didn't really know how to be gentle.
'Not Puck.' Kurt decided. 'Finn is gentle but he has experience with kissing. I doubt it's him.'
"Artie." Kurt said, looking at his friend.
"That was fast." Artie said, looking a touch embarrassed.
"Maybe. But it was a good kiss." Kurt said. "But-"
"I know, you love Sam." Artie intervened, raising his hand. "I'm not going to get involved, especially since I'm straight. It's just a game, and even though I was curious on what it was like to kiss a guy, that's been taken care of now."
"Okay." Kurt said, glad that was sorted out. "Next person?"
"Pass the mask." Santana said, holding out her hand. Kurt tossed it over, and she put it on. "Let's go already."
Rachel made a face as she scooted up in front of the Latina woman. She leaned her face in and kissed Santana sweetly before shifting back beside Finn.
Santana tugged the mask off.
"Definitely a chick." She said, looking at Rachel and Quinn. "Gotta be Berry."
"How'd you know?" Rachel asked, shocked.
"I didn't. You just told me." Santana sneered, crossing her arms over her chest.
"Oh." Rachel said.
"My turn!" Brittany piped up, taking the mask from Santana and sliding it on. "Ready!"
Brittany sat waiting as Puck made his way across the floor. He shot Kurt a dirty look before crushing his mouth to the blonde cheerleaders' lips. Puck used his tongue and teeth in the kiss, nipping and biting Brittany's tongue and lips before finally withdrawing back to his spot.
"Was he trying to make me jealous or something?" Kur whispered to Sam as Brittany took the mask off her face.
"Looked that way to me." Sam whispered back.
"I have to say...it was Puck." Brittany said, as Puck gave his signature smirk.
"How could anyone not know it was Puck?" Santana said.
"Pass me the mask, yo." Artie said.
Brittany handed the mask to her boyfriend, and he removed his glasses to put it on.
"Ready, Artie?" Finn asked, watching Quinn make her way over to the boy. Artie nodded as Quinn kissed Artie, lingering long enough before pulling back. As she settled into her place, Artie took off the mask and replaced it with his glasses.
"Definitely women lips." Artie looked between Santana and Quinn.
"I'm going with Quinn." Quinn nodded, and Artie grinned.
"Okay, four people left..." Kurt said, looking at Sam and Tina, who had yet to be kissed, and Santana and Finn, who had yet to do the kissing.
"We need another mask, Kurt." Mike said.
"Luckily, I think I have one." Kurt walked to his bedside table and rummaged around. "Yep, got one!"
Kurt walked back and handed it to Sam as Tina took the other mask from Artie.
"Only Finn and Santana are left to kiss you." Kurt said to Tina and Sam. "We'll see if you guess right."
Once their eyes securely covered, Tina and Sam waited to be kissed.
"Alright, get to it." Kurt said to Santana and Finn. Santana made her way to Tina, and Finn awkwardly made his way to Sam.
"Lean in, and...kiss!" Santana and Finn leaned in simultaneously and kissed the person in from of them. Finn kissed Sam quickly, but Santana let her tongue slide in and around Tina's mouth.
"Okay, enough. Back to your spots." Kurt said, breaking up the kisses.
Finn and Santana sat back down and Sam and Tina removed their blindfold.
"Okay, there's no way Finn would kiss anyone other than Rachel that way." Tina said, looking pointedly at Santana.
"Yeah, and that kiss was like a brotherly peck, nothing more." Sam said. "Finn kissed me, and Santana kissed Tina."
"Right you are, Trouty-Mouth." Santana said, inclining her head.
"Well then, that was everyone." Kurt said. "Hopefully what happened in this room stays in this room."
Kurt looked around. Everyone nodded in agreement. Kurt felt eyes lingering on him and he turned his head. He found Puck staring at him with fierce intensity. Kurt shifted his gaze to the other kids.
"Okay, game is over. We still have music if you guys wanna sing, or dance. Or both." Kurt said, standing up and pulling Sam to his feet as well.
"And there's still plenty of wine coolers left too. Feel free to drink them." Sam added, gesturing to the bottles.
As everyone began to stand, Kurt pulled Sam to the side.
"We have to set up the cameras later for phase two of the plan." He said.
"As soon as everyone leaves, and he goes to the washroom, no problem." Sam smiled.
