Hoi Hoi Hoi, NyanToDaMax here, and welcome back to Smash Whodunnit! This series will most likely go on for some time. Perhaps even 20 Chapters or more. At any rate, let's get started!


"Okay, so did you manage to keep Toon from killing Ike?" I ask Pi. I just came back from a sleepover with my friends, and I am reviewing the case file that Pi and Nayi had written up.

Pi nods and chomps down on her white chocolate.

"At any rate, I suppose it's a good ending or something as any." I sigh. Suddenly, Nayi bursts into the room.

"NYAN! PI! You've gotta come right away!" Nayi screeches. Pi raises her eyebrows as I jump off my chair right away.

"What is it?!" I cry. Nayi takes a few deep breaths. Her hair is messy and her face is flushed.

"Corrin and Kamui just found Palutena knocked unconscious in the west wing!" Nayi cries. Pi then topples off my chair as I rush out of the door at full sprint. I hear Nayi and Pi rushing after me.

I try to stop in the west wing, promptly tripped, and faceplanted onto the floor.

"You alright?" I get up and dust myself off.

"Yeah, I'm fine, Pit." I sigh. I glance around and see Palutena sitting up, rubbing her head. Corrin and Kamui are next to her. As I watch, Kamui's dragon head disappears into her normal head. (?)

"Hey, Nyan." Corrin says. Pi and Nayi rush towards me and stop short.

"Oh wow. Nayi forgot to mention all the water." Pi muttered. I nod in agreement. Water covers every inch of the room. Palutena groans and shakily stands up.

"Pi. Nyan. Nayi. What…" Palutena shakes her head. She looks a little disoriented and dizzy. Pit rushes up to her.

"You should get to the infirmary, Lady Palutena!" he cries. Palutena places a hand on her forehead, still confused. Corrin turns to me.

"We found Palutena when she screamed. We ran in here to see all this." She gestures to the soaking wet room around us. I pull my clipboard and hat out of my hammerspace.

"Did you happen to see anyone near the scene?" I ask them. Kamui shakes his head.

"I thought I saw a few very small figures running away though…" Kamui mutters, "But it could have just been my imagination." I nod slowly and write Kamui saw very small figures running away.

"Crackers, how tall were they?" Nayi asks. I glance over at Pi, who is checking the room for clues.

"Smaller than any Smasher, that's for sure." Kamui explained. Corrin and Kamui walked out of the room in a hurry. Pi looked up from where she was crouching.

"Nyan, you might want to have a look at this." I stroll over to her. A small cherry was hidden in a dark corner.

"A cherry? Why is this here…?" I wonder. Pi shrugged.

"It's a little squashed. I just thought it was weird." I scoop the cherry into a plastic bag and pin it to my clipboard.

"Hey hey Nyan! Will this apple help?" Nayi is holding up a roll of crime scene tape. I stare at her in confusion.

"I'll rope off the area, I mean-"

"Nayi, it's not necessary, I don't think." Pi groans.

"Come on, guys, let's figure this out in our room." I say. Nayi looks sad and drops the roll of tape.


"Okay, so what do we know about the culprit so far?" I asked, tucking my pen behind my ear. Pi pinned one more picture on the corkboard and stepped back, admiring her work. We had put up a corkboard in our room and pinned our evidence so far on it, including our notes.

"Well, whoever did this has to have a water attack of some sorts, or have some sort of item or buddy pretty small." Pi reasoned. Nayi flipped through the Smash Roster.

"If I'm remembering correctly, Cola, the Smashers who have water attacks are Mario, Greninja, Pac Man, Kamui, and Corrin." Nayi counted off. Pi looks a little confused.

"Corrin and Kamui? They don't seem like the type to do something like that. After all, they did discover Palutena in the first place." she muses. I shrug, thinking about it.

"It's best to suspect everyone, to be honest. You never know, after all." I mutter. Pi shrugs and scribbles something down on her clipboard.

"Okay, how are we gonna split this up?" Pi asks. Nayi suddenly claps her hands together.

"I know Pocky! What if we post our case on the bulletin board, and anyone who has any clues can come to us!" Nayi explains. I blink.

"That's… actually a great idea!" Pi cries. I nod vigorously in agreement. Nayi could really come up with awesome ideas if she put her mind to it.


"Okay, we've posted the case. So now… I think… Nayi, you talk to Mario and Pac Man, Nyan, you talk with Kamui and Corrin, I'll talk with Greninja." Pi planned. Nayi and I roll our eyes in unison.

"You just want the least work, huh?" I sigh. Pi blows a raspberry at me.

"So what? I'm tired!" she sighs. Nayi suddenly snaps her fingers.

"Come to think of it melon, maybe Olimar could have done it! Ya know, Kamui saw those small figures, right? What if they were Pikmin? And Olimar is good enough at technology to make something like Mario's thingie!" Nayi screeches. Pi groans.

"I guess you'll take Olimar then~" I laughed while I wrote: Nayi thinks that the small figures running away were Pikmin, so it could be Olimar's doing. Pi sighs and trudges off.


"Yo Nayi, I saw that you have a new case!" Nayi turned around to see Ike waving at her.

"Ya, peaches! Do you have any info?" she asked. Ike nodded and pointed to Kamui and Corrin, who were just walking down the hall, discussing something quietly.

"Palutena destroyed those two is a Smash Battle last week. They've been pretty salty about it. But she more recently beat Mario, and I don't know how he feel about it. I hope that helps." Ike explained. Nayi scribbled down frantically: Palutena beat Kamui and Corrin in a battle last week. Palutena more recently beat Mario.

"Thanks, sushi! I'm glad I ran into you!" Nayi cried over her shoulder, charging away down the hall.


"Pi. Glad I ran into you." Pi turned around to see Samus standing behind her.

"Oh, hey Samus. What's up?" Samus lifted her faceplate up.

"Well, I saw the poster thing, and since you're talking with everyone that uses water moves, Greninja would be a suspect, right? But out of all of you, only Nyan speaks Pokemon. So I assume Nyan-" Pi faceplamed in realization.

"Oh god, I didn't even think about that! What was I thinking? I was supposed to chat with Greninja and Olimar, but… god, I really didn't think this through…" Samus chuckled.

"How about I assist you with Greninja. You can go talk to Olimar, and I'll check with Greninja and get back to you later. How about it?" Samus asked. Pi sighed with relief.

"Oh Samus, thank you so much! I'll repay you with an omelette later, I promise!" Samus sweatdropped.

"No offense but.. Could you get your sister to cook it…?" she asked before disappearing. Pi took a second to register what she meant.

"HEY! I'M NOT THAT BAD AT COOKING!" Pi screamed after her.

"Yeah, but your sister makes better omelettes!" Seamus yelled. Pi stalked off to the lab in a huff.


Nayi skipped towards the east hallway, looking left and right for Mario or Pac Man. When she rounded the corner, she noticed Mario and Luigi rounding into a side room, carrying some wooden planks, a hammer, and the F.L.U.D.D.

They walked into the room, and Nayi heard some thumps as the items were place down.

"Mario-Mar! Hi hi!" Nayi cried. Luigi and Mario looked up from the booth they were building. Nayi screeched to a stop right next to them.

"Ooooh, what's this booth for? OH! I KNOW! THE NEWCOMERS! RIGHT?!" Luigi climbed down from the stepladder.

"Why-a yes! They're supposed to be arriving by-a December, but-a Master Hand wanted us to start early. We're-a waiting for Olimar, in fact." he explained.

"So Nayi. What-a did you want from us? You're-a wearing that hat, I assume something went down?" Mario asked. Nayi did an insane twirling pencil trick and flipped it behind her ear.

"Why yes, cherry! We found Palutena unconscious just a few minutes ago. She was knocked out by a water attack which drenched the whole hallway. And since it was a water attack, Mario, I'm sorry to say that you're on the suspect list!"

"That can't-a be right! Mario's F.L.U.D.D. has been-a broken all day! In-a fact, Olimar promised to-a fix it, but he's-a been busy." Luigi explained. Mario nodded slowly for a second. Then a lightbulb appeared above his head.

"You-a know, Pac-Man has-a been secretive lately. I wonder if-a he had anything to-a do with it." Nayi thought for a second and could see what Mario was thinking. She had seen Pac-Man slinking around in the halls earlier, after all.

"Thanks Mario!" Nayi cried. Mario's F.L.U.D.D. has been broken all day, according to Luigi. Mario noticed that Pac-Man has been secretive lately.


"Yeah, so then we ran to the hallway, and Palutena was all sprawled out on the floor. Then Pit ran in because he heard her scream, and then Nayi, and you know the rest." Corrin explained. Kamui nodded in agreement.

"Then again, that cherry might point to Pac Man. You know… for obvious reasons." I scribble down this information quickly. Corrin and Kamui heard Palutena scream, and then found her drenched in the hall. Kamui thinks that the cherry points to Pac Man.

"Thanks guys." I sigh. Despite talking to them, I barely gleaned any information. Suddenly, I had an idea. I headed back to the crime scene. There was still water everywhere. I took a small bottle from my hammerspace and scooped up some water.

"I hope Olimar can analyze this. He might be a suspect, but he can probably figure out what kind of water this is." I slip the bottle into my hammerspace and start heading towards the lab.


"Hmmm… Palutena found in the west wing, eh? Strange. Mario did ask me to fix his F.L.U.D.D. earlier. But I haven't had the time. And as for Corrin and Kamui, to be honest, it might be them." Pi and Olimar were sitting in the lab. Pikmin scurried in and out of the lab at random intervals, bringing tools or making items.

"What makes you say that?" Pi asked as she observed the Pikmin. Olimar gestured to the Pikmin.

"Well, if my Pikmin are following orders, they've only traveled to the supply closet and kitchen all day. Those are nowhere near the west wing. But since you told me that Corrin and Kamui noticed the 'Pikmin', I have no other choice to conclude that."

Olimar's Pikmin have been nowhere near the west wing all day. Therefore, Corrin and Kamui were lying.

"Thanks for the info, Olimar. I'll be sure to check with Alph to-"


"OLIMAR!" I scream, crashing into the lab. Pi toppled off her stool in surprise, while Olimar looked at me cooly.

"What is it, Nyan?" he asked. I held up the vial of water.

"Can you analyze this and find out where it came from?" I gasp. Olimar tilted his head to the side in thought. Pi picked herself up and dusted herself off.

"I most likely can. It will take a while, though. It will make the entire mystery a lot easier, I assume." Olimar mused. Pi nodded in agreement.

"Thanks Olimar!" I cry, handing him the vial of water. Pi rolled her eyes and stalked out of the room.


"Weird… so Greninja has seen Pac-Man near the west wing earlier?" Pi asked. Samus nodded.

"Isn't it strange? And also, I found him in the training room, and I realized that his water attacks don't have the range to cover the whole west wing stairwell." Samus explained.

Greninja saw Pac-Man near the west wing earlier today. Greninja's water attacks don't have enough range to cover the whole west wing stairwell.

"Thanks for the info, Samus. I hope we can figure this out soon." Pi sighed.


"Pac-Man, have you seen Palutena around recently?"

"Not really. I did see Corrin and Kamui talking about Palutena earlier, though." Pac-Man muttered. Nayi raised her eyebrows.

"Corrin and Kamui? Muffins, that's a little weird. Did you catch what they were saying?" Nayi asked Pac-Man shook his head.

"Just something about Palutena kicking their butts last Smash Battle." Pac-Man mused. Pac-Man overheard Corrin and Kamui talking about Palutena earlier today.

"Thanks for the info sushi. Can I assume that you weren't the culprit…?" Nayi asked. Pac-Man shrugged nonchalantly.

"It's up to you. But Robin can vouch for me; I was in the training room with him all morning."


I tacked my list of evidence on the board. I might have gotten everything in order, but it didn't feel like I had all the pieces. Nayi and Pi walked into the room, sighing.

"Did you guys get anything…?" Pi asked, rubbing her forehead. I rub my forehead in annoyance.

"This case is giving me a headache. Although we have a lot of evidence against a few characters, we don't really have all the pieces…" I groan. Nayi plops facedown onto the floor.

"Noodles, I do have a feeling it might be-" Nayi's muffled theory is cut off by a crash upstairs.

"The lab! Olimar!" Pi cried. We hightailed it upstairs at top speed, skidding around corners. When we reached the lab, we realized that the door was hanging off its hinges. Someone tall was running away from the scene, but we couldn't see who it was.

"Nayi, after that person! Pi, come on!" I cried. Nayi guzzled down a soda and shot off after the runner, while Pi and I rushed into the lab.

A scene of total devastation met our eyes. Olimar was lying on the floor, shattered beakers around him. His Pikmins were scattering everywhere, while Pikmin ghosts floated upward.

"Olimar!" I cried. Pi pushed her glasses up to her nose.

"Unconscious. But you know, he could just be staging the whole thing, and the person running away could just have been caught in a bad moment." the second Pi said that, there was a crash behind me.

"I heard a crash up here? What's going on?" Kamui cried, rushing into the lab. Pi gestured the area around us.

"I think you can see for yourself." she sighs.

"Did you catch whoever was running away?"

"Nope. Not a clue of their whereabouts."

While Pi and Kamui talked, I noticed that the beaker of water I had given to Olimar to analyze was missing. I also found a hair on the floor of the room. Normally, the lab is kept completely clean of dust and mess, to avoid experiment corruption.

"Come on, sis. We've gotta figure this out fast." Pi sighs. Nayi crashes into the room just a few seconds later.

"They got away! I don't know how tomatoes!" Nayi cries. I smile as I place the piece of hair in an evidence bag.

"There's no need, Nayi. I know who drenched Palutena."


So, do you know who drenched Palutena in the west wing? The clues are all here, and I believe this was quite an easy mystery. The suspects are Mario, Greninja, Pac Man, Kamui, and Corrin. Let's review the clues:

-Kamui saw very small figures running away. They were smaller than any Smasher.

-Nayi thinks that the small figures running away were Pikmin, so it could be Olimar's doing.

-Palutena beat Kamui and Corrin in a battle last week.

-Palutena more recently beat Mario.

-Mario's F.L.U.D.D. has been broken all day, according to Luigi.

-Mario noticed that Pac-Man has been secretive lately.

-Corrin and Kamui heard Palutena scream, and then found her drenched in the hall.

-Kamui thinks that the cherry points to Pac Man.

-Olimar's Pikmin have been nowhere near the west wing all day. Therefore, Corrin and Kamui were lying.

-Greninja saw Pac-Man near the west wing earlier today.

-Greninja's water attacks don't have enough range to cover the whole west wing stairwell.

-Pac-Man overheard Corrin and Kamui talking about Palutena earlier today.

-Someone tall was running away from the lab when Nyan, Pi, and Nayi got there.

-Pi theorized that Olimar could just be staging the whole thing to get rid of the vial, and the person running away could just have been in the vicinity.

-The beaker of water Nyan gave to Olimar to analyze was missing.

-Nyan found a hair on the floor of the room.

Figured it out yet? I sure hope you did! It's probably pretty easy! Now then, on to the reveal!


"Hey Kamui, where's Corrin?" Nayi asks her. Kamui shrugs.

"No clue. Why?" she asks. I roll my eyes and step up to her.

"Because you did this, didn't you. After all, you and Corrin are known to be salty about losing battles." I accused her. Kamui backed up, acting confused.

"Whoa, whoa, no we didn-"

"For the record, we didn't tell anyone about the person running away yet! But you still knew about it. Corrin was running away after stealing the beaker, right? Plus, you're both pretty tall." I explained. Nayi snapped her fingers.

"Oh yeah sugar cookies! Also, you and Corrin have been plotting this for days, huh? Pac-Man heard you talking about Palutena, and also, you were lying about seeing the small figures. Furthermore, when we found Palutena, Kamui was transforming out of her dragon form!" Nayi added.

"Also, when Nyan found that hair, it basically eliminates Pac-Man, Greninja, and Olimar from the list. You, Corrin, and Mario do have hair. But Mario is shorter than the both of you- therefore, he doesn't match the description." Pi analyzed.

Kamui took a step back. She knew she was defeated.

When we presented our evidence to Master Hand, he charged Corrin and Kamui with cleaning the West Wing after he let the Koopa Kids loose in there.


AAAAAAAAAAGGGGGGHHHHH THIS TEMMIE IS SO SORRY FOR GETTING THIS TO YOU LIKE THREE MONTHS LATE! But I've just had a super packed summer and I'm ready to continue with writing! I hope I'll be faster at writing next chapter! Also, this was one of my worse mysteries. I'm sorry TAT

So thank you guys so much for watching, and me, NyanToDaMax145, will see you guys next time! BOOOOOIIIIII!