Author's note: Hey guys! thanks so much for favoriting and following my story! I love getting notifications about someone new taking interest in this story. I would love for you guys to tell me what do you think about it so far. I am going somewhere else with this story, taking bits and pieces from the show to add in my story. Anyhoo, I'll try to write chapter 22 soon but the boxes won't do themselves as I am moving in three weeks.

Enjoy ;)

Chapter 21

Both Hailey and Sam spent the last week researching a way to find Lilith. At first Hailey was against the idea, saying she didn't care about the first demon, all she wanted was to get Dean back, after they could work on finding the bitch that sent him to hell, but Sam told her she was their best shot at retrieving his brother. After even more debating she realised Sam wasn't going to change his mind and if they wanted results, they had a better chance working together. Bobby was finally coming back home, relieved by the news of Sam being home.

Hey Garth, what's up? Hailey answered the phone, while Sam desperately looking for a lead on Lilith.

(...) Sounds like a shifter to me. (...) Silver usually does the trick, aim for the heart or you can just chop off the head. (...) Yeah your welcome- (...) Maybe some other time Garth... Kinda have my hands full here... (...) alright talk to you soon, stay safe. (...) bye!

Garth? Asked Sam an eyebrow raised.

Yeah, side hunter, turned fulltime hunter. I think that's the fourth time I turn the poor bastard down. Guy can't take a hint...

Sam laughed before going back to his Pc. His smiled soon vanish as the computer got all his attention.

I think I got something. He said and Hailey quickly got to him, looking at the laptop.

Unexplained disappearances in Kamas, Utah. Residence are worried a wild animal is roaming the streets... Hailey read from the article.

Yeah, says here they found three dead bodies with broken necks and their hearts ripped out. The missing person count is up to twelve in the past week. Sam resumed for her.

Could be an actual wild animal...

Could be Lilith. We know the Colt didn't work, but I'm betting the demon blade will. She might be the first demon but she's still, a demon.

We make her release Dean then we kill her. He said as if it was the most evident thing ever.

Hailey didn't like the vague plan at all. But if it was their best shot of getting back the man she loved, she was all in.

Alright dad should be home soon enough, let's pack and once he's here, we'll go.

Bobby pulled in the drive way and saw Hailey throw a duffle bag in her car.

Balls... he said to himself as he parked the car.

He got out and walked over to his daughter.

What's all this? He asked gesturing to the opened trunk.

Hey dad! How was the hunt? Hailey asked, shoving her hand in her back pockets.

Answer the damn question.

Sammy thinks we might have a lead on Lilith... We're going to check it out... Hailey explained looking at her feet as Sam came out of the house.

Hey Bobby-

A word. Now. He told Sam as he walked inside the house

Sam nodded and without a word followed the elder hunter. Hailey rolled her eyes and checked her weaponry, making sure she didn't forget anything. Sam found Bobby in the kitchen.

Listen son, I get the whole revenge thing, trust me I do. But it won't bring him back. Maybe it's time you guys-

Give up?! Bobby he's my brother.

And that's my daughter! Look, we've all lost Dean, son. Doesn't mean we have to go on suicide missions to get stupid revenge-

This isn't about revenge. Bobby, she's the only one who can give him back to me... to Hailey. Tell me your okay knowing that Dean's in hell.

Of course I'm not okay with it... But it doesn't mean I'll let you put Hailey in the crossfire. What's your great plan anyway?

Get Lilith to release Dean's soul then, kill the bitch.

And how do you plan on convincing her to do that?

With this. Sam pulled out the carved demon knife.

With that!? You think you'll get close enough to actually use it? Over my dead- Bobby was cut off by Sam's right hook punch, knocking the hunter out cold.

Sorry Bobby... Sam said softly rubbing his knuckles before grabbing the last bag on the table and walking out.

How did it go? Hailey asked as Sam walked to her side.

Can't say he's thrilled about it. But it's our only shot. I thought we'd take the Impala? Sam quickly changed the subject.

Doesn't seem right to take Baby... Hailey explained softly, pain showing on her face.

Right. Okay, let's go. Sam said putting his bag in the trunk, closing it and sat in the passenger seat. Hailey looked back at the house, knowing if she'd say goodbye to her father he would just try to convince her to stay so she decided to avoid a fight and got inside Beauty, starting the engine and pulled into the road, heading to their only lead, Kamas, Utah.

They made it to Utah, Kamas in 13 hours, they decided to drive straight there, grab some food and settle into a motel for the night. Hailey was eating her burger and sipping her coke when she noticed Sam pull out a couple of spell ingredients and lay them on the table in front of her.

What's that? Hailey asked, her mouth full.

An energy spell, If Lilith is really here, I'll be able to pin point her location and she might not see us coming so-

Woah, woah, woah, back up... what? Sam we don't know what she's up to or what we'll be walking into... Let's investigate the case first, then-

We don't have time! Look, Hailey, I lied before, I keep tracking her down but as soon as I get where she's supposed to be... She's gone. We need to act fast. Now.

Sammy, I'm all for shooting first and asking questions later, but, but this is Lilith we're dealing with. If we want a chance at this, we have to do things right.

How long do you think Dean's soul will have before it's turned into a demon Hails? It's been two almost months already.

I know how long it has been Sam. But I'm not sure Dean would want us to-

Dean isn't here! And if we wait any longer it might be too late. You want to sit this one out? Fine by me, but I'm doing this spell and as soon as it tells me where she is I'm out that door, with or without you.

Hailey had to admit, Sam was scaring her. Usually he was the reasonable one of the gang. Now he was ready to jump in god knows what to have his change to bring his brother back. She had been reckless herself the past couple of weeks, but having a faceoff with Lilith hoping for a shot to scare her enough with the blade so she would release dean's soul, seemed too risky, even for her. But she knew that look Sam was giving her. He wasn't going to change his mind on this. She remembered Dean asking her to look out for Sam. She couldn't let him go by himself.

Okay, I'm in.

Once Sam did the spell all there was left on the map of the city of Kamas was a building in an old industrial area. They arrived to the old abandon workshop, getting out of the mustang and opened the trunk to retrieve their weapons. A wave a nausea past through Hailey as she grabbed onto her car for support.

Hey, hey, Hails... you okay? Sam asked as he rushed by her side, worried.

I got a bad feeling about this Sammy... Hailey confessed.

It's our shot Hails... I can't back down, not now.

I know, just... gimme a sec. Hailey said before taking a couple of deep breaths.

Okay, let's do this. Hailey said pushing her nausea away.

They both grabbed their weapons and closed the trunk. As they walked cautiously to the abandon building they both felt the air change around them. They stopped and shared a worried look. A blinding white light appeared from inside the workshop and it seemed to explode and both were thrown away by a blast, Sam landed on the mustang's windshield, smashing it. The light was gone as fast as it appeared. Sam struggled to get out of the windshield, but finally managed to pull himself out of it.

Hailey! Hailey! He yelled as he scanned around him, looking for Hailey but she was nowhere in sight. He ran around the car but she wasn't there.

No... He whispered to himself before running in the building.

As he entered, the smell of sulfur was so strong. He started choking on it, before he noticed a dozen of dead bodies on the concrete floor. They were still smoking. the odor was making Sam gag. He approached one and noticed his eyes seemed to have been burnt off leaving smoky holes were they should be. They were all the same. Lilith was nowhere in sight. Sam ran back outside, throwing up vomit as he knees gave out.

Hailey! He screamed out to the empty parking lot.