AN: apologies for the delay! RL can be a needy mistress.
Away over there you'd follow me, if you loved me! There you'd not be dependent on anyone...The open sky, the wandering life, the whole wide world your domain; for law your own free will, and above all, that intoxicating thing: Freedom! Freedom! - Carmen, Bizet
-o-
- Chapter 15 -
-o-
The next morning Christine woke up with a new sense of purpose. She had heard him speak her name while in the midst of passion. There was no denying it. He wanted her too... She'd just have to show him that his advances would not be ignored.
When Erik saw Christine the next morning, he smiled at her as if nothing was different. "Good morning, I trust that you slept well?" He asked, poking his head into her room nearly first thing that morning.
She smiled sleepily at him. "I did, thank you teacher." her voice was thick and husky from sleep.
He entered the room, as he set out another dress for her; elegant, fitting perfectly. "I'll let you dress," He said, moving to leave as he watched her once more. "We will continue your lessons today."
She smiled and nodded. When she rose to dress, she pouted a bit when she saw the garment. It was a beautiful brown with gold highlights, but the cuffs were long and the neckline pinched right below her chin.
She counteracted this by not bothering this time with a corset and left her hair down in a wild wave. Walking into the main cavern, she approached him like a good student, and stood waiting, hands folded in front of her.
Erik watched her as she approached. She looked different, the dress laying differently on her; her hair wild and falling free about him. Narrowing his gaze, he began to play the intro to her warm ups, taking her through them.
She stood close to his side as he played. his shoulder would be about the height of her breasts. Were she to bend even a bit, she would be able to brush her chest against him.
Erik turned and he would notice her breasts brushing against him. She was so close, he could smell her, and it was an intoxicating scent. They sang, going through exercise after exercise, a low tension coursing through them.
Slowly, she felt the strength of her lungs return. The feeling of power, of strength in her body.
Erik paused in the exercises. "This is good. You are returning to where you were; you'll be ready to return in no time...Which I must admit, I will miss as I have been enjoying your company."
She didn't understand what he meant, at first. Then she realized he was talking of returning to the surface. Of course. How silly. Of course she would return. Why did that make her so unhappy then?
Erik gave her the slightest smile as he moved on with more exercises. Finally, they would come to a conclusion. "Well, I think that is great progress for today," he said, seeming a bit distracted. It was her, the thought of her leaving troubling him more than he would like to admit.
However, Christine took his expression as disappointment or disinterest in her, so she began to retreat to her room, emotion full and plain on her face.
Erik watched her retreat then impulsively stopped her. "Christine..I...I was wondering if you would like to have dinner with me?" he asked, his voice surprisingly nervous.
Christine stopped and turned to him with wide eyes. "Of course, teacher. I would be honored."
He smiled at that, nodding. "Good. Then I will see you later for that. I have preparations to make," he informed her.
"I will have a dress for the evening waiting for you here in an hour."
It was the longest few hours of Christine's life. She ran to the hot pool to bathe heavily with scented soap and scrambled to find instruments to put her hair into something proper. By the time she returned from the bath, a dress was waiting for her, far more ornate than the one she wore this morning - and, notably - more low cut. It was a blue you would only see staring into the ocean. Dark lace sleeves ended at her elbow. The neckline was cut in a complimentary square, which pushed her breasts together attractively. The skirt was pleated and voluminous.
Christine paced, she pinched her cheeks to redden them. Finally, after a lifetime, she heard movement outside of her door.
When she opened the door to her bedroom, she found Erik wearing a formal tuxedo and his hair immaculately combed. The stark white of his mask stood out like an intentional ornament. His presentation was both effortless and formal. Christine nearly melted.
He turned to face her directly and offered her a gloved hand, with which he drew her to him with. The glove seemed to make it easier to touch her; less afraid that she would recoil.
"You look beautiful...Christine," he commented, eyeing her; his gaze sweeping over her form.
"Thank you, teacher. You look very elegant as well." She smiled. Her heart was beating so fast, it was a wonder she could hear through the pounding. Obediently, she followed her teacher through a complex maze of tunnels and canals.
Surprisingly, Christine found herself above ground, outside of the Opera House. No, he had a place for her; and would lead her through the streets of Paris, taking back alleyways and shortcuts to remain in the shadows. Finally, he would lead her to an opulent restaurant, leading her through the back entrance. When they entered, everyone seemed to know exactly who he was and where he was to dine, all greeting him with private nods and knowing smiles. The couple was taken towards a small, private corner, an intimate curtained dining nook, away from the eyes of any prying customers.
Christine had never been in a restaurant so grand! The most she has been in were dingy saloons that attempted affluence but succeeded only in looking gaudy. No, this restaurant with its rich red velvet seats and crisp white tablecloths was completely foreign to her.
She clumsily allowed the martre'd to seat her and she blushed as the man unfolded her napkin and laid it across her lap. Looking down at the table, her eyes widened. So much silverware! How would one possibly know which one to use!
Erik watched her wide eyes take in the silverware options. "Start with the outside, work your way in. That's the simplest way of navigating it," He offered her with a kind smile. Christine blushed even deeper.
A menu was set in front of her and a wine order was made, Erik ordering a white wine to begin with for the appetizers.
Looking at the menu, Christine wanted to ask if it was in another language. She did not understand any of the words on the page! To stall, she took a large sip of sparkling wine and almost choked on it- surprised at the sweetness and carbonation.
"I have not been here before. What would you recommend?" She asked Erik, trying to cover her ignorance
He gave her a slightly knowing look and smiled. "Mlle. Daaé; what are some of your favorite foods? Tell me that and I will make recommendations." The waiter drew the curtains behind him as he left, affording them privacy.
Oh god, Christine was going to die of embarrassment if she kept this up. "I...don't think I've gotten to choose what was to eat since childhood." She still was a child, she thought with a bit of self-deprecation. " When I was still in Sweden, I remember the most delicious fish…" she offered.
"Fish. Of course, he offered with a smile. "There will be a fish course. Do you trust me, Mlle. Daaé?" He asked, watching her with an intriguing look as he took a sip of his wine, holding her gaze.
"Completely," she answered automatically, not shying away from his intense eyes. The air was heady, tense and she felt as if she would drown.
The waiter returned, breaking the tension and refilled her wine without being asked. Christine vowed to find a different stalling tactic and go easier on the alcohol if her glass was going to refill every time she drank from it.
"I will order for you then," he replied and turned to the waiter. It was a multi course, formal meal that he was planning;a dn the conversation that he had with the waiter showed expertise and a well formed palate.
Her entire view of this mysterious man shifted over the night. Instead of the intimidating recluse, she found an intelligent gentleman with exquisite manners
When the appetizers came, she was still so deep in thought over this strange man, she jumped when a plate was put in front of her.
The plate was served to the right, oysters being the first course that was given to her. They were served on the half shell, with a sauce to the right and a lemon for garnish and seasoning. Erik let her take the first bite, curious as to how she enjoyed them.
On the other side of the table, Christine was frozen in place. Was she supposed to use one of the forks? Outside, work your way in. Right. She grabbed the outermost fork to the right of the plate and attempted to stab the flesh of the an oyster. Of course, the rest of the shell came right along with it. It hovered in the air for a moment, then clattered back onto the plate. Christine pursed her lips and looked up to the Phantom. "Pardon me, I'm not very good at this," she admitted with a blush.
Erik picked up his utensils and showed her how she could scoop the oyster from underneath, then put it in his mouth, following it with a sip of wine. "There, like that," he said, watching her.
She followed his lead and successfully the oyster in her mouth. The flavor was tart and rich and more than Christine was used to. She followed it with the wine and even more colors exploded on her tongue. It was phenomenal and she closed her eyes in near ecstasy.
"I think it is time, soon, for you to return. I am excited to see your career flourish, Christine."
Christine's eyes slowly opened when Erik spoke. She tried to keep the emotion -whatever emotion that was- from showing on her face. "You will.. continue to tutor me, yes?" She hoped she didn't sound too pathetically hopeful.
He smiled as he watched her enjoy the oyster. "Yes, of course I will tutor you..I couldn't imagine giving that up," he said a bit more vulnerable than perhaps he would have liked to have let on. "This next season they are to produce La Traviata. I feel that Violetta would be a marvelous role for you."
"La traviata! You think I am ready for such a role?" Her stomach flipped almost as violently as anytime Erik looked at her.
He nodded, grinning. "Of course. If Marguerite fits you so well, it only makes sense that Violetta would be in your wheelhouse. Don't you think so?"
It was such a huge, beloved opera! If she were to botch the role, she would be booed off stage! "I trust your judgement, but I'm a little stunned at your confidence in me. T-thank you, I mean," she fumbled. "It is all due to you that I am here at all."
"That is not entirely true, Christine. Your voice, that is why you are where you are. You have simply allowed me to draw it out of you. If anyone should be grateful for the opportunity, it is me. It is a rare treat that a teacher can work with such a prodigy," he complimented, taking a sip of his wine.
Honestly, how many times could Christine blush in one night! It couldn't be healthy for a young girl!
The soup arrived next and Christine was able to find the correct spoon with no difficulty - it was the only spoon in the line. The soup was cold and strange to her, but she dutifully picked at it. If the amount of utensils were any indication, she would not starve this night and coming across as a glutton would not suit her at all!
The fish was next, with a fresh selection of wine. When it was all laid out on the table, Erik raised his glass in a toast. "To your success..and our partnership."
She raised her new glass of wine and smiled. "Our partnership." She sipped the wine and looked down at the plate of sea bass. "Surströmming!" She exclaimed with surprise. "How on earth-" She stopped and looked up at the handsome man before her. "Thank you," she whispered with emotion.
He had taken a gamble that she would have enjoyed the traditional Swedish dish, and it paid off. It was native to her homeland. As a result, his face lit up; his smile was broad as he soaked in her reaction. "You know this? It was a good choice then, Mlle. Daaé?"
She smiled knowingly at Erik. "It was a staple from my childhood. I've missed this."
"Then I'm glad you enjoy it." As he watched her, taking in her beauty, her grace, the simple joy that she had; he felt his heart stir. Erik knew that having her away from him would be a dreaded day indeed, though return she must to the surface. He took in a slow breath, savoring this moment with her.
"I am going to miss your presence when you return to the surface," he admitted, his gaze dropping slightly.
Christine shrugged inelegantly. "Maybe….we can continue our lessons down here?" Her voice was unsure, tentative. "You are my," she blushed a bit, "patron, after all, at least in name. It would not be...unusual for me to spend nights away from the conservatoire as long as it does not impede rehearsals." Oh god, did she really just say that?
Erik's lips twisted into a slow, approving smile.
Her heart stuttered. Warmth spread throughout her body. He was truly beautiful when he smiled. Instead of groveling at his feet or jumping onto his person like she so desired to, she placed her hands onto her chest, in a gesture of reverence. "Thank you, teacher. You've been so kind to me. You've already done more for me than anyone ever has. You've saved my life."
He held her gaze, nodding subtly. "I do not do these things to impress you. I do these things so that you may know that I care for you...in...many ways." He explained, second guessing himself at the end.
Her mouth opened to respond, but the waiter returned with a salad course, saving them from the awkward conversation.
After the salad, both warm and cold dessert courses were next. It was getting a little ridiculous, but Christine was happy to have something to do other than say something embarrassing to her teacher. Sticking to lighter conversations, Christine spent the rest of the meal enjoying the company as her corset slowly became tighter and tighter.
On Erik's end, he found Christine's conversation to be sparkling, witty, and crystal clear. As the dinner wound on he found himself utterly satisfied, nearly equally with the wonderful food and perfect company. The moment she suggested using his alter ego The Baron as her alibi, he felt as if she had accepted his proposal of marriage. She wanted to be here! He vowed not to do anything rash or thoughtless.
The end of the night was just as lovely as the meal. Christine found herself sad to leave the beautiful restaurant.
As they would stand to leave, he would lead her through alleyways and hidden, secret paths; taking her back all the way to the lair. "Soon you should return, but I will let you chose. Did you wish to spend one final night here before returning home, Mlle. Daaé?"
Oh, how the timber of his voice made her quake. She knew he meant it innocently, but her body reacted as if he asked her straight to his bed!
Blushing furiously, she nodded. "It would be easier to sleep here for the night before returning, I think..."
"Of course...then you can return in the morning. They'll discover you. You'll tell them that you woke up in your apartment, remembering nothing," he explained, turning and walking toward a small cabinet; a crystal decanter filled with brandy and several small crystal glasses sitting on it. He would pour both of them a drink, offering one to her.
"Then let us enjoy tonight. How would you like to spend it?" he asked, taking a sip.
There had been pairings of wine with every meal. She was already light and giddy on her feet, but she accepted the brandy to be polite. "I would like to hear you sing, if I may. "
"Hear me sing?" he asked, surprised at her response as he walked toward an immaculately cleaned, gorgeously designed organ. "Why would you want that?" he asked, sitting at it.
"I have never heard you sing, not truly. But you have the most beautiful voice- please. For me." Christine followed him to the large instrument and stood beside him.
He caressed the keys and played an echoing minor chord, nodding. "Very well, then. Tell me, Mlle. Daaé; what would you like to hear?"
"Anything you sing would be a blessing to witness," she whispered, eyes locked on his fingers caressing the piano keys.
He would interrupt her, smiling. "I have just the piece." He murmured as he began the heavily chromatic opening portion of the aria he was to sing. The tension in it built before settling into a gentle, pleasant, D Flat major key. The general feel of it was haunting coming from an organ.
"La fleur que tu m'avais jetée,
Dans ma prison m'était restée.
Flétrie et séche, cette fleur
Gardait toujours sa douce odeur;"
Translation
"The flower that you had thrown me,
I kept with me in prison.
Withered and dry, the flower
Still kept its sweet smell;"
The Flower Song. Carmen. Don Jose. A song sung to a mocking lover to convince her of his devotion to her. The piece naturally was wrought with desperation, ardency, passion.
The first note that Erik sung echoed off of the stone walls and sent chills down Christine's arms.
Traditionally, the F natural of the "La" was floated; the opening phrasing being lyrical and sweet, allowing for a powerful build through the later chromatically rising sequence. Yet when Erik would sing it, it would be full; present. Commanding. His voice was darker, richer than a traditional lyric tenor. Rather, it would have an edge to his tone; a cut that would easily conquer a larger orchestra. As she listened and inevitably attempted to classify him, she might settle on the larger, more heroic voice; as the Italians might say, a lyrico spinto or even a tenore dramatico's sound. The tone, though dark; was brilliant and pharyngeal, clearly Italianate in nature. This became more apparent as he progressed through the aria.
"Et pendant des heures entiéres,
Sur mes yeux, fermant mes paupières,
De cette odeur je m'enivrais
Et dans la nuit je te voyais!"
Translation:
"And for hours,
On my eyes, my eyelids closed,
I became intoxicated by its fragrance
And in the night I saw you!"
The vocal line rose, and so did his passion. The declamation was true to the intent of the text: passionate, loving, full of desire for her. The first high note of the piece blossomed with a brilliance that captured the adoration of the man who sang it and the man in the opera who he was portraying. The A Flat of the "m'envrais" lept out, hanging in the air only to decrescendo in a tender manner, Erik releasing onto the "Et dans la nuit…"
"Je me prenais à te maudire,
À te détester, à me dire :
Pourquoi faut-il que le destin
L'ait mise là sur mon chemin?"
Translation
"I began to curse you,
and hating you, I began to tell myself:Why should fate put you on my path?"
He sang this with an urgency to his declamation; truly embodying a man who was trying to convince a lover of his devotion swiftly and with no delay. His interpretation hinted at the agony and torment that he was about to express.
"Puis je m'accusais de blasphème,
Et je ne sentais en moi-même,
Je ne sentais qu'un seul déisr,
Un seul désir, un seul espoir:
Te revoir, ô Carmen, ou,
te revoir!"
Translation
"Then I accused myself of blasphemy,
And I felt within myself,
I only felt but one desire,
One desire, one hope:
To see you again, Carmen, oh,
you again!"
The chromatic ascending vocal line gave Erik the vehicle he needed for his interpretation. What began as a soft but intense singing would grow in intensity. In a moment of virtuosic showing, Erik swelled the organ with his line, the tension through "Un seul désir, un seul espoir:" anxiety inducing before it finally released, the high A-flat of "Te revoir" ringing and reverberating off of the cavernous interior.
"Car tu n'avais eu qu'à paraître,
Qu'a jeter un regard sur moin
Pour t'emperer de tout mon être,
Ô ma Carmen!
Et j'étais une chose à toi
Carmen, je t'aime!"
Translation:
"For all you needed was to be there,
to share one glance with you
To long for you with all my being,
O my Carmen
And I was yours
Carmen, I love you!"
The line would descend, each high note explosive, only to retreat. It was as if the corporal had finally gotten out of his head and was thinking with clear, honest, fearless, devotion for her.
The final phrase was taken traditionally, which might have shocked her. For someone who had taken such a demanding interpretation of the aria, the ending was tender and floated. The final High B-Flat of "je t'aime!" was tender, floated; the high pinging sound filling the cavern.
Erik finished the piece looking straight at - almost through - Christine. He had chosen a song sung by a man desperate to show her how much he loved her on the eve of him leaving her.
One could only hope that the ending would be far less lethal, Christine thought.
"Why Don Jose?" She could only ask in a soft voice that displayed her awe. He'd be able to hypnotize her completely if he tried!
He rose from his organ console, turning to face her, reaching for his brandy and taking a sip as he explained, "In order to understand Don Jose, one must realize that the man has a past; he has a history. One does not join the Légion étrangère without reason. The man knows trauma; he knows longing and pain. As a result, the singer must understand true desire; he must have walked that thin edge of control before. Simply putting it, the singer must be as dangerous as the character. And he must know true longing."
She didn't see how that answered her question at all, but she could tell what he was saying, whatever it meant, was important to him.
He looked down, searching for more free, honest words to describe. "I guess what I was trying to say is that there is no way to sing that final phrase without truly meaning it. You don't have to love your Carmen, but there must be a Carmen in your life for you to love with such fearless abandon. I don't believe there has been a tenor who has sang that convincingly who didn't feel such emotions himself."
"Ah," Christine commented with her eyes averted. Her face was flushed - such a common occurrence when around this man! - and her mind worked to analyze his words. Was he...expressing his love? To her? To someone else? Was he just making a point or did his words hold some deeper meaning? She decided there was only one way to find out.
Christine took to the age-old teenage habit of jumping in head first.
She looked up to his face, catching his golden eyes. "And must the Carmen have such a love?" she whispered.
He gave her a sad smile. "The tragedy of the story is that Carmen's true love is freedom. She loves that more than anything else. Unfortunately for her, José is a dangerous man who's love borderlines on obsessive. Nothing but complete devotion to him will satisfy him, and that leads to tragedy in the final act."
Christine swallowed her fear and stepped even closer to him. She didn't think she had ever willingly been this close to a man before, let alone her teacher! She was so close, she had to crank her neck to look at his face and clench her fists to keep from reaching out and touching him.
"But is Carmen not lost in the passion herself? Perhaps it is a different intensity of affection, but she is pulled by him as well, is she not?"
"She is," he said, meeting her gaze, pulled in by the conversation. The fact that it was about a field that he was so passionate about made him light up, not realizing in that moment just how close his muse was.
"She obsessed over him, as well, in a public setting. The wonderful quintet in act two. She publicly declares, much to the frustration of her renegade compatriots, that she is in love like never before, and that she simply cannot join them on their latest scheme." As he finished that, he paused, realizing then just how close she was. He grew stiff, almost rigid, afraid to let his muscles reach or touch or even explore the space around him. "That passion, along with his, led to tragedy," he reminded, the tone more for himself than her.
"But without it, there wouldn't be an opera at all," Christine said softly. Intimately. She was growing bolder, finding her courage. Almost imperceptibly, she leaned in closer to him.
"Art is always worth making, even when the ending of the story is not what you would hope it to be," he replied to her, fixing his gaze on hers. She was so close; he could smell her. She naturally smelled like rose, and that floral tone intoxicated him. He was hardly breathing, terrified that even too strong an inhalation would make him brush against her skin and ruin the illusion that she was not close to a wretched, walking corpse.
"Yes. It's worth all of this," she breathed. She licked her lips nervously. One second passed before she struck like a waiting viper.
The kiss was chaste but eager. Lasting only a moment, she pulled back before he could react and blushed furiously, keeping her eyes down to her shoes. She bit her lip, waiting for his response.
Erik was frozen. She had just kissed him. Christine would be able to feel every muscle in his body go rigid.. This woman to whom he had no right to claim someone as charming and beautiful and clever as him had just kissed him. His mind was flooded, and he found that he could only simply utter her name in response. "Christine.."
When Erik leaned his body toward her, she immediately responded in kind. She stepped forward to close what little distance where was left between them and practically attacked his lips with her own. Her arms flew up and she reached to grab both sides of his head to deepen the kiss. Unfortunately, her left hand knocked his mask off kilter, shifting it so it was already halfway off of his face.
Time stood still.
She tried to reach for his mask? Did she? The little mynx! To get him to this moment, only to try and reveal his identity. Erik snapped and a hand shot up, full of all the tension that had been coursing through him before that point. "What...do you think you are doing?" His voice was pained, his grip on her hand hard and unrelenting as he turned his face away from her.
Christine gasped loudly as she felt the iron grip on her wrist pull her away from him. She watched him quickly adjust his mask. "I- I- I'm sorry!" she cried, not understanding what had set him off. She cried out as he shook her by the wrist painfully. "I'm sorry!" she repeated with tears thick in her throat.
"Was it your intent this entire time to humiliate me? To give me hope for your affection only to reveal my wickedness and cast me away?" He snarled at her, that once tender gaze now turning vicious and spiteful. He would release her hand, shoving it away from him, taking a step back. "Tell me now! Was that your game all along!?"
"I- no! I mean, yes I wanted to… but… oh God, I'm so sorry!" Christine stumbled back, mortified at how terribly wrong this all went. She shrunk back from his anger and quickly wiped the tears from her cheeks.
"Your sorrow matters little in this moment. What you did..the betrayal..." He turned away to more securely fasten the mask.
In those fleeting moments of him turning, Christine saw a glimpse of a face that was disfigured beyond comfortable conversation. Burn marks, perhaps, or illness. Those cheekbones that should have been made for an actor proved a merciless landscape that too little skin stretched agonizingly across. The skin was angry, raw, with open sores from where the mask constantly rubbed. He had suffered greatly, and suffered still.
"I didn't mean to-" she tried to get out, but he wouldn't let her finish.
"Why would I believe that for a second?" Rage was coursing through him, preventing him from thinking clearly.
Christine's whole body shook as she backed away from him. It wasn't fear, not really, but seeing Erik this upset made her chest burn.
"Because I… I just wanted to…I'm sorry!" She turned and ran from him, upset and ashamed of the pain she had so unwittingly and yet so easily caused him. She locked herself in her room and threw herself on the bed, curling in on herself and weeping loudly.
After Christine had locked herself in her room, Erik began to cool. He fixed the mask back into place and paced like a caged animal, unsure of what to do with himself.
No. This was the inevitable ending of things. She would, one way or another, discover who he truly was. When she discovered that, how could she be able to look at him the same way, just knowing what a monster he was? He stepped toward her door; resting one hand on it, not daring to allow himself to get any closer to this muse which he had no business claiming. And there he stayed.
Christine could feel him on the other side of the door. With as much courage as she could muster, she rose and walked to the room's entrance and unlocked the door, pushing it open to reveal the striking form of The Phantom, basked in shadows. His cat eyes nearly glowed as he looked upon her.
"I believe it is time to leave, Mlle. Daae. I will show you how to return to the surface safely." With that, he turned and walked away, leaving Christine to gather her things.
She could not discern what he was thinking or feeling through his stoic expression and expressionless voice. She had the horrible feeling that she had completely shattered their relationship and that nothing would be the same ever again.
Christine continued crying softly as she hugged her bag of fine dresses and accessories that had been gifted to her. The Phantom did not speak to her again as he lead her back through dark tunnels, trick walls, and even a black lake, still and cold as the dead.
She was left alone on the other side of her dressing room's mirror where she collapsed and let out an anguished, sorrowful scream.
The trip back had been agonizingly long for Erik. Still, this is what must happen. It was for her own good, her own safety. The feelings that he was feeling for her..It was enough to give her the opportunity to see him as he truly was. No, this was for the best: Isolation for him. A career for her. Because, damn it, no matter how hard he tried, he knew that he would never let her go, that her voice would forever ring in her ear.
As Christine sobbed on the other side of the mirror, so did he on the opposite side, sinking down, losing himself. He pulled the mask off of his face, sobbing as he gazed down at the porcelain prison that he wore. In a moment of rage he roared, smashing it to the ground before standing and stalking back to his lair.
