Thanks to Barry's last thought before he fell asleep his dreams were filled with Spencer. It was innocent little things like going on a picnic. Holding hands in the park and pushing each other on a swing set. In one of the dreams Barry even told Spencer about his powers. The dreams were good, but they were more of what someone with a crush would think about. It may have been better if it was a sex dream because when Barry woke up he realized he was developing a crush on the genius.

It wasn't some simple desire to sleep with the guy. No, Barry wanted to be with him and actually go on dates. Never before had Barry desired a man. Sure he had seen an attractive guy or two, but it wasn't like that then. Eddie was a good looking guy, but that was just a general assessment. Spencer… it was different. Barry could actually see him being intimate with the guy. Kissing and holding hands. Things that Barry would be too scared to admit to anyone.

Spencer was an insanely intelligent guy though. Sooner or later he would figure it out and then what would happen? Barry thought back on that time they had dinner with Iris and Eddie. Eddie had thought the two of them were together which meant somehow Barry had come off as gay and so had Spencer. Thinking about it now it really didn't bother Barry because surprise! He was kinda gay. Spencer himself had shrugged it off as no big deal. Barry wondered why that was.

Barry jumped when a loud knock interrupted his thoughts. "Hey Barry, I made breakfast. You should get dressed quickly so we can finish and go." Footsteps signal Spencer had left. Barry sighs and gets up. He quickly changes and heads out. Spencer was at the kitchen table looking cute as fuck which didn't help Barry. A box of cereal and two bowls were on the table. "Oh you shouldn't have! You didn't have to cook for me!" Barry was grinning as he took the seat opposite Spencer.

Spencer's lips twitch into a small smile "I didn't want to take the time to cook. I figured you'd want to get started as quickly as possible." Barry nods and grabs for the box of cereal. It was simple Cheerios. The two eat quickly and head out. Barry noticed Spencer was acting a little stranger to normal too. Maybe he had already figured out how Barry felt about him… he was a genius… it was possible. Barry had to push his thoughts out of his head when Spencer pulled in front of a large blue and white house.

"Ready?" Spencer asks as he puts his car into park. Barry nods and slides out. All thoughts of Spencer in a romantic way get pushed to the back of his mine. This was more important than that. Spencer took charge and knocked on the door. Mrs. Eldora answered looking worn out and depressed. "May I help you?" She asks in an equally tired tone. "Yes, we are with the BAU" he flashes his badge "My name is Spencer Reid and this is Barry Allen" He gestures to me "There was a recent kidnapping that we have reason to believe connects to your daughter's kidnapping. May we come in?"

She nods and steps to the side. Her eyes are red and she looks like she had been crying. "Excuse the mess Mr. Allen" She leads the way to the living room. "My Husband just recently divorced me, so I am in the middle of moving out." She gives a weak smile as she sinks into a chair. "Ms. Eldora… do you mind if we ask why he asked for a divorce?" She sighs and picks up a nearby picture. "When Susie was kidnapped our marriage fell apart. With each year that went by we would fall further apart. I guess it just got too much."

She sets the picture back down "This recent kidnapping… it could be connected?" Spencer speaks up "The evidence leads to it, yes. I know this is a difficult time to rehash the details of your daughter's kidnapping…" She cuts him off with a raised hand "I already told the FBI that I would do anything to help the investigation. It may have been a few years ago, but that will remain true. What is it you need?"

They go over the folder, only the points they were allowed to bring up. There was one new piece of information. The lily could have an important meaning. A few years after Susie's case was deemed a cold one the Eldoras decided to try and adopt. To offer their empty home to a child who needed it. The adoption center they went to was called Lily Christian Center.

JJ and Emily had gone to the second family to ask questions and gain any new information on the kidnapping. Spencer and Barry went to check out the adoption agency. They really didn't know how it connected yet. The lady at the desk in the front was reluctant to help, but once Spencer flashed his badge she called in the manager. The manager was rather helpful for the case. He kept records of every adoption or possible adopter. Mr. Eldora had adopted a little baby girl in his 20's. Her name was Lily.

Spencer called Garcia and she worked her magic. It took some time for her to get into the file, but sure enough when Mr. Eldora was 24 he adopted a baby girl. She was only a few months old when he brought her home. Her name was Lily Eldora. When she was 8 she was kidnapped and after a week was found in a cow pasture. She had died from exposure. Nothing popped up during their first investigation because the file had been locked and hidden. There was never any connection to it anyway because Mr. Eldora never told anyone about it. His background search never showed the previous adoption which meant someone had scrubbed it off his file.

Mrs. Eldora probably never knew about the adoption. Spencer hangs up and explains his findings to Barry. "Looks like we have a suspect" Barry says and Spencer agrees. There wasn't any real connection to the other families. Mr. Eldora was reliving his daughter Lily's death. That was Spencer's theory and it was a decent one. Barry called Joe and asked him to look into Mr. Eldora and see if he moved down there. Next the two went back to the bureau to gather up teams. They searched every cow field in a 50 mile radius of the Edora's house and the adoption agency.

One team found an abandoned cow field. There was a large barn that had obviously been rebuilt and taken care of. Inside Susie was trapped in a small room that had been locked. She was dirty and looked like she hadn't eaten in days. She was no longer 8 years old. She was almost 12 and she was obviously shaken up. It was a miracle she was still alive. She shrunk away when anyone came close to her. Everyone except JJ. Something about her voice calmed the little girl. Susie clung to JJ and allowed her to take her to the ambulance. She was checked out and was given an IV by a female responder. JJ stayed by her to make sure she wasn't left alone.

The team had continued to look, but the rest of the barn was empty. Hotch considered the idea that maybe the other girl hadn't survived, but Spencer thought different. If Mr. Eldora kept Susie alive than he was probably incapable of killing the other two. Alice and Millie were most likely still alive.