Cabin Fever
"Are you doing okay, Nick?"
Nick looked over at Jess with slightly sad eyes. Angie had left pretty abruptly after Nick expressed that he had actual feelings for her and that he wanted something more serious. Jess didn't hear the entire conversation, not wanting to intrude but through the slightly open door she did catch a bit of their conversation. It was basically just Angie telling Nick that she was "Sorry" that she's "not ready for the kind of thing". He hadn't said much in response by what she could hear, but the sound of his defeated sigh as he told her to leave still broke Jess's heart.
"You know what Jess? I think it was actually for best. She didn't want anything serious and thinking about it, she's really not the type of person I'd want to build a life with anyway."
Jess grabbed his hand, squeezing a little and smiled at him. "I'm proud of you, Nick." He returned her smile and squeezed her hand before dropping back down to the couch. Sam returned from the bathroom holding a giant bottle of Tequila.
"Well, Nick. You've had a pretty rough night, what do you say we get drunk and forget?"
It was now an hour later, all three of them were considerably drunk, sitting on the couch with Jess in the middle of the two men. All three of them laughing and talking about pretty much anything and everything. Jess looked over at Nick, the big smile on his face making her heart speed up in her chest. Seeing him smile, like really smile, always did weird things to her insides, she had always convinced herself that it was just because he never really smiled much, but lately it was getting more difficult to convince herself. He really was attractive, like really, really attractive.
Jess was broken from her Nick-trance by the feel of Sam's hand on her thigh, she looked over at him and could see the arousal in his eyes. He leaned in and kissed Jess deeply as he continued to caress her thigh, going a little higher each time. Jess felt a shift on the couch as Nick rose up, ready to leave the room, she heard him mutter "Well, that's my queue… Night guys."
Jess broke away from sam and grabbed Nick's arm before he could walk away, she tugged on his arm, making him sit back down next to her.
"I want you to stay, Nick."
"Um… Jess, I'm not really into the whole Voyeur thing…"
Jess looked over at Sam, she leaned in and whispered in his ear. "I want him to join, Sam… Are you okay with that?" Jess had expressed to Sam that she might be interested in having a threesome, she had always thought it would happen with another woman if it ever did happen, but the thought of having these two men, mostly Nick, all over her was making her seriously aroused. Sam smiled and nodded, to Jess's relief. She wasn't really sure how suggesting a threesome with another man would go over with her boyfriend, but apparently he was into it.
Jess looked over at Nick, who was staring at the floor, his brows furrowed together and he was deep in thought. She looked at his hands, he was rubbing his thumbs back and forth across his pointer fingers, something he always does when he's nervous. She grabbed his hand and he finally looked up at her. She could see his want for her in his eyes.
"What do you think, Nick? You wanna join me and this lovely lady in our bedroom?"
Nick never took his eyes off of Jess as Sam spoke. "Yes, let's do it." Jess smiled at him before rising to her feet, she grabbed both Sam and Nick by the hand and led them upstairs to the bedroom. Once they entered the bedroom, Jess tugged on Nick's hand, pulling him back towards her. She dropped his hand and placed both of her hands on his chest. She watched his dark eyes become even darker as he grabbed her by the hips, pulling her into him before crashing his lips against hers and okay, wow. Turns out, Nick is an amazing kisser.
Jess felt Sam come up behind them, he pulled her hair aside before attacking her neck with his lips, kissing, licking and sucking her skin. He reached around and grabbed her breasts, molding them in his bigs hands, making her whimper into Nick's amazing mouth. Nick's hands dropped from hips to her ass and squeezed gently. Nick was much gentler than Sam, but the sensations she's receiving from the both of them is almost too much.
Jess breaks away from both men, and moves over towards the bed. They both move to follow. "No, wait there." They both freeze and watch her with wide eyes as she starts to slip of her boots before starting on her pants. She unbuttons her pants and turns away from both men, while she pulls them down. Giving them both a fantastic view of her bare ass, split by the lacy blue thong she's wearing.
Jess is trying to give both men equal attention, but she finds that she can't take her eyes off of Nick. The look on his face as she slowly reveals her body to him is amazing. Sam always complimented her and told her she had a great body, but he had never looked at her the way Nick was right now, like he had never seen something so incredible in his life.
Jess turned back towards them, only glancing at Sam as her eyes locked with Nick's once more. She slowly started to unbutton her checkered shirt revealing her matching lacy blue bra, loving the way Nick's eyes widened as she pushed the shirt off her shoulders to the floor, revealing her creamy bra clad breasts to his hungry gaze.
She felt a shiver run down her spine as she watched him lick his lips. "Wow, Jess… Your body is… Wow" Jess smiled sweetly at Nick before looking over at Sam. "You already know how I feel about that body, Babe." Jess felt a pang of disappointment that she didn't have the same affect on her boyfriend that she did on Nick, but as she looked back over to Nick, the awed look on his face as he continued to take in her almost naked body made her forget instantly.
"Okay, Boys. It's your turn. You've seen mine, now I wanna see yours."
This was obviously mostly directed towards Nick, as she has seen Sam naked many times, in many different positions. She had to suppress her laughter as she watched both men fumble with their clothing, trying to get undressed as quickly as possible.
Finally they were both down to just their underwear, she looked over at Sam and let her eyes drop down to his clearly visible erection protruding violently from his black boxer briefs. She looked back up into his eyes and smiled before setting her sights on Nick. He was rubbing his forehead, clearly feeling a little self conscious standing next to Sam. She let her eyes drop down, noting that he was not as aroused as Sam, due to nerves she guessed.
She really hated that Nick was always so hard on himself, never thinking himself worthy of well… anything really. Obviously what happened with Angie earlier tonight and the way Schmidt always ragged on him about his body didn't help at all. It made Jess's heart ache for him.
Wanting nothing more than to make him feel comfortable, Jess slowly walked up to Nick and pulled his hand from his face, she smiled up at before leaning up to kiss him and as she broke the kiss she smiled at him once more before taking his hand in hers, she turned towards Sam and did the same, leading them both towards the bed. She dropped down on the bed, rising up on her knees bringing both men down with her, she alternated between kissing the two as they both ran their hands all over her body.
"What do you want, Jess? Do you want Nick to taste that sweet little pussy?"
Jess moaned loudly as Sam spoke and she felt Nick's lips against her neck. "What do you think, Jess? Do you want me to taste you?" The way he spoke against her neck, all low and gravelly made her cry out. "Yes!"
Sam leaned back against the pillows on the bed and pulled Jess between his legs, her back pressed against his chest. He reached behind her back and unsnapped her bra, revealing Jess's naked breasts to Nick for the first time. She watched as Nick's pupils dilated before he leaned in to take one of her hard nipples into his mouth while Sam kneaded the other. She arched her back, feeling Sam's erection digging into her lower back.
She locked eyes with Nick as his attention went lower, running his lips from her breast down her flat stomach before reaching the waistband of her thong, he ran his lips along the skin just above the elastic before placing his fingers inside and sliding it down her legs, revealing her bare pussy to him. He smiled up at her wickedly before grabbing her legs, pulling her down the bed and spreading her legs making her gasp.
He slowly kissed his way up her thighs towards her center, moving back and forth between her legs, making her squirm. Finally he reached her pussy and kissed it tenderly before burying his tongue in her folds. "NICK! Oh my… UH!" Jess could no longer form words with Nick's amazing mouth on her. How was he so good at this? Sam began to gently pinch her nipples as she dug her nails into his legs that were on either side of her, thrashing around against his chest.
"How does it feel, Jess? Does Nick's tongue feel good?"
"Yes, oh my god…. YES!"
Jess felt her sudden orgasm rip through her body as Nick continued to lick and swirl his tongue on her clit. She cried out loudly, digging her fingers in his soft hair. As her body calmed from the intense pleasure Nick had just given her, she could no longer control her actions. Completely ignoring Sam, she pushed Nick down on the bed and straddled his body, kissing him wildly while rubbing her naked body against him, hearing him groan loudly into her mouth as his big, warm hands explored her body.
She broke the kiss with a pop and looked deeply into his dark eyes, she smiled sweetly at him before lowering her mouth to his chest, she ran her fingers through the hair on chest as she kissed her way down to his boxers, as she reached them she pulled her head back and her eyes widened in excitement as she took in his size. Damn… It was big. Bigger than Sam, not by too much, but definitely bigger.
She dug her fingers into his boxers and pulled them from his body, watching his cock spring free she licked her lips and took him in her mouth, watching as his eyes rolled into the back of his head. He buried his hand in her chocolate curls and moaned loudly from the pleasure she was giving him. "FUCK, Jess! That feels amazing."
Jess had almost forgotten about Sam until she felt his hands on her hips, pulling her up onto her hands and knees, she felt him run his hard cock along the lips of her dripping pussy. She moaned and took Nick's cock even deeper in her throat, hearing him whimper.
She could faintly hear the sound of Sam opening a condom behind her before she felt his cock against her again, he roughly stuffed himself inside of her, causing her to fall forward and almost choke on Nick's penis which was still very much down her throat. She let him fall from her mouth to catch her breath, coughing a little.
Nick looked down at her and cupped her cheek as Sam continued to fuck her roughly from behind. "Are you okay, sweetheart?" She felt her heart do flips in her chest as Nick spoke those tender words, concern flashing across his features. Although she was being roughly taken from behind by another man, she found that Nick held most of her attention. She smiled at him before taking him in her mouth again.
She let this go on for a while, going out of her mind with the feeling of being fucked from behind while pleasuring Nick with her mouth. She opened her eyes and looked up to see Nick looking down at her and something inside of her snapped. Without a second thought about Sam, She sat up and crawled over Nick's body, feeling Sam fall from her core. She took Nick's hands in her and laced her fingers through his and lowered herself down onto him, throwing her head back in pure ecstasy as he filled her so completely.
"Oh my god, Jess. You're so tight and wet… FUCK!"
She started riding him, keeping her eyes locked with his. She heard Sam speak behind her, saying something about needing some attention too, but she really didn't care. She wanted Nick. No one had ever felt better than he does inside of her, she had never felt the type of connection with anyone that she was feeling with Nick. She was always far too self conscious when it came to eye contact during sex, but with Nick she found that she couldn't take her eyes off of him.
She felt Sam come up behind her, grabbing at her breasts with one hand and using his other to rub his cock along her ass. "I'm gonna fuck you in the ass while Nick is inside your pussy. How do you feel about that?" Jess stopped riding Nick, shocked by what Sam had just suggested as he continued to rub his cock against her puckered hole.
Nick must have seen the apprehension in her eyes and he sat up, taking her face in his hands, looking deeply into her eyes. "Jess, you don't have to do anything you're not comfortable with." Jess smiled at him, he always took care of her. "Come on Nick, she totally wants it. You're a dirty little girl, aren't you Jess?" She watched as Nick clenched his jaw in anger. Jess just took his face in her hands and kissed him. "It's okay, Nick… I think… I think I want to try it."
Nick didn't look convinced at first, but as she began to ride him again he smiled at her and laid back down on the bed and grabbed her hips. She leaned forward a little so Sam would have better access and she felt the tip of his penis slowly start to enter ass. She slowed down her movements on Nick as she felt Sam go deeper into her other hole, soon he was fully buried inside her ass. She cried out loudly, the feeling of being filled so fully, so overwhelming and amazing at the same time.
She started to slowly move up and down on top of Nick as Sam thrusted into her ass, it wasn't long before they picked up the perfect rhythm. Sam held her from behind as he roughly massaged her breasts. Nick kept one hand on her hip while the other slid to her center so he could gently rub her clit. Never in a million years did Jess ever think she would be with two men at the same time, let alone have them both inside her at the same time but it felt So. Fucking. Good.
Even with everything that was going on around her, Jess still hadn't broke her eye contact with Nick. Looking into his dark eyes just made everything that much more intense. She felt Sam tense up behind her as he spilled himself in her ass."Fuck, your ass is so tight baby, I'm gonna come!" He pumped into her ass a couple more times before she felt him slip out of her and fall back on the bed, hearing the snap of the condom as he removed it.
She slowed her movements for a moment to pull Nick up into a sitting position and wrapped her arms around his neck, kissing him deeply. He wrapped his arms tightly around her waist and moaned into her mouth, pumping his cock up into her. He pulled back from the kiss and brought one hand up to her cheek, locking eyes with her. "Are you gonna come for me, Jess? I want to feel you come around my cock so bad." He whispered against her lips, kissing her breathless before burying his head in her hair and tightening his arms around her.
"Oh, Nick! I'm close… I'm so close baby. UH!"
Nick brought his hand back down to her center to rub at her clit and that's when Jess lost all control. It was the most intense orgasm she had ever had in her entire life, her entire body was shaking and Nick kept her wrapped in his arms, holding her against his chest as he continued pumping himself inside of her, screaming out her name as he spilled his hot seed inside of her.
She laid her head on his shoulder as he held her in his arms, rubbing his hand up and down her spine while they both catch their breath. She pulled back to look at him, they smiled at eachother and he took his hand up to push her bangs to the side and kissed her forehead. As she looked into his dark eyes, everything suddenly became clear to her and she knew what she had to do.
She kissed Nick on the cheek before raising her body from his. She was sore in a way that she had never felt before. She looked around, noticing that Sam was no longer in the room. She stood up from the bed and pulled on her robe that was hanging on the back of the door. She looked over at Nick as he stood up and started getting dressed, he pulled on his boxers and looked over at her. She could see the sadness in his eyes, she knew he had felt the connection that she did, but in typical Nick Miller fashion, he didn't believe that she could ever feel the same. He thought he was going to be rejected again.
She walked up to him and wrapped her arms around his neck, feeling his arms immediately wrap around her body. She kissed him sweetly and brought her hands around to his face. "I want you, Nick. Only you. But… I have to go talk to Sam. I have to do this the right way." Nick smiled at her and gently kissed her on the lips. "I understand, Jess. You go talk to him, I'm not going anywhere."
Jess left Nick in the bedroom and walked down the stairs to find Sam sitting on the couch, now fully dressed staring at the fire. She sat down next to him, but he refused to look at her.
"Sam… We need to talk."
He finally looked at her and she could see the anger and jealously in his gaze. "What the hell was that, Jess? I thought this was just for fun, you know? Just a fantasy thing… But it wasn't, was it? You barely even acknowledged me the whole time! I'm your boyfriend!"
"Sam, Look… At first it was, you know… Just for fun. But, I just… I felt something with Nick. A connection that I've never felt before, more than just friendship. I think it's always been there, but I just never realized it until now… I'm so sorry."
Sam scoffed at Jess before standing up abruptly. "Are you kidding me, Jess? Are you breaking up with me? After I agreed to have a threesome, with another dude because you wanted to, that's just it?!" Jess winced as Sam continued to yell at her, not fully listening to what he was saying.
"Fine, you know what? Whatever, he can have you. Just tell me one thing, Jess and I'll leave… Do you love him?"
Jess looked up at him with wide eyes. Did she love Nick? He was her best friend, her partner in crime, he took care of her and protected her and made her feel more safe and comfortable than anyone ever had… But did she love him? The realization hit her like a ton of bricks. Yes, she did. She had for a very long time. Looking Sam directly in the eyes, she stood up from the couch and walked towards him, stopping just out of reach.
"Yes, I do. I love Nick. I'm sorry, Sam."
Sam didn't say a word, he ripped his coat from the hook it was hanging on and stormed out of the door, slamming it in Jess's face. Jess just stood there, not quite believing the night she just had. She was broken from her thoughts when she heard the creak of the old wooden stairs and couldn't help but smile as she looked up to see Nick standing in front of her, smiling back at her.
"I'm sorry, Jess… I tried to give you some privacy, but when I heard him yelling at you I couldn't stand it. I didn't hear everything, but I heard enough." He pulled her into his arms and kissed her passionately. "I love you too, Jess. I've loved you since the moment I first laid eyes on you."
She couldn't fight the tears of joy that leaked from her eyes as she looked up at him. She had never seen him look happier and it made her heart swell. He pecked her once more on the lips before bending down and wrapping his arms around her thighs, lifting her into his arms. She gasped and let out a little chuckle.
"Take me to bed, Miller."
"You got it, Day."
**Thank you all so much for reading! I will continue to take requests and write them to the best of my ability. For the next chapter I will write the highest voted scenario, so throw your ideas out there!**