After Kaylee, had spent as much time away from the brothers as she could without it seeming suspious she returned to find Dean, Sam and Andy sitting where she left them.
"Victim's name was Holly Beckett. 41. Single" Kaylee said appearing next to them startling Andy but Sam and Dean were used to it.
"Who is she?" Sam asked looking at Andy.
"Never heard of her" Andy explained with a shrug.
"I did some research on her before coming back. Apparently, Holly Beckett gave birth when she was 18 years old, back in 1983… same day you were born, Andy" Kaylee explained looking at Andy.
"Andy, were you adopted?" Dean asked looking at Andy.
"Well, yeah" Andy said simply while Kaylee rolled her eyes annoyed.
"You were? And you neglected to mention that?" Dean asked slightly annoyed.
"It never really came up. I mean, I never knew my birth parents, and, like you said, my adopted mom died when I was a baby. Do you think this Holly woman could actually be…?" Andy asked shocked looking over at Kaylee.
"I don't know" Kaylee said with a shrug, not caring before noticing Dean, Sam and Andy all looking at her. She closed her eyes and took a deep breath instead of saying what she really wanted to say before looking at Dean.
"Fine" She growled out before disappearing and reappearing moments later with a folder in her hand.
"I thought you didn't like it when I used my gifts unnecessarily" Kaylee mocked at Dean and Sam before giving the folder to Sam with a bit more force than necessary. She went and sat down next to the fence while Sam open and read the folder.
"Andy, it's true. Holly Beckett was your birth mother" Sam said softly.
"Does anyone have a Vicodin?" Andy asked shocked.
"Dr. Jennings was her doctor, too. I mean, he oversaw the adoption. You have a solid connection to both of them" Sam continued softly.
"Yeah, but I didn't kill them" Andy protested and Dean looked at Andy.
"We believe you" Dean said firmly.
"Yeah. But, uh, who did?" Sam asked and Kaylee chuckled gaining their attention. She had her eyes closed and was leaning against the fence.
"Oh, I think I got a pretty good guess. Keep reading, Sammy" Kaylee said amused as Sam kept reading before pausing. He sighed.
"Holly Beckett gave birth to twins" Sam read as Dean and Andy looked surprised while Kaylee chuckled. The brothers grabbed a shocked Andy and took him back to their hotel room to recover. Kaylee walked into the room and fell face first onto the bed, exhausted from the stress of today.
"I have an evil twin" Andy said in shock as he sat down at the table and put his hands on his head.
"Holly put you and your brother up for adoption. And you went to the Gallagher family, obviously, and your brother went to the Weems family from upstate" Sam explained continuing to read the file, sitting down across from him.
"Andy, how you doing? Still with us?" Dean asked looking at him worried as he sat down next to Kaylee on the bed and placed a hand on Kaylee's shoulder, rubbing it softly.
"Um...what was my brother's name?" Andy asked softly.
"Here. Um, Ansem Weems? He's got a local address" Sam said but Andy shrugged.
"He lives here?" Andy asked before Dean walked over and grabbed the laptop hacking into the DMV and grabbing a picture.
"Let's get a look at him. Got his picture coming over from the DMV right now" Dean said before pulling up the picture. Sam and Dean looked at the laptop before looking at each other.
"Hate to kick you while you're freaked" Dean muttered before turning the laptop around to show a photo of the waiter from Andy's work. Kaylee lifted her head up for a moment to see the photo before laying back down too exhausted and too drained to care. Not that she probably would care in her current state. She really hoped that Kane would call her back soon with an answer.
"You coming Kaylee?" Dean asked breaking Kaylee out of her thoughts. She sighed and pulled herself to her feet as Sam and Andy went to the car.
"Hey, are you okay? You've seemed a bit… off today" Dean asked softly, grabbing Kaylee's hands. Kaylee looked at their hands curiously before blinking and remembering what Kane said.
"I'm just tired, Dean. It's been a while since I've gone and hunted as a werewolf and it drains me a bit" Kaylee explained doing her best to be convincing. The brothers and Kaylee had always had this silent agreement about Kaylee's werewolf feeding habits. They didn't ask and she didn't tell but she had to break that silent agreement in order to save Dean from the truth. Dean pulled Kaylee in for a hug, hiding his shock over the conversation about her feeding. He knew that she had to feed on animal hearts every once and while to keep her strength up but it still disgusted him a bit.
"Then after this hunt you should go… go do what you need to do" Dean whispered awkwardly but lovingly. Kaylee nodded before they were interrupted by Sam shouted out to them. They left the hotel room and jumped into the car.
"All right, Andy, tell us everything you know about this guy" Sam said as Dean started driving.
"I don't know much. Webber shows up one day like eight months ago, acting like he's my best friend in the world. He's kind of weird, like trying too hard, you know?" Andy explained leaving forward in the backseat while Kaylee sat next to him staring out the window. She was trying to come up with a plan to… relieve some of this power built up inside of her.
"He must've known you guys are twins. Why did he change his name? Why not tell you the truth?" Dean asked before Sam grabbed his head in pain. Kaylee broke out of her thoughts and looked at Sam sitting in the front seat in pain.
"Sam? Sam?! Sam!" Dean shouted as he stopped the car and bolted over to Sam's side.
…
The Impala pulled up at the bridge where Sam's visions told him to go to find another car sitting there. They pulled over and Dean, Sam and Kaylee got out of the car and walked around to the boot.
"Dean, you should stay here" Sam said softly.
'No argument here. I had my head screwed with enough for one day" Dean agreed as Andy got out of the car.
"I'm coming with you. That's Tracy out there, and I'm coming" Andy said firmly before Sam looked at Kaylee who was grabbing her daggers. She shrugged at him in response. They walked over to find Webber talking to Tracy and making her undo her shirt. This made Kaylee's temper flare up. She punched the window and shattered it.
"Get out of the car! Now!" Kaylee shouted while Webber just looked at her calmly.
"You really don't want to do this" Webber said trying to use his power but to no avail. She responded by punching him in the jaw. Sam had his gun on Webber as Kaylee pulled him from the car while Andy grabbed Tracy.
"Trace, give me your hand. Come here, come here" Andy said holding Tracy to his chest.
"I couldn't control myself" Tracy cried before Andy ran over and put tape over Webber's mouth. He started kicking Webber.
"I will kill you! I will kill you!" Andy shouted as Sam pulled him back. Kaylee watched as Tracy picked up a large stick and hit Sam in the back with it, knocking him unconscious.
"Tracy, stop!" Andy said before Tracy turned to Kaylee. She went to hit her but Kaylee caught the stick easily.
"I said, stop it!" Andy said using his power reluctantly. Tracy dropped the branch and started crying.
"How did you do that?" Andy asked turning to Webber in shock.
"Practice, bro. If you just practiced, you would know. Sometimes... you don't need to use your words. If you have to, all you need is this. Sometimes the headache is worth it" Webber explained as Kaylee watched the conversation out of Webber's view.
"You twisted son of a bitch!" Andy said going after Webber.
"Back off, Andy! Or Tracy is gonna do a little flying. Aren't you, Trace? I'm stronger than you. I can do it" Webber said as Kaylee moved towards Tracy at a human pace.
"Back off" Webber tried to use his power but Kaylee smirked at him.
"A little performance issue? It's okay, it happens to the best of them" Kaylee mocked as Webber looked at Andy confused.
"She's a werewolf" Andy explained before Webber made Tracy step onto the ledge.
"Okay, okay. Okay. Kaylee, stop moving, please" Andy begged and Kaylee shrugged disinterestedly. She didn't care if Tracy tried to fly but she stopped moving and leant against Webber's car, interested in where this conversation was going to go.
"Don't be mad at me, okay? I know. It's all wrong. I didn't mean for this to happen. It's just... Tracy. She's trying to come between us" Webber begged.
"You're insane" Andy muttered.
"She's garbage! Man, they all are! We can push them. We can make them do whatever we want!" Webber continued as if Andy didn't interrupt.
"Are you really… Are you really this stupid? Is it… you learn you got a twin, you call him up, you go out for a drink. You don't start killing people!" Andy shouted at Webber making Kaylee chuckle. She noticed Sam was moving slightly and made eye contact with him.
"I wanted to tell you for so long, bro, but… he didn't let me. He said I had to wait until the time…" Webber explained as Sam silently told me to move on them.
"Who?" Andy asked confused.
"The man with the yellow eyes" Webber explained making Kaylee stop in her tracks and cock her head to the side with interest as Sam froze and listened as well.
"What are you talking about?" Andy demanded confused.
"He came to me... in my dream. He said I was special. He told me he's got big plans for me. Wait till you see what's in store, Andy, for both of us. See, he's the one who told me that I had a brother, a twin" Webber explained as Kaylee and Sam listened closely.
"Why did you kill our mother? And why Dr. Jennings?" Andy asked sadly.
"Because they split us up! They ruined our lives, Andy! We could've been together this whole time Instead of alone. I couldn't let them do that. I couldn't let them get away with that. No" Webber said before Kaylee heard Dean creeping through the trees and getting his sniper ready. Unfortunately, so did Webber.
"I see you. Bye-Bye" Webber said as Dean put the gun to his chin. Andy pulled out his gun and shot Webber, making Dean lower his gun shocked. Kaylee pulled a now free and frightened Tracy off the bridge.
…