Dean, Sam and Kaylee broke into Kurt's apartment and the brothers immediately started looking around while Kaylee took a step into the apartment but didn't smell anything indicating Kurt was a werewolf.
"Anything?" Sam asked as Dean looked in the fridge.
"Nothing but leftovers and a six pack" Dean said simply.
"Check the freezer. Maybe there's some human hearts behind the Häagen-Dazs or something" Sam joked seriously but before Dean could check Kaylee heard a noise near the window. She walked over and moved the curtain. She stepped out onto the balcony before smelling werewolf. She looked around until she found scratch marks up the wall.
"Boys, come here" She called out as the brothers joined her on the balcony.
"Check it out" Kaylee said pointing to the claw marks before Kaylee heard a noise in the nearby alley.
"Is somebody there?" A man called out as Dean and Sam went back inside unaware of what Kaylee was hearing. Suddenly she heard growling and gun shots. Sam and Dean ran out to the balcony only to see Kaylee jump down into the alleyway. She ran over to where the police officer was but she was too late. The police officer was mauled to death.
"I'll call 911" Sam said as Dean and Sam walked over to Kaylee and the body.
"I'd say Kurt's looking more and more like our Cujo" Dean said and Kaylee opened her mouth to tell him the truth but closed it thinking of another idea.
"We better check on Madison" Kaylee said simply as they left the alleyway and arrived at Madison's apartment minutes later. Sam knocked on the door but Glen opened his door opposite Madison's.
"What's going on?" Glen asked as Kaylee smelt a recent change from him.
"Police business, Glen" Dean said as Madison opened the door.
"What is it?" Madison asked confused.
"Well, maybe we should talk privately?" Sam asked before Madison let them into the apartment and pouring them a coffee. Kaylee declined. She hated coffee.
"Has Kurt been here?" Sam asked.
"Not exactly" Madison replied with a sigh.
"What exactly does "not exactly" mean?" Kaylee asked walking through the kitchen.
"Well, he was outside last night. Just looking. Just looking at me. Has he done something?" Madison asked worried.
"We're not really sure" Sam replied.
"It's probably nothing. But we just don't wanna take any chances. In fact, one of us should probably stay here with you, just in case he stops by" Kaylee said intending to stay herself and talk to both Madison and Glen about what was going on.
"Where does he work?" Dean asked.
"He owns a body shop" Madison explained
"You mind grabbing that address for us?" Kaylee asked as she turned to the brothers.
"You two go, I'll stay with Madison" She explained firmly but Sam shook his head.
"No, you're the werewolf you need to be the one hunting him. I'll stay with Madison" Sam said as Kaylee opened her mouth to argue but Madison walked back into the room with an address. Kaylee bit her tongue before grabbing the address and yanking Dean out the apartment to track down Kurt… which was totally pointless. Kaylee had no idea what she was going to do. For the next few hours Madison and Sam sat in her apartment in silence.
"Um, do you wanna sit on the couch?" Madison asked Sam awkwardly.
"No. No, no, I'm okay" Sam said.
"It's more comfortable" Madison replied.
"Aw, I'm fine" Sam said politely before watching Madison grabbed her laundry and started folding her underwear right in front of Sam.
"You know what? I think I will sit on that couch" Sam said gulping and moving to sit on the lounge when his phone started ringing.
"Let me guess. You're sitting on her couch like a stiff… trying to think of something to say" Dean said as he and Kaylee walked down the street after checking out Kurt's work.
"You find Kurt?" Sam asked softly confirming what Dean said was true.
"He hasn't been at work. But because I'm good..." Dean started to say.
'You mean, I'm good" Kaylee cut in and Dean winked at her.
"Because Kaylee is good, we got a line on where he might be. What's she wearing?" Dean asked making Kaylee smack him up the side of the head.
"Bye, Dean" Sam said hanging up making Dean laugh.
"Oh, Sammy" Kaylee said sympathetically before they followed Kurt to a strip club.
"Oh brother" Kaylee muttered before Dean looked at her excited.
"Can I?" Dean asked slightly begging and Kaylee rolled her eyes but motioned for him to go in. He kissed her on the lips before running into the strip club like a kid in a candy store. Kaylee chuckled before pulling out her phone and calling Kane.
"Hey, what's going on?" Kane asked.
"I've got a… situation here" Kaylee said with a sigh as she went across a café and sat down.
"We are hunting some werewolf attacks but I've currently found two werewolves who have no idea what they are… Sam and Dean don't know I've identified the werewolves and I've held off telling them so far because our laws are I can't kill them, I've got to help them get into a pack. Dean and Sam aren't going to like that and I don't know what to do" Kaylee said softly so no humans would overhear. Kane let out a low whistle.
"Wow… okay. What are you going to do?" Kane asked and Kaylee rubbed her face.
"I don't know… I'm royally screwed here Kane" Kaylee whispered before seeing Kurt walk out with a stripper and Dean followed behind them. Kaylee met up with Dean outside Kurt's motel room.
"Did you have fun?" Kaylee mocked Dean who smirked and kissed her cheek before they heard screaming from the motel room. They ran inside to find Madison in her werewolf form killing Kurt.
"What the…" Dean said before Madison shoved him into the wall. Kaylee quickly turned and stood between them. Madison paused and looked at Kaylee confused as if seeing another werewolf for the first time. Kaylee let out a warning growl but the distraction gave Dean enough time to recover and grab a silver knife. He went to stab Madison but Kaylee shoved him out of the way but the knife cut both Madison and Kaylee along the arm. They both hissed in pain before Kaylee knocked Dean out.
….
Sam woke up to his phone ringing, he reached out and grabbed it.
"You okay?" Sam asked worried.
"Now that I'm conscious. Kaylee knocked me out. Sam, it's Madison and Kaylee wouldn't let me kill her" Dean growled annoyed and frustrated.
"What?" Sam asked running to her bedroom.
"Yeah, awesome job of keeping an eye on her" Dean said sarcastically as Sam opened the door to find Madison sleeping.
"I've been here the whole time. She's in bed, asleep" Sam whispered in disbelief.
"She wasn't an hour ago. Check her right arm below her elbow. I nicked her with a silver knife. I've got to try and find Kaylee" Dean said annoyed before hanging up. Sam sighed looking at his phone before walking into the bedroom.
"Morning. Um, where are my pajamas?" Madison said waking up before looking down at her naked body confused. Sam looked at her elbow and saw the cut Dean was talking about.
"Sam? What's going on? Where are you going?" Madison asked confused as Sam walked out of the room with Madison following him. Sam quickly locked the front door.
"I'm not going anywhere. And neither are you" Sam said firmly pulling out his gun and tying Madison up on a chair after she put some clothes on.
"You're psychotic. The whole "I'm a cop" trip. God, I am so stupid" Madison cried.
"I guess neither of us are who we said we were, huh?" Sam said angrily.
"Sam, you're sick, okay? You're imagining things. Monsters don't exist, not really. I am not a werewolf. There is no such thing. It's made up, all right? They're not real. You know they're not real" Madison begged scared.
"No? Then where did that come from?" Sam asked pointing to the cut on her elbow.
"I don't know. Sam, God, you need help. Please, don't do something that you're gonna regret. I'm not what you think I am. I'm not" Madison begged before someone knocked on the front door. Sam looked through the peephole to see Dean. He let Dean in before locking the door behind them.
"We gotta talk" Sam whispered to Dean and lead him to the kitchen.
"She says she has no idea what I'm talking about" Sam explained.
"She's lying" Dean said firmly before Kaylee jumped through an open window scaring them both.
"No, she isn't. Sorry about knocking you out but I couldn't let you kill her" Kaylee said holding her bleeding arm and Dean noticed she was bleeding from her shoulder wound again as well.
"Why the hell not?" Dean demanded as Sam grabbed a first aid kit and handed it to Kaylee so she could patch herself up.
"She doesn't know she's changing. When the creature takes over, she blacks out. Normal werewolves don't remember their turn that's why they are normally recruited into a pack so the purebloods, like me, can clean up after their turns and help them out" Kaylee explained cleaning out the cut on her elbow and wrapping a bandage around it.
"Like a really hot Incredible Hulk? She ganked her boss and her ex-boyfriend. That doesn't sound rash and unconscious" Dean argued before Kaylee let out a low annoyed growl.
"The animal part of her brain saw those guys as a threat, the same with a cop" Kaylee said through gritted teeth.
"She's killing people" Dean snapped and Kaylee slammed her hand onto the table angrily.
"She has no control over it! I need to get her into a pack so she can be looked after by our kind. We don't kill them unless they know the laws and are still refusing to obey them. Madison has no idea what she is" Kaylee said firmly.
"She can't control it, it won't change anything" Dean said firmly and Sam stepped towards Kaylee.
"I'm not putting a bullet through some girl's chest" Sam said taking Kaylee's side.
"She's a monster and you're feeling sorry?" Dean asked disgusted and Kaylee shoved Dean back into the counter.
"She is a werewolf! She is my kind. If she is a monster than so am I! How dare you say that in front of me?! If you think we should kill her than you should kill me and trust me; that is the only way you are going to get to her" Kaylee threatened dangerously, her werewolf instincts telling her to protect her own kind. Dean and Sam looked at Kaylee shocked and all three of them stood in tense silence for a few minutes, no one daring to move or say another word until Sam finally took a deep breath and sighed.
"Look. There might be another way we can get the job done without having to waste her" Sam said taking a step between an angry Dean and a furious Kaylee.
"Are you thinking what I think you're thinking?" Dean asked as Sam pulled out John's journal.
"Dad's theory: 'Lycanthropy might have a cure if you kill the werewolf who bit you... severing the bloodline'" Sam read and Kaylee shrugged, never hearing that before so she didn't know if it was true or not.
"'Might have a cure.' Meaning who the hell knows?" Dean asked angrily and Sam looked at Kaylee not wanting to fight with her.
"It's worth a shot" Sam said silently saying to Dean 'it's worth a shot if it means saving our relationship with Kaylee.
"We don't know where to start looking. The puppy that bit her could be anyone, anywhere. Could have been years ago" Dean argued.
"No, I don't think so. She said she was mugged" Sam said thinking it was then that she changed. Kaylee walked into the room where Madison was crying, still tied to a chair.
"When were you mugged? Please. It's important, all right? Just answer the question" Kaylee begged wanting to save not only Madison but also her relationship with Dean and Sam.
"About a month ago" Madison explained confused.
"Did you see the guy?" Sam asked.
"No. Grabbed me from behind" Madison explained.
"Did he bite you?" Kaylee asked and Madison look at her shocked.
"How did you know that?" Madison asked and Dean looked at Kaylee surprised.
"Where?" Kaylee asked firmly.
"On the back of my neck" Madison stuttered as Kaylee walked around and checked out the scar.
"Well, that was just a love bite. Believe me, that could have been a lot worse" Dean joked weakly.
"Let me guess: Not too far from Hunter's Point?" Kaylee asked and Madison nodded before Sam, Dean and Kaylee went back to the kitchen.
"Same place where those other murders happened. I'm telling you, it's a werewolf's hunting grounds" Sam said firmly.
"That doesn't mean it'll be out tonight" Dean argued and Kaylee clicked her tongue.
"It doesn't matter. I know who it is. It's Glen. I smelt it on both Madison and Glen the moment I met them. I didn't tell you because I knew that you wouldn't care about the fact they didn't know what they were" Kaylee confessed and Dean glared at her furiously.
"You're forgetting something. Madison's probably gonna turn soon. We can't just let her take off to an all-you-can-eat buffet" Dean stated.
"I'll stay with her" Sam said.
"And if she busts loose? Sam?" Dean asked when Sam looked over at Kaylee.
"I'll do it. I'll shoot her, all right?" Sam said and Kaylee growled again.
"No, you won't" Kaylee ordered and Dean got in her face.
"Kaylee, this is what we do. It doesn't matter that they don't know what they are. She killed people, she is a mon…" Dean said angrily before trailing off.
"Go on, say it" Kaylee dared.
"She is a monster and she needs to die" Dean said bitterly before Kaylee punched him in the face and jumped out the window. Sam opened his mouth to snap at Dean but Dean stormed past Sam and out of the apartment. Sam bit his lip regretful of the situation before going back to Madison.
"Please. Just let me go" Madison begged.
"Look. I know you're scared. I also know that there's no way in hell you're gonna believe me. But I'm doing this because I'm trying to help you. I'm not gonna lie. The odds aren't exactly in our favour. But if this goes the way I pray it does... I'll untie you... and I'll walk out that door and I'll never come back. You'll live the rest of your life... and I'll just be a bad memory" Sam promised sadly, tearing in his eyes as she looked at him with hatred.
…..