Back to the pit, we see the gang still falling in the pit. Claudette started to talk as Saul finished his story.

"I spy with my little eye something that is... Black!"

Brian raised his hand and answered. "Ooh ooh! Everything!"

"Correct! Yay for Brian!" She started to clap.

"Yay for Brian!" He said to himself. Claudette then spoke up again.

"Hey guys, who wants to pass the time by spinning?"

"No." Saul said annoyed by the bottomless hole. But Claudette didn't care. She then took Saul's body and started to spin him around.

"Woooaah!" Saul said as he started to spin uncontrollably.

Brian and Wayne started chuckling.

Claudette then starts running on top of Dipper. "Weeee!" She yelled in excitement.

"Ow, ow, ow, ow."

"Saul's pain is funny, but I'm starting to get bored. Brian, tell a story."

Brian then started to think of something. He then gasped and started to talk.

"Okay, Okay. This story is called "Brian's really good Pinball story. Is that a good title? Does it have to be a pun or whatever?"

"Go! Go! Go! Go! Go! Go!" We hear the two teens chanting as Brian was playing an arcade game. He was playing pinball. The theme was western and this was his best game to play.

"This is it, dudes. After 4 long months of trying, I might finally get a high score on this creepy old pinball machine. If I do this, I'll go down in pinball history, with the likes of Sal, Gaff, and of course, Poo."

"Have you ever tried maybe tilting the machine?" Saul asked.

"I don't know, dudes, isn't breaking the rules like, against the rules?"

"Nuts to the rules! Tilt! Tilt! Tilt!" Then they heard the noise. It was the "You Lose" Noise that would usually play.

"Failure! You stink!" The cowboy head inside the game said.

"All right, that's it! Are you ready, kids?" The two then started to rock the machine back and forth as Brian started to play. The cowboy head said only this.

"Quit tiltin', partner. Quit tiltin'!"

"Tilt!" Brian said as he pulled up the game. The ball then tilts into the goal)

"Bulls-eye! New high score!" The cowboy said. Everyone started cheering.

"This is the best moment of my life. This totally beats my old best moment of being able to stick three balls in my mouth."

"Rubber balls right?" Claudette asked.

"Um… it tasted like that…"

"That ain't right. You cheated…." The cowboy head said.

"Oh, yeah. What are you gonna do about it? You're just a Pinball game."

"Uh, isn't there an awful lot of green lightning coming out of that game?" Saul asked with Brian answering.

"No, that's the normal amount of green lightning." Lightning then strikes them. We see Brian lying down and hitting a buzzer. He then says this.

"Uh, 5 more minutes." He then gets up. "Ah! Wait. That's not a normal alarm clock." Runs up to the teens; they are all wearing old west themed clothes.

"Brian! We're inside the game!" Claudette said.

"Awesome!" Saul exclaimed.

"Dude, if this is a dream, I never want to wake up!" Brian said as the camera pans out and we see more of the pinball game set with him in the middle. Then a voice was heard.

"That can be arranged." Everyone turned and we see the pinball cowboy head. "Welcome to Tumbleweed Terror, partners."

"Did you zap me into your game to congratulate me on getting my new score? I beat Poo, dude!"

"Pardon, and if'n I do recall, I did warned y'all not to cheat. I tried to be gentleman-like, but I'm plum sick of being tilted. So, now I reckon, I'm gonna tilt you." He said ominously. He then laughs.

"Get yourselves ready for the..." A flip-card ontop of the head started to flip and then it froze on one word… Multi-ball.

"Multi-Ball!" Everyone screamed. Everone started to move out the way as the balls were coming. Then Saul yelled and pointed to a direction.

"Over there!" They all run behind a wall.

The pinball cowboy then looked around. "Where are you? I'm not done teaching you a lesson about cheating yet!"

We see the gang panting behind a wall. Claudette speaks up. "How are we gonna get out of here? Think, guys."

"I'm trying. But it's hard with that gorgeous pinball wench distracting me." Brian said as the camera then cuts to a cutout of a woman. He waves at the cutout. The two teens give him a look and he stops.

"Okay. Don't worry, guys, I know every inch of this machine. There's a manual power switch inside. I can sneak in there and turn off the game. But we'll have to distract the cowboy guy. Are any of you good at jumping up and down and making annoying noises?"

"Our time has come!" Claudette and Saul said together. Then Saul began to speak.

"Alright, let's go. Brian?" we then see him with the pinball wench.

"So are you, like, doing anything later?" Saul kicks the wench and reveals to him it's fake. "Oh, right."

Saul and Claudette then jump up on a buzzer as Brian goes to the lower level.]

"Hey! Hey! Hey! Look at me and listen to what I'm doing! BUZZZZZZ! DISTRACTION! DISTRACTION! LA! LA! LA! LA! LA!" Claudette exclaimed as she moved around.

"Something ain't right here. Let me see where this is going." We see Brian go to the depths of the machine and we see the off switch. It's green and has text written on the wall behind it.

"Yippy ti yi what? Where are ya?" They left. He tries to turn. "Darnit, I wish I had a neck."

We see the teens are looking in the hole that Brian made to get in the off switch room and Saul speaks up. "What's going on? Just press the switch already!"

"Okay, so I was gonna do that, but I've been thinking. According to this, turning off the power will erase the scores permanently. That score is like my one big life accomplishment."

"What? If you don't hurry up, we could die in here!"

"Fair point. But, what is life anyway when compared to the immortality of a high score?" The walls then fall down and the cowboy head starts to inhale. The gang is being sucked toward the cowboy skull.

"Please! Turn it off!"

"Goodbye, high score." Pushes the button and the pinball game turns off. He and the teens wake up outside of the game "Woah! You okay?"

"Yes! You did it! You freed us! I'm sorry you had to lose your high score."

"That's Okay. I've got a new life accomplishment now. Saving you dudes." We hear aw's from the two.

"You think that pinball wench will call me?" Brian said.