Chapter 3

Thank you to everyone who has made it this far! I'm not that good at writing the kissing scenes but I will try my best. Please review the story! I'm putting a poll up in my profile take it! It's which Pretty Little Liars Couple is your favorite. I want to see who the favorite is. Mine is of course Spoby :) If you have any ideas for how you want the story to go please PM me or just post it in the review section. I'll see it either way. I have a few ideas for where I want the story to end up but I have to figure out how I should add this twist I came up with.

Disclaimer: I don't own Pretty Little Liars. Or The Backpack Song.


Spencer realized that if she kissed him now, it wouldn't matter. She had the excuse of being drunk anyways. Little did she know, Toby was thinking the exact same thing.

Spencer looked up and put her arms around Toby's neck and placed her lips on his mouth. It suddenly exploded into a kiss filled with fiery passion. It was nervous like their first kiss, passionate like their first time, and loving like when they were reunited after Toby went away, it was everything.

Spencer tangled her fingers in his hair as he lifted her up and walked over to her bedroom, not a speck of guilt or regret in their minds.


The first thing Spencer noticed was the pounding headache she had. The second thing she noticed were the warm calloused hands wrapped around her waist. It felt nice. But then Spencer remembered who's hands they were.

She didn't know what to. She knew that if she got up she would wake Toby, and she didn't want to deal with him right now. She also didn't want to lay there, sure it felt nice and comforting but it was still considered cheating. She didn't want do get in between him and Yvonne. Of course deep down inside of her she knew that she really wanted them to break up, but she didn't want to be the reason they did.

While she was debating her options her mind was made for her as Toby began to stir on the other side of the bed.

"Morning Spence." He murmured while kissing up and down her shoulders.

She suddenly decided that she would like to just lay there forever, just cuddling in between Toby's arms.

Spencer didn't want to care about Yvonne anymore, she just wanted to be here, with Toby, like last night. So she turned over in bed and kissed Toby back.


About an hour later the two got up. Spencer threw on Toby's t-shirt and he took his shorts, just like that night at the motel.

They decided that they needed coffee, so they could effectively think and discuss what happened the night before.

"You just want black coffee, right?" Spencer double checked as she made the coffee.

"Yeah, that's fine." Toby answered as he sat down on the sofa. He really didn't want black coffee. Yvonne had him hooked on her vanilla creamer she put in her coffee. He knew Spencer had some in the cabinet but he didn't want to bring up Yvonne, well at least not yet.

After making the coffee Spencer walked over to the couch where Toby was sitting and handed him his coffee. When their hands touched they both felt a spark. They both found it so hard to deny the chemistry they still had.

Toby broke the awkward silence that followed by saying what they were both thinking. "About last night."

"We were drunk and we slipped up. That's it." Spencer said, trying to convince herself more than Toby.

"Yeah but we weren't drunk this morning Spence." Toby said

"I know." Spencer replied, finally admitting defeat.

"So what now Spencer, we can't ignore what is happening." Toby added.

"Well Toby, you are the one with the fiancee, I think this might be more your choice than mine." Spencer noted.

"Don't put this all on me Spencer. Its your choice too." Toby replied. He was about to continue when he was interrupted by Spencer's phone.

Spencer leaned over the couch's side to reach her phone on the coffee table. Her mouth formed a tight line.

"Toby, look at this." Spencer said with an unsure tone in her voice, something that was rare for Spencer. She leaned over to show Toby her phone.

"Oh shit." Toby murmured.

"That's what I thought." Spencer replied.

It was an email from Yvonne.

Dear Spencer, Kelly, Willow, and Taylor,

As most of you already know, I will be a Mrs. in two weeks. I wanted to invite you four to be my bridesmaids for the wedding. I scheduled us all a dress fitting for this afternoon at three in Philadelphia. I thought it would be fun if we all drove over there together. We could have some bridesmaid bonding time. Let's all meet at my house at two. I thought we could all have dinner after and then go out for drinks. I'll see everybody at two!

-Yvonne

"Should I do it?" Spencer asked, looking up at Toby with her big brown eyes.

He didn't know what to say. But he did know that she was in the perfect position for him to kiss her. So he did.

"Toby!" She exclaimed, "I thought we were trying to not cheat on your fiancee."

"Yeah well you're to sexy to ignore." Toby said with a low growl. "Just don't get drunk and you'll be fine."

"Toby! She giggled, "Stop that, I have to get ready!"

"Fine," he sighed,"I have to go anyways, Yvonne is going to wonder where I am." He got up and was about to walk out of the door when Spencer yelled at him.

"Figure out what you are going to do about us!" Spencer yelled.

Toby stopped at the door. "What do you want for us Spencer?"

"I still love you Toby. I need you. But I know that you are committed to Yvonne and I don't want to come between you two. I want you to be happy."

He looked at her like he was seeing the sun for the first time. He didn't know what to do. So he just left.


It was 1:45 so Spencer decided to head over to Yvonne and Toby's house. She saw the girls all outside of the garage waiting by Yvonne's car.

"Hey Spencer!" Yvonne yelled.

"We were just about to leave!" a petite blonde yelled.

Spencer saw movement from inside the garage and realized it was Toby, fixing something on his truck. Well, technically her truck. Spencer couldn't believe he still had that old thing. She smiled at the memories that they both shared through that truck. Then she started to wonder if Toby an Yvonne had done anything in the old truck. That ruined her trip down memory lane.

Spencer snapped back to reality when Yvonne staring introducing her to the girls. The petite blonde's name was Willow, she was Yvonne's best friend from high school and roommate in college. Then there was a taller version of Yvonne, except with lighter skin. That was Yvonne's sister, Taylor. The last girl was Yvonne's cousin, Kelly. She was about average height with brown hair and olive skin.

The group of girls were all pretty nice, the only problem was that Spencer didn't know why Yvonne wanted her to be a bridesmaid. It's not like they were that close of friends, and ever since A dredged up the article about Yvonne's abortion, they hadn't really talked.

"Alright everybody, into the car!" Taylor yelled. She seemed the most uptight of the group, possibly even more than Spencer.

Everybody piled into the car. Taylor drove while Willow took the passenger seat. I somehow got stuck in the middle of the back. Squished between Kelly and Yvonne.

"So Yvonne, are there any cute bachelors attending your wedding?" Willow asked.

"Why do you care Willow, aren't you dating Aiden? Kelly jokingly accused.

"Nah, were broken up right now. You would know all about that wouldn't you Kelly? How many times have you and Jack broken up and got back together? Willow retorted.

"That's irrelevant, we are together now, that's all that matters." Kelly said.

"So Spencer, been with any guys lately?" Yvonne asked.

Spencer didn't know what to say. She didn't want the girls to think she was single because she knew they would try to get her to hook up with some random guy at the club that they were going to after the fitting. She also didn't want to say she was with anyone because that would require details. Details that she couldn't tell. Spencer briefly considered mentioning Marco but that made her sound like a slut.

"Nope, recently, I've been quite boring." Spencer decided to say. Hopefully whoever they tried to set her up with wasn't too ugly.

"Ohh, lets find Spencer a guy at the club!" Willow exclaimed.

Spencer just went with it.

After that it was pretty quiet. Spencer decided to play the language game on her phone that she was addicted to. She had almost beat it.


Twenty minutes later they arrived in Philly. The group of girls went to this little boutique in downtown. Yvonne's dress was beautiful. The top half was a strapless mermaid gown, but the bottom was like a ball gown. It fit perfectly. The bridesmaids dresses were light blue with a lace halter top connected to the bodice which was just a normal dress. They were also beautiful.

The fitting took three whole hours, so the girls were starving after. Turns out that the clubbing was also the bachelorette party. The girls were staying in a Sheraton right on downtown. Since Spencer missed the memo and didn't have any extra clothes she just had to make it work.

So the girls had dinner at this cute little cafe and then went to a local bar. Spencer remembered that Toby told her not to get drunk and she would be fine.

Spencer wouldn't have gotten drunk but Taylor tried to spike her one beer while Spencer went to the bathroom. She accidentally poured all of the alcohol in the flask into her beer. So Spencer got really drunk. She couldn't remember anything else.


It was like déjà vu for Spencer that morning. But this time Spencer knew the girls must of made her hook up with someone. But the weird thing was, Spencer recognized this man's cologne she decided to roll over in bed to see who it was.

"Oh my gosh! Why are you here!?" Spencer screeched.


Did you like the cliffhanger? Comment on who you think the mystery man is. In order to get Chapter 4 by tomorrow evening I need 5 people to guess! Good old fashioned bribery, I love it. Like always please like, review, follow, favorite, ect... Also don't forget to take my poll!