Chapter 4

I'm going to apologize in advance, I started school the 15th and I know that I won't be able to post updates as often. I'm thinking that I might just have to post on weekends because I can't find time during the week. I'm also sorry that this chapter is a little shorter, I don't know how some people write those 3,000 word chapters. I can't do that, I'll go crazy trying to find little plots to add to the huge chapter. Anyways, I saw that a lot of you thought that Spencer's "Bed Buddy" would be Marco. So I've been debating whether or not to make her little friend Marco of the person I was originally going to have sleeping with Spencer. Due to the fact that I think that it will go along with the plot better if I make Spencer's friend who he is. Please please review! You guy's reviews keep me writing! I normally would of quit by now but I saw some people reviewed so I decided to write. Anyways, thanks for reading!

Disclaimer: I don't own Pretty Little Liars or the Backpack Song.


It was like déjà vu for Spencer that morning. But this time Spencer knew the girls must of made her hook up with someone. But the weird thing was, Spencer recognized this man's cologne, so she decided to roll over in bed to see if it was who she thought it was.

"Oh my gosh! Why are you here!?" Spencer screeched.

Caleb shot out of bed, disoriented and startled.

"What the hell Spencer?! Why am I naked and in bed with you?!" Caleb screamed.

Spencer gathered the thin comforter up in front of her bare chest.

"I don't know Caleb! After we broke up did you really think I would want to sleep with you! No! I'm over you!" Spencer furiously exclaimed.

"Do you remember anything from last night?" Caleb asked in a slightly softer tone.

"Not at all. I remember Taylor saying that she spiked my drink, me slapping her, and then nothing." Spencer replied in an aggravated tone of voice.

"You slapped who now?" Caleb said in a concerned voice.

"No one important. The important thing is that this never happens again." Spencer frustratingly replied.

"Hey, do you remember anything from last night?" Spencer added.

"No Spencer, I don't remember anything from last night. Don't you think that if I could I also would of been able to stop what happened?" Caleb replied.

"Oh yeah." Spencer muttered.

After the awkward conversation with Caleb, Spencer put on her clothes from last night and called Yvonne.

No answer. Of course.

Then she called Kelly, they had exchanged numbers on the ride over, she was actually pretty nice for being related to Yvonne and Taylor.

Right as Spencer was about to hang up, Kelly answered.

"Hey Spencer, are you alright?" Kelly asked in a concerned tone.

"Yeah, I'm fine. I'm going to kill Taylor." Spencer replied.

"Me too. Apparently after I chastised her for spiking your drink, she did something to mine." Kelly said.

"Well are you okay now?" Spencer asked.

"My ex, Noah lives in Philadelphia. Apparently in my drunken state I went and gave him a visit. Now I'm in the bathroom at his apartment. On the bright side he still has some of my clothes so I don't have to wear what I wore last night." Kelly regretfully admitted.

"That sucks. Basically the same story here. Except my ex, Caleb, was super drunk." Spencer replied.

"Hey, are you at the hotel now?" Kelly asked.

"Yes, but I don't know what room we are staying in." Spencer realized.

"We're at room 1537. Tell them I'm at Noah's, Yvonne should know where it is." Kelly replied.

"Okay, I'm heading up now." Spencer said. Then she hung up.

"Alright Caleb, I'm leaving. You better not tell a soul about last night." Spencer threatened.

"Don't worry, I wasn't planning on telling anyone." Caleb responded.

Then Spencer left.


That Evening:

Spencer was exhausted by the time the day had ended. The awkward silence on the ride home from Philadelphia was enough to make her want to scream. Not to mention the fact that the love of her life was going to be married in less than two weeks and she had a front row seat as bridesmaid.

She knew that she would of never even gone to the wedding if it weren't for Yvonne. Maybe this was Yvonne's way of punishing her for spilling the news about her abortion. Making Spencer watch Toby leave her.

Spencer heard her phone buzzing on her nightstand, and went to grab it. It was Toby, probably asking about the bridal shower and how it went. As Spencer lifted the phone to her ear she briefly wondered if she should tell Toby about Caleb. But that idea was quickly removed from her head as she remembered what she promised Caleb.

"Hey Toby." Spencer greeted while sitting down on her sofa, mentally preparing for a long painful conversation.

"Can I come over, we need to talk." Toby asked, his voice begging her to say yes.

"Tobes, I don't think that's the best idea in the world. I still love you and all, but I really don't think we can afford having sex again. Why can't we just talk on the phone or something?" Spencer answered

"Well you see, I'd really rather come over." Toby admitted.

"Why Toby, why do you want to come over?" Spencer exasperatingly asked.

"Because I'm right outside." Toby sheepishly replied.

Spencer put her face in her hands. "Why did he have to be so damn persistent," she wondered.

"Come in." Spencer begrudgingly agreed.

Before she knew it she felt the couch shift and he was sitting next to her, just like it used to be.

"Hey Spence." Toby greeted.

Spencer's heart fluttered at the sound of the nickname he had given her seven years ago.

"Hi." She responded.

"Listen Spence. I still love you. And I also know that you still love me. But I also love Yvonne, and I am committed to her. I don't know what to do. Should I break up with her? Should I stay with her? I don't know the answer and I need your help." Toby breathlessly stated, combing his fingers through his hair.

"I don't know if I'm the one you should be going to in this situation. You see, I'm slightly biased in this situation. Maybe talk to Emily or Caleb?" Spencer said, immediately taking her words back as she said them. He couldn't go to Caleb in this situation, Caleb could tell Toby about the previous night.

"I guess that makes sense. I'll go talk to one of them." Toby said, a little disappointed that she didn't want to talk to him. And with that, he got up from the sofa, and walked towards the door.

"Toby wait!" Spencer shouted. But it was too late, he was already out the door. She would just have to trust Caleb.


A few hours later, Spencer got a call from her friend Aria.

"Hey Aria." Spencer greeted.

"Spencer, I'm late." Aria murdered.

"Like late for a flight or..." Spencer began to say but was quickly interrupted by her friend.

"Like late for my period Spencer! And Ezra is in Columbia!" Aria shouted.

Hearing about Aria's problem made Spencer think up of one of her own.

"Hey Aria, what is the date today?" Spencer asked, concern ebbing at her own voice.

"April 19th, why?" Aria impatiently asked.

Spencer was trying to remember when she was due, and was slightly shocked at the number. It was normal for her to be late, but never this late.

"Whats wrong Spencer? Are you late too?" Aria sarcastically added.

Aria was met with silence on the other line.

"Don't tell me that you might be pregnant too. I can't believe this." Aria exasperatingly responded.

"Can you come over to the barn? Buy a couple tests along the way." Spencer murmured.

"I'll be right there." Aria said, and then promptly hung up.

Spencer couldn't believe it. She couldn't be pregnant. That was the reason her and Toby broke up in the first place. Spencer suddenly wondered if she had used protection with Toby or Caleb. She couldn't remember, not at all.


A few moments later Aria knocked on the door. She had a grocery bag full of pregnancy tests, they were the expensive brand too.

Spencer immediately wrapped her tiny friend in a hug.

"Do you want to go first?" Spencer asked.

"Sure." Aria responded. She took a handful of pregnancy tests and headed towards the bathroom.

About a minute later she emerged, with a glum look on her face.

"They take five minutes to get the results. Go ahead and take your tests now." Aria murmured.

"Okay, thanks." Spencer responded, her voice barely above a whisper.


Five minutes later the girls had laid out their tests on the coffee table, nervously awaiting their results. They were both curled up on the sofa, not wanting to know the answers the tests revealed, while also, desperately wanting to know.

Spencer heard the timer go off in the kitchen, knowing the tests were ready the girls both got up at the same time to look at their tests. Spencer couldn't bring herself to look at the results, but Aria could. Spencer suddenly heard a high-pitched scream from her friend.


Hey everybody! Sorry this chapter took so long to post, its been a crazy week. I'm sorry to say that the next few weeks might be just like this. The only time that I'm able to write seems to be the weekend. If I get to a total of twenty reviews I will try and update before Saturday, 8/27. If not, I'll see you then. If you have any ideas for how you want the story to go just PM me or review, I'll get the message either way. I want to see who you guys think is pregnant, both of them, one of them, or neither one. Put your guess in the review section! Thanks for reading!