House Finarfin on House Feanor:

House of Finarfin on House of Feanor: With friends like these, who needs enemies?

In more Detail:

On Feanor:

Finrod on Feanor:

If he ever leaves Mandos, I hope he learns wisdom and compassion first.

Angrod on Feanor:

I hate to say this, but I'm glad he's dead.

Aegnor on Feanor:

Rash fool, and we were fools to trust him. Yet, here we are, and life goes on. I quite like Middle-earth, actually. I was bored in Valinor.

Galadriel on Feanor:

I despised him, and would not give him so much as a hair from my head… my opinion of him has gotten even worse now he's done so much harm.

Orodreth on Feanor:

Did he go mad after his father's death? Why did his madness have to doom the rest of us? I wish I stayed with Finarfin.

Finduilas on Feanor, Caranthir, Amrod, and Amras:

I've never met any of them, and I've no real desire to.

Gil-galad on Feanor:

How on Arda did you manage to make such a mess? You had the world handed to you on a silver platter, and you broke it.

On Maedhros:

Finrod on Maedhros:

I am so glad his younger brothers aren't mine. I am impressed by his tenacity and courage in surviving what Morgoth did to him, as well as his willingness to give up the crown for the good of the Noldor. If only he'd had the courage to defy his father sooner…

Angrod on Maedhros:

He is charming, so long as I don't look at the missing hand. I keep thinking how much that had to have hurt.

Aegnor on Maedhros:

Much as I like his younger brothers, I am so glad I'm not their liege lord.

Galadriel on Maedhros:

It is impressive that he remained sane so long, but that does not undo the damage he did. Such a shame. He was a good person before the oath and all that came after.

Orodreth on Maedhros:

No, I won't take part in your battle. No offense. So long as you tolerate those who connived at Finrod's death by torture, I want nothing to do with you.

Finduilas on Maedhros:

I remember him. He has the most amazing hair. I wanted to touch it, but those scars, and his height, made him too intimidating for me to dare ask. The handless wrist is creepy.

Gil-galad on Maedhros:

I fear whatever good was in him was destroyed by the oath. I will not stay my hand against him, should he raise his own against any of my people.

On Maglor:

Finrod on Maglor:

I wish Maglor had been born into another family. He would be happier, and I wouldn't feel guilty about liking him.

Angrod on Maglor:

A party just isn't a party without him singing. I find it hard to understand how he could leave Maedhros there like that, though…

Aegnor on Maglor:

I was so surprised to find him High King when we arrived – not to mention married! He was overjoyed when Fingon brought Maedhros back. He never wanted the crown.

Galadriel on Maglor:

If you're reading this Makalaure, Elrond is worried about you. Please send him a letter, at the least.

Orodreth on Maglor:

The easiest Feanorian for me to get along with. Poetry discussions are a useful way to hide ill feelings.

Finduilas on Maglor:

His singing voice is amazing. He has a nice laugh, too.

Gil-galad on Maglor:

Elrond is looking for you. He's very upset. Please contact him, and at least let him know that you are alive.

On Celegorm:

Finrod on Celegorm and Curufin:

I still can't believe they betrayed me like that. Well, I suppose I must, but I don't want to.

Angrod on Celegorm:

He is great fun to spend time with, when the oath isn't involved.

Aegnor on Celegorm:

Fun so long as he isn't angry. He really does have an awful temper, especially these days.

Galadriel on Celegorm:

Charming when he's happy, but he has the most appalling temper, and his ethics leave much to be desired.

Orodreth on Celegorm and Curufin:

If they ever show their faces around me and mine again, it will be the last thing they ever do.

Finduilas on Celegorm:

Cruel and untrustworthy. I hope I never meet him again, and I wish I had never met him.

Gil-galad on Celegorm:

Nasty piece of work. I find it hard to understand how he could do that to Finrod, especially after having seen what captivity did to his own brother. Then to leave children to die like that… was he an orc disguised as an elf?

On Caranthir:

Finrod on Caranthir:

Oh no, not him again! The man's a diplomatic disaster waiting for an opportunity. Thank Eru he will never meet Elu Thingol.

Angrod on Caranthir:

I can't believe I'm related to that obnoxious git.

Aegnor on Caranthir:

Caranthir is a pain in the rear.

Galadriel on Caranthir:

He was angry all the time, which did not make him pleasant to be around.

Orodreth on Caranthir:

I am glad he lives so far away these days.

Finduilas on Caranthir, Feanor, Amrod, and Amras:

I've never met any of them, and I've no real desire to. Especially Caranthir. I've heard too many stories about him.

Gil-galad on Caranthir:

A Feanorian I will never meet due to him dying while killing other elves over the silmarils.

On Curufin:

Finrod on Celegorm and Curufin:

I still can't believe they betrayed me like that. Well, I suppose I must, but I don't want to.

Angrod on Curufin:

Not as bad as he's painted, honest! Well, except for the oath and so on.

Aegnor on Curufin:

Is surprisingly entertaining once you get to know him. He has a talent for mimicry and a sarcastic streak. Damn his father. Being Feanor's favorite was more of a burden than he lets on.

Galadriel on Curufin:

He and Celegorm are lucky we never crossed paths after they betrayed my brother.

Orodreth on Celegorm and Curufin:

If they ever show their faces around me and mine again, it will be the last thing they ever do.

Finduilas on Curufin:

Quieter than Celegorm, but every bit as nasty. If he dies fighting Morgoth, I will not shed a tear for him.

Gil-galad on Curufin:

Not quite as bad as Celegorm. At least he wasn't involved in those poor children's demise.

On Amrod:

Finrod on Amrod:

The poor child.

Angrod on Amrod:

Why did we have to have such similar names? Someone calls one of us, and both of us answer! Until his father burnt him to death on the ships. Never thought I'd pity a Feanorian.

Aegnor on Amrod:

I miss him. Still can't believe his own father did that.

Galadriel on Amrod and Amras:

I hate to admit this, but I kept getting them confused. Sadly, that is no longer a problem.

Orodreth on Amrod:

I never really knew him, but I feel sorry for him. He was led astray by bad company he did not choose. Not so much unlike me, though at least I never killed anyone or took oaths of horror.

Finduilas on Amrod and Amras:

I've never met any of them, and I've no real desire to.

Gil-galad on Amrod:

A horrible way to die, but perhaps less cruel than what he might have gone through had he lived to kill and die over the silmarils with his twin.

On Amras:

Finrod on Amras:

I wonder a little about his sanity these days. To lose his twin like that – it does not bear thinking on.

Angrod on Amras:

He seems a little lost sometimes.

Aegnor on Amras:

He's quieter than he used to be, and has developed an obsession with hunting. If you get him and Celegorm together in a room, it's all they'll talk about.

Galadriel on Amrod and Amras:

I hate to admit this, but I kept getting them confused. That is no longer a problem, alas.

Orodreth on Amras:

I haven't seen him in ages, and never knew him well. He's still a doomed son of Feanor, though, so I don't want to.

Finduilas on Amrod, and Amras:

I've never met them, and I've no real desire to.

Gil-galad on Amras:

Another Feanorian to die over those bloody silmarils. At least he's one less to continue spilling blood for their oath.

On Celebrimbor:

Finrod on Celebrimbor:

He has a lot of potential, if he can be coaxed out of his father's shadow before he gets dragged into his family's doom.

Angrod on Celebrimbor:

It's kind of cute, actually, the way he follows his father around like a puppy.

Aegnor on Celebrimbor:

He may look like his father and Feanor, and have their famous crafting skill, but he's a lot gentler in temperament. Unfortunately, he appears to lack Curufin's political skill. Instead, he causes offense by accident and doesn't understand why. Curufin needs to criticize less and explain more.

Galadriel on Celebrimbor:

A Feanorian who hasn't sworn the oath or killed innocents! He really is brilliant at his craft, but I see the shadow of our Doom lying heavily on him. I must keep an eye on him and guide him.

Orodreth on Celebrimbor:

I suppose he's ok. I'm keeping an eye on him just in case he gets any ideas, though.

Finduilas on Celebrimbor:

He's sort of weird. He spends all his time in the forge making things, writing out equations, and muttering to himself.

Gil-galad on Celebrimbor:

Are you really that politically inept, or are you putting it on? No, don't… Apparently smart people can be really stupid. Oh dear. Now I have another mess to clean up.