Hello, everyone! We FINALLY have a tie breaker! Drum roll please...the winner is:...

Before I announce the winning emotion, a quick shout out!

A big thanks to everyone for participating in the poll and a big thank you to everyone for all the wonderful feedback that you have given me over the past few years! Another big thank you for those who gave this story a chance! I really appreciate you taking the time to read my story! One more thank you: to the loyal readers! You guys have been so patient and I'm so glad that you all waited for this moment.

...

I will try my best to keep the story going, and I will be going back through and fixing any grammatical/spelling/loophole errors that I find.

...

One more BIG thing: thanks to everyone for the amazing 2,500 views! Thank you so very much!

...

And the winner is: Attraction!

Without further ado, let the reading commence! I don't own rights to Fairy Tail or its characters! This chapter will have two parts, one for GraLu and one for NaLu. Each chapter will be marked accordingly, so if you are a fan of one but not the other, you can skip the chapter you don't wish to read.

Normal

Flashbacks


Frozen and Forgotten Feelings

Undeniable Attractions-Part 1: GrayXLucy

Lucy POV

"Lucy, why aren't there any colors in that image?" The boy before me whispered as the image wavered like an old lacrimal.

I remained silent as my eyes met his. "Empty...nothing..." Something within me sparked as his hands rose and cupped my face, his dark eyes searching my own. My vision cleared slightly as I felt him take a step towards me. "Gray...that's all I see..."

He blinked, releasing my face. "Are you saying that you don't see any colors?" He pointed to his hair. "What color is this?"

"Gray..." I reached up and brushed my fingers over his nearly black tresses. "And before you ask, so is your skin, eyes, and clothes." He glanced down at my words, but instead of cursing himself out like I vaguely remembered, he looked at me with a strange look, one that awoke something...impossible.

"Lucy," he murmured, his eyes becoming half lidded and his voice lowering slightly. "Be honest, do you like me?"

My head tilted to the left as my eyes traveled downward. Besides the black symbol on his bare chest, the scar above his right eye, and the scar on his torso, his body was spotless. The muscles in his arms and legs suggested that he was physically active, and the muscles in his chest looked as if they were chiseled from stone. "Physically, you appear around a nine out of ten. Any girl wouldn't think twice before throwing themselves at you."

He shook his head. "That's not what I asked you," his voice lowered even more. "I wanted to know if you liked me, not what others would think." His hands rose and grasped my arms, pulling me against him.

The strange feeling from before sparked the second his hands touched my arms and something in my chest faltered as my hands rested against his chest. The strange feeling set my nerves on edge and made every hair on my body stand up. His muscles were firm, but they were cushioned by his pale skin.

"Are you feeling anything?" he whispered, his lips brushing my ear. "Or am I just imagining this spark?"

Spark? As in, electricity? "Explain."

The strange feeling intensified as his hands rested on my waist, his fingers brushing the top of my skirt. "Your mind may have forgotten many things," he rested his forehead against mine. "But your body knows what it wants."

What my body wants? I looked down at my hands as questions filled my mind. What did he mean by that? Why was he holding me in such a manner? "Why am I letting you do this?"

His hands rose until they were nearly brushing my chest. "You haven't stopped me yet," his lips brushed my cheek, sending something shooting through my body. "I'll stop the second you tell me to, Lucy, but I want you to tell me what you are feeling until then." A shiver shot down my spine as his hands suddenly dropped to rest on my rear and pressed his hips against mine. "How does this make you feel?"

...

I was pushed up against the wall by Gray, his hands keeping my own above my head. "Tell me what you are feeling."

My spine stiffened. "I don't know, I can't put a name to it!"

"How does it make you perceive yourself?"

"Like I'm a nuisance!" I shouted, my head hanging.

His hands slowly released my wrists, but kept his hands on either side of my head, blocking off any way of escape. "Lucy, you're feeling guilty for all this, but you need to get over it."

My head shot upward at his harsh tone, my temper flaring. "Excuse me?"

"You heard me," he said, his voice low. "Get. Over. It. We would do anything to help you, Lucy," he whispered, sliding until we were sitting. "You are very special to us, as well as the guild; we are a team, a family."

...

"Can I show you something?" Gray wrapped his arms around me, squeezing me tightly. "I saw that memory you just saw, and I want to help complete it." I felt something rise from within me, filling my mind with images.

...

Fingers gently tilted my chin upward until my eyes met his. "When I first met you, I thought that you were like any other chick, nothing too incredibly special. That changed though as I got to know you more, and I felt guilty for putting you in the same category as normal girls," he smiled. "I've come to think of you as a really close friend, a sister, a comrade. You are truly unique, Lucy, and I don't want you to ever forget it."

...

My words cut off as a hazy image of a group of people appeared in my minds' eye. They were all smiling and waving to me, and many of them were crying as they drew me into hugs. My eyes fell on the blue insignia before me then to the matching pink one on my hand. "Fairy...Tail..."

...

The air was filled with the various sounds of cracks and yells along with flying food. There was a navy haired man that was especially loud and was butting heads with a pink haired man. A girl from the bar yelled something about clothes, which brought his lack of attire to my attention. "Excuse me, miss," I blushed as naked navy haired man approached. He held out his hand, bowing slightly. "Could I please borrow your underwear?"

...

My hands clenched. How was I supposed to explain what I was feeling when I didn't understand them myself? "Nothing...makes sense... I don't understand..." I inhaled sharply as another memory flashed before my eyes.

...

I froze as ice cold fingers were touching me, leaving burning trails and causing every hair on my body to stand straight. The hands were unfamiliar and large, making me feel incredibly small and fragile. There was a strange mist gathering around me and it blurred everything in sight. My hair brush fell from my hand and clattered to the tiled bathroom floor as the hands drew me backwards and enclosed around me.

...

Every cell in my body felt like it was frozen. "Who was that? What did they-" Something felt wrong... Horribly wrong. Blinking, I looked down at the arms holding me. The skin was a familiar light olive and was cool to the touch, and the firm muscles under my hands rippled as I shifted slightly. Something felt off though and my face felt strange, as if I had been in the sun too long as I looked down farther. "Um, Gray?"

He drew back, his hands cupping my face and searching my eyes. "Did you remember anything?"

I nodded, hiding my face in my hands. "I've remembered a few things, and I want you to let go of me. Right now." He hesitantly stepped back from me, his arms falling to his sides. "I remembered a lot of things, Gray, including the fact that you are naked."


Well everyone? What did you think! Don't worry, I'll upload the NatsuXLucy chapter when I've finished with it! Please be patient, okay?