Jekyll and Hyde

Chapter 2

It had been a couple of months since the Shield, as they were now called, had first debuted by saving CM Punk's little sister. An interesting pattern had set itself up in that time that had the WWE Universe in stitches from laughing so hard. The cameras were constantly catching Dean Ambrose flirting with Amalthea Brooks and trying to seduce her, only to fail miserable as she shot him down every single time. Phil would be put in a match against someone wanting his title, often Ryback or another equally large male, and the second it looked like Amalthea was in any kind of danger the Shield would come racing in to begin the beat down on whichever idiot was stupid enough to target her. The fans were often torn between cheering and booing when it came to the Shield. They would cheer when they rescued Amalthea, but they would boo when they went out and randomly attacked superstars they didn't like. This night was different though…this time Phil was having to face the Rock…who Amalthea found out was Roman's cousin.

"So…let me get this straight…you're related to the Rock? Seriously?"

"Yeah Babygirl. He's my cousin. We don't see each other often though. The Usos are my cousins too."

"How the hell big is your family?"

"Pretty big Babygirl…pretty big."

"You'll introduce me to him right? Please?"

"Don't give me that little puppy face of yours Babygirl…I'll introduce you."

The little squeal of happiness she made had all of the men in the room laughing softly, one of them watching her with an unusually soft look on his face. Phil leaned over to speak to Dean in a low voice.

"I know you're interested in her, and because you've been keeping her safe I'm going to tell you something she doesn't want you to know."

"What might that be Punk?"

"She's attracted to you…but she's afraid to give in and be with you. She's kind of had it rough in relationships and she doesn't trust easily…she also has a bit of a dark side, as I'm sure you've noticed whenever I get really hurt out there."

"Yeah…I've noticed. She kind of snaps and it's like a whole other side of her comes out."

"You're not far from the truth. You and she have more in common than you might think Ambrose. Just like you have another person in there…so does she, and that other person doesn't take shit from anyone and tends to react violently if someone she cares about is hurt."

Dean just sat there for a while, letting all of that information sink in while he had a mental conversation with Moxley. No one seemed to notice he'd zoned out except Amalthea who watched him with a concerned frown on her face.

"Mox…were you listening to all that?"

"Yeah…our little spitfire just got even more interesting."

"I knew she was interested but I couldn't figure out why she kept resisting…now I think I get it. She's not afraid of us…she's more afraid of getting hurt emotionally..."

"So we just need to prove that we're not gonna hurt her like that. She's watching us Dean…best go back to reality now."

Dean shook his head a bit and gave Amalthea a crooked little grin that earned him an eyeroll. She had moved to stand in front of him when he didn't respond to her calling his name and when she turned to leave he gently grabbed her wrist and pulled her down into his lap.

"Hey there darlin'."

"Dean…let go."

She sounded more resigned than annoyed so he just wrapped his arms around her waist and buried his nose into her hair. She huffed softly at him and crossed her arms, intent on ignoring him if he wasn't going to let go anytime soon. Dean made it impossible to ignore him when he started to gently nibble on the back of her neck where no one could see what he was doing, feeling her shiver against him as her body reacted.

"Dean…stop that right now….I'm not kidding…"

She elbowed him in the side which forced him to let her go, at which point she immediately planted herself between Roman and Seth, snuggling into Roman's side as the big Samoan wrapped an arm around her and gave his brother an amused look. Roman and Seth had become like surrogate brothers to Amalthea in their time spent together backstage and they were almost as protective of her as Dean was. Phil just watched Dean's face fall into a pout and had to bite his lip to keep from laughing, his brothers had no such problem. When it was time for Phil's match the two siblings went out to the ring and Phil did his usual trash talking before the match started, with the Rock trash-talking right back at him. The only mistake the Rock made was when he started trash-talking Amalthea, saying that she must be a good slut if she had all three members of the Shield wanting to keep her safe. The look of hurt on her face set Dean off to the point Roman had to almost sit on him to make him stay put, though he needn't have worried. Amalthea walked up to the Rock and backhanded him hard enough to leave a big mark on his face.

"How dare you accuse ME of being a slut just because I have friends who are willing to protect me. Not that it's any of your business Rock…but I happen to still be a virgin. Before you go insulting people and calling them horrid names…maybe you should take a long hard look in the mirror."

She dropped the microphone and turned into her brother's waiting arms as he hugged her before leading her over to the announcer's table. JBL was glaring hard at the Rock as he wrapped a comforting arm around the poor woman, even he would never cross that line with someone as sweet as her. The Rock looked upset at having made the girl cry, he'd thought she was like her brother but apparently he'd been wrong. He started to move in her direction to apologize but was cut off by Punk's fist hitting his jaw as the man screamed at him for hurting his baby sister. The match went on for a long time until the Shield decided to get involved. They stood close to Amalthea after coming out through the crowd, looking like bodyguards and glaring at the Rock. Dean was standing right behind Amalthea with his hands on her shoulders as he massaged them a bit to try and soothe her, which seemed to be working as she relaxed a little, and he glared over the top of her head with a look that sent most men running for cover backstage. As soon as the Rock tried to go for the cover The Shield descended on him like a pack of hungry dogs. Phil rolled out of the ring as the Ref called the DQ and went to his sister's side pulling her into a hug as they watched the Shield beat and kick the hell out of the Rock, Amalthea was smirking rather wickedly as she listened to the shit Dean was growling at the Rock as he hit him repeatedly. The Authority's music hit and Vince McMahon walked out onto the stage with a microphone, Triple H right behind him with Stephanie at his side.

"CM Punk…and Miss Amalthea. To you Miss Amalthea…I do apologize for the Rock's behavior towards you. He should never have said such a vile thing to such a sweet girl. That being said…I am getting sick and tired of CM Punk's little Shield interfering on his behalf…"

"Whoah, whoah, whoah…hold it right there Vince. These guys don't work for me. They only come out when Amalthea is in trouble because they like her. They don't come out here to help me, trust me there is no love lost there. They've been attacking a lot of people in this company."

"None the less…You will be facing the Rock at the TLC pay-per-view for the title…and if the Shield interferes you will be stripped of the title."

The Authority left the stage, and Phil stormed off backstage looking angry and leaving Amalthea standing there looking a bit lost. Dean walked over to her and started to lead her to the barricade, pausing for a moment when she pulled back from him.

"What's the matter Darlin'?"

"I…I can't go through the crowd Dean."

"Why not?"

"What if people try and touch me?"

"I won't let them get close enough Darlin', neither will these two. We'll keep you between the three of us so no one can reach you alright? Trust us Darlin'?"

She hesitated a moment longer but nodded and allowed him to jump the barricade before lifting her over to join him, Roman and Seth jumping over as well before the three men surrounded her like a literal shield. They led her through the screaming fans and up into the skybox they'd been given for the night where dean immediately, but gently, pushed her into a plush chair.

"Sit down Darlin', you look like you're gonna pass out on me here."

"I'm not…I'll be fine."

"Hey, look at me Darlin'. Don't let that bastard get inside your pretty little head alright? You are so much better than anyone here…I mean that."

"Thanks Dean."

The room was enveloped in a comfortable silence for a while before Amalthea spoke up again, her voice soft and hesitant as she gently laid a hand on Dean's arm.

"Hey Dean? How…um…how is Moxley doing?"

Dean turned to her with an amused little smirk on his lips and mischief dancing in his blue eyes.

"Aww…you worried about me sugar? I'm touched…really."

She rolled her eyes at him and huffed softly in irritation, making him give a short laugh in response. Moxley loved to rile her up anytime he got to come out because seeing her flushed with anger excited him.

"If you're going to act like a jackass then I won't bother to worry about you anymore."

"Aww…don't be like that sugar. I like having you worry about me…makes me feel all warm inside."

"I think that's your ego inflating."

Roman and Seth collapsed against each other in a fit of laughter. They loved listening to her dish Moxley's shit right back to him. Moxley just gave her a little smirk before wrapping his arms around her and squeezing her ass with his hands, earning him a slap to the face as she squeaked and turned bright red. He let out one of those dark chuckles that sent chills down her spine, though they were good chills, and made every hair on her body stand up.

"Careful there spitfire…you don't want to start a fight you can't finish. You know what happens with me when a woman fights back. It just turns me on and makes me want to force her into submission."

Amalthea felt like her whole body had caught fire as he spoke those words in her ear with a low, almost menacing tone. He placed one hand on the back of her head, leaving the other one resting on her ass as his brothers pretended to be busy watching the show, and pulled her in for a hard kiss that left her breathless and clinging to his muscular arms. Once he pulled back and looked at her that infuriating smirk came back and she snapped out of the daze he'd managed to put her in, slapping him again and storming out of the room tog o find her brother. After she left Moxley rubbed his jaw and laughed.

"Little spitfire…god I love it when she fights back."

"Easy Mox…you heard what she said to my idiot cousin right? You gotta take it easy and be careful with her."

"I know this. Why do you think I let Dean stay in control so much? She's not ready to handle me full on yet."

Amalthea found her brother in his locker room throwing things around in his anger. She stayed outside the room with Paul, who had been watching with a concerned look on his face, until he calmed down enough that he was only pacing. With a heavy sigh she walked into the room and stood in her brother's path, stepping back a bit as he leveled a harsh glare at her.

"This is your fault. If you hadn't been there they would have stayed out of it."

"Are you hearing yourself right now? Paul hired them to help you dumbass, not me. They only help me when I'm in danger…and that's mostly because Dean comes rushing out and the other two come with him."

"Did you hear what Vince said out there? Were you even paying attention or were you too busy being a little baby to notice anything else?"

Amalthea slapped Phil and ran out of the room, heading straight to AJ who listened to her and tried to make her feel better. AJ knew Phil was under a lot of pressure trying to keep his title, but she also thought he loved his sister enough to not hurt her like that. AJ sighed softly and asked her friend Kaitlyn to do her a favor and find the Shield.

"What? Why? I don't want to go near those guys…they're dangerous AJ."

"I know…but they also care about her and right now I think she needs them…and I need to go knock some sense into her idiot brother."

Kaitlyn sighed but one look at Amalthea crying in AJ's arms was enough to make her steel her nerves and go find the most dangerous group in the WWE. She found them heading for catering and stopped them, flinching back when they turned to look at her.

"Umm…AJ…AJ sent me to find you three…um…Amalthea…she came running into the Diva's locker room…she's really upset and crying…"

That was all she managed to get out before the three men were off and running, Dean outpacing his brothers by several feet as he literally slid into the Diva's locker room, ignoring the few that shouted at him that men weren't allowed. He went straight to Amalthea and pulled her into his arms, looking over to AJ for an explanation when he realized Amalthea was too upset to say anything yet.

"The fuck happened to make her cry? Who's ass do I have to beat down?"

"From what I managed to get out of her she went to Phil's locker room and he was throwing shit around and then he started screaming at her, blaming her for what Vince did tonight. I'm going to go try and talk some sense into him. I know he's under a lot of pressure but that's no excuse for upsetting her like this."

AJ left the room to go find her Fiance while Dean lifted Amalthea into his arms and carried her back to the skybox. Seth went to catering and grabbed some snacks and water, as well as a Kit-Kat bar for Amalthea since it was her favorite. He entered the skybox to see Amalthea curled up in Dean's lap while Roman was rubbing her back and both men where speaking to her in soft tones, something that was only heard from Dean when she was around.

"Hey sweetheart…I brought you a Kit-Kat bar. If you give us a little smile you can have it ok?"

She gave Seth a small watery smile and he handed over the chocolate, laughing softly when she sniffed it before practically inhaling it. She remained in Dean's lap, not wanting to move because he made her feel safe and protected. Roman and Seth sat nearby, each of them having a hand on her back so she knew they were with her too. Meanwhile AJ had gone into Phil's locker room with her 'crazy face' on and Paul quickly left the area rather than face the wrath of the tiny diva.

"AJ…"

"What the actual FUCK is wrong with you?! She is your baby sister and you hurt her. She came running to me in tears because of you. It isn't her fault that her friends want to protect her and avenge any wrong done to her. You're supposed to protect and care for her, not accuse and insult her. You are sleeping alone tonight. I'm going to room with Kaitlyn and Amalthea is going to room with the Shield. At least they can keep her safe."

AJ left before Phil could even get a word out of his mouth, slamming the door behind her. She found Kaitlyn first and told her what she'd told Phil, gaining a high fice from her friend.

"You can room with me anytime AJ, now go tell Amalthea your little plan so she knows where she's sleeping tonight…if she doesn't snap at you for it."

AJ winced a bit but she knew Amalthea would be better off with the Shield tonight than with her brother and his temper. She finally found them after threatening a member of the production crew who pointed her to the skybox. She quietly knocked on the door and smiled at Seth when he opened it.

"Can we help you?"

"I need to see Amalthea…please?"

"Let her in Seth."

Seth opened the door and let AJ into the room, where she immediately had to bite her lip to keep herself from squealing at the adorable image in front of her. Amalthea was curled up in Dean's lap, her head resting against his chest while his chin rested on top of her head and his arms wrapped around her.

"Thea? Sweetie? You ok?"

"I'll be fine April. It just hurt is all."

"I screamed at him for you."

"Thanks April."

"I also told him he's sleeping alone tonight. I'm gonna room with Kaitlyn."

"But…that'll leave me alone with him all night…April…"

"No…you'll be staying with these guys tonight. I already decided it for you so don't argue. They can keep you safe and you can avoid your idiot brother for the night."

Amalthea just blinked owlishly at her friend and felt Dean's chuckle against her skin as he found AJ amusing as all hell. Roman and Seth were already nodding in agreement with the tiny Diva.

"Yeah…that's a great idea. It'll be like a big sleepover."

"What are you ten?"

The two men started bickering back and forth and Amalthea was soon laughing herself silly while Dean smiled down at her. April slipped out of the room while they weren't paying attention and returned to Kaitlyn before heading to the hotel. Amalthea and the Shield ended up spending the night watching geek movies because she and Seth wanted to, and Dean sided with Amalthea so Roman was outnumbered. Roman was on one end of the large sofa, Seth in the middle, and at the end was Dean with Amalthea in his lap. They ended up watching the Avengers movie at one point and Dean looked amused at how badly Amalthea was into Loki.

"You do realize he's technically the bad guy right?"

"I don't give a damn…he's hot as hell…and he has that whole dark thing going for him too."

Dean's blue eyes seemed to almost glow in the light from the TV as he looked down at her, the blue growing a bit darker in color as Moxley took over.

"Is that so sugar? You like your men dark huh?"

"Hmm? Yeah…Loki's got this crazy dark side but he can be really sweet too…like when he's with his mother."

She didn't even realize Dean and Moxley had changed places as she was so focused on the movie. Roman had gone to bed before this movie had even started and Seth had crawled off halfway into it when his eyes refused to stay open anymore, leaving Dean and Amalthea alone in the lounge space. Moxley carefully ran his hands up her sides and leaned in to nibble on the back of her neck, letting out a low growl when she squirmed in his lap and made a soft mewling sound.

"Sounds like I've got a little kitten in my hands…you gonna purr for me kitten?"

"Dean? What are you doing?"

"Not Dean kitten…he's watching though. I want to taste you kitten…"

Amalthea's eyes widened slightly when she realized this was Moxley and not Dean. Moxley was more unpredictable, and tended to be a lot more dominating than Dean was.

"Mox…I…"

"Hush little kitten. I'm not gonna hurt you. I just wanna taste…just a little taste kitten…"

Amalthea let out a soft gasp when one of Moxley's hands slid between her legs, resting atop her cloth-covered sex. Her entire body shivered at his touch and her hands grabbed onto his arms with a tight grip.

"M…Mox…What…?"

"Shh…just relax kitten. I'm not gonna hurt you…just relax and trust me."

She whimpered softly and he groaned in her ear, the sound making him hard as a rock in an instant. He started moving his hand, rubbing her gently and making her squirm in his lap and whimper softly in his ear as her head fell back to lay on his shoulder. When her whimpers grew more intense he slid his hand up a bit and slipped it under the waistband of the little shorts she was wearing, making her gasp in surprise as his warm fingers began to stroke the sensitive flesh between her thighs. Her hand tightened on his arms in a death grip, nails digging into his skin, but he just shrugged off the pain and focused one her.

"Mox…Moxley pelase…"

"Please what kitten?"

"I…I need…please…"

Moxley hid his satisfied smirk in her hair as she failed to find words. He knew what she needed though and he slid a finger inside her slick folds, earning a high keening whine that sent all of his blood rushing south.

"Ah, fuck kitten…my little spitfire…do you have any idea what you do to me? What you do to dean? Hmm? You make us both crazy for you pet."

He lifted her with one arm, the other still moving a finger in and out of her, carrying her into his room and laying her on the bed. She panted at him, her chest heaving with harsh breaths as she looked up at him with hesitant trust in her eyes. Moxley ran his free hand along her thigh and up her body to gently push her down onto her back.

"Relax kitten…I'm gonna make your pretty little body sing for me…"

He placed her hand next to her head and told her to leave them there or he'd stop, waiting until she said she understood before sliding down her body until he was crouching between her legs. It took him only a few seconds to slide her little shorts off entirely, groaning deep in his throat at the sight of her glistening sex just waiting for him to ravage it. He placed gentle kisses and licks all the way up one thigh and then the other before placing a single feather-light kiss to her sex, chuckling softly when she jumped in surprise.

"What's the matter kitten? You never had a man touch this before?"

"Umm…n…no…I…"

"It's alright kitten. I'll make it good…believe that."

Moxley was amazed that she'd never even been touched by a man's hand, but in a way he was also happy. It meant he'd be her first everything and for some reason that made him feel all warm inside and soothed his jealous possessive side. Dean was silent in his head, just watching with rapt attention and sharing the feelings of what Moxley was doing to her. Moxley leaned in and began feasting on her sex, licking, sucking, and even nipping the sensitive flesh until she was squirming and begging.

"Moxley…Mox…please…"

"Soon kitten…you're so close aren't you pet?"

Amalthea was helpless to do anything but nod at him, her breath coming in harsh pants and her hands fisted in the comforter to try and stay still. He started thrusting his tongue in and added a finger as well, eventually slipping in a second finger and scissoring them to open her up a bit and earning him some very pretty moans from his girl. He could tell she was teetering on the edge and moved up her body to lay next to her, the one hand keeping his fingers moving inside her while the other was stroking her hair away form her face. He slid a third finger into her and she bucked against his hand, his dark gravelly voice rolling through her as he growled into her ear.

"Come on pet…cum for me…do as I say and cum for me…right…Now."

Her back arched up off the bed and turned her head to bite into his shoulder as she flew apart and squirted all over his hand. He hissed a bit from the pain of her bit but it only made him grow harder in his pants. He knew she wasn't ready for that though, not yet. Moxley kept rubbing her clit, pulling out another two orgasms form her before she finally begged him to stop and he pulled his hand away. He lifted that hand to his mouth as she watched him with wide eyes, licking his hand to clean it and grinning at the little whimper she gave him.

"You wanna taste kitten? Here…lick my hand clean for me pet."

She hesitantly stuck her little pink tongue out to lap at his hand, moaning softly as she decided that she actually tasted pretty good, a sentiment he agreed with wholeheartedly of course. She kept licking and even sucking on his hand until he finally pulled it away from her.

"Enough pet…it's clean now. Such a good little pet aren't you. Did you like that kitten? Did you like feeling me lick you, feeling my tongue inside you? I'm not gonna do anything else tonight kitten, we have all the time you want to wait until you're ready for more. This was just a little taste of the pleasure I can give you pet. I'm gonna let Dean come back now…just know this one thing kitten…you belong to us…and we're not going to let anyone else have you or hurt you."

Dean shook his head as he came back to the front and looked down at the dark-haired angel underneath him, still panting softly as her eyes started to drift shut.

"Sleep now Darlin'. I'll watch over you."

"What about…you? You're…you know…?"

Dean let out a soft chuckle and ran his fingers through her hair, marveling at the softness of it. He'd been worried that Moxley was pushing her too far too fast, but she seemed to have enjoyed it so he relaxed a bit.

"I'll be fine Darlin'. Go to sleep and I'll be here when you wake up."

He watched her as she slept, praying to a god he hadn't believed in for a long time to help him keep her safe and keep her as his own. Dean and Moxley took turns watching over her during the night, making sure she stayed in a comfortable position and didn't have any nightmares.

A/N: I know it may seem like they're moving a bit fast but I'm timing it out so that the first chapter was 2 months before this one. Do you guys like their dynamic so far?