Sweetie Belle checked the morning paper, to find a filly named Screwtop, had not returned home yesterday. She couldn't help but grin at this. "Oh my, Sweetie have you read the paper yet? It's just dreadful" Rarity said, entering the room. "Yeah sis, it sounds terrible" Sweetie Belle lied. "Anyway, i'm off to school Rarity, bye!" Sweetie Belle ran out the door before Rarity could say anything. "Well she's in a hurry, I wonder what she's up to." Rarity thought, then went back to making dresses.
As Sweetie Belle made her way up to school, she met up with Pinkie Pie, who happened to be standing outside of sugarcube corner. "Oh, hi Pinkie Pie!" Sweetie said. "Hi Sweetie Belle, how are you doing?" Pinkie asked. "I'm doing incredible, have you read the paper yet?" Sweetie Belle replied. "Oh yeah! Great job Sweetie Belle! I'm so proud of you, was it also your first?" Pinkie asked. "Yeah.. to be honest, it was kinda scary Pinkie, I cant believe I actually killed a little filly, just like that" Sweetie said and lowered her head. "Aww dont worry Sweetie Belle, I sorta felt that way when I killed my first pony too, but you will get used to it" Pinkie said to cheer her up. "You know what? You're right Pinkie, and i'm gonna find a new victim today" Sweetie said, standing tall. "That's the spirit!" Pinkie cheered, then Sweetie Belle Trotted off on the way to school.
Sweetie Belle trotted as fast as she could to school, but as she walked through the door, she was greeted with a familiar unpleasant voice. "Well well well, if it isnt blank flank" Diamond Tiara and Silver Spoon snickered. "What do you want now Diamond Tiara" Sweetie stared in anger at her. "Oh nothing, oh wait, did you hear about the papers?" Diamond asked, "Y-yeah, why?" Sweetie Belle questioned, even though she knew she caused the disappearance of Screwtop. "Better be careful little blank flank, hope you dont end up missing like that sad low-life filly" Diamond tiara warned sarcastically and Silver Spoon snickered. This did make Sweetie Belle really angry, she wanted to hit Diamond Tiara right in the face, however, Applebloom and Scootaloo walked right in front of Sweetie Belle. "Y'all best get outta here before we get Miss Cheerilee" Applebloom said. Diamond Tiara Growled at hearing this "Fine" she said, "but dont expect me to get back at you later" she warned, then trotted away. "You alright Sweetie Belle?" Scootaloo asked. "I'm fine" She mumbled. "What on earth did she say to you Sweetie Belle? Ah'v never seen you like this before" Applebloom started questioning her friend. "It's nothing guys, Applebloom, i'll tell you at recess" Sweetie said. "Alrighty then" Applebloom replied.
The school bell rang after class. "Recess time!" Miss Cheerilee said, Applebloom walked out the door after Sweetie Belle, who was headed to a tree near the corner of the playground where nopony went. "Alright Sweetie Belle what's going on with ya?" Applebloom asked.
"It was was Diamond Tiara said about the newspapers, she wanted me to go missing like the filly did" She answered, "But here's the truth Applebloom, and please don't tell anypony what i'm about to tell you" she pleaded. "You have my word Sweetie Belle" Applebloom said "Pinkie Promise" they giggled. "That filly on the papers, Screwtop, I killed her applebloom, I killed her and baked her into pancakes" Sweetie Belle lowered her head. "Woah, that's incredible Sweetie Belle! I didnt know you had it in ya" Applebloom said. "Y-you're not mad?" Sweetie asked, eyes tearing up a little. "Of course I aint mad at you, didnt Miss Pinkie Pie tell you? I work with her on making her pastries, ya know? Killing ponies and baking them into cupcakes?" Applebloom comforted her friend. "Woah really?" Sweetie Belle looked at Applebloom, actually not knowing this information. "Yup" she answered. "Say, hows about I join you and we can make pancakes together?" Applebloom said as an idea. "I'd love to! It's always nice to have some company". "Alrighty then, i'll ask Miss Pinkie Pie if that's alright and we can pick a pony today" Applebloom said. "No worries Applebloom, I got a certain somepony in mind to play with us" she smiled, Applebloom smiled back. "Now lets finish up class and go meet Pinkie Pie" Sweetie motioned to leave. "Right" Applebloom followed after after Sweetie Belle, smiling even more knowing that one of her closest friends makes pastries just like she does, and in the same way.
Sweetie Belle was walking down a path until she saw Diamond Tiara alone by a tree reading a fashion magazine. Sweetie Belle brewed a clever idea that instead of putting Diamond to sleep, she would trick her instead, besides, it was difficult carrying a filly, let alone a mare or stallion all the way to her hideout to play. She hardly got Screwtop to the secret hideout without getting caught, but she was lucky. Sweetie Belle walked up to Diamond Tiara and she looked up, making a frown. "What do you want now blank flank?" She said, angrily. "Diamond Tiara, I need your help doing something really important" Sweetie said. "And what is that?" Diamond Tiara said, annoyed. "I want you to help me pull a real prank on Scootaloo and Applebloom in a new hideout they made without me, I think they dont like me anymore and I was hoping you would want to do something really mean to them together" Sweetie said convincingly. Diamond Tiara churned up her snout and looked suspiciously at Sweetie Belle. "Why should I believe you blank flank?" She started to question Sweetie. "Well I know you hate Applebloom and Scootaloo for fact, and you dont like me either, but knowing you, I know you would do such a thing like I just said" Sweetie said. Sweetie Belle was right Diamond Tiara thought she did hate the three fillies, and she would do many mean things to them, besides, she vowed to make them pay earlier. "Fine, i'll help you, but this will not make us friends" Diamond finally said. "Good, follow me and i'll show you the hideout" Sweetie said, and the two fillies walked off.
"Alright blank flank, now where is this hideout" Diamond Tiara was eager to do some bad deeds. "Just a little further Diamond Tiara, dont get your tail in a twist" Sweetie Belle said, annoyed at her. After a few more yards, Sweetie Belle finally said "Alright we're here". Diamond Tiara looked around then stared at Sweetie Belle questioningly "Where? I dont see a hideout" she said. "Its right down there, just look and you will see them" she pointed to a hole in the ground with a hidden door. Diamond Tiara peered down the hole, but did not see anything "I dont
see anypony down Ther-" WHAM! Sweetie Belle struck Diamond Tiara in the back of the head, making her fall down the hole, then sweetie went down after her to begin her work.
After a few hours, Diamond Tiara finally wakes up, peering around a dark room, she tries to move, but is restricted due to something holding her against some sort of stone cold table that was almost vertical really tight. "W-where am I? Diamond said out loud, her head still throbbing upon the impact on her head. Sweetie Belle walked into her line of view, "Wakie wakie Diamond Tiara, it's time to play" she gave a crazed smile that completely terrified Diamond Tiara. Her pupils contracted, and her smile was so big, it looked as if it resembled Pinkie Pie's own smile if it was the happiest day of her life. "Sweetie Belle?! What is happening? Why am I tied up?" Diamond Tiara started to panic a little. "Sorry Diamond Tiara, I guess we weren't going to do a prank on the girls after all" she started to snicker. "Say Diamond, do you happen to remember the paper this morning?" She asked, "Y-yes, why?" She trembled. "I'm the one who did it, that missing pony? I killed her and cooked her up into sweet sweet pancakes, ever noticed my cooking got better?" She smiled at Diamond Tiara and added "You are going to have a rich flavour when i'm done with you" she laughed maniacally. "Wait...What?!" Diamond Tiara started to struggle against her bonds, but it was useless, she was tied down too tight. "Please dont kill me, i'll give you anything!" She tried to plead to the white unicorn filly, but she only laughed at her pathetic attempts to trick her. "You arent going anywhere Diamond Tiara, you know why?" She stood for a moment as if she was waiting for a response. "It's because you went too far this morning during class, telling me that I should disappear like that little filly? I was the one who made her disappear when I killed her, and I will look forward to making you join her" Sweetie Belle made that terrifying look again, and Diamond Tiara started to cry.
Applebloom enters the lair and sees a crying Diamond Tiara and a very happy Sweetie Belle. "Did ah miss something girls?" Then both Sweetie Belle and Diamond Tiara looked at Applebloom, at first, Diamond felt relieved, but then Applebloom said "So it's Diamond Tiara we get to kill huh?" Upon hearing this, Diamond Tiara whimpered. "Applebloom?! You're part of this too?!" The little yellow filly couldn't help but smile. " I sure am" she said. "Great timing Applebloom, I was about to start, what did Pinkie Pie say about you joining?" Sweetie Belle asked. "She said it was a great idea and said I can join with you" Applebloom replied. "Oh and Miss Pinkie Pie let me take some adrenaline in case our victims are falling asleep while we play" she added. "Perfect, that means she gets to see all of it" Sweetie said with a smirk. "Want to start with the cutie marks and go from there Applebloom?" She asked. "Sure, why not, we can always use them to make memos or clothing" Applebloom answered. "NO PLEASE,!" Diamond Tiara screamed as loud as she could, but her captors only laughed. "Nopony will hear you, we are in the abandoned orchard and nopony comes here" Sweetie Belle said.
Sweetie Belle went to the left side of Diamond Tiara's flank, while Applebloom went to the right, Scalpels in hoof, and slowly, at the same time, they carved neat circles around her tiara shaped cutie mark, and with a skinning knife, cut it off. Diamond Tiara was screaming in agony as she watched her own flesh being removed from her, but this only pleased the two fillies. "I got an idea Sweetie Belle, lets take her mane and tail and we should make something incredible"
Applebloom suggested. "Great idea Applebloom" Sweetie replied. Applebloom grabbed Diamond Tiara by her mane and gave her a terrifying look, which only made Diamond Tiara whimper even more. "You wont be needing this anymore Diamond Tiara" she said. And sliced off her mane, then her tail, Diamond Tiara already this far was sobbing uncontrollably. "Hey Sweetie Belle, have you ever felt an eyeball before?" Applebloom asked. "Not yet, I never did much to my first victim, Diamond Tiara here is my second victim ever" Sweetie Belle replied. "Here, i'll let you try it" Applebloom grabs her scalpel and a spoon like tool, she sticks the spoon into Diamond Tiaras eye socket, and the eyeball popped out, after that, Applebloom cut the optical nerve, separating the eye from Diamond's head and gave it to Sweetie Belle. "It feels all wet and squishy and gooey, thats gross" she said with a laugh. Diamond Tiara was falling of consciousness at this point. "Uh oh, she's falling asleep, i'll go get the adrenaline shot ready" Applebloom said. She grabbed the needle, and jabbed it into Diamond Tiara's chest. Within seconds, Diamond Tiara's eyes burst open and she gave a gasp. "What did you do to me?!" She said. "Oh nothing special, we just gave you some adrenaline so you stay awake, we dont wanna lose you just yet" said Applebloom. Sweetie Belle was in the corner of the room putting a liquid in a container and boiling it in a cooker. "Hey Sweetie Belle, whats that?" She asked, and Diamond Tiara also looked over. "It's olive oil, I brought it with me from Rarity's Boutique, I have a great idea". After a few short minutes, Sweetie Belle comes over to Diamond Tiara with boiling and bubbly hot olive oil, and very slowly, started dripping it over areas of Diamond's body. The heat was too intense for her, and she made deafening screams as the hot liquid burned her body. After she had a little bit of the oil left, she splashed it all over Diamond Tiara's face, making her scream in so much pain, she couldn't take it anymore. Then Sweetie Belle walks up to Diamond's body, staring, Diamond Tiara looked at her, and made out a soft "Please...dont...kill..me" however, Sweetie Belle started punching Diamond Tiara with her hooves until a few bruises formed, and said "It's too late for apologies, you know what you did, and now you're gonna pay and so will Silver Spoon in due time" and she backed up to see what she had done so far. Diamond Tiara looked terrible, almost unrecognizable. Her cuties marks were gone, her mane and tail were gone, she had only one eye left, and she was covered in burns and bruises, it was quite a scary sight.
All of a sudden, Diamond Tiara starts screaming "YOU BASTARDS, I HOPE YOU BOTH BURN IN HELL!" She mostly said it because of the sorrow she felt knowing that her best friend, Silver Spoon was going to be next. This took Sweetie Belle and Applebloom by surprise, having never heard Diamond Tiara ever use such language, and they gasped. "What a potty mouth" Applebloom said. "How about we cut out her tongue, that should teach her a lesson for saying all those nasty words" she suggested. Not waiting for a response from Sweetie Belle, Applebloom already grabbed the scalpel, pulled out Diamond Tiara's tongue, and sliced it off. She screamed in pure terror, and now she cant say anything. "That was really rude Diamond Tiara, you should be ashamed, swearing is never an answer to making friends" Sweetie Belle and Applebloom started laughing. Applebloom once more walks up to Diamond Tiara and sliced off her left ear. Not being able to speak, she only screamed while blood gushed out of her mouth, then she started fading. "Again?" Sweetie Belle said, unsurprised, and grabbed another adrenaline shot and jabbed it into Diamond Tiara, her one eye eye bursting open again. "Well, It's time for the final round Diamond Tiara, it was so fun playing with you for the first time" Sweetie Belle said. She grabs the scalpel, making the traditional surgical cut one vertical line down the middle of her chest and two horizontal incisions above and below the vertical line into a pair of double-doors. Diamond Tiara couldnt help but empty the contents of her stomach, she was going to do it again until her stomach was removed, only able to cough up blood instead. Next was the liver, the lungs, pancreas, kidneys, and intestines. All that was left was Diamond Tiara's heart, However, Sweetie Belle did not want to take her heart, she slowly placed her hoof against it. The last words Diamond heard were "Goodbye you brat" and Sweetie Belle crushed her heart, sending blood all over her body. Sweetie stares at the gruesome corpse of Diamond Tiara, blood splattered everywhere, she quickly grabbed a pail and got every last drop of blood in Diamond's body and looked to Applebloom. "That's everything we need, lets cut up the body and sneak it over to Pinkie Pie" she said. "Alrighty then, and great job Sweetie Belle, you took that really well" Applebloom applauded Sweetie Belle, who only blushed. "Aww thanks Applebloom, that means alot to me." Then both fillies headed towards sugarcube corner later at night. "Great to hear how well you're already doing Sweetie Belle!" Pinkie cheered. Sweetie Belle, Applebloom, and Pinkie Pie, were in Pinkie's bedroom. "It's only a matter of time before I get Silver Spoon next" Sweetie Belle said. "We still have a long way to go"