Every day, Rarity and Sweetie Belle always checked the papers, as every day, more and more ponies disappeared, Rarity started freaking out, and Sweetie Belle tried to calm her, even though Sweetie Belle knew still that she was the killer of the dead ponies. After Rarity calmed down enough, Sweetie Belle brought her to her bed and hugged her for a nap. "I'll be going to Pinkie Pie if you need me Rarity, dont worry, I know she can protect me" Sweetie said. "It's alright dear, just dont be gone all day" Rarity replied. Sweetie Belle nodded and trotted out the door. Down a sugarcube corner, Pinkie Pie and Applebloom were discussing something. Sweetie Belle came in and asked what they were up to. "We were thinking of ideas to make your hideout more easy to access, we were just waiting for you to come so we can look around" Pinkie said. "Well it would be nice to get in without a problem for us, lets go find a perfect spot" Sweetie said.
The three ponies went to sweet apple acres , in the abandoned orchard. They had all the supplies they needed, and looked around. After a few minutes, Applebloom spotted a little cave, and said "We can dig a hole here and work it to your underground hideout" she suggested. "That would be perfect!" Sweetie Belle said. "Good thing I brought some Picks and Shovels" Pinkie added, and they giggled. "Alright girls, there's no time to lose" Sweetie chanted, and all three went to work. After two days of hard work, they managed to dig a hole in the cave, not only allowing easier access to the little dungeon, but also making it more hidden, and a wooden door was also placed to keep anypony out in case it is spotted. "Great job girls!" Pinkie said in exhaustion, tired from all that work, but gained all her energy back after devouring a whole bucket of candy. " I couldn't have done it without you girls" Sweetie said, drinking a cup of water. " Hey Pinkie Pie" Sweetie called. "Whats up Sweetie Belle?" She asked. " Applebloom told me you like to make clothes out of the cutie marks, right?" Sweetie said. "Yup! That sure is correct!" Pinkie said happily. "Is it alright if I can borrow some cutie marks to make something of my own?" She asked. "Sure thing!" Pinkie said, passing her a bag full of cutie marks. "Thanks Pinkie" Sweetie said. "No problem! Anything to help" she that night, Sweetie Belle was in Rarity's work room sewing up a new Crusaders cape, and a little chestplate like Princess Luna's. The next morning, she brought it to her secret hideout, then went to discuss who was "next" to bake.
"I think it's Silver Spoon's turn now" Sweetie said, Pinkie and Applebloom agreed. As the trio walked down the pathway that was to Silver Spoon's house, Sweetie Belle noticed that Silver Spoon was on the school playground, crying and alone. They walked up to her and said "Hey Silver Spoon whats wrong?" "Its Diamond Tiara" she sniffled, wiping her eyes "She never came home and I haven't seen her for two days" she finished, sobbing. "Its alright Silver Spoon" Sweetie Belle comforted her "How about the four of us go to my secret hideout and eat some of my famous pancakes?" She suggested. Silver Spoon sniffled, but let out a little "okay."
The four ponies trotted over to the abandoned orchard in Sweet apple acres and laid down near the cave. Sweetie Belle distributed four pancakes, making sure Silver Spoon had the one with sleeping powder. Everypony enjoyed the pancakes. Silver Spoon started to feel a little dizzy and light-headed, then she fell to the ground, and had fallen asleep. Later that evening, Silver Spoon awakens to see a cold and damp room, she can't move, so she tries to call out for somepony. "H-hello? Sweetie Belle?" She asked out loud, but received no answer. The little white unicorn, along with Applebloom and Pinkie Pie, reveal themselves, creating a little fright for Silver Spoon. "Sweetie Belle? Whats going on? Why am I tied up?" She asked. But then her eyes widen, as she sees the clothing Applebloom and Sweetie Belle are wearing, Applebloom has a new bow on her head made of cutie marks, along with an apron, also made of cutie marks. Sweetie Belle was wearing what looked like a cutie mark crusaders cape, but made of cutie marks, and the chestplate was made of cutie marks, but only one of them caught her eyes. "Is that?.. Is-it cant be." She mumbled, not believing what she is seeing. On the chestplate of Sweetie Belle, right in the middle, is a heart, is Diamond Tiara's Cutie marks. Silver Spoon gasped, then started sobbing. "Aww dont cry" Pinkie Pie said. "You can join her too, you both can always be together" she added with a wide smile. "Why are you doing this?" Silver Spoon asked in fear. But she didnt get an answer, instead, she got "Well Silver Spoon, have some of Diamond Tiara since you're here" And forced bits of the meat of Diamond Tiara in her mouth, and held her jaw shut. "I wont let go unless you chew and swallow it" Sweetie said, a smile unlike any other smile Silver Spoon had ever seen on even a filly. Sweetie Belle was about to cut off Silver Spoons Cutie marks, of obviously a silver spoon, until she had this weird feeling. All of a sudden, even surprising Pinkie Pie and Applebloom, Sweetie Belle Leaped up at Silver Spoon and kissed her, on the lips. Silver Spoon was frenzied at what just happened. Why did Sweetie Belle kiss Silver Spoon? Then She backed up, her eyes wide, jaw dropped. "Why did I...why do I feel…." She mumbled, even surprised at herself on what she done. Silver Spoon had this weird feeling too, very strong, as if Sweetie Belle was meant for her in some way, then an idea clicked. "W-wait…" Silver Spoon said. all three ponies looked at her acknowledging that she is now speaking. "What if.. What if I joined you? Sweetie Belle, I dont know why, but I feel as if I love you and I want us to be together" she said, and now Everypony dropped their jaw, especially Sweetie Belle, to even think Silver Spoon would say that, but this feeling aroused in her too. "F-f-fine you can join us" then Pinkie and Applebloom looked at Sweetie Belle, confused by her decision.
Sweetie Belle unties Silver Spoon, letting her down gently, then they both kissed again, this time much longer. Pinkie looked at them and put two and two together "OH MY GOSH! OH MY GOSH! OH MY GOSH!" She exclaimed "I think Sweetie Belle just found her fillyfriend!" She jumped in pure excitement, and they all looked at Pinkie, then Sweetie Belle and Silver Spoon met eyes. "I think she's right, they both said at the same exact time" then both dropped, laughing too. Applebloom still stared in confusion, then said "Ew" then laughed along with them.
In ponyville, everypony congratulated the two fillies, happy that they "found eachother" then after the party, Sweetie Belle noticed that Scootaloo had been following them all day, very suspicious about what's going on, Sweetie Belle came to the conclusion that somepony still has to disappear. The next day, Silver Spoon was officially part of the baking crew, then Sweetie Belle was talking to the group "I have a bad feeling about Scootaloo" She said. "She had been following us around a lot since Silver Spoon and I became an item, I fear she will follow us to the hideout and discover what we do, I think it's time to take her out" she said, and everypony nodded. As sad as it is, Scootaloo would eventually figure out the truth behind the disappearances and possibly tell the guards. Later that afternoon, Sweetie Belle and Silver Spoon went looking for her, and found she was practicing stunts on her scooter, however, when she saw them, she tried to fake a smile. "Hey guys, what's up" She said. "Scootaloo, I know you're disappointed about me and Silver Spoon coming together, but we need your help. Sweetie Belle said. "With what?" Scootaloo said. "We think we found Rainbow Dash but she looks stuck and we cant get to her, she sent us to get you to help", she said she knows you're tough" Sweetie Belle lied. "She really said that?! Wow!" She exclaimed, i'm so happy to hear that Rainbow Dash actually needs help and she wants me! This was so exciting for Scootaloo, but little did she know, she was falling in a trap. They went to the old apple orchard and Sweetie Belle pointed to a cave, "She's trapped in that cave, we think she's at the end, but she's trapped under large boulders, think you can help?" Sweetie Belle said. "Sure thing!" Scootaloo said, she didn't believe it, they found Rainbow dash, the pony who had been missing for a month, and she'd get to save her. However, when Scootaloo entered the cave, a large blunt object hit Scootaloo in the back of the head. It was Pinkie Pie, the pink party pony had a large wooden plank, and hit Scootaloo with it. "Great job Pinkie" Sweetie Belle said. "Dont mention it" she smiled.
Scootaloo wakes up in the cold and damp dungeon. She tries to move her body, but is restricted due to the straps that held her in place. "Whats going on here! Where am I?" She yelled. The four ponies appear, Sweetie Belle, Applebloom, Pinkie Pie, and Silver Spoon, and they stare at her. "Good afternoon Scoots!" Pinkie said happily. "What am I doing here and why am I tied up? And where is Rainbow Dash?" She questioned the ponies. "Oh,
dashie? Luckily I brought her along just for the occasion, she pulls out a Mannequin, but its not the same kind, Rainbow dash covers the large body, and she is covered in dried blood, her cutie marks were gone, her eyes were missing, and she was full of stitches. Scootaloo gasped and started crying at this sight, Rainbow Dash, the only pony Scootaloo based her life on, the pony she cared about so much, was dead and sewed into a mannequin,it was a disgusting sight. "Why! Why did you do this to her?! To everypony else?!" She screamed, but now they started to feel annoyed at her shouting. "She has no cutie marks girls, what are we going to do about that?" Silver Spoon said. "Then we'll improvise, pretend she has cutie marks anyway and just cut off the skin" Sweetie Belle said with a crazed smile. She grabs the scalpel and the tip of the blade pierces through Scootaloo's skin, the burning sensation was very painful, but Scootaloo tried her hardest to stay tough, though she couldnt help but cry a little. Next were her wings, Silver Spoon holds one wing, and Sweetie Belle chopped it off, Sweetie Held the other wing, and Applebloom chopped it off as well. This made Scootaloo scream and cry, her beloved wings were taken away from her. "I'm surprised Scootaloo, you are much tougher than Rainbow Dash was when I took it away from her" Pinkie said. "Oh! I got a great idea, lets have you eat some of the leftovers I have of her!" And out of suddenly nowhere, Pinkie pulls out a container, holding bits of meat from Rainbow Dash's dead body, and forced all of it into her mouth, holding her jaw. "If you're so tough, lets see how you can handle eating your beloved Rainbow Dash, now chew and swallow and this will be easy for all of us" Pinkie ordered. Scootaloo did not want to eat the dead meat of Rainbow Dash, but all of the emotional pain and mental torture was too much for even a filly of her age, so she very regrettingly chewed on the meat, then swallowed. The four ponies cheered for Scootaloo, but then stopped after she attempted to pass out. Pinkie grabbed the adrenaline shot and put it in Scootaloo's chest, her eyes bursting open, however, very unexpectedly, her left eye popped out of her head, everyone stared at her, then started cackling, then Silver Spoon grabbed the scalpel and cut off the optical nerve connecting the eye to Scootaloo's brain, then started playing with it as if it were a ball of yarn. Applebloom grabbed a pair of pliers and pulled each tooth out of Scootaloo's mouth, then chucked it at her as hard as she could, leaving scrapes and cuts all over her body, then blood filled her mouth and she started choking. "Well i guess its time to end it girls, it was great knowing you Scootaloo!" Sweetie Belle said, Then she did the traditional surgical cut on Scootaloo's belly opening up the skin, then pulled out all the organs. Before removing the heart, the last words Scootaloo would ever hear were "Goodbye Scootaloo, we all love you as our best friend" Sweetie said. Then Scootaloo was gone. The next morning the four ponies went to sugarcube corner to greet Twilight Sparkle, Fluttershy, Rarity, and Applejack, with a platter full of fresh baked pancakes, "These are very delicious Sweetie Belle" Twilight said. "What did you put in it?"
"It's a "secret" ingredient Twilight" Rarity said. "I just cant wait to be a famous chef all over equestria, and Pinkie and my friends will be by my side!" Sweetie said, smiling, they smiled back.
"I really cant wait" She thought to herself.