Prompt: Either Beca or Chloe decide to play a prank on the other one
"Okay, Aubrey just text. Chloe's on her way home now." Jessica announced to the girls beside her.
Beca and Chloe had been married for almost two years when Chloe decided to play a prank on her wife. So when Beca opened the envelope containing the divorce papers that Chloe had told her were in there, she instead found a letter of confirmation for Chloe to begin her fertility treatment so that they could start a family together.
Needless to say, Beca hated the prank.
And in an effort to get even with Chloe, Beca enlisted the help of her fellow Bellas to pull a prank of her own by having the redhead catch her cheating with Stacie. Miraculously, she even convinced Aubrey to invite Chloe over for dinner and fake having to leave for an emergency at work, sending Chloe home early.
"Guys, are you sure this is gonna work?" Flo asked.
"Yeah, as long as the rest of us can stay hidden, why wouldn't it work?" Fat Amy answered.
"Well, it's Beca and Stacie." Flo responded. "Are you sure she's gonna fall for that?"
"Well I doubt she's going to have time to consider the reality of Beca and Stacie hooking up when she walks in on them in bed together and starts freaking out." Amy replied matter-of-factly.
"Beca, are you ready for this?" Emily turned to ask the brunette.
"Yeah I think so." She said, looking uncertain. "She's literally going to kill me for this, isn't she?"
"Probably. But you came up with the idea and she's already on her way here so you're not backing out now." Cynthia-Rose added.
Fifteen minutes after Jessica got Aubrey's text, Flo and Emily were acting as lookouts for the Chloe's arrival while the rest of the Bellas prepared themselves for the prank in the couple's bedroom.
"Guys, she's here!" Emily shouted out when she saw the redhead's car pull up in the driveway.
"Okay it's prank time!" Fat Amy said, clapping her hands together. "Beca and Stacie, get in bed and pretend to be asleep when she comes in. Everyone else scatter and find somewhere to hide yourselves."
And at that, everyone did as Amy said.
Beca and Stacie climbed into bed and pulled the sheets up high enough to cover the clothes they were both still wearing. Everyone else found suitable places to position themselves where they wouldn't be spotted by the redhead.
Moments later, Chloe walked into the house and with no sign of Beca downstairs, she made her way upstairs, expecting to find her working on a new mix in their bedroom.
"Becs, I'm-" She said as she entered the room but her speech was quickly cut off by the sight of the two women laying in bed.
The younger woman sat up quickly and both her and Stacie faked looks of shock as they saw the redhead standing in the doorway.
"Chloe! Oh my god! Why are you do-?" The brunette shrieked.
"What the hell Beca?! You're in bed with Stacie! Are you kidding me?!"
"I didn't think you would find out." Beca responded, knowing it would only worsen Chloe's mood and add to the effect of the prank.
"I can't believe you Beca." Chloe responded, her voice already straining as the tears started to roll down her face.
Beca quickly jumped up when she saw her wife starting to cry, ready to come clean about the prank.
"How am I supposed to have this baby with you now?" Chloe said as she turned to walk out of the room.
And then there was a beat of silence as Beca frantically looked around the room in shock and the rest of the Bellas emerged from their hiding places.
"Baby? Did she just say baby?" The brunette asked Stacie in a panic and the taller woman nodded.
"Oh my god." Beca said as she ran out of the room. "Chloe! Wait! Chloe!"
The younger woman ran down the stairs after her wife and eventually caught her in the kitchen.
"Get away from me. I can't believe you did this Beca!" The redhead yelled as the younger woman tried to stop her from walking any further.
"Chlo- listen to me!" She said firmly, holding on to both of her arms. "It was just a prank. I swear, I didn't cheat on you. It was all just a prank!"
And it wasn't until the rest of the women in the house (including a fully clothed Stacie) appeared behind Beca, that Chloe finally calmed down and realised she was telling the truth.
"You didn't cheat on me?" The redhead asked, already letting out a sigh of relief.
"Never." Beca replied, smiling. "Are you pregnant? Are we having a baby?"
And Chloe smiled too.
"We're having a baby." She said.
Then the younger woman lunged towards her wife to kiss her before turning to face the other women and leaping in the air "We're having a baby!"