Chapter 9: The Arkham Games
Pinocchio made an appearance in Arkham Asylam (he was voiced by young actor Real Steals Dakota Goyo.). His role in the game, he is among the villains Who appear in the game. He is first seen in the game where he captures Batman and attempts to turn him into one of his friends. He still talks to Jimminy, like Poison Ivy and Bane he is not allied with The Joker.
Batman manages to brake free from his strings and battles Pinocchio's Monstro as he controls it. Batman causes it to malfunction sending Pinocchio and his whale crashing through the wall down into the water below.
He is the forth alternate ending, like Bane, Killer Croc and Scarecrow, Pinocchio's hand seen bursting out of the water and grabbing a Titan Crate.
Pinocchio returns in Arkham City with Goyo reprising his role. He has a side mission he has kidnapped the first born children of Gotham which involves rescuing Pinocchio's Young captives from Pleasure Island, by tracing the song " I've got no Strings," to each prisoner and defeat the Pinocchio goon holding the child.
After saving the last hostage, Pinocchio himself appears, but before he could defeat him he gets inside a giant puppet bot controlling it
Where Batman has to cut each string and the last string makes the giant puppet bot crumble apart, but Pinocchio uses a string like rope to hoist himself up to escape.
It is revealed that he had killed a couple of guards and successfully escaped. But Strange decides to not go after him finding it a waste of time.
In Arkham Origans, he makes a cameo as he is seen opening up Pleasure Island.
He returns once again, in the final installment The Arkham Knight as he is one of the villains along side Scarecrow to kill Batman. Pinocchio acts as Scarecrows second in command along side The Arkham Knight.
His appearance changed only a little as he now has his face painted like a puppet. He has a more vicious attitude he still talks to Jiminy and mentions "The Blue Fairy,"
The self proclaimed living puppet is first seen leading Scarecrow's men to dispose of Poison Ivy on behalf of Scarecrow. He and the goons spot Batman and have a shorts altercation as the Bat takes out the thugs he escapes with the help of The Arkham Knight. It is revealed that Scarecrow and Pinocchio had Arkham Knight capture Barbra.
Pinocchio nearly killed Barbra, but Scarecrow and Arkham Knight convinced him not to. They take Gordon instead where Pinnochio suggests that " he would make great firewood,"
He is later seen setting the Fear Toxin and Scarecrow tells him to turn on the self destruct, leaving Batman for dead.
Pinocchio is the only one of the trio to actually interact with most their fellow villains on behalf of Scarecrow. He often flees once the villain is defeated leaving them to be taken to prison.
He goes with Gordon to make sure he abducts Robin, and gets the job done as seen on the cameras.
After The Arkham Knight goes into hiding, Pinocchio officially becomes Scarecrow's second in command. When Batman surrenders to Scarecrow Pinocchio and his goons arrive to take him captive and Pinocchio threatens if he tries anything he will be the one hung up with strings.
His goons load him up into the truck and Pinocchio even drives, very terribly as he swerved and hit nearly every speed bump while crashing into stuff on the way to Arkham Asylum.
He is present for the unmasking of Batman and mocks him with a snotty comment. " He's not a real bat his a billionaire on strings,"
After Batman gets free of The Joker. Scarecrow gets defeated by the combined effort of Batman, Jason Todd, and Gordon knocking him out.
Pinocchio manages to escape which, Gordon sends some police to search the area and hunt him down.
It is assumed he ditched Gotham as mentioned by Aron Cash. Batman tells him that they shouldn't worry because he has a friend where he is headed that will take care of him in Montropolise.