The Forgotten Girl

by 23a

When Hook and Milah ran away together, they never expected a child. But they still loved her. And when the Dark One put their family in danger, they had to send her away, and drink a potion to forget about her. But when years later in Neverland she comes across her Papa there to rescue a boy, she will find a way back to her family - and into their memories. Has sequel.

3. Henry

I spent days thinking about it. I knew I'd made the right choice, saying no to Pan's proposal. But I really wanted to go home... I came up with a plan. A plan that would get me home, but wouldn't kill Henry. In fact, I was going to try and save him.

...

I needed a song. I thought about it for a while, then decided to use one my Mama sang to me when she would put me to bed when I was little. I sang the first verse. There were more verses, but I barely remembered them and had no interest in digging up painful memories. But it was enough. Henry came.

"Who - who are you?", he asked.

"I am Elizabeth."

"You have a beautiful voice", he said.

"Thank you." I switched gears. "Henry. Pan is going to tell you to do something. Don't do it. You'll die."

"What?"

"He wants you to give him your heart. Just promise me you won't do it."

"Um... I... uh -"

Just then, someone came through the woods. It was Felix, that annoying boy.

"Don't believe her Henry. She's a siren."

"Don't they live in water?"

"Not in Neverland."

"I didn't know they even existed in Neverland."

"Well, now you do." They left. I sighed. So much for my plan. I decided they didn't need me; they'd save Henry on their own. I'd just sneak onto their ship afterward and go to that place. What was it called again? Storybrooke?