Italics - No one's P.o.v
Bold - Rachel's P.o.v
Bold/Italics - Puck's P.o.v
To Fix A Broken Heart
The next day the girls were woken up by Santana's phone going off, the girl picked it up answering without looking at the id.
"What do you want at this time in the morning?" Santana moaned down the phone loudly, making Rachel giggle quietly.
"Hello to you too loser" Puck chuckled down the phone to his best friend.
"What do you want Puck, too fucking early?" She looked at Rachel to see her reaction of her ex boyfriends nickname.
My eyes shoot open when Santana said 'Puck', I forgot that I'd have to see him again, the boy who still held my heart.
"Come and open the door loser, it's 10 o'clock, everyone will be here soon for movie day" He sighed down the phone at her.
"Crap!, I forgot about movie day with everyone" Looking at Rachel softly.
"What?" Rachel mouthed to her before getting up to go to the bathroom
"Loser?!, hurry up it's freezing" Puck groaned at her.
"Alright, two seconds Puck" Hanging up on him, walking towards the bathroom "Rach?"
"Yeah?" Opens the door, walking out "Can I borrow some clothes Tana?"
"Yeah of course, just take what you want, are you ok with this? Puck and our glee club are coming over today" Looking at her best friend
"Of course, spend time with your friends, you're life can't just stop because of me, i'll just sit up here and read one of your books" Smiles at her as she changed into Santana's clothes.
"You could join us, you know i'm sure Puck would love to see you again, he still loves you Rach" Smiling at her "Our friends will love you too"
"No you're ok, go and enjoy spending time with your friends" Sitting down on the bed after grabbing a book.
Santana sighed looking at Rachel before getting changed and going downstairs to let Puck in.
"You took you're time loser" Chuckles, walking inside closing the door after him.
"Tough night last night" Smiles slightly at him
"You ok San?" Asking as he follows her into the living room
"When was the last time you spoke to Rachel?" Looking at him, seriously
"Eh, i spoke to her on the phone on Wednesday, and I tried to phone her yesterday but it went straight to voicemail, why?" Looking at her confused
"How did she seem on the phone on Wednesday?" Sitting next to him on the couch
"She seemed fine, until we were about to hang up but she always gets upset when we hang up, why? Santana, what's happened?" Concerned about the girl that still had his heart
Santana looked at him, sighing knowing Rachel might hate her for this but he deserved to know.
"She turned up here last night crying" She looked over at Puck "Puck, she's ran away"
"She ran away? Why the fuck would she run away?" Looking at Santana confused then realises "Is she still here?"
"She's upstairs in my room, she doesn't want to come down" Looking away from him, knowing he's annoyed
"Why?, Why did she run away?" Slightly annoyed that Rachel didn't come to him or even tell him something was wrong.
Santana started to tell him why Rachel ran away, as soon as she finished he was up and running upstairs with her following but he shut and locked her bedroom door so she couldn't get in.
"Tana, I said I didn't want to watch movies with yous, go and enjoy your movie day" Rachel said from the bed without looking up
"I'm not Tana, baby" Puck said standing at the door, looking at her sitting there.
"Noah?, What are you doing up here?" Looking at him nervously.
"Why do you think I'm up here Rach?" Asking as he walked towards the bed
"She-She told you" Rachel looked down, playing with the hem of Santana's top she's wearing.
I was standing right in front of her, placing my hand on her cheek making her look me in the eyes, I stroked her cheek with my thumb gently.
"Yeah, she did baby, but the question is why didn't you?, you know you can tell me anything?" Puck asked her quietly, looking her in the eyes.
"I'm sorry, I didn't know how to tell anyone, when I left I didn't know where to go" Sniffs, looking him in the eyes
"You don't have to apologise to me ever, ok? I'm sorry I wasn't there to protect you" He whispered to her while wiping away her tears.
"What they did to me, it wasn't your fault Noah, you can't blame yourself, do you hear me?" Looking him in the eyes, feeling annoyed at him for blaming himself.
"I hear you Rach, I just wish you would of told me" Sighing as he looked down at her
"I know, I tried to so many times but I just couldn't - I didn't know how to" Looking at him, hearing more voices downstairs, smiles softly at him "You should go and join your friends Noah"
"Come and join us too, they'll love you just not as much as I love you" Puck said smirking slightly, taking her hand
"I'm alright up here with my book, - Wait you love me?" Shocked, looking him with wide eyes.
"Of course I love you baby, you were my first girlfriend, my only girlfriend, my first kiss and my first and only time, your my first and hopefully last love" Noah spoke proudly to her, looking her in the eyes.
He still loves me?, he hasn't had a girlfriend in 4 years, not slept with anyone apart from me?, I've ruined his life because our break up wasn't bad and we always talk on the phone...No he can't love me, I can't let him.
"Go watch movies with your friends and Santana, Puck" Looking him in the eyes, feeling sick at saying his nickname. "I'm not your girlfriend"
"Rach, I just told you I stil love you?" Looks at her with sad eyes, trying to take her hand again "You could be my girlfriend, do you still love me baby?"
"And I told you to go watch your movies." Rachel snapped softly before speaking again "No"
No?, No what? That she didn't want me to go?, She didn't want to be my girlfriend? If it's 'No I don't love you' I think I'll break down.
"No what Rachel?" He looked at her, nervously
"No I don't love you anymore, now I think you should leave me alone" Feeling her own heart breaking as she spoke.
Puck leant forward and kissed Rachel's cheek and whispered that 'He'd never leave her alone, never again and that he loved her' before walking downstairs and sitting next to Sam.
"Alright man, was wondering where you were" Sam smiled at him, holding his fist out for Puck
"Yeah whatever Evans" Puck stands up walking into the kitchen.
"I'll go see what's wrong with him" Santana said following Puck into the kitchen and sees him with his head in his arms as he sat at the table "What happened up there?"
"I told her everything, that I still love her, that I haven't had any other girlfriends or slept with anyone else since her, and that if she still loved me, well that she could be my girlfriend again and she" He looked up at Santana, annoyed "She said she didn't love me anymore and I've to leave her alone"
"She said that?" She was shocked that her best friend would lie like that to him when she had told her she still loved Puck so much. Sighs seeing him nod his head "She's lying, she still loves you, she's told me many of times, plus she mumbled your name in her sleep last night"
"Why would she lie then loser? She's the love of my life and she told me to leave her alone. Forget it, see you later San" Puck waved slightly before walking out of the house.