Italics - No one's P.o.v
Bold - Rachel's P.o.v
Bold/Italics - Puck's P.o.v
To Fix A Broken Heart
After everyone left Santana walked upstairs to her room to see Rachel lying there sleeping with tear stains down her cheeks hugging onto the one thing she brought with her, one of Puck's old shirts.
She got an idea and took a photo sending it to Puck sending with it 'If that's not still in love with you then I don't know what is'
"Rachel?, Honey wake up I need to speak to you?" Santana whispered as she sat down on the bed next to Rachel
"T-tana?" Opening her eyes, sitting up feeling more tears grow in her eyes "I've messed up"
"What do you mean, Rach?" Santana looked at her best friend confused
"I-i need to talk to him, I need to fix my mistake" Rachel jumped up from the bed with the old top in her hand
"What are you talking about Rach?, Your confusing me, honey" Watching her jump about
"I'll be back soon, don't worry" Rachel ran out of Santana's room and downstairs to the door
I ran outside to my car as fast as I could. I can't believe I told him I didn't love him, I'm such an idiot. I drove to Noah's house as quick as possible, getting out and running to the front door, knocking.
"Rachel?, What are you doing here? You told me to leave you alone" Puck looked at her with sad eyes
"Please don't leave me alone I need you Noah, I need you so much" She sniffed looking up at him "I do, I do love you"
"Baby, come here" He pulled her into him, letting her cry in his arms "I love you too baby girl"
"I'm so sorry Noah" Rachel cried into his shoulder, wrapping her arms around him
"You don't need to apologise to me, remember?, You're hurting I understand" Puck kissed her temple.
"Please don't let me go, please" Holding onto him as tightly as she could, crying
"I'll never let you go baby" He whispered to her
I slid my hands to the back of her thighs lifting her up to carry her inside. This felt good having her in my arms again.
"Promise?" Rachel looked up at him as he carried her upstairs to his bedroom
"I promise Rach, my arms are always opened for you" Puck looked her in the eyes as he walked into his bedroom
"I love you" She sniffed,smiling at him as he sat down with her in his lap
"I love you too" He leaned in to kiss her but she pulled back "What's wrong?"
"I love you and I really do want to be your girlfriend again but I think with everything that's going to start after I speak to the police that us getting together maybe a bit too much, can we just be friends till I get over this please?" Asking as she played with the collar of his shirt
"If that's what you want then that's how we'll take it baby, until your ready to be my girl again" He smiled at her softly "Does that mean we can't spoon or cuddle?"
"No we can still spoon and cuddle with each other, I've missed being in your arms" Rachel giggled at him softly
I squealed quietly as Noah lay down pulling me with him, I cuddled into him burying my face in his neck, sighing softly.
They lay on Puck's bed tangled together quietly for a while before Rachel spoke up softly.
"Noah?" Rachel looked up at him from her position
"Yeah, baby girl?" Puck looed down at her
"Will you be there tomorrow when I speak to the police?" Asking him quietly
"Yeah, Baby if that's what you want?" Holding her close to him, kissing her forehead
"That's what I want" She moved closer to him, running her hand up his chest, smiling softly
"Rach?" Puck pulled her up against him more
"Yeah?" She looked up at him from his shoulder
"Why did they start hitting you?" Looking down at her, playing with her hair
"I don't really know but it was a Tuesday night, I had just came home from cheer practice, I walked into my room to get changed when Leroy came in and started shouting about how late I was and when I tried to remind him he slapped me across the face. I screamed and then Hiram came running in and he had this smirk on his face" Rachel sniffed, looking up at him as she played with his shirt
"You don't need to do this Rach, you can tell me whenever your ready" Moving a strand of hair out of her face, wiping away her tears
"No I need to tell someone this, before I repeat it to the police. He had this smirk on his face and he told Leroy to hold me and then he started hitting me, I couldn't stop crying, I was begging him to stop and after that night they kept doing it, after a while I just gave up on trying to get them to stop" Sniffs, leaning her head back on his shoulder as she tried to stop crying
"They're assholes baby, they don't deserve a beautiful, talented, smart, sexy daughter like you. You deserve to be around people who love you, care about you and would do anything to protect you" Puck tangled his hand in her hair, making her look up at him "When your ready, I really want to be that person for you"
"Right now with what your saying and how your making me feel so loved and cared for, I think I might be ready soon" Rachel smiled at him softly, leaning up and kisses his cheek
I really wish I was ready to be his girl again, right now I've never felt this loved and cared for in 4 years. He's always made me feel so special.
They lay there for a while talking about some small stupid stuff, when Rachel sat up on the bed.
"I should get back to Santana's, I didn't really tell her where I was going, she might be worried" Looking down at him,smiling.
"Ok, I'll walk you to your car" Puck said standing up from his bed walking to the bedroom door before turning to see her playing with the hem of her top "What's wrong baby?"
"Do you think that, maybe I could have one of your shirts, the one I have from years ago doesn't really smell like you anymore, plus it doesn't really fit anymore" Rachel asked looking up at him, nervously
"You had one of my shirts all these years?" Puck looked at her, smirking softly as he unbuttoned his shirt
"Yeah, I wore it to bed when it fit me, it made me feel close to you when it smelt like you. W-what are you doing?" She looked at him, giggling softly.
"Giving you my shirt, and baby that's the hottest thing i've ever heard" Puck took his shirt off,walking towards her smiling.
"Really?, You think me wearing your shirt is hot?" Giggles as she looked him up and down
"You in any of my clothes is hot Rach, see something you like?" He smirked at her seeing her look him up and down, handing her his shirt
"You know i've always thought you were hot, but your hotter than you were 4 years ago, and thank you for the shirt" Rachel smiled up at him
"I'll give you as many shirts/t-shirts as you want, as long as your here in Lima and want my shirts" He wrapped his arms around her waist, smiling down at her "I love you baby"
"I love you too Noah" Smiling up at him, holding onto his arms "I should go, I'll see you tomorrow?"
"I'll be there baby, don't worry" Puck kissed her cheek,walking her to the door.
Rachel drove back to Santana's with a smile on her face. When she walked through the door Santana launched herself onto Rachel making her laugh as she wrapped her arms around her best friend