A/N: I first want to apologize if anyone wasn't happy with last chapter. I've been writing two stories at once, and I rushed the last chapter. I admit I am trying hard to make Claringberry as interesting as Smytheberry. I think both guys would be awesome for Rachel. My story may be out of canon but remember this is an alternate universe type story. This is a Claringberry story. I added Sebastian for a little drama for the story. But my true OTP is Smytheberry. I just love Sebastian and Rachel together. Hunter is similar to Sebastian, a little bit of a bad boy. In case you're wondering Ian is an oc I made up because I don't know the names of the new warblers.

Disclaimer: I don't own Glee, characters, or story lyrics.

Hunter was in class, when Ian another Warbler, nudged him.

Ian: So Hunter, what happened with you and that hot babe Rachel?

Hunter: Not much to tell except I did kiss her.

Ian: Wait, wasn't she hooking up with Smythe who just left?

Hunter: All fair in love and war.

Ian: Well damn, wasted no time to make a move, I see. I mean, I get why but damn kind of unfair to Sebastian.

Hunter: Well his loss. Now quiet, trying to learn here.

Ian: I know we're not really friends yet, but just be careful. Rachel seems really nice. Plus Blaine might kill you I you hurt her.

Hunter: So would Kurt, Sam, Puck and every other guy. She's a grown woman, and her decision. Just saying she should take a chance on someone who will actually be around.

Madam Benoit: Monsieur Clarington, do you have something to share?

Hunter: No Madame Benoit, my apologies.

Madame Benoit: Please pay attention. Also that goes for you too, Ian.

Ian: Good luck, bro. .

Hunter knows he may have rushed things the other night, but frankly he could care less about what Mr. Smythe wants or feels. They both wanted Rachel. Perhaps he has been a little immature and not really thinking about what RACHEL WANTS. He should talk to her later. All he wants is one date without anyone else interfering. Smythe got to go out with her, why not him. Damn, Hunter has to work this hard for any girl. Is she really worth the fight? Rachel was invading his thoughts too quickly and they aren't even officially dating. He needs time ,. .

Text message (Hunter to Rachel)

Rachel, I had a great time the other night. I apologize if I came on too fast for you. I know I should of waited for Sebastian to be long gone, but I didn't want to wait. I don't regret kissing you. Hope we can talk later. Xoxo Hunter

Sebastian was in his business class, and it was first day back since his visit to Ohio. He got to go out with Rachel. Why he never paid attention in high school he didn't know. And he never had to work so hard for someone, well except Blaine. That's a different time and different story. . sexually attracted to Blaine and someone he couldn't have. Blaine and Kurt never made sense to him, but who was he to judge? Rachel was someone he can see himself falling for, but problem is distance and could she give herself completely to him. She's back in Ohio and who knows if she will stay or not. Perhaps teaching or mentoring was her calling in life. Plus losing Finn Hudson was hard on her. He heard what that douchebag Brody Weston did to her. He didn't blame Finn for beating his ass. Sure people did stupid things if desperate enough and perhaps he had reasons but lying to Rachel and sleeping with Cassandra July was shady as hell. Rachel deserved someone committed to her. Maybe he is wrong turning this battle for her heart into a competition where the prize was Rachel. What would happen once prize was won?

Trent: Hey Sebastian, what happened with you and Rachel?

Sebastian: What do you mean?

Trent: You and Hunter both want her, but she can only choose one of you. But are either of you doing this because you truly want her or is this to compete with Hunter? All I am saying is be fair to her,.and be in this for the Right reasons because if it goes wrong, it will be Rachel who is hurt and she honestly doesn't deserve it. Hunter has been pursuing her you're in New York. Do you want to be tied down? And you're bi, can you FULLY commit to her? I am just offering my opinion. And if you hurt her, plenty of people will kick yours AND Hunter's asses.

Sebastian: Thanks for the support, Trent.

Trent: I am not saying you don't care for her, but are you truly in this FOR HER.

Sebastian: You aren't telling me anything I haven't thought of. And I wouldn't be surprised if Clarington made a move once I was out of sight because everyone else is encouraging him like Kurt.

Trent: Well he would be an influence on Rachel since Kurt is her BFF. And you are not on best of terms. You did try to blind his boyfriend.

Sebastian: And I apologized. I guess I could be nicer,.but .the fun of that. It's our thing. He calls me meerkat and Craigslist and I call him betty white, lady Hummel, and he has serious case of the gay face. Just saying.

Trent: Good luck, Sebastian. This is between you and Rachel.

Sebastian: Thanks Trent. Guess I have some thinking to do. I do care for Rachel.

Text message (Sebastian to Rachel)

Rachel- just missing you and thinking of you, us, do we go from here? Talk soon. Xoxo Sebastian

The ball is in Rachel's court, and he's willing to wait. But would Hunter?

Rachel was in her office, working at her desk. Her thoughts to Sebastian and Hunter. Both are great guys and can see herself with both. But, question is,.are they truly in this for her or is this just a game and she's their prize? What happens once they got her heart? She couldn't suffer anymore heartbreaks and she wasn't a heartbreaker. She was attracted to Sebastian, I mean, just look at him. He is GORGEOUS and talented and matches her vocally. Bad side he's got his bad boy side and not on the best of terms with her bestie, Kurt..Also he lives in New York.

Hunter...definitely a bad boy and pursues her relentlessly and a bit more forward. He didn't waste anytime kissing her everytime she has been near him. She would be lying if she said she wasn' to him. But being attracted has gotten her into trouble before: Finn, Jesse, Brody...

Perhaps Rachel needs to concentrate on her New Directions. She's just tired of being alone to be able to open her heart again but can she trust either .heart?

Rachel read the texts from Hunter and Sebastian. She simply responded: Give me time..xoxo Rachel.

Rachel left the office and sat at the piano. Suddenly a song came to mind. She played a time, and hummed.

"Can I Trust You With My Heart" (by Travis Tritt)

(Rachel)
When you meet that certain someone,
You've been searchin hard to find...
It's a new love full of passion,
That can sometimes make you blind.
I don't mind being swept away,
If I know right from the start...
So before we go much further boy,
Can I trust you with my heart?

In the time we've spent together,
I have learned to trust in you.
So many things you given...
Before I even asked you to.
But reality and romance,
Are sometimes far apart.
So, what I really need to know is...
Can I trust you with my heart?

Can I cast my cares upon you?
Can you stand the heavy load?
Can I count on you to walk me, down that long and winding road?
If you promise me these simple things, I can guarantee...
You can always count on me.

Can I cast my cares upon you?
Can you stand the heavy load?
Can I count on you to walk me, down that long and winding road?
When two hearts souly surrender, and are sworn to understand...
It completes a perfect union, between a woman and a man.
So please don't misunderstand me,
I don't want to go too far,
Without knowing just one answer ...
Can I trust you with my heart?
Please Boy...
Give me just one answer...
Can I trust you with my heart?

Who will protect and cherish me and my heart, she thought. She didn't want to be a prize or worshipped. She just wants to be loved...a REAL LOVE.

A/N: I hope this chapter is a little better. Read & Review.