Two more months passed. Gray had tried to prove his innocence towards Leo but the orange haired man still disagreed. The sudden murders that have been appearing from here and there had stopped. About ten Fairy High student have been killed, one of them Evergreen. I remember how much Elfman cried when he heard that, he was the girl he was in love with.

Leo has been acting strange since the murders have started. Rumors are saying threats have been coming out towards Angel the last couple of days but she's been brushing them off. She hasn't talked, teased, or beat me up since Evergreen died either. People have been silent since the murders have started.

The final bell rang making me snap out of my recent thoughts. Gathering my things, I headed to the front of the school. Everyone was waiting there chatting, smiling, and joking around. Lets say we looked like complete idiots to some people. "Lucy! Want to go to the Sakura Café with us?" Levy asked. Lucy shook her head, "I would love to, but I have some clubs in a bit. I'm free tomorrow though. Maybe then?" I suggested. Everyone agreed along with Levy. Waving goodbye, I headed to the Astrology club first.

Natsu POV

I watched as Luce ran back into the school. "Now that Lucy mentions it, I can't attend as well. I promise that I'll be there tomorrow as well." I explained. Feeling slightly guilty. Levy sighed, waving me off to leave. Bidding them bye, I headed to my apartment.

Walking into the lobby I greeted Macao at the front desk before climbing the up the stairs to the second floor. Going to door '12', I unlocked the door to find another package with a white envelope on top. Sighing, I opened the package to find a new scratching post, a feathered ball attached to a stick, and a new food bowl that had the name 'Happy' engraved into it. Frowning, I set it a side. I always find this stuff in my room in a package and a blank letter. In the packages were stuff for Happy, but I never ordered stuff for him. I usually get the blank letters everyday. I still opened them, even if they had nothing good to say on it.

Picking off the waxed seal, I pulled the piece of paper out of the envelope. Folding it open, I wasn't surprised about the blank part but the signature at the bottom. It said 'Sincerely from The Nightmare'. I choked on my own spit. I didn't anybody named The Nightmare did I? I always thought this stuff was from Macao to tell the truth. He was the only person I knew who had the other key to my apartment. But then again, he told me he lost it years ago.

Running out of my apartment, I jogged to the Sakura Café. Slamming the door open I saw my friends looking at me with jaws aghast. "Natsu?" Erza asked softly. Speed walking to the table they sat at, I plopped into the seat next to Sting. "Okay guys, this has been funny and all, but seriously. Tell me who's been sneaking gifts for Happy and putting letters in my apartment for the last few months?" I asked seriously to the gang. They gave me strange stares. "What are you talking about?" Leo snickered. "Just like I said! Someone's been leaving gifts for Happy and blank letters in my apartment for the last couple of months?" I yelled.

"So you've been getting these things for the last months and you decide to tell us this now?" Lisanna asked bitterly. I nodded, "I just thought it was you guys playing a prank on me so I always brushed it off. "Do you have on of the letters, or packages now?" Leo asked. I nodded again, taking the recent letter I got today out of my pocket. Handing it over to him, I saw him scan it until he reached the signature. His eyes widened when he saw it.

"C-can I keep this for a bit?" he asked. I looked at him strangely before nodding slowly. He tucked it into his pocket before speaking. "So you're saying this stuff has been appearing inside your apartment?"

"Yeah, it was never outside my door, always inside my apartment. I assumed that one of you guys stole the spare key to my apartment from Macao and started this silly prank on me." I growled. Erza put a hand on my shoulder, "Natsu, we don't have a key to your apartment. Hell, we didn't know we had a cat until a few weeks ago. We'll figure this out." She promised. "For now, change your lock for your apartment. We'll see what happens next after that." Leo commanded. I nodded, feeling a little scared when I saw the anger in his eyes.

Leo POV

He's getting on my nerves now. It was him. I should've believed my instinct instead of blaming Gray. For now, we have to make sure he's not going to hurt any more of my friends, if he does, there's going to be some problems from now on.

~The Next Day~

Lucy POV

Leo came home late last night. I asked him if everything was okay, but he just brushed it off, saying everything was fine. My suspicion only grew when I saw Natsu shaking in the classroom earlier today. Feeling bad, I spent the rest of the day trying to calm him down, he was a little pale in the face, but when I started hanging out with him for the day, he said he was grateful that I was there for him when he needed it.

I was about to lead him to the Sakura Café but he said he had something to do today. It made my heart falter a bit when I heard that. Sighing, I waved good-bye before walking to the café that we were gonna meet up at.

Opening the front door to the small café, I spotted everyone sitting at a table at the back of the room. Skipping over to the table, I slung an arm around Leo. "Natsu said he couldn't make it today. He said he was sorry about it." I explained as I sat down next to Leo.

"It's alright, he wasn't looking to good today, so I wouldn't blame him." Levy sighed.

We chatted until nightfall came. Leo had to go buy groceries for tomorrow's dinner and offered me to come. I was about to agree when Sting interrupted, "I'll walk her home, I have something important to tell her." Leo glanced at me before agreeing. The blonde led me into a park that was close to my house. We continued to walk until we were in the middle of the park where a big fountain was laid.

"Sting?" I called nervously. What was going on? Sting took a deep breath before turning to face me. "Lucy," he started, grabbing my hand. "I…I just wanted to tell you my true feelings before someone else took you from me. Lucy Heartfillia…I…I love you!" he shouted before smashing his lips into mine making my eyes widened.

Sting POV

Her lips were so soft against mine. After a few seconds into the kiss, she started to push me away, making me frown. "Sting," she gasped. "I'm so sorry, but I don't feel the same way. I think…I think I like someone else." She whispered. I frowned when I heard that.

"I don't care." I mumbled. "I'll still wait for you! I'll always love you Lucy!" I yelled at her. I felt tears pricking my eyes. Her eyes turned glassy as well, she put a hand on my shoulder before walking away.

Sniffling, I started walking towards my house as well. That didn't go as well as I expected. I thought she would at least think about it. Sighing, I pulled out my keys. Before I could open my front door, I felt hands wrap around my next and squeeze. I struggled under the person grasp, trying to get air. Then everything went dark.

~ A Few Seconds Later~

When I opened my eyes, I felt myself being dragged to somewhere. I got thrown a few feet away from my captor. Jumping to my feet, I managed to punch the man in the side of the face. Apparently he was warring a mask that had stars from one side of it. It shattered from the impact giving me a clear view of the man. "G-Gray?" I whispered.

The last thing I remembered was him cutting my right cheek and a snap come from the back of my neck. Everything went dark after that. The last thing on my mind was the girl I loved most standing there, tears streaming down her face as she repeated the word 'sorry' over and over again.

~A/N~

Luvviez: Was this a good chapter? I tried my best to make it as well as I could. I wanted something tragic to happen when the last chapter came.

Lightningpanda- thanks for visiting the story you once owned. Come again any time.

Tell me what you think though guys. Did you love it? Hate it?

Review to tell me!