Hi guys. So I'm finally Updating. I hit a bump and couldn't move on
But thanks to Bec's(Redmagic) encouragement and input, I got over it
Thanks Bec
Enjoy and remember to comment :D
Chapter 6
Scooping Haley up into his arms Sam headed for the bed, Haley letting out a shriek. Sam threw her on the bed, covering her with his body once again. Sam gently wiped the hair out of her face and smiled down at her.
"I should probably go. Dean's called about ten times and I can't still be here when Brooke returns" Sam explained. Haley faintly smiled and nodded.
"Yeah, but just stay here, like this a few more minutes" Haley asked with pleading eyes
"Sure" Sam said before leaning down, taking Haley's bottom lip between his.
MN
Logan looked at the man standing at the step, his heart beating wildly in his chest. He knew exactly who he was and he heard what he said. Logan stepped forward, placed his hands on Brookes shoulders and led her further out the house
"Brooke, take Sarah, see you guys later" Brooke turned to Logan wanting to protest but the look on his face stopped her. She looked back at Dean giving him a questioning look then picked Sarah of the ground and walked to her car.
Logan stood aside and showed Dean to enter once Brooke had left. Closing the door quietly Logan took a deep breath before walking towards the lounge. He mentioned for Dean to sit, sitting down himself. None of them said anything just shifted around awkwardly. Dean glanced around the room, looking at the photos on display. He sniffed and shifted again
"She's cute" he blurted. Logan looked up at him and Dean gestured toward a picture of Sarah.
"Yeah" Logan answered softly, smiling
"So you and Sam were friends in college" Dean said more a statement than a question
"Yeah, we were roommates, had a lot of the same classes, we became friends." Logan elaborated. Dean nodded
"How do you know who I am?" Dean asked after a short silence.
"I saw a picture of you once but Sam didn't want to answer questions. When he went missing I had investigators looking for him, they told me he had a brother and showed me a picture . . . I connected the dots" Logan answered
"What else did they find out?" Dean asked interested
"Not much. Your mom died when Sam was a baby, you moved a lot. Your dad fell of all radars. Every time they got close, you guys vanished again. You're good." Logan said getting up, walking to the window
"Why'd you stop looking for Sam?" Dean pushed. Logan looked out the window not answering right away. After a minute or so he turned to face Dean
"Haley asked" was all he said. Dean nodded and a silence fell between them
MN
Picking up his jacket Sam moved towards the door, opened it and waited for Haley to walk out in front of him. She took his one hand in hers and led him down the stairs, smiling the whole time. Haley swirled around when they reached the bottom of the stairs, threw her arms around Sam's neck, leaned up and kissed him. Sam drew her closer to him as he deepened the kiss. Sam pulled away and smiled down at Haley. Sam looked up and passed Haley, he froze. Haley frowned and followed his gaze. She swallowed hard at the sight
"Logan" she gasped out
"Dean?" Sam questioned
"I was worried when you didn't come back; I was worried when Brooke said you weren't feeling well. Stupid me" Logan said hurt evident in his voice
"Logan . . ." Haley started, moving towards him. Logan shook his head and held his hand up stopping Haley in her tracks. Haley looked at the floor as Logan turned his back to her
"Sammy . . . I um . . . Bobby called." Dean stuttered out. Sam's eyes widened at the statement. Haley's head yanked up and towards Sam. His eyes caught hers,
"Are you leaving again?" Haley asked her voice cracking. Sam looked to Dean and then to the floor.
"Did you really think he was gonna stick around?" Logan's voice echoed through the room. All three turned to look at him.
"He left you, you cried yourself to sleep for months. You needed him, we looked for him. Four years Haley, not a word. But he waltzes back into our lives and you forgive him instantly. I thought you'd at least consider what we build in this time. Guess I was wrong. I mean it's not like I stepped up when you needed me to . . ." Logan continued hurt building with every word
"Logan!!" Haley interrupted him, afraid of what he was about to reveal
"Don't worry Hales. But I'm done, I hoped you'd learn to love me but you and Sam share something we don't."
"Logan . . . I do love you, more than you'll ever know." Haley said tears forming in her eyes as she stepped closer to him.
"But not the way you love Sam" Logan said looking to Sam and then back at Haley
"I love her like she was my own but you need to tell him" Logan whispered as he leaned down leaving a soft kiss on Haley's cheek. Logan walked around Haley took his keys and left. Haley stood with her back to Sam and Dean; she couldn't bring herself to face them. Sam took a hold of Dean's arm and led him into the hallway
"I can't go now, she needs me" Sam started
"I did this" Sam continued. Dean looked to Haley then back to Sam
"Sam, they'll work it out, he's her child's father. We have a job to do, one that's too dangerous to involve innocents" Dean said sighing. Sam nodded in understanding. Not taking his eyes of Haley
"I know Dean, but I left once and hated myself for it, I have a chance to fix it. Please let me fix it" Sam pleaded
"Sam . . ."
"Dean, you can do this job with your eyes closed, let Bobby help you. Please, just a couple of weeks" Sam continued. Dean could see the desperation in Sam's eyes and knew he would be fighting a losing battle trying to convince Sam to go with him. Dean sighed, giving a small nod.
"If there is a slight hint of anything supernatural, you call me Sam, I'm serious, don't let your guard down, not even for a second. You have them to look out for as well as yourself." Dean warned looking at Sam
Sam gave a weak smile and followed Dean to the door. Dean ran to the car took out Sam's duffle and handed it to him
"Be careful Sammy" Dean said before driving of. Sam watched the Impala disappear around the corner; he looked around, taking everything in before turning and entering the house. Sam quietly closed the door behind him, dropped his bag at the bottom of the stairs before moving closer to Haley. Her back was still to him, but she was now standing in front of the window.
"Hales?" Sam asked carefully, she didn't move. Sam stepped closer and placed his hand on her shoulder
"You should go, before this gets any harder" Haley's voice came softly
"Dean already left, I'm staying . . . if that's okay" Sam said just as soft. Haley spun around and looked up at Sam
"Really, are you sure?"
"Yeah" Sam nodded. Haley laid her head against his chest and wrapped her arms around Sam. He pressed her closer to him and rested his chin on top of her head
"Thanks" Haley whispered and Sam kissed the top of her head. They stood like that for a while, Sam just holding Haley close.
.
Haley pulled out of Sam's hold and away from him when the front door flew open hitting the cabinet with a thud, followed by Sarah running towards the stairs
"Hi momma, daddy" She yelled over her shoulder thinking it was Logan. Haley's heart skipped a beat, knowing the truth in Sarah's innocent statement. Haley looked up at Sam, the hurt on his face. He looked down at her with a faint smile
"Sam, I . . ." she started
"It's okay, she thought I was Logan" Sam interrupted. Haley nodded, moving further away from Sam.
"But she's right" Haley said softly not looking at Sam. He scoff-laughed, then her words dawned on him
"What?" Sam asked unsure.
"Haley?" Brooke's voice came from behind Sam, having heard the statement. Haley looked between Brooke and Sam, both staring, waiting for her to continue.
"I lied . . . to both of you. Logan . . . he's not . . . Sarah's father" her voice came broken. Brooke stepped closer shaking her head
"No, I saw you. He slept over, in your bed. I caught you" Brooke said confused
"I was with you when you found out you were pregnant, months after Sam left" she continued. Haley looked at Brooke tears in her eyes. "Oh my god" Brooke gasped
"I found out I was pregnant a few weeks after Sam left. I was scared and didn't know what to do. I told Logan, he said he would be the father." Haley started to explain. Sam sank onto the closest chair, Brooke didn't move
"So me finding you guys . . . were a setup? Sarah wasn't born early?" Brooke asked hurt in her voice. Haley shook her head
"I'm sorry . . . I was falling apart, Logan's plan made sense, I couldn't do it on my own, have a baby, go to school" Haley continued, looking between them.
"You weren't on your own, I could've helped Hales" Brooke said moving closer to her friend. Haley nodded
"Sam?" Haley asked turning her attention to him. Sam who hasn't said a word looked up, his gaze shifting between them, before resting on Haley.
"I have a daughter?" he said more a statement than a question. Haley nodded, tears in her eyes. Sam stood up nodding not breaking his gaze from Haley. Letting out a shaky breath Sam moved away from Brooke and Haley.
"I . . . have to . . . uhm . . . go. I'll see you later" Sam said pointing to the door. Brooke tossed her car keys to Sam
"Thanks . . ." he said catching the keys turning and disappearing out the door. Brooke turned to Haley, engulfing her in a hug
"He'll be back" she whispered into her hair. Haley let Brooke hold her as raw cries escaped from her tiny body.