Sorry for not updating in so long...I've been super busy. Here's the next chapter.

Piper's POV

Sunday morning I was the first one awake. I put some water to boil for coffee and started making pancakes. Someone knocked on the front door so I turned down the stove and went to open it. Standing outside was Pheobe's ex-boyfriend, Todd. Isn't He supposed to be in New York?

"Hi." I said my eye brows wrinkled.

"Hey. Is Pheobe home?" He asked trying to look around me.

"Um, well let me see if she's awake yet. Wait here." I said closing the door leaving him outside. I wasn't about to let him in the house. I ran upstairs to Pheobe's room. I walked in and she was on the phone. "Pheobe," I whispered, "Todd is here."

"What?" She mouthed.

"Todd is waiting for you outside." I said a little louder.

"Jess, I'm sorry, I got to go." Pheobe said into the phone. "I'll call you. Bye." She hung up.

"Todd's here?" She repeated making sure she heard correctly.

"Yup."

"Where's Prue?"

"Sleeping, she got home late."

"I'm going to go talk to him." She started walking down stairs. I followed.

"Pheobe...?"

"I know...Be careful."

"Really careful."

"He won't hurt me." I looked at her skeptical.

"Just please don't go too far." She nodded.

Pheobe's POV

I walked outside and sure enough there was Todd.

"Hey babe." He said walking toward me. He hugged me then tried to give me a kiss, but I turned my head and he missed. I looked up at him.

"What are you doing here?" I asked.

"Ouch. So that's how it's going to be?" He asked.

"Todd, you practically beat someone to death, your sent to juvie for a year, then are shipped to some military school in New York. I haven't seen you. How did you think it was going to be?" I said harshly.

"But I did it all for you." Todd said leading me towards the park.

"I didn't ask you to do that!" I said getting angry.

"You didn't have to ask. I'm your boyfriend I'm supposed to protect you from jerks."

"Were, you were my boyfriend." I corrected him and stopped walking and looked at him. "And that guy you practically beat to death wasn't even doing anything to me."

"He was looking at you wrong and I know he was about to do something inappropriate and rude." He answered.

"But he didn't!" I said sternly.

"Pheebs, please, I'm a change man." He pleaded. I looked at him straight in the eyes. I wasn't sure I f I should believe him or not. "Pheobe, I love you." He said leaning closer to me. I didn't move. Tears were forming in my eyes. He kissed me. I started to kiss back but then quickly I pulled away.

"I loved you too, but you left me." I said quietly looking away. A tear escaped from my eyes. Everyone I lobe ends up leaving me some way or another, except for my sisters of course.

"I didn't leave you because I wanted to, Pheebs. I left because I was forced to go."

"Nobody forced you to do what you did to get sent away in the first place. You knew you were on your last strike." I said turning away and walking back towards my house. He quickened his own walk to catch up to me.

"Please, Pheobe let me prove to you that I've changed, please." He begged. I was quiet for a while then we reached my house. I turned to face him.

"We're not together, okay. You need to show me that you really have changed." He smiled.

"Thanks." He said. He gave me a quick peck on the lips and started to leave. He turned around suddenly as I was opening the door. "I'll find a way to prove it to you Pheobe. I love you!" He shouted. He didn't expect an answer and I didn't give him one. I walked inside.

Review PLEASE! They help me keep going. Thanks for reading I'll update soon.