Finn walked down the hall grumbling loudly. His best friend Logan stopped him outside his classroom.

"Woah! What happened to you?" He asked

Finn growled, "Wrestling! That's what happened!" Finn had a black eye and half his face was red and he was limping, "I'm done!" He yelled

"With what?" Colin asked, walking up behind Logan

"With Rosemary! I'm done trying to win her over!"

"Woah, you've been going after Rose since we were in diapers, practically" Colin said shocked, "What happened?"

"She has a date this weekend with a jock, so I figure, okay she likes the sporties, so I try out for the wrestling team... NEVER AGAIN!" Finn yelled, "PAIN AND LOTS OF IT! NEVER AGAIN!"

"Okay, okay, we got it!" Logan laughed

"Not funny" Finn growled again

Logan gave a charming grin, "Little funny"

"What's funny?" Rory asked as she came up and gave Logan a small hug to his back before slipping around to his side as his arm rested across her shoulders.

So Colin regaled Finn's dilemma to Rory and she burst out laughing.

"Not funny!" He repeated

"Little funny" Rory answered, unknowingly repeating her boyfriend, "Have you tried, oh, I dunno, talking to Rosemary?"

Everyone looked at Rory as if she belonged to a mental hospital.

"Why would I do that?" Finn asked.

"You know what? I have no idea" Rory said sarcastically, rolling her eyes as if to say 'boys'

"I have an idea." Logan said suddenly

"This can't end well," Rory mumbled as she leaned in to hear.

"Oh, I see her everywhere I turn. She my fire inside, I burn. My Love! My Light! My...Rosemary!" Finn sang in the middle of the dining hall to a flushed redhead.

"Finn! What are you doing?" Rose asked, fingering the dozen roses Finn had gave her in the beginning of his serenade.

"Singing" Finn said as if it was the most natural thing in the world, "Hold on, I;m only at the second chorus" And he continued, oblivious to his friends' roaring laughter behind him and Rory video taping the whole thing. 'So the embarassment can live on for years to come' she had said.

"Now, will you go out with me, my dear Rosemary?" Finn asked

"No"